From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/indulgences
← Protestant or evangelicalDoes the Catholic Church still sell indulgences?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minNo. The Catholic Church banned selling them more than 450 years ago, in the 1560s. And an never buys forgiveness. Forgiveness comes first, free, from . An indulgence is about healing the damage that forgiven still leaves behind.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 1471–1479
- Council of Trent
- Session 21, chapter 9Session 25, Decree concerning Indulgences
If you know one thing about how the churches began, it's probably this. The Catholic Church sold forgiveness, and a German monk called stood up to it.
So there are really two questions. Did the Catholic Church sell indulgences, and does it still? And even with no money involved, doesn't an indulgence add something to what Christ did on the cross?
Yes, there was a trade
The story starts in Germany around 1517. A preacher named Johann Tetzel was travelling from town to town, raising money to rebuild St 's Church in Rome.1
He taught that you could gain an indulgence for a dead loved one with money alone, without even being sorry. Even a Catholic encyclopedia that defends him on other points admits it.1
Luther was furious. He mocked preachers who claimed that the moment the coin hits the box, a soul flies out of .2 His protest helped start the Reformation, the split that created the Protestant churches.
Luther was right that this was an abuse. The same Catholic encyclopedia admits that greedy clergy used indulgences to make money.3 Church leaders had tried to stop it in the 1200s and 1300s, and it didn't work.3
How the selling ended
In 1562 the Catholic at the got rid of the travelling indulgence collectors everywhere.4 From then on, bishops would announce indulgences, and any gifts would go to two local clergymen who could take no fee.4 The reason, they said:
that so all men may at length truly understand, that these heavenly treasures of the Church are administered, not for gain, but for godliness.
The next year they kept indulgences, but ordered that all evil gains for the obtaining thereof be wholly abolished.5
Then in 1567 the went further. He cancelled every grant of indulgence that involved fees or any money changing hands.3
Older indulgences had been labelled with a number of days or years. Officially, that never meant so many days knocked off a stay in purgatory. It meant as much as that many days or years of penance in the early Church would have done.3
The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1910 admitted the reckoning makes no claim to absolute exactness.3
But to be fair, many ordinary Catholics did hear it as time off purgatory, and plenty of preachers let them. Many late medieval indulgences promised terms longer than a lifetime, and the labels were widely misunderstood.8
In 1967 Pope Paul VI called indulgences free gifts. He scrapped those labels and cut back the number of full indulgences.7
What an indulgence actually is
So if it isn't buying forgiveness, what is it? The 's definition is short: a release from the temporal punishment still due for sins whose guilt has already been forgiven.6 Those are old words, so take them one step at a time.
First, your sin must already be forgiven, through being truly sorry and, for serious sins, confession.6
An indulgence never forgives sin.
Second, forgiven sin still leaves damage behind. Bad habits. Things you're too attached to. Harm done to other people. That's what temporal punishment means. It isn't God's revenge. It comes from the very nature of sin, and it still needs healing.6
Third, an indulgence is the Catholic Church asking God to heal some or all of that damage, drawing on what Christ won, when you pray or do good with a changed heart.6 A partial indulgence heals some of it, a full one all of it. Catholics can offer one for someone who has died, too.6
That can sound like Tetzel again, selling help for a dead loved one. But no money changes hands now. Paul VI wrote that indulgences are granted for the living as well as for the dead only on determined conditions.7
Think of it like this
Say you're twelve, and you kick a football straight through your neighbour's window. Your heart sinks. You walk over, knock on his door and say sorry. He looks at you for a second, then smiles: It's okay. I forgive you. Just like that. You didn't pay a thing for it.
But the window is still broken. There's glass all over his floor and cold air coming in. And you're still a bit careless, the kind of kid who kicks a ball near windows.
So your dad comes over with you. He pays for the new pane, which your pocket money could never cover, and fits it himself. You hold the dustpan beside him. That doesn't earn the forgiveness. It was already given. You're there because you're sorry, and working next to your dad is how you learn to be more careful.
Forgiveness came first and cost you nothing. The repair is about healing what your mistake left behind, and it's your father's generosity that does it. That's an indulgence: Christ's generosity, healing a forgiven person.
And it isn't automatic. For a full indulgence, you do the prayer or good deed it's attached to. You also go to confession and , and pray for the pope's intentions, the needs he asks the whole Church to pray for.7
It also requires that all attachment to sin, even to venial sin, be absent.7 Venial sins are the everyday, smaller ones. You can't still be clinging to any sin, even a small one. If your heart isn't fully there yet, it counts as a partial one.7
Paul VI put it simply: indulgences cannot be acquired without a sincere conversion of mentality, a real change of heart.7
Does it add to Christ's work?
This is the deeper Protestant worry, and it's a fair one. If I'm already forgiven, why not just ask God to help me heal? Why does the Church need to be involved?
Catholics do ask God directly, every day. The Catechism tells forgiven Christians to work at healing themselves, by works of mercy and charity, as well as by prayer.6
But it also says nobody does this alone. Christians are one family, and the holiness of one profits others.6 An indulgence puts that whole family's help behind you.
And nothing is added to the cross. The Catechism says the riches the Church draws on are the infinite value, which can never be exhausted, which Christ's merits have before God.6 Even the prayers of Mary and the saints help only because they were done by his .6
And the Catechism says the Church doesn't only want to help. It also wants to spur Christians on to works of devotion, penance, and charity.6
Other Christians don't use indulgences at all. The practice grew up in the Western Church over centuries, out of older customs of doing penance.3
So no, nothing is for sale, and nothing is added to the cross.
Sources8
- 1Catholic Encyclopedia, Johann Tetzel (1912)Tetzel preached the indulgence for St Peter's from 1516; his teaching on indulgences for the dead "repugnant to the teaching of the Church".
- 2Martin Luther, Ninety-five Theses (1517), thesis 27Luther's protest against the slogan that money frees souls from purgatory.
- 3Catholic Encyclopedia, Indulgences (1910)The abuses admitted; Lateran IV (1215) and Boniface IX (1392) against them; Pius V's 1567 cancellation of grants involving fees.
- 4Council of Trent, Session 21 (16 July 1562), chapter 9The name and office of the questors of alms abolished.
- 5Council of Trent, Session 25 (3–4 December 1563), Decree concerning IndulgencesIndulgences kept; all evil gains from them abolished.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1479What an indulgence is; temporal punishment; the treasury of Christ's merits.
- 7Paul VI, Indulgentiarum Doctrina (1 January 1967)Indulgences as free gifts; the conditions; the end of days and years; fewer plenary indulgences; 2 November.
- 8Wikipedia, IndulgenceDays or years were meant as equivalent penance but widely mistaken for time in purgatory; many late medieval indulgences ran longer than a lifetime.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.