Part VIII · Chapter 22
The Eastern-Western schism

Did the Church split in 1054?

10 scenes · about 25 min read

The short answer

Not in one year. 1054 is the date people remember, but the split was a slow drift over centuries.

In 1054 the 's envoy left a document on the altar of Hagia Sophia, Constantinople's great church. It excommunicated the patriarch, the city's , and two other men. That cut them off from the .

It didn't name the Eastern Church, but it broke trust.

The real quarrels were older. The West had added and the Son to the Creed, the statement of faith Christians say together. Underneath lay a bigger question: how far the pope could govern churches outside the West.

What broke the bond was an army, not a document. In April 1204 crusaders sacked Constantinople.

In 1965 the two Churches lifted the sentences of 1054, but they still don't share the sacraments as one Church. In 2025, at ancient Nicaea, their leaders said the original Creed together.

Follow the trail

Ten moments from the Creed of 381 to the prayer at Nicaea in 2025, and not one is an order that split the Church.

AD 381Historical2 min read

The Creed says "from the Father"

The First Council of Constantinople

In 381 the bishops of the East met at Constantinople, today's Istanbul. They expanded the Creed, the short statement of Christian belief. It says the comes from the Father, with no and the Son. East and West agree that this is what the original says.

Icon of the First Council of Nicaea with the text of the Creed in Greek.
Icon of the Council of Nicaea, 325, with the Creed written out in Greek.
IWhat was going on

In 325 a council, a meeting of bishops, had settled at Nicaea that the Son is fully God. But the argument didn't stop there. Some bishops went on to deny that the Holy Spirit was fully God too.

In 381 the emperor Theodosius called the bishops of the East to Constantinople, his capital. That council expanded the Creed of Nicaea, adding a longer section on the Holy Spirit.

IIWhat was at stake

Christians already prayed to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. The question was whether the Spirit is God in the same full sense, or a lesser power sent by God.

How the Spirit comes from God was the heart of it. The council took its words from Jesus in John's , one of the four accounts of his life: the Spirit proceeds from the Father.

IIIWhat happened

The council's creed calls the Spirit the Lord and giver of life. He proceeds from the Father, and is worshipped and glorified together with the Father and the Son.

It says nothing about the Son's part in the Spirit's coming.

The text reaches us through the records of a later council, at in 451, which credited it to this council. Where exactly it came from is still debated.

IVWhat came of it

This creed became the one Christians say at the , the shared bread and wine at the centre of their worship, in East and West alike. Catholics call it the Nicene Creed.

Centuries later, the West added one Latin word to it: Filioque, meaning and the Son. The Catechism of the Catholic Church, its official summary of teaching, says plainly that the word was not in the original.

VRead the source
And [we believe] in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver-of-Life, who proceeds from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified, who spoke by the prophets.
First Council of Constantinople (381): Creed and Canons · Creed, clause on the Holy Spirit (Percival, NPNF2 vol. 14)

Why it matters

Everything later in this story turns on this one sentence of the Creed. Both sides agree on what the council wrote.

They disagree on two things. Could anyone add to it without another council of the whole Church? And is the addition true?

An analogy may help. Think of the Father as a spring, and the Spirit as the water that flows from it. Both sides agree the Father is the spring.

The Orthodox fear that and the Son makes the Son a second spring. Catholics say it means the water reaches us from the Father through the Son, with the Father still the only spring. The scenes below follow that argument as it grew.

early 5th c.Inference1 min read

A Latin bishop already says "and the Son"

Augustine of Hippo

In the early 400s Augustine, a bishop in North Africa, wrote that the Spirit proceeds from the Son as well as the Father. He added the word principally to keep the Father as the source. It was two centuries before anyone changed the Creed.

Saint Augustine by Philippe de Champaigne, c. 1645.
Augustine. Philippe de Champaigne, c. 1645.
IWhat was going on

Augustine was bishop of Hippo, in North Africa, and he wrote in Latin. Over many years he worked on On the Trinity. It is a long attempt to understand how one God can be Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

In the Latin West the old enemy was still Arianism, the teaching that the Son was less than the Father. Saying the Spirit comes from the Son too was a way of saying the Son is fully God.

IIWhat was at stake

The , the second part of the Christian , calls the Spirit both the Spirit of the Father and the Spirit of the Son. Does that mean the Spirit takes his being from the Son as well?

Augustine said yes, but he guarded the Father's place. The Father, he wrote, is the one from whom the Spirit principally proceeds.

IIIRead the source
God the Father alone is He from whom the Word is born, and from whom the Holy Spirit principally proceeds. And therefore I have added the word principally, because we find that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son also.
On the Trinity (De Trinitate), Book XV · On the Trinity XV.17.29 (NPNF1 vol. 3, trans. Haddan)

Why it matters

The teaching is older than the quarrel. It was not invented by the Franks, the people who later pressed the words into the Creed. That is the strongest point on the Catholic side.

The Orthodox reply that Augustine's careful word principally was later lost. When the Latin Creed simply said and the Son, Greek ears heard two sources in God.

AD 431Historical1 min read

A council forbids a different faith

The Council of Ephesus

In 431 the bishops meeting at Ephesus forbade anyone to put forward a faith different from the one set out at Nicaea. East and West have read that rule in two ways ever since.

IWhat was going on

The Council of Ephesus met in 431 to settle a quarrel about Jesus and his mother Mary. Near its end, it heard that a different creed was being given to new converts.

In reply it passed a , a church rule. No one may write or put forward a faith different from the one the bishops at Nicaea had set out. Bishops and clergy who did so were to be removed from office.

IIWhat was at stake

What counts as a different faith? The Greek word can mean a rival creed that contradicts Nicaea, or simply any other wording.

If it means any change at all, adding words to the Creed breaks a council's rule. If it means a rival creed, an explanation that agrees with Nicaea is allowed.

IIIRead the source
the holy Synod decreed that it is unlawful for any man to bring forward, or to write, or to compose a different (ἑτέραν) Faith as a rival to that established by the holy Fathers assembled with the Holy Ghost in Nicæa.
Council of Ephesus (431): Cyril's Second Letter to Nestorius and the sentence against Nestorius · Canon 7 (Percival, NPNF2 vol. 14)

Why it matters

A Catholic encyclopedia from 1909 sums up the Eastern objection: by breaking this rule, Rome went beyond its rights.

The Catholic answer, in the same encyclopedia, is that the councils forbade another faith, not a clearer explanation of the same one. Henry Percival, an Anglican scholar who edited the councils' texts in English, gives the same answer.

The canon names the Creed of Nicaea in 325, not the longer one of 381 that carries the disputed line. So neither reading fits the rule neatly.

8th c.Inference1 min read

The Greek answer: through the Son

John of Damascus

In the 700s John of Damascus, a monk near Jerusalem, set down the Greek answer. The Father is the one source of the Son and of the Spirit. The Spirit comes from the Father through the Son.

Icon of John of Damascus in a monk's headdress, holding a scroll.
John of Damascus. Icon by Emmanouel Tzanes, 17th century.
IWhat was going on

John was born in Damascus around 676, when the city was the capital of the Muslim caliphate, the Islamic empire. He served as a senior official there, as his father had. Then he became a monk at the monastery of St Sabas near Jerusalem.

He lived outside the Byzantine empire, the Greek Christian empire ruled from Constantinople. So he could write freely when its emperor turned against icons, the painted holy images used in prayer.

His Exposition of the Orthodox Faith gathered the teaching of the Greek Fathers, the great early teachers who wrote in Greek, into one book.

IIWhat was at stake

The Greek Fathers had long said the Spirit comes through the Son. But what does that mean?

Is the Son a second source of the Spirit alongside the Father? Or is he the one through whom the Father's Spirit is given? John chose the second.

IIIRead the source
The Father is the source and cause of the Son and the Holy Spirit: Father of the Son alone and producer of the Holy Spirit.
An Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, Book I · An Exposition of the Orthodox Faith I.12 (NPNF2 vol. 9, trans. Salmond)

Why it matters

John states the Greek answer plainly: the Father alone is the cause. The Spirit proceeds through the Son, from the Father.

Rome now says the two answers can fit together. In 1995 the Vatican's office for Christian unity wrote a statement on the question. It calls the Greek through the Son a happy expression, and insists the Father is the only origin.

Much of the gap is in the words, not the faith.

AD 809Historical2 min read

A pope refuses to add the words

Leo III, at Rome

In 809 the Franks pressed Pope Leo III to put and the Son into the Creed, and he refused. By an Anglican scholar's account, he had the Creed engraved without it, in Latin and Greek, on two silver shields at St 's.

IWhat was going on

In Spain the Visigoths, the Germanic people who ruled there, turned from Arianism to the Catholic faith in 589. Arianism taught that the Son was less than the Father.

The Visigoths' councils at Toledo confessed that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. It was a way to stress that the Son is fully God.

From there the longer wording spread through the West. By 800 the Frankish king Charlemagne ruled much of western Europe, and that Christmas the pope crowned him emperor. His churches already sang the Creed with the added words.

IIWhat was at stake

In 809 a council at Aachen, Charlemagne's capital, appears to have backed the longer Creed. Envoys went to Rome to win the pope over.

Leo III owed his safety to Charlemagne, and saying no to him was costly. But the Greeks still said the Creed without the words.

In 1995 the Vatican's office for Christian unity wrote that Leo resisted because he wanted to keep the same confession of faith as the East.

IIIWhat happened

When the Frankish envoys met him in Rome, Leo accepted the teaching but would not have the words in the Creed. The accounts differ on his reason.

Henry Percival, an Anglican scholar who edited the councils' texts, says Leo opposed the words because the councils of the whole Church had forbidden any addition. A Catholic encyclopedia of 1909 says he approved the teaching and advised leaving the words out.

Percival reports that Leo had the original text engraved in Latin and in Greek on two silver shields, set up at St Peter's. Some accounts date the meeting in Rome to 810.

The Franks kept singing the longer Creed, and Rome kept singing the shorter one.

IVWhat came of it

Rome held out for about two hundred years. In 1014 Pope Benedict VIII allowed the longer Creed to be sung at , the Latin service of the Eucharist.

He did it at the request of the German king Henry II, whom he crowned emperor that year. Scholars don't all agree on the exact year, but most place it under Benedict VIII.

The shields later disappeared.

VRead the source
So firmly resolved was the Pope that the clause should not be introduced into the creed that he presented two silver shields to the Confessio in St. Peter’s at Rome, on one of which was engraved the creed in Latin and on the other in Greek, without the addition.
Historical Excursus on the Introduction into the Creed of the Words "and the Son" · Excursus, under proposition 2, on the silver shields and on 1014

Why it matters

One pope refused the addition, on Percival's account because the councils forbade it. Later popes and councils accepted it. The Orthodox ask how both can be right.

Catholics answer with the Council of Florence, held in 1439: the words explain the faith rather than change it. Adding them was a matter of need and timing, and Leo judged that one way and later popes another.

16 July 1054Historical2 min read

A document left on the altar

Cardinal Humbert, in Hagia Sophia

On 16 July 1054 Cardinal Humbert, the pope's envoy, laid a document on the altar of Hagia Sophia, the great church of Constantinople. It excommunicated the patriarch and two other men, cutting them off from the sacraments. It did not name the Eastern Church.

Coloured section of Hagia Sophia drawn as the Byzantine church: the gold dome, mosaic angels and saints, and Justinian's column outside.
Hagia Sophia, Constantinople, in section: Wilhelm Salzenberg's reconstruction of the Byzantine church, published in 1854. The papal legates laid their bull on its altar in 1054.
IWhat was going on

By the 1000s East and West had grown apart. They spoke different languages, Greek and Latin, and had different emperors. The breakup of the old Roman empire had made it harder for them to talk to each other.

In southern Italy, the Normans, warriors from northern France, were conquering lands where many Christians followed Greek customs, and those customs were being suppressed.

In reply pressed the Latin churches in his city to adopt Greek customs. He was the patriarch of Constantinople, the bishop of the eastern capital.

In Rome, Pope Leo IX was a reformer. He was set on cleaning up the Western Church and strengthening the pope's authority.

IIWhat was at stake

On the surface the quarrel was about practice. At the Eucharist, the shared bread and wine, the two sides used different bread. Latins used unleavened bread, made without yeast, and Greeks used leavened bread.

Leo, archbishop of Ohrid (Achrida), wrote against the Latin customs, above all their unleavened bread.

Underneath lay a bigger question: how far the bishop of Rome could govern churches outside the West.

IIIWhat happened

Pope Leo IX sent envoys, called legates, led by Cardinal Humbert. The talks went badly from the start. After a cold first meeting, Cerularius refused to deal with them.

On 16 July 1054, during a service, Humbert laid a bull, a formal papal document, on the altar of Hagia Sophia.

It excommunicated the patriarch, Leo of Ohrid, a court official and their followers, unless they repented.

The patriarch and his synod, the council of bishops around him, answered by excommunicating the legates.

IVWhat came of it

Pope Leo IX had died before Humbert issued the bull. The next pope, Victor II, did not withdraw it.

Communion, the shared sacraments that make churches one, did not end that day. Other Eastern churches stayed on friendly terms with Rome for some time.

Peter, patriarch of the ancient Christian city of Antioch, begged Cerularius not to break with Rome.

VRead the source
As far as the pillars of the Empire are concerned, and its wise and honoured citizens, this city is most Christian and Orthodox.
The Orthodox Eastern Church, chapter 5, "The Schism of Cerularius" · Chapter 5, translating the bull from Will, Acta et Scripta, pp. 153–154

Why it matters

1054 is the date in the textbooks. But the bull named three men, not a Church. In the same document it called the city itself Christian and Orthodox.

In 1965 Rome and Constantinople said together that the sentences were aimed at persons, not at the Churches. 1054 was a real break in trust. It was not yet the split.

April 1204Historical2 min read

Crusaders sack Constantinople

Niketas Choniates, eyewitness

In April 1204 a crusading army, raised to win back the Holy Land, took Constantinople instead. For three days the soldiers plundered this Christian city, its churches included.

Eugène Delacroix, The Entry of the Crusaders into Constantinople, 1840.
The Crusaders enter Constantinople, 12 April 1204. Delacroix, 1840.
IWhat was going on

In 1198 Pope Innocent III called a new crusade, an armed pilgrimage to win back Jerusalem. The French knights who answered planned to strike at Egypt first. They hired Venice to ship the army.

They could not pay what they owed Venice. In exchange, the Venetians had them help capture Zara, a Christian city on the Adriatic coast, in November 1202. Innocent had urged them to sail for the Holy Land instead.

IIWhat was at stake

Alexius, a prince of the Greek empire ruled from Constantinople, offered a deal. His father, the emperor, had been overthrown.

Put them both back on the throne, he said, and he would pay the crusaders 200,000 marks. He would also join the crusade and bring the Greek Church back into union with Rome.

For the crusade's leaders it solved the money problem. For the Greeks it meant a foreign army deciding who ruled them.

IIIWhat happened

In July 1203 the crusaders forced their way into the city, and Alexius was crowned beside his father. He could not keep his promises. In February 1204 both were overthrown.

The crusaders and the Venetians agreed in advance how to share out the empire. On 12 April 1204 they stormed Constantinople.

For three days the city was plundered, churches included. An eyewitness, the Greek official Niketas Choniates, saw the altar of Hagia Sophia broken up and shared out among the soldiers. Mules were led into the sanctuary to carry off the silver.

He saw the Eucharist itself, which Christians on both sides believed was 's body and blood, 'spilled upon the ground or thrown about'.

Then he wrote of the streets. 'No one was without a share in the grief.' He lists 'the groaning of men, the shrieks of women, wounds, rape, captivity, the separation of those most closely united'.

Old people wandered the streets in tears, and the rich were left in poverty.

IVWhat came of it

Innocent III wrote in fury to his legate, his envoy with the army. Yet a Western bishop was installed as patriarch of Constantinople. Baldwin, a count from Flanders, was crowned emperor in Hagia Sophia.

The Greeks won their city back in 1261, after fifty-seven years of Latin rule. The Orthodox Church in America calls 1204 the final sealing of the schism.

VRead the source
How shall I begin to tell of the deeds wrought by these nefarious men! Alas, the images, which ought to have been adored, were trodden under foot! Alas, the relics of the holy martyrs were thrown into unclean places!
Niketas Choniates, The Sack of Constantinople (1204) · Account of the sack, opening (trans. D. C. Munro, 1912)

Why it matters

If one moment broke the relationship, it was this one. It was an army that did it, not a document. For ordinary Greeks, the Latin West now became the enemy.

In 2001, in Athens, Pope John Paul II spoke about it. He said that the attackers being Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret. He begged the Lord's forgiveness for the of Catholics against the Orthodox.

6 July 1439Historical2 min read

Two reunions signed, and rejected

The Council of Florence

Two councils tried to reunite East and West: at Lyons, in France, in 1274, and at Florence, in Italy, in 1439. Both unions were signed under pressure, and the East rejected both.

IWhat was going on

After 1261 the Byzantine empire, the Greek Christian empire ruled from Constantinople, was weak and surrounded. In the 1270s Charles of Anjou, the French ruler of southern Italy, planned to attack it.

By the 1430s the Ottoman Turks had shrunk the empire to little more than the city of Constantinople.

Byzantine emperors needed Western help, and popes wanted the churches reunited. From the start, church union and military aid were tied together.

IIWhat was at stake

Union on whose terms? The Latins asked the Greeks to accept three things. The Spirit proceeds from the Son too. There is a , a cleansing after death. And above all, the pope has authority over the whole Church.

The Greeks had another question. Could a delegation, however senior, sign for the whole Eastern Church?

IIIWhat happened

At Lyons in 1274 the envoys of the emperor Michael VIII accepted Rome's terms.

A modern edition of the councils' decrees, edited by Norman Tanner, says in its introduction that the union appears to have been imposed by the emperor. He wanted the pope's support against Charles of Anjou, while most Greek clergy opposed the union.

In 1438 a Greek delegation of about 700 people came to Ferrara, in Italy, led by the emperor John VIII and the patriarch. The council moved to Florence in 1439.

On 6 July 1439 the union was proclaimed. According to the Orthodox Church in America's history, every Greek bishop present signed except Mark of Ephesus.

IVWhat came of it

The same Orthodox account says the Greek bishops signed under severe pressure from the emperor and the patriarch. At home, clergy and people rejected the union. The Orthodox honour Mark of Ephesus as a saint for refusing it.

By the same account, the union was proclaimed in Hagia Sophia only on 12 December 1452, as the Ottoman army gathered. Constantinople fell in May 1453.

Its first patriarch under Ottoman rule, Gennadios, had led the opposition to the union.

VRead the source
We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need.
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks (1439) · Laetentur caeli, session 6, 6 July 1439, clause on the addition to the creed

Why it matters

Catholics count Florence as a council of the whole Church, and hold its teaching true. But a union signed out of military need did not bring people together.

In 1993 the official Catholic-Orthodox commission for dialogue met at Balamand in Lebanon.

It agreed that an old method can no longer be the way to unity: bringing one part of an Orthodox Church over to Rome on its own. That method split Eastern Churches in two.

The Churches now meet as equals, and call each other sister Churches.

7 December 1965Historical2 min read

The old sentences are lifted

Paul VI and Athenagoras I

On 7 December 1965 Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I of Constantinople lifted the excommunications of 1054 and removed them from the Church's memory. In the same statement they said this alone could not end their differences.

Bishops in session at the Second Vatican Council, photographed by Lothar Wolleh.
The Second Vatican Council in session, 1962–65.
IWhat was going on

In January 1964 Paul VI and Athenagoras met in Jerusalem, at the places where Jesus died and rose. Athenagoras was the ecumenical patriarch: the archbishop of Constantinople and first in honour among Orthodox bishops.

At the same time the was rethinking how Catholics relate to other Christians. It was the worldwide meeting of Catholic bishops, from 1962 to 1965.

IIWhat was at stake

The excommunications of 1054, the sentences cutting men off from the sacraments, were still on the record. They named only three men. But for centuries each side had remembered them as a verdict on the other Church.

Could two Churches lift an old sentence without pretending the split had never happened?

IIIWhat happened

On 7 December 1965, the day before the council closed, a joint declaration was read at once in Rome and in Istanbul, as Constantinople is now called.

Both sides regretted the offensive words and gestures of 1054. They removed the sentences of excommunication from memory and from the midst of the Church.

They said the sentences had been aimed at persons, not at the Churches.

IVWhat came of it

The same declaration says the gesture is not enough to end the differences, old and new. The two Churches are still not in . Their priests and bishops do not celebrate the Eucharist together.

In 1980 a joint commission for theological dialogue held its first meeting, on the Greek island of Rhodes.

In 2007, at Ravenna in Italy, it agreed that in the first thousand years the bishop of Rome held first place among the patriarchs. It also agreed that the two sides still read the powers of that place differently.

VRead the source
They likewise regret and remove both from memory and from the midst of the Church the sentences of excommunication which followed these events, the memory of which has influenced actions up to our day and has hindered closer relations in charity; and they commit these excommunications to oblivion.
Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration of Pope Paul VI and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I · Joint Declaration, §4 B

Why it matters

Lifting the sentences did not heal the split. But it changed the way the two Churches speak of each other. In 1993 their joint commission called them sister Churches.

Sixty years after 1965, their leaders went back to Nicaea together.

28 November 2025Historical2 min read

The Creed said together at Nicaea

Leo XIV and Bartholomew I, at İznik

On 28 November 2025 Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew prayed together at İznik in Turkey, ancient Nicaea, 1,700 years after its council. With other Christian leaders they said the Nicene Creed in its original form, without and the Son.

IWhat was going on

Nicaea, today the town of İznik in Turkey, is where the first council of the whole Church met in 325. 2025 was its 1,700th anniversary.

Pope Leo XIV, elected in May 2025, made it the main reason for his first journey abroad. Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople hosted the prayer.

IIWhat was at stake

The Creed of Nicaea, as expanded in 381, is the one statement of faith shared by Catholics, the Orthodox and many Protestants. But for a thousand years East and West have said one line of it differently.

To say it together, they had to choose one form.

IIIWhat happened

On 28 November 2025 they met by the ruins of the Basilica of St Neophytos, partly under the waters of Lake İznik.

Other leaders came too. Some led the Churches of Egypt, Syria, Armenia and India, ancient Churches separate from both Rome and Constantinople.

Others came from the , and from Anglican and Protestant bodies.

Prayers were led in English, Greek and Arabic. A Catholic choir sang in Latin and an Orthodox choir in Greek.

They recited the Creed together without the added words. Recent popes have done the same at prayer services with other Christians.

IVWhat came of it

The next day, at the patriarch's residence in Istanbul, the two leaders signed a joint declaration. They called the faith of Nicaea what binds them together. They also named the obstacles to full communion that their dialogue is still working through.

They promised to keep looking for a way for all Christians to celebrate Easter on the same day every year. In 2025 the dates happened to fall together.

The Russian Orthodox Church, the largest Orthodox Church, was not represented. It broke off relations with Constantinople in 2018, over Constantinople's recognition of an independent Orthodox Church in Ukraine.

VRead the source
In addition to acknowledging the obstacles that prevent the restoration of full communion among all Christians – obstacles which we seek to address through the path of theological dialogue – we must also recognize that what binds us together is the faith expressed in the creed of Nicaea.
Joint Declaration of the Holy Father Leo XIV and His Holiness Bartholomew I · Joint Declaration of Leo XIV and Bartholomew I, 29 November 2025, second paragraph

Why it matters

The Creed of 381 was said together, in the form both sides agree is the original, in the place where the first council met.

The Catholic Church did not give up its teaching that the Spirit proceeds from the Son as well. It chose not to press the words.

The two Churches are still not in full communion. The pope's authority and the added words are still open questions. But they are now argued over by Churches that pray together.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Catholics don't claim that the words and the Son were in the Creed of 381. The , its official summary of teaching, says plainly that they were not.

It also says that adding them to the Latin , the Western Church's worship, "constitutes moreover, even today, a point of disagreement with the Churches".

The Catholic claim is narrower: the teaching is older than the quarrel.

, a North African bishop of the early 400s, already taught it. He added the word principally to keep the Father as the source.

In 1995 the Vatican's office for Christian unity looked again at the words. Greek has one word, ekporeusis, for the Spirit coming from the Father as the only source. Latin used processio, a broader word.

When the Creed was translated, the office said, "a false equivalence was involuntarily created". The two sides were partly using one word for two different things.

Could anyone add to the Creed at all? The Catholic answer is the one the Council of Florence gave in 1439. The words were "licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need".

An explanation is not a rival faith.

That answer has a practical shape today. In 1995 the Vatican's unity office said the Catholic Church has refused to add the words where the Creed is prayed in Greek. That holds even in churches that follow the Western form of worship.

It also said: "The liturgical use of this original text remains always legitimate in the Catholic Church".

So Rome declines to say in Greek what it means in Latin, because in Greek the words would say something Rome does not mean.

Recent popes have prayed the Creed in that original form with other Christians, most recently at İznik in 2025, as the last scene tells.

On 1054 and 1204 the Catholic position is not really a defence. Rome never excommunicated the Eastern Church as such, and in 1965 both Churches said so together.

The pope of the day condemned the 1204 sack of Constantinople. regretted it at Athens in 2001.

Since then the Catholic Church has given more ground than that. At Athens the same pope said: "If certain models of reunion of the past no longer correspond to the impulse towards unity which the Holy Spirit has awakened in Christians everywhere in recent times, we must be all the more open and attentive to what the Spirit is now saying to the Churches".

That sets aside the old model of Lyons and Florence: union by the East submitting to Rome.

In Ut Unum Sint, his letter on Christian unity, he went further. He asked other Christians to help him rethink the pope's , his first place among bishops.

He asked them to find "a way of exercising the primacy which, while in no way renouncing what is essential to its mission, is nonetheless open to a new situation". The limit he set is part of the offer.

Many Orthodox theologians reply that the invitation is about how the primacy is exercised. It leaves untouched what the , in the 1800s, defined about the pope. So they don't think it goes far enough.

The conversation has moved since. In 2007, at Ravenna, the joint Catholic-Orthodox commission agreed that the bishop of Rome held first place among the patriarchs in the first thousand years. They still disagreed about what that place allowed him to do.

In 2024 the same Vatican unity office, now called the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, gathered the answers to John Paul II's invitation. It published them in a study called The Bishop of Rome.

In 2025 Leo XIV and Bartholomew said their dialogue is now examining the issues that have historically divided them.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

For the Orthodox, the argument is about two things. Many hold that the added words are wrong about the , the one God as Father, Son and Holy Spirit: they seem to make the Son a second source of the Spirit, when the Father alone is the source.

It is also about who has the right to change the faith set out by a of the whole Church.

And they can make that case almost entirely from Western documents.

The forbade a different faith. Pope Leo III refused the addition, and had the original Creed engraved in Greek and Latin. Henry Percival, an Anglican scholar, says Leo refused because the councils forbade additions.

Rome then gave way to a German emperor in 1014. And the Council of Florence in 1439 declared the same addition lawful.

If Leo III was right in 809 and Florence was right in 1439 on the same question, the Orthodox ask, what guarantees the Catholic account of ?

Underneath the words lies a bigger complaint. The Orthodox Church in America names the biggest single reason for the : the popes pressing again their claim to authority over all the churches.

Orthodox readers add that this was the part of the Florence decree the Greek bishops could not live with once they were home.

Neither reunion council, the Orthodox add, was freely accepted. The introduction to Norman Tanner's edition of the councils' decrees says the Lyons union "appears to have been imposed, on the Greek side by the emperor Michael VIII".

It adds that "the majority of the Greek clergy opposed the union". The Orthodox account says the Greek bishops at Florence signed under "severe pressure from the Emperor and the Patriarch".

Where things stand now: at İznik in November 2025 Patriarch Bartholomew said the Creed with Pope Leo XIV in its original form. The next day the two signed a declaration naming the obstacles still to be worked through in their dialogue.

For the Orthodox, the pope's authority remains the largest of them.

Catholics of the Byzantine tradition

Some Churches in with Rome pray in Greek. They don't add the words, and Rome says they shouldn't.

The Vatican's 1995 statement on the question says the Catholic Church has refused to add kai tou Uiou, Greek for and the Son, to the Greek wording. It says the original text remains always legitimate.

For these Catholics the real question is not whether the East must adopt a Latin word. It is whether two ways of confessing the same faith can live in one communion.

Reading the documents together

No document fixes the moment communion, sharing the sacraments as one Church, ended.

The 1965 declaration, signed by both Churches, says only that a chain of events "eventually led to the effective rupture of ecclesiastical communion". The Orthodox Church in America says the schism "gradually deepened and spread" until 1204.

Read together, those two sentences describe a slow process rather than one event. They put the turning point at 1204 rather than 1054.

The judgement that the 1054 sentences were aimed at persons was itself made in 1965, by two Churches hoping to come closer.

Anglican and Protestant

Henry Percival was an Anglican scholar who edited the standard English series on the seven councils of the whole Church. He is quoted above at 809 and 1014.

He sums up the Western position in two points. First, "no pretence is made by the West that the words in dispute formed part of the original creed as adopted at Constantinople".

Second, "That so far from the insertion being made by the Pope, it was made in direct opposition to his wishes and command".

Percival writes to calm the dispute down: the West never claimed the words were original, and Rome resisted them for two centuries.

churches took no part in the quarrel of 1054. They inherited the Western Creed.

At İznik in 2025, Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, Baptist, Mennonite, Pentecostal and evangelical representatives joined the pope and the patriarch. Together they said the Creed in its original form.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself8
The documents, in order11 steps

Eleven texts, in order. Four are Western, five are Eastern, and two were signed by both sides.

One is modern: the introduction to Norman Tanner's edition of the councils' decrees.

The question at the end is not who was angrier, but when, and by what act, communion was actually lost.

  1. The clause that is not there

    381

    The Creed is known through the records of the Council of Chalcedon in 451, some seventy years later. Chalcedon credited it to the council of 381 and had it read twice.

    Its exact origin is debated. East and West both print the line on the Spirit without the words *and the Son*.

    “who proceeds from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified, who spoke by the prophets.”
    HistoricalFirst Council of Constantinople (381): Creed and CanonsCreed, clause on the Holy Spirit (Percival, NPNF2 vol. 14)The evidence ↓
  2. The Latin doctrine, before any creed was altered

    early 5th c.

    Augustine, the North African bishop, traces the Spirit's coming from the Son back to the Father. The Father begets the Son, the Church's word for how the Son comes from him. In doing so, he makes the Spirit come from the Son as well.

    This is the strongest part of the Catholic case: the teaching comes from the early Church Fathers, not from the Franks.

    “Therefore He so begot Him as that the common Gift should proceed from Him also, and the Holy Spirit should be the Spirit of both.”
  3. The canon the whole dispute turns on

    431

    Everything turns on one Greek word in the council's rule, its canon: ἑτέραν (heteran). It can mean a rival faith, or simply a different one.

    The canon also names the Creed of Nicaea in 325, not the longer Creed of 381 that carries the disputed line. That makes both readings harder to hold.

    “But those who shall dare to compose a different faith, or to introduce or offer it to persons desiring to turn to the acknowledgment of the truth, whether from Heathenism or from Judaism, or from any heresy whatsoever, shall be deposed, if they be bishops or clergymen”
  4. The Greek answer, stated as a rule

    8th c.

    John puts the Greek answer as a rule: we call the Spirit the Spirit of the Son, but he proceeds from the Father through the Son. The Father alone is the cause.

    In the old English translation below, through is a misprint for though.

    “And we speak also of the Spirit of the Son, not as through proceeding from Him, but as proceeding through Him from the Father. For the Father alone is cause.”
    InferenceAn Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, Book IAn Exposition of the Orthodox Faith I.12The evidence ↓
  5. Rome refuses, and then Rome yields

    809 and 1014

    Henry Percival was an Anglican who edited the standard English series on the councils. He reports this meeting from an old printed collection of council records.

    In 1995 the Vatican's office for Christian unity agreed with him. The words spread on their own in the West, a pope resisted them, and Rome let them in only in 1014.

    A Catholic encyclopedia of 1909 words Leo's answer differently. It says he approved the teaching but advised leaving the words out.

    Three dates are disputed. The first is when the words entered the Creed. Percival, following the church historian Hefele, says it was at the Third Council of Toledo, in Spain, in 589.

    Rome's 1995 document won't confirm that: "If these Councils did not perhaps insert it in the Symbol of Nicaea-Constantinople". The Symbol is an old name for the Creed. The document names the Council of Aquileia-Friuli in 796 as the first certain record.

    The second is the meeting with the pope. Percival dates the Aachen council to 809, while other accounts date the meeting at Rome to 810.

    The third is when Rome took up the words. The same encyclopedia says scholars disagree, though most put it under Benedict VIII (1014-15).

    “The Pope opposed the insertion of the Filioque on the express ground that the General Councils had forbidden any addition to be made to their formulary.”
    HistoricalHistorical Excursus on the Introduction into the Creed of the Words "and the Son"Excursus, under proposition 2 (the council of Aix-la-Chapelle, 809)The evidence ↓
  6. The bull of 1054, read closely

    1054

    The sentence names three men and their followers. It does not name the Eastern Church.

    Anathema Maranatha is an old, solemn form of excommunication. That sentence cut a person off from the sacraments until they repented.

    The Latin survives because Humbert kept it, and there is no separate Greek copy. The English is by a Catholic priest who is openly hostile to Cerularius in the same book.

    The Orthodox Church in America adds the hardest point against the Catholic side. Leo IX died before Humbert issued the bull, the formal papal document. The next pope "could easily have revoked Humbert's action, but he did not choose to do so".

    “That Michael, patriarch by abuse, neophyte, who only took a monk's habit by fear and is now infamous because of many very bad crimes, and with him Leo, called Bishop of Achrida, and the Sacellarius of the said Michael, who with profane feet trampled on the sacrifice of the Latins and all their followers in the aforesaid errors and presumptions shall be Anathema Maranatha … with all heretics, and with the devil and his angels, unless they repent. Amen.”
    HistoricalThe Orthodox Eastern Church, chapter 5, "The Schism of Cerularius"Chapter 5, translating Will, Acta et Scripta, pp. 153–154The evidence ↓
  7. An Eastern patriarch begs Constantinople not to break

    1054

    Peter III of Antioch was an Eastern patriarch, not a Latin. He wrote to Cerularius in the year of the quarrel.

    His letter shows that in the East a break was not felt to be certain, or already done.

    “Consider what would certainly happen if that great first and Apostolic See be divided from our holy Churches—wickedness would spread everywhere, and the whole world would be upset, the kingdoms of all the earth would be shaken, everywhere would be much woe, everywhere tears.”
    HistoricalThe Orthodox Eastern Church, chapter 5, "The Schism of Cerularius"Chapter 5, footnote 71, translating Peter III of Antioch from Will, Acta et ScriptaThe evidence ↓
  8. The event that is not in dispute

    1204

    This is the best-documented moment in the whole story. Niketas Choniates, a Greek eyewitness hostile to the crusaders, and Pope Innocent III, furious with them, describe the same atrocities within about a year of each other.

    The Orthodox Church in America's history dates the hardening of the schism here, not to 1054.

    “Nor can the violation of the Great Church be listened to with equanimity. For the sacred altar, formed of all kinds of precious materials and admired by the whole world, was broken into bits and distributed among the soldiers, as was all the other sacred wealth of so great and infinite splendor.”
    HistoricalNiketas Choniates, The Sack of Constantinople (1204)Account of the sack, on the Great ChurchThe evidence ↓
  9. How the two unions were got

    1274 and 1439

    The introduction to Norman Tanner's edition of the decrees of the councils says this in its own voice. The Lyons union appears to have been imposed by an emperor who wanted the pope's protection, and most Greek clergy opposed it.

    The Orthodox Church in America's history says the same of Florence. The Greek delegation signed under "severe pressure from the Emperor and the Patriarch", every bishop but Mark of Ephesus.

    “The union however appears to have been imposed, on the Greek side by the emperor Michael VIII. He wanted the support of the pope in order to deter Charles of Anjou from an attack on the Byzantine empire, while the majority of the Greek clergy opposed the union.”
    HistoricalSecond Council of Lyons (1274): Constitution on the procession of the Holy SpiritEditorial introduction to the council reproduced at papalencyclicals.net, paragraph beginning "The council had six general sessions"The evidence ↓
  10. What reunion was made to mean

    1439

    The same decree that calls the addition lawful also defines the pope's authority over the whole Church.

    An Orthodox reader will say this was the real argument, and the question about the Spirit was only its surface.

    “We also define that the holy apostolic see and the Roman pontiff holds the primacy over the whole world and the Roman pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter prince of the apostles, and that he is the true vicar of Christ, the head of the whole church and the father and teacher of all Christians, and to him was committed in blessed Peter the full power of tending, ruling and governing the whole church, as is contained also in the acts of ecumenical councils and in the sacred canons.”
    HistoricalCouncil of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks (1439)Laetentur caeli, session 6, clause on the Roman pontiffThe evidence ↓
  11. The limit both sides signed

    1965

    The declaration that lifts the sentences of 1054 says, in the next sentence, what lifting them does not do. Lifting the sentences did not restore communion.

    “Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I with his synod realize that this gesture of justice and mutual pardon is not sufficient to end both old and more recent differences between the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church.”
Every claim this chapter leans on9 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The creed attributed to the First Council of Constantinople in 381 says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father, and does not contain the words "and the Son". The Catechism of the Catholic Church says the same, and says that the Latin liturgy's introduction of the clause remains a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches. In 1995 the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity stated that the Catholic Church has refused to add the clause in churches, even of Latin rite, that pray the Creed in Greek.

Rests on
  • Creed, clause on the Holy Spirit (Percival, NPNF2 vol. 14)
    “And [we believe] in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver-of-Life, who proceeds from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified, who spoke by the prophets.”
  • §247
    “The affirmation of the filioque does not appear in the Creed confessed in 381 at Constantinople.”
  • §247, closing sentence
    “the introduction of the filioque into the Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed by the Latin liturgy constitutes moreover, even today, a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches.”
  • Main text, after the citation of CCC 248
    “Being aware of this, the Catholic Church has refused the addition of kai tou Uiou to the formula ek tou Patros ekporeuomenon of the Symbol of Nicaea-Constantinople in the churches, even of Latin rite, which use it in Greek. The liturgical use of this original text remains always legitimate in the Catholic Church.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Nicene Creed', paragraph on the Niceno-Constantinopolitan formula
    “Its alteration into the Nicene-Constantinopolitan formula, the one now in use, is usually ascribed to the Council of Constantinople, since the Council of Chalcedon (451), which designated this symbol as "The Creed of the Council of Constantinople of …”
    Read the full passage
    “Its alteration into the Nicene-Constantinopolitan formula, the one now in use, is usually ascribed to the Council of Constantinople, since the Council of Chalcedon (451), which designated this symbol as "The Creed of the Council of Constantinople of 381" had it twice read and inserted in its Acts. The historians Socrates, Sozomen, and Theodoret do not mention this”
Other readings
  • Catholic theology holds that the absence of the words from the creed text says nothing against the doctrine, which the Latin West confessed before 381 and which Rome regards as compatible with the Greek formula when the two vocabularies are correctly translated.
  • Orthodox theology holds that the text of an ecumenical council is not a draft to be improved, so the absence is decisive whatever the doctrine behind the addition.
Limits
  • The creed is known through the acts of the Council of Chalcedon in 451, which attributed it to the Council of Constantinople of 381 and had it read twice. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that the historians Socrates, Sozomen and Theodoret do not mention it, and that its exact origin is debated. Both East and West print it without the clause, so the gap does not favour either side.
  • The bracketed "[we believe]" and "[and]" in the translation are Percival's supplements and are not in the Greek; the "(II)" in the same paragraph is his note marker.
  • The Greek reads "to ek tou Patros ekporeuomenon", and the whole dispute turns on whether the Latin "procedit" is a fair equivalent of "ekporeuomenon".
  • The 1995 refusal to add the clause in Greek is a statement about liturgical practice and translation. It is not a retraction of the doctrine confessed at Lyons in 1274 and defined at Florence in 1439; the same document quotes Lyons with approval.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

02InferenceStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Double procession is Latin theology of the patristic period, not a Frankish novelty. In On the Trinity, written in the early fifth century, Augustine says that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son also, and adds the word "principally" to keep the Father as the source. John of Damascus, in the eighth century, gives the Greek formulation that keeps the Father as the sole cause: the Spirit proceeds through the Son, not from him. The Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity's 1995 clarification argues that the Latin and Greek terms were never exact equivalents, and that a false equivalence was created involuntarily when the Latins translated the Greek creed.

Rests on
  • On the Trinity XV.17.29 (NPNF1 vol. 3, trans. Haddan)
    “God the Father alone is He from whom the Word is born, and from whom the Holy Spirit principally proceeds. And therefore I have added the word principally, because we find that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son also.”
  • An Exposition of the Orthodox Faith I.12 (NPNF2 vol. 9, trans. Salmond)
    “And we speak also of the Spirit of the Son, not as through proceeding from Him, but as proceeding through Him from the Father. For the Father alone is cause.”
  • Main text, paragraph on the Western Fathers before Chalcedon
    “In the meantime, on the basis of the earlier Latin theological tradition, Fathers of the Church of the West like St. Hilary, St. Ambrose, St. Augustine and St. Leo the Great, had confessed that the Holy Spirit proceeds (procedit) eternally from the Father and the Son.”
  • Main text, on the Latin translation of Jn 15:26 and of the Symbol
    “In this way, a false equivalence was involuntarily created with regard to the eternal origin of the Spirit between the Oriental theology of the ekporeusis and the Latin theology of the processio. The Greek ekporeusis signifies only the relationship …”
    Read the full passage
    “In this way, a false equivalence was involuntarily created with regard to the eternal origin of the Spirit between the Oriental theology of the ekporeusis and the Latin theology of the processio. The Greek ekporeusis signifies only the relationship of origin to the Father alone as the principle without principle of the Trinity. The Latin processio, on the contrary, is a more common term, signifying the communication of the consubstantial divinity from the Father to the Son and from the Father, through and with the Son, to the Holy Spirit.”
Other readings
  • Orthodox theology holds that the Latin formula, however ancient, endangers the monarchy of the Father unless it is stated as procession through the Son, and that Augustine's own safeguard "principally" is precisely what the later Latin creed dropped.
  • An Orthodox reader can accept part of the translation argument and still find it too convenient: calling the rupture a linguistic accident leaves untouched the question of who may amend a creed.
Limits
  • Augustine is writing a treatise, not a creed. Roughly two centuries separate this theology from anyone putting the words into a creed, and roughly six centuries separate it from Rome singing them.
  • That the Latin West held double procession does not show that the Greek East ever received that theology as belonging in the Creed.
  • New Advent prints "not as through proceeding from Him" in the Damascene passage. The reading "not as though proceeding from Him" is what the sense requires, but no printed copy of Salmond's translation was checked for this claim, so the text is quoted as New Advent prints it.
  • Chapter and section numbering for De Trinitate follows New Advent's rendering of NPNF1 vol. 3 (chapter 17, section 29); other editions cite this passage differently.
  • The 1995 document's word "involuntarily" does heavy work: it makes part of the dispute a translation accident. It is a Catholic clarification, not an agreed statement, and Orthodox readers are not bound by it.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

03HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Part of the dispute is about authority, not the Trinity: whether any church may add to the creed of an ecumenical council. Canon 7 of the Council of Ephesus (431) makes it unlawful to bring forward, write or compose a different faith as a rival to the one established at Nicaea. The Eastern objection, as the 1909 Catholic Encyclopedia states it, was that Rome had overstepped her rights by disobeying that injunction. The Catholic answer, in the same article and in the Anglican editor Henry Percival, is that the councils forbade a different faith or creed, not an explanation of the same faith; and the Council of Florence defined in 1439 that the words were licitly and reasonably added.

Rests on
  • Canon 7 (Percival, NPNF2 vol. 14)
    “When these things had been read, the holy Synod decreed that it is unlawful for any man to bring forward, or to write, or to compose a different (ἑτέραν) Faith as a rival to that established by the holy Fathers assembled with the Holy Ghost in Nicæa.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Filioque', closing paragraphs
    “Had not Rome overstepped her rights by disobeying the injunction of the Third Council, of Ephesus (431), and of the Fourth, of Chalcedon (451)?”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Filioque', closing paragraphs
    “It is true that these councils had forbidden to introduce another faith or another Creed, and had imposed the penalty of deposition on bishops and clerics, and of excommunication on monks and laymen for transgressing this law; but the councils had not forbidden to explain the same faith or to propose the same Creed in a clearer way.”
  • Excursus, under proposition 4, on the Ephesine decree
    “But while this is the case it might be that they understood ἑτέραν of the Ephesine decree to forbid the making of contradictory and new creeds and not explanatory additions to the existing one. Of this interpretation of the decree, which would seem without any doubt to be the only tenable one, I shall treat in its proper place.”
  • Laetentur caeli, session 6, 6 July 1439, clause on the addition to the creed
    “We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need.”
  • Excursus, proposition 1
    “That no pretence is made by the West that the words in dispute formed part of the original creed as adopted at Constantinople, or that they now form part of that Creed.”
  • The paragraph beginning "From the Eastern Orthodox perspective"
    “From the Eastern Orthodox perspective, however, the biggest single reason for the Great Schism was the reassertion of Papal claims to have jurisdictional authority over all the Churches of Christendom.”
Other readings
  • Orthodox: the canon means what it says. No local council, no emperor and no single see may add to the faith of an ecumenical council, and a doctrine that may be true is still not thereby creedal.
  • Catholic: the canon forbids a rival faith, not a clarification of the one faith, and the same council's fathers would not have recognised an explanatory phrase as a "different" creed. Florence settled the question with conciliar authority.
  • Percival, editing the standard English series, notes that the fathers of the Third Council of Toledo cited this very canon, and argues, with Pusey, that they cannot have believed they were breaking it.
Limits
  • The canon speaks of the creed of Nicaea in 325, not of the creed of 381 that carries the disputed clause. Strictly, this complicates both readings.
  • Percival is an Anglican editor writing inside a Protestant-published critical series and is openly trying to lower the temperature of the dispute, so his handling of the Greek is an argument rather than a neutral report.
  • His first proposition is nonetheless a real concession for the Orthodox side of the argument, and his second is sharper still: the insertion was made in direct opposition to the pope's wishes and command.
  • The 1909 encyclopedia states the Eastern objection in order to answer it, and puts it down to national resentment of Rome. That motive is its author's judgement, not the Orthodox account of the matter.
  • No quotation from Photios or another Orthodox writer stating the objection in his own words was read for this claim, so the Eastern case is reported through a Catholic and an Anglican writer, and through the Orthodox Church in America's general judgement on authority.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

04HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

The Filioque entered the creed in the West through local councils and usage, not through any ecumenical council, and against the express refusal of a pope. In 809 Leo III received envoys from a council Charlemagne held at Aachen and opposed the insertion, on the ground that the general councils had forbidden additions to their formulary; Percival reports that he had the unaltered creed engraved in Latin and in Greek on two silver shields at St Peter's. Rome first used the altered creed at Mass in 1014, under Benedict VIII. The Holy See's own 1995 clarification says the same: the clause spread spontaneously in the West, Leo III resisted it, and Rome admitted it only in 1014.

Rests on
  • Excursus, under proposition 2 (the council of Aix-la-Chapelle, 809)
    “The Pope opposed the insertion of the Filioque on the express ground that the General Councils had forbidden any addition to be made to their formulary.”
  • Excursus, under proposition 2, on the silver shields and on 1014
    “So firmly resolved was the Pope that the clause should not be introduced into the creed that he presented two silver shields to the Confessio in St. Peter’s at Rome, on one of which was engraved the creed in Latin and on the other in Greek, without the addition. This act the Greeks never forgot during the controversy.”
  • Excursus, under proposition 2, on 1014
    “It was not till 1014 that for the first time the interpolated creed was used at mass with the sanction of the Pope. In that year Benedict VIII. acceded to the urgent request of Henry II. of Germany and so the papal authority was forced to yield”
  • Main text, the paragraph tracing the Filioque from Toledo to 1014
    “In the ninth century, however, faced with Charlemagne, Pope Leo III, in his anxiety to preserve unity with the Orient in the confession of faith, resisted this development of the Symbol which had spread spontaneously in the West, while safeguarding …”
    Read the full passage
    “In the ninth century, however, faced with Charlemagne, Pope Leo III, in his anxiety to preserve unity with the Orient in the confession of faith, resisted this development of the Symbol which had spread spontaneously in the West, while safeguarding the truth contained in the Filioque. Rome only admitted it in 1014 into the liturgical Latin version of the Creed.”
  • Opening paragraphs
    “Then in 1014, the Roman Church, after resisting for over 200 years Germanic pressure to adopt the filioque, finally used this addition to the Creed in public worship for the first time—at the coronation of Henry II as Holy Roman Emperor. Ironically, …”
    Read the full passage
    “Then in 1014, the Roman Church, after resisting for over 200 years Germanic pressure to adopt the filioque, finally used this addition to the Creed in public worship for the first time—at the coronation of Henry II as Holy Roman Emperor. Ironically, forty years later the Latin Christians would accuse the Greek Christians of being heretical for not using the filioque.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Filioque', paragraph on the history of the addition
    “In 796 the Patriarch of Aquileia justified and adopted the same addition at the Synod of Friaul, and in 809 the Council of Aachen appears to have approved of it. The decrees of this last council were examined by Pope Leo III, who approved of the …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 796 the Patriarch of Aquileia justified and adopted the same addition at the Synod of Friaul, and in 809 the Council of Aachen appears to have approved of it. The decrees of this last council were examined by Pope Leo III, who approved of the doctrine conveyed by the Filioque, but gave the advice to omit the expression in the Creed. The practice of adding the Filioque was retained in spite of the papal advice, and in the middle of the eleventh century it had gained a firm foothold in Rome itself. Scholars do not agree as to the exact time of its introduction into Rome, but most assign it to the reign of Benedict VIII (1014-15).”
Other readings
  • Catholic theology answers that the West never taught a doctrine contrary to the Greek formula, and that Leo III's refusal was a judgement about prudence and unity, not about truth. The Council of Florence later judged the addition licit and necessary.
  • Orthodox theology answers that a pope who refused on the express ground that councils forbade additions was making a judgement about lawfulness, and that a later council cannot make lawful what was unlawful when it was done.
Limits
  • The 809 conference is reported here at second hand. Percival cites Labbe and Cossart, and the Frankish notary's own report was not retrieved for this chapter.
  • The two Catholic and Anglican accounts word Leo III's answer differently. Percival says he opposed the insertion on the ground that the councils forbade additions; the 1909 Catholic Encyclopedia says he approved the doctrine but advised omitting the words. Both agree he did not want them in the creed.
  • All the witnesses for the 1014 date are modern. No eleventh-century document for the event was retrieved, and the Catholic Encyclopedia says scholars do not agree on the exact time, though most assign it to Benedict VIII (1014-15). The date is cited as that majority view, which Catholic, Orthodox and Anglican sources here share, not as a read primary fact.
  • Whether the Third Council of Toledo in 589 put the clause into the text of the creed is disputed. Percival, following Hefele, dates the creedal insertion there; the Pontifical Council's 1995 document says the Toledo councils "did not perhaps insert it" and gives the Council of Aquileia-Friuli in 796 as the first certain attestation. The spread between the earliest witnesses is about two hundred years.
  • The OCA's account of Pope Sergius IV and the removal of Rome from the diptychs in 1009 is not used in this chapter, because no contemporary document for it was retrieved.
  • The silver shields reach this chapter only through Percival's 1900 excursus. He reports that Photios referred to them, that Peter Damian about two centuries later mentions them as still in place, and that Veccus (whom he calls "Veccur"), Patriarch of Constantinople, about two centuries after that declared they still hung there. That is corroboration from both sides of the controversy, but none of the three texts was read.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

05HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

The excommunications of 1054 were personal, not church-wide. The bull Humbert laid on the altar of Hagia Sophia on 16 July 1054 names Michael Cerularius, Leo of Achrida, a court official and their followers, and in the same document calls the city most Christian and Orthodox; the patriarch's reply excommunicated the legates and those responsible for the bull. In 1965 the Catholic and Orthodox churches jointly stated that the censures had been directed against the persons concerned and not the Churches, and were not intended to break ecclesiastical communion.

Rests on
  • Chapter 5, translating the bull from Will, Acta et Scripta, pp. 153–154
    “As far as the pillars of the Empire are concerned, and its wise and honoured citizens, this city is most Christian and Orthodox.”
  • Chapter 5, immediately after the bull
    “We should note that this is the only sentence that the Roman Church pronounced against the Eastern Communion. She has never excommunicated it as such, nor the other patriarchs.”
  • Paragraphs on Humbert's legation and its aftermath
    “After waiting about two months in the capital, on July 16, 1054, Humbert strode into the great cathedral of Hagia Sophia during a service and placed on the altar a bull of excommunication against "Patriarch Michael and all his followers." In a day …”
    Read the full passage
    “After waiting about two months in the capital, on July 16, 1054, Humbert strode into the great cathedral of Hagia Sophia during a service and placed on the altar a bull of excommunication against "Patriarch Michael and all his followers." In a day or two, he and his fellow legates left for home. Michael, in his turn, excommunicated Humbert "and all those responsible" for the bull of excommunication against him.”
  • Joint Declaration, §3
    “They had directed their censures against the persons concerned and not the Churches. These censures were not intended to break ecclesiastical communion between the Sees of Rome and Constantinople.”
  • Joint Declaration, §4 C
    “Finally, they deplore the preceding and later vexing events which, under the influence of various factors—among which, lack of understanding and mutual trust—eventually led to the effective rupture of ecclesiastical communion.”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox account holds that what mattered in 1054 was not the bull but the Roman claim behind it. The OCA names the reassertion of papal jurisdictional authority over all the churches as the biggest single reason for the schism.
  • Peter III of Antioch, writing in 1054, begged Cerularius to give way rather than divide from Rome, which shows that the East itself did not regard a rupture as inevitable. In the same letter, as Fortescue renders it, Peter calls the Latins "our brothers" whose "rusticity and stupidity often make them behave indecently", so the letter is not a pro-Roman document.
  • Most academic historians treat 1054 as a quarrel between two hard men that later generations promoted into a date, and locate the real break in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.
Limits
  • The bull survives because its author kept it. There is no independent Greek copy, Cerularius's synod alleged that the legates circulated a corrupted translation, and the only English text used here is by Adrian Fortescue, a Catholic priest writing an openly polemical book.
  • Fortescue's further claim, that the other patriarchs lost Rome's communion because they struck the pope's name from their own diptychs, is a partisan assignment of blame and is not used in this chapter as fact.
  • The 1965 judgement that the censures were not intended to break communion is an ecclesial statement made 911 years after the event by two parties with an obvious interest in minimising it, and it hedges with "insofar as we can judge". That the bull names persons is a fact about the text; that it was not meant to break communion is an inference both churches agreed to make in 1965.
  • The OCA states that Leo IX died before Humbert issued the bull and that his successor Victor II did not revoke it, which would mean the legates' commission had arguably lapsed. No primary document for Leo IX's death date was retrieved, so this is reported as the OCA's account and not asserted flatly.
  • No document used in this chapter fixes the date at which communion actually ended.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The sack of Constantinople in April 1204 by the army of the Fourth Crusade, not the exchange of censures in 1054, is what made the division permanent in memory. A Byzantine eyewitness and Pope Innocent III describe the same atrocities within about a year of each other, and the Orthodox Church in America's own history says the schism gradually deepened and spread until 1204 left later efforts at reconciliation with virtually no chance of success.

Rests on
  • Account of the sack, on the Great Church (trans. D. C. Munro, 1912)
    “Nor can the violation of the Great Church be listened to with equanimity. For the sacred altar, formed of all kinds of precious materials and admired by the whole world, was broken into bits and distributed among the soldiers, as was all the other sacred wealth of so great and infinite splendor.”
  • Letter to Peter, Cardinal Priest of St Marcellus, given 12 July 1205 (Fordham, trans. Brundage; also cited as Register 8:126)
    “How, indeed, is the Greek church to be brought back into ecclesiastical union and to a devotion for the Apostolic See when she has been beset with so many afflictions and persecutions that she sees in the Latins only an example of perdition and the works of darkness, so that she now, and with reason, detests the Latins more than dogs?”
  • Editorial headnote above the letter, Internet Medieval Sourcebook, adapting Brundage
    “Despite these bitter words, there was little that the Pope could do to alter what had happened and so, as his initial anger subsided, Innocent first recognized and then embraced the new order in Constantinople.”
  • Paragraph on the aftermath of 1054
    “And while relations between some of the Eastern Churches with Rome continued to be relatively friendly for quite some time, the reality and extent of the schism gradually deepened and spread, until the sack of Constantinople and its conquest by the …”
    Read the full passage
    “And while relations between some of the Eastern Churches with Rome continued to be relatively friendly for quite some time, the reality and extent of the schism gradually deepened and spread, until the sack of Constantinople and its conquest by the Latin knights of the Fourth Crusade in 1204 increased the mutual animosity to such a degree that future efforts at reconciliation had virtually no chance to succeed.”
  • §3
    “It is tragic that the assailants, who had set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their own brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.”
  • §3
    “In particular, on this occasion we cannot forget what happened during the month of April 1204. An army that had set out to recover the Holy Land for Christendom marched on Constantinople, took it and sacked it, pouring out the blood of our own brothers and sisters in the faith.”
Other readings
  • Catholics point out that the papacy neither ordered, approved nor benefited from the sack, and that Innocent III's letter is a furious reproach to his own legate rather than a defence of the army.
  • Orthodox readers answer that the letter was private correspondence, that Rome then accepted the results, and that a Latin patriarchate in Constantinople was the visible form of that acceptance.
Limits
  • The papacy condemned the sack and then accepted its results. That Innocent first recognized and then embraced the new order in Constantinople is stated by the Fordham editor adapting Brundage, which is a modern editorial headnote and not a source; a scholarly monograph should be substituted for it. A Latin patriarch sat in Constantinople for fifty-seven years.
  • Between Innocent III in 1205 and John Paul II at Athens in 2001 no papal statement of regret for the sack was retrieved for this chapter. The 796-year silence is part of the evidence.
  • The 2001 and 2004 statements express regret, indignation and sorrow rather than an admission of corporate Latin guilt, and neither is a formal act of the magisterium. Orthodox commentators noted at the time that the 2004 address does not name the Latin patriarchate that followed the sack.
  • Choniates is an eyewitness and also a displaced Byzantine official writing partly to explain a catastrophe, and parts of the same passage are rhetorical set pieces of a kind Byzantine historians used.
  • The Fordham electronic texts of both Choniates and Innocent III carry visible OCR damage. Passages with corrupted words have been avoided here rather than silently corrected.
  • What the sources do not record is the mechanism by which 1204 ended communion. No single document states that.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Both reunion councils defined the Western position and neither union held. Lyons in 1274 professed that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son as from one principle, and condemned those who denied it. Florence in 1439 defined that the words "and from the Son" were licitly and reasonably added to the creed, and in the same decree defined that the Roman pontiff holds the primacy over the whole world and the full power of tending, ruling and governing the whole church. According to the Orthodox Church in America's history, every bishop in the Greek delegation at Florence signed except Mark of Ephesus, and the union was not proclaimed in Hagia Sophia until 12 December 1452, as the Ottoman armies gathered. The Orthodox churches never received it.

Rests on
  • Constitutions II.1, "On the supreme Trinity and the catholic faith" (translation reproduced at papalencyclicals.net)
    “We profess faithfully and devotedly that the holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father and the Son, not as from two principles, but as from one principle; not by two spirations, but by one single spiration.”
  • Constitutions II.1, "On the supreme Trinity and the catholic faith", closing sentence
    “But because some, on account of ignorance of the said indisputable truth, have fallen into various errors, we, wishing to close the way to such errors, with the approval of the sacred council, condemn and reprove all who presume to deny that the …”
    Read the full passage
    “But because some, on account of ignorance of the said indisputable truth, have fallen into various errors, we, wishing to close the way to such errors, with the approval of the sacred council, condemn and reprove all who presume to deny that the holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father and the Son, or rashly to assert that the holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son as from two principles and not as from one.”
  • Editorial introduction to the council reproduced at papalencyclicals.net, paragraph beginning "The council had six general sessions"
    “The union however appears to have been imposed, on the Greek side by the emperor Michael VIII. He wanted the support of the pope in order to deter Charles of Anjou from an attack on the Byzantine empire, while the majority of the Greek clergy opposed the union.”
  • Laetentur caeli, session 6, 6 July 1439, clause on the addition to the creed
    “We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake of declaring the truth and from imminent need.”
  • Laetentur caeli, session 6, the definition on the procession
    “We declare that when holy doctors and fathers say that the holy Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son, this bears the sense that thereby also the Son should be signified, according to the Greeks indeed as cause, and according to the Latins as principle of the subsistence of the holy Spirit, just like the Father.”
  • Laetentur caeli, session 6, 6 July 1439, clause on the Roman pontiff
    “We also define that the holy apostolic see and the Roman pontiff holds the primacy over the whole world and the Roman pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter prince of the apostles, and that he is the true vicar of Christ, the head of the whole …”
    Read the full passage
    “We also define that the holy apostolic see and the Roman pontiff holds the primacy over the whole world and the Roman pontiff is the successor of blessed Peter prince of the apostles, and that he is the true vicar of Christ, the head of the whole church and the father and teacher of all Christians, and to him was committed in blessed Peter the full power of tending, ruling and governing the whole church, as is contained also in the acts of ecumenical councils and in the sacred canons.”
  • Section "The Council of Florence"
    “Under severe pressure from the Emperor and the Patriarch, every bishop in the Greek delegation signed this so-called “Decree for the Greeks” promulgated at the Council of Florence—all except Saint Mark, Bishop of Ephesus. When told that Mark had refused to sign, Pope Eugenius is reputed to have said, “Then we have accomplished nothing.””
  • Section "The Council of Florence", on the proclamation of the union
    “The Union of Florence was not publicly proclaimed in the Eastern Church until December 12, 1452, in the Cathedral of Hagia Sophia in Constantinople, as the Turks were amassing their forces to begin their siege of the city.”
  • Excursus, under proposition 3
    “And what this was is evident from the definition of the Council of Florence, which, while indeed it was not received by the Eastern Church, and therefore cannot be accepted as an authoritative exposition of its views, yet certainly must be regarded as a true and full expression of the teaching of the West.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Filioque', on Lyons and Florence
    “But however sincere the individual Greek bishops may have been, they failed to carry their people with them, and the breach between East and West continues to this day.”
Other readings
  • Catholics hold both councils to be ecumenical and their definitions binding, and read the failure of the unions as a political and pastoral failure rather than a doctrinal one.
  • Orthodox theology holds that a union agreed under imperial pressure and rejected by the body of the faithful was never a union at all, and that the Florentine phrase "according to the Greeks indeed as cause" concedes to the Latins exactly what Greek theology reserves to the Father.
  • An Orthodox reader, following the OCA's judgement that papal jurisdiction was the biggest single reason for the schism, adds that the decisive clause of the decree was the one on the Roman pontiff, not the one on the Spirit, and reads that as the reason the delegations could not hold to it once they were home.
Limits
  • That the Lyons union was imposed by Michael VIII over the objection of most Greek clergy is stated in the editorial introduction to the edition of the decrees edited by Norman Tanner, which hedges with "appears to have been". It is editorial matter and must not be attributed to the council itself.
  • The OCA page hedges Eugenius IV's reported line about Mark of Ephesus with "is reputed to have said", and no contemporary source for it was retrieved. The hedge is kept here.
  • The Catechism dates the Florentine explanation to 1438 while the decree Laetentur caeli is dated 6 July 1439. This chapter follows the decree's own date.
  • The OCA pages are confessional Orthodox catechesis rather than critical history. The datable facts taken from them here, one non-signatory and the proclamation of 12 December 1452, were not checked against a second source.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 7 December 1965 Paul VI and Athenagoras I removed the sentences of excommunication of 1054 from memory and from the midst of the Church and committed them to oblivion. The same declaration says the gesture is not sufficient to end the differences between the two churches, and Ut Unum Sint calls the lifting a very significant step on the way towards full communion rather than communion itself. John Paul II read the 1054 excommunications as having become the symbol of the schism rather than its cause, and asked other Christians to help him find a way of exercising the primacy that is open to a new situation. The two churches are not in communion today.

Rests on
  • Joint Declaration, §4 B
    “They likewise regret and remove both from memory and from the midst of the Church the sentences of excommunication which followed these events, the memory of which has influenced actions up to our day and has hindered closer relations in charity; and they commit these excommunications to oblivion.”
  • Joint Declaration, §5
    “Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I with his synod realize that this gesture of justice and mutual pardon is not sufficient to end both old and more recent differences between the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church.”
  • §52
    “The resulting change found its historical expression in the ecclesial act whereby "there was removed from memory and from the midst of the Church" the remembrance of the excommunications which nine hundred years before, in 1054, had become the symbol of the schism between Rome and Constantinople.”
  • §56
    “the lifting of the mutual excommunications, by eliminating a painful canonical and psychological obstacle, was a very significant step on the way towards full communion.”
  • §95, second paragraph
    “I am convinced that I have a particular responsibility in this regard, above all in acknowledging the ecumenical aspirations of the majority of the Christian Communities and in heeding the request made of me to find a way of exercising the primacy …”
    Read the full passage
    “I am convinced that I have a particular responsibility in this regard, above all in acknowledging the ecumenical aspirations of the majority of the Christian Communities and in heeding the request made of me to find a way of exercising the primacy which, while in no way renouncing what is essential to its mission, is nonetheless open to a new situation.”
  • §95, third paragraph, quoting John Paul II's earlier address to Dimitrios I
    “for a great variety of reasons, and against the will of all concerned, what should have been a service sometimes manifested itself in a very different light.”
Other readings
  • Many Orthodox theologians reply that the invitation in Ut Unum Sint 95 concerns the manner of exercising the primacy and leaves the definitions of the First Vatican Council untouched, which is why they do not regard it as going far enough.
  • Some Orthodox readers regard the 1965 act as a gesture between two sees that could not, by itself, bind the other Orthodox churches.
Limits
  • The 1965 act lifts anathemas. It does not restore communion, and the signatories say so in the same document.
  • The reading of 1054 as a symbol rather than a cause is a papal judgement made in 1995 about an event in 1054, and both churches had an interest in minimising the 1054 quarrel.
  • No joint Catholic-Orthodox text later than 1965 was retrieved for this chapter, including the 2007 Ravenna document, so nothing is said here about where the theological dialogue currently stands.
  • Footnote markers appearing inline in the vatican.va HTML have been removed from these quotations.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

09HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 28 November 2025, at İznik (ancient Nicaea), for the 1,700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea, Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew prayed together with other Christian leaders and recited the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed together without the filioque. The next day they signed a joint declaration naming the faith of Nicaea as what binds them and the obstacles to full communion as matters for theological dialogue. The Russian Orthodox Church was not represented.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Some Catholics read the omission as a courtesy at an ecumenical service, not a change of teaching; the Catechism still teaches that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. Some Orthodox read it as a sign that the addition is negotiable.
Limits
  • The Vatican's own bulletin records a choral recitation of the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed but does not itself say which form; the absence of the filioque rests on the Catholic News Service report from the scene.
  • The prayer and the declaration did not restore communion.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

Questions people ask next