← No religion, or not sure
Church and community

Why are there so many different kinds of Christian? Doesn't that show none of you know?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

ACG works this question through in his own story. Read that part of his story: Why not Protestant, or Orthodox? · 5 min

Most Christians belong to three big families: Catholic, and . The famous figure of 33,000 denominations is misleading. The splits are real and painful, but they show people disagree about the faith, not that there's nothing true to know. Almost all Christians still share the same core beliefs.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

It's a reasonable worry. If Christians can't agree, why should anyone believe them? Online you'll often read that there are 33,000 kinds of Christian church.

But look at how that number was made. A big reference book counted a church again in every country where it exists. It counted thousands of single independent churches one by one. It even counted the Catholic Church as 242 'denominations'.1

So it measures something real, just not what most people think.

Look at it another way. About half the world's Christians are Catholic. About 37% are Protestant, counted broadly, and 12% are Orthodox, the old churches of the Christian East, from Greece and Russia to the Middle East.2 Most Christians belong to a few big families.

How the branches split

The first lasting split came in the 400s. Some Eastern churches, like the Copts of Egypt and the Armenians, disagreed with the rest over how to put into words who Jesus is: how he can be both God and human.3

And here's the remarkable part. Today both sides widely agree they meant the same thing all along. The difference was only in the words.11

The big break between East and West is usually dated to 1054. That year the 's messengers and the leader of the Church in Constantinople cut each other off.4

Behind it lay centuries of argument. One fight was over how much authority the pope has. Another was over a phrase the West added to the Creed, the shared statement of faith, about where the comes from.10

Christians believe in one God who is Father, Son and Holy Spirit: three persons sharing one life. So this was an argument about how the three relate to each other. The Orthodox also say no of the whole Church ever added the phrase.15

Orthodox Christians would say they never left anything. They see their own Church as the one true Church, where real unity is found.12

In the West, the split came in 1517. A German monk, , protested at how the Church was selling .5 Underneath lay a bigger question: how does God accept us?

In Catholic teaching an indulgence is a release from the after-effects of God has already forgiven: the damage and consequences sin leaves behind, which still need healing.14 Many churches then broke from Rome, and became the Protestant churches.3

A family fight isn't proof of nothing

What gets lost is this. Almost all these churches believe the same core things. One God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Jesus, truly God and truly man, who died and rose again.

Most of the splits are about who has authority and how to worship, not about whether Jesus rose from the dead.

Disagreement shows a question is hard, or that people are stubborn.

It doesn't show there's no answer.

Think of it like this

Think of a big family after a long fight over grandpa's will. Some cousins stopped talking years ago. One branch moved overseas and doesn't come to the big holiday dinner any more. There are lawyers involved.

A stranger hearing all this might shake his head and say: they can't agree on anything, so maybe there was no grandpa at all.

But that gets it backwards. They're fighting over the will because every one of them knows he lived. They all carry his name, his photos, his stories. They argue about what he meant, and who got what, because what he left them matters.

Christians are like that. They argue about authority and worship. But they argue because almost all of them agree Jesus lived, died and rose, and left them something that matters.

To be fair, many Christians don't think the splits are small. The Russian Orthodox Church, for one, says they're not just about side issues.12 So why not just merge? Because what's left to settle, above all who has authority, is about things each side believes Jesus himself set up.

A wound, not a menu

The Catholic Church doesn't treat the splits as a menu of flavours. It calls them a wound. The said division openly contradicts the will of , scandalizes the world, and harms the spreading of the , Jesus's message.3

And it admitted something many people don't expect. When the big splits came, it said, often enough, men of both sides were to blame.3

People born into other churches cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation.3 Everyone who believes in Christ has a right to be called Christian, and Catholics are to treat them as brothers and sisters.3

The says these Christians already share a real, if incomplete, bond with the Catholic Church. With the Orthodox, it says, that bond lacks little to be complete.9

Catholics do believe the full unity Christ gave his Church is still found in the Catholic Church.9 Many evangelicals see it differently. For them the true Church is everyone truly joined to Christ by faith, wherever they worship.13

Both can't be fully right about where the Church is, and both know it. That's exactly why they keep talking.

A skeptic will ask: if you can't agree how to settle things, why trust any of you on the core?

Because the core came first, in the Creed agreed at Nicaea in 325, and nearly every church still holds it.6 It's not proof, but it's not nothing.

Closing the gaps

Some of those gaps have closed in living memory.

In 1965 Rome and Constantinople lifted the sentences of 1054 by which each side had cut the other off, after more than 900 years.4

In 1999 Lutherans and Catholics agreed on that bigger question, how God accepts us. They agreed it's a free gift, not because of any merit on our part.7 Methodist, Anglican and Reformed churches have since joined that agreement.8

And in November 2025, leaders of many churches gathered at Nicaea in Turkey. There Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew, the senior Orthodox leader, prayed the Creed together, in the city where it was first agreed 1,700 years before.6

The pope said faith in Jesus is shared by all Christian Churches and Communities throughout the world, including those that don't say the Creed in their services.6

Why does it matter so much? Because on the night before he died, Jesus prayed that his followers may all be one, so that the world would believe (John 17:21). The Catechism says that's why the work for unity never stops: praying together, changing our hearts, and getting to know one another as friends.9

Division doesn't prove that nobody knows. It's a wound Christians have to heal, together.

Sources15
  1. 1National Catholic Register, We Need to Stop Saying That There Are 33,000 Protestant Denominations (9 February 2016)Where the 33,000 figure comes from and how the World Christian Encyclopedia counted.
  2. 2Pew Research Center, Global Christianity (19 December 2011)About half of Christians are Catholic, 37% Protestant, 12% Orthodox.
  3. 3Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (21 November 1964), 1, 3, 13Division contradicts Christ's will; both sides to blame; the main divisions of East and West.
  4. 4Paul VI and Athenagoras I, Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration (7 December 1965)Recalls the 1054 excommunications and removes them from memory.
  5. 5Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), Martin LutherLuther posts the 95 Theses on 31 October 1517.
  6. 6Holy See Press Office, Ecumenical prayer at İznik and Pope Leo XIV's address (28 November 2025)Pope and Patriarch recite the Nicene Creed together 1,700 years after Nicaea.
  7. 7Lutheran World Federation and Catholic Church, Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999)'A consensus in basic truths of the doctrine of justification'.
  8. 8Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, Joint Declaration 20th anniversary (2020)Methodists (2006), Anglicans (2016) and Reformed (2017) affirm the Joint Declaration.
  9. 9Catechism of the Catholic Church, 817–822, 838Wounds to unity, the call to restore it, and communion with other Christians.
  10. 10Orthodox Church in America, The Symbol of Faith: Holy SpiritThe Orthodox view: the Western addition of the filioque is unscriptural and unacceptable to Orthodoxy.
  11. 11CNEWA, The Oriental Orthodox ChurchesWho the Oriental Orthodox are, why they rejected Chalcedon, and the recognition that the difference was verbal.
  12. 12Russian Orthodox Church, Basic Principles of Attitude to the Non-Orthodox, 2.3 and 2.8Genuine unity only in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church; divisions not only about secondary matters.
  13. 13Evangelical–Roman Catholic Dialogue on Mission, 1977–1984 (report)Evangelicals distinguish the visible church from the invisible church of genuine believers.
  14. 14Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1472
  15. 15OrthodoxWiki, FilioqueThe Orthodox view: the filioque was added in the West without an ecumenical council.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.