Why not Protestant, or Orthodox?
This is where Scripture alone leads, the line that never stopped, and what still divides us from the Orthodox.
Why I’m Catholic, and not or , is my own opinion, not a finding of the research.
I owe Protestants a lot, and I mean that.
They got me reading the seriously.
They keep asking the question every Catholic needs to hear: does this tradition really come from Jesus, or did we just get used to it?
I’m especially grateful to a Protestant ex-colleague of mine.
She kept asking me questions like that, in detail, and she wouldn’t let me get away with a lazy answer.
That pushed me to research far more deeply than I would have on my own.
She used an analogy I will never forget: faith is like an onion.
You keep peeling back the layers until you get to the core. That line is one of the reasons this site exists.
Protestants make sure tradition never buries Scripture.
Their churches began in the 1500s with the Reformation, when reformers like broke with Rome over what they saw as its errors.
And looking back, I believe God used the Reformation to carry the gospel and the Bible into corners of the world that might never have heard it.
The Catholic Church says it clearly too: everyone into is a brother or sister in the Lord, and God works through the Protestant churches as well.
Protestants are not outsiders to me. We’re one body in Christ through baptism.
But when I asked “who decides?”, the Protestant answer was Scripture as the final authority, with creeds and teachers to help.
The trouble is, the Protestant churches have no one shared way to settle what the Bible means. So when they read it differently, each church ends up following its own reading.
And I could see where that leads, because I could see it on the River, the timeline of Christian history on this site.
Everyone reads the same Bible honestly, and everyone lands somewhere slightly different.
The Bible never changes; our readings of it do. And the Bible doesn’t come with its own table of contents.
The early Church put that list of books together. In the end I couldn’t make work without quietly leaning on the Church that handed Scripture to me.
Sincere Christians read the same Bible and land in different places. Why do you think that happens?
Pick an answer below.
And there’s one more thing, and for me it’s the big one.
All through the Bible, God’s plan to rescue us ran through one line of people, from to King David to Jesus. That line never stopped.
Luke’s , one of the four accounts of Jesus’s life, traces his family tree all the way back to , the first man in the Bible’s story.
Then Jesus chose twelve and gave them his own authority. He told the followers he sent out: whoever listens to you listens to me.
Before they died, the apostles placed their hands on the next men to carry it on, which was the sign of handing on their authority. Those men did the same.
Every bishop in the Catholic Church today stands in that line, and so does every bishop in the Orthodox churches of the East.
Many of those lines are documented a long way back, though the earliest records are patchy. Catholics and the Orthodox call it apostolic succession.
And in every generation, the ’ job has been the same: interpret Scripture faithfully, and hand on what the apostles taught without adding to it or losing it.
And when a hard question comes up, settle it, with the , the bishop of Rome, as the point where it all holds together.
Here’s the part that matters most to me.
It isn’t faith in men. It’s faith in God.
Jesus promised that the , God himself, would guide his Church into all truth, and that the gates of , meaning the powers of death and evil, would not win against it.
The men in that line have been sinners, and some of them were terrible. The Spirit guarding the line is the reason it has held anyway.
The way I see it, two thousand years of history says it all.
It’s a structure run by flawed people. It has come through corruption, (churches splitting apart), empires and persecution.
Rome has had splits of its own. For almost 40 years, from 1378, two and then three men each claimed to be pope, until a ended it in 1417.
And it still hasn’t fallen apart. That, to me, is the sign that this is the structure God intended.
Honestly, the Orthodox question was the closer one.
The Orthodox are truly our brothers and sisters.
They kept the bishops going back to the apostles, the , the ancient (their way of worship), the saints, and a deep love for Mary, Jesus’s mother.
The Catholic Church teaches that their sacraments are real, and in some situations it lets Catholics receive them.
Most Orthodox churches don’t do the same. For them, sharing is a sign that two churches already share one faith, and we don’t yet.
It shows how deep the split still runs. But in so many ways we’re very close.
What the Orthodox don’t have, as I see it, is the one role Jesus gave , the leader of his apostles.
They’d say the bishop of Rome once had first place of honour among the bishops, but never authority over all the others.
The Orthodox settle disputes through councils, and they’ve done it well for centuries.
Their churches are organised by place, the ancient way, and over time most have come to run along national lines: Greek, Russian, Serbian and more.
That gives each one deep roots in its own people. But when two of them fall out, as Moscow and Constantinople did in 2018, there’s no one above them both to bring them back to the table.
The Orthodox would say their unity lives in one shared faith, not in one man. As I see it, that’s where one shepherd would help.
Churches organised by nation can also end up leaning on their nation’s rulers.
To be fair, the Catholic Church learned that lesson the hard way too, back when popes ruled as kings over a large part of Italy, right up to 1870.
When East and West split in 1054, both sides kept almost everything.
But two things that mattered a lot divided them: what the pope is, and a word the West added to the creed.
The creed is the short statement of what Christians believe. The West added that the Holy Spirit comes from the Father and the Son.
To this day, each side believes the other was the one who walked away.
Catholics say the East broke from the pope. The Orthodox say Rome broke away, by changing the creed and claiming more than the first popes had.
I just came to believe that the unity Jesus prayed for needs someone whose job is to hold it together.
And I came to believe that Jesus gave that job to Peter and to those who came after him.
Where there’s no one in Peter’s role, you can watch what happens on the River on this site.
East and West drift apart and stay apart; the Orthodox kept one faith, but apart from Rome.
The Reformation splits, then the splits split, and the branching never stops.
To be fair, the River also shows churches finding their way back together.
Yet if you trace any of those branches back far enough, they all run into the same trunk.
It’s a Church that received the word of God and has kept handing it on, with Scripture, and the teaching office still there.
The gates of hell have not won, and I don’t believe they will.
None of this makes Protestants or Orthodox any less Christian. The trouble starts when one of us judges and condemns the other.
That’s pride, not faith.
And if a day ever comes when Christians everywhere are persecuted, I hope nobody asks “Are you Catholic, Orthodox or Protestant?”
I hope we just say: Christ is Lord. Come take shelter with us.
What would help Christians find their way back to each other?
Pick an answer below.