From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/luther-now
← Protestant or evangelicalWhat does the Catholic Church think of Martin Luther now?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minThe Catholic Church sees Luther far more warmly than it used to. Popes and official Catholic-Lutheran reports now call him a man of deep faith who wanted to fix the Church, not split it. They say he was right about real abuses. Catholics still disagree with him about the Church, the and the .
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 1471–1473
- Vatican II
- Unitatis Redintegratio, 6
- Council of Trent
- Session 25, Decree on Indulgences
For about 400 years, Catholic books painted as a runaway monk and a heretic. Protestants painted the mirror image: Luther the hero who freed people from a corrupt Rome.1
So does the Catholic Church still see him as the villain? No. And the change is bigger than most people know.
In the 1900s, Catholic historians sat down and read Luther carefully. What they found was an earnest religious person and conscientious man of prayer.1
What happened in 1517
In 1517 Luther was a monk and a teacher in Germany. He objected to how were being promoted to ordinary people.
An indulgence is a release from what the calls the temporal punishment still due for God has already forgiven.8 Put simply: forgiveness takes away the guilt, but sin still leaves damage and consequences behind, and those still need healing.8
Back then, people often paid money to get one. Luther asked why that money wasn't going to the poor.1
The row grew into a fight about who had the final say. In 1521 the pope excommunicated him, cutting him off from the sacraments.1
What Luther was right about
Catholics now say openly that the abuses were real. And they said it early. In 1522, just five years in, the new pope admitted abuses and trespasses, sins and errors by church leaders.1
Then in 1563 the ordered that all evil gains from indulgences be wholly abolished.2 It was fixing the very abuse Luther had protested. But Trent didn't drop indulgences. It said they were to be kept, and it condemned anyone who called them useless.2
In 2016, chatting with reporters on a plane, Pope Francis said Martin Luther's intentions were not mistaken, though perhaps some of his methods were not right.3 That was an off-the-cuff answer, not official teaching. But it shows how far things have moved.
Think of it like this
Think of a young accountant at a big company. One day he spots something wrong. Customers are being overcharged, and the extra money is quietly flowing upwards.
He writes a memo to the bosses. He's not trying to bring the company down. He loves the place. He just wants it fixed.
The bosses handle it badly. They get defensive and tell him to back off. He refuses, and gets louder. Both sides say things they shouldn't. In the end the bosses show him the door, and half the staff go with him to start a new firm across the road.
Fifty years later, both companies are still going. And now they can sit down and say it together: he was right about the overcharging, and the old company did fix it after he left. What they still disagree about is deeper: what the company is really selling, how it should be run, and who gets the final say.
A German pope in Luther's monastery
In 2011 Pope Benedict XVI, himself a German, stood in the very monastery where Luther had lived as a young monk.4
He talked about the question that drove Luther's whole life: How do I receive the of God? In other words, how can someone like me be right with God?
And the pope said that this question never ceases to make a deep impression on me.4 He also admitted that back then, both sides could only see what divided us.4
Luther's question was a good one, and it's still everyone's question.
Agreed on the heart of it
In 2013, Catholic and Lutheran scholars, in official talks, wrote a report together. It says Catholics now recognise that Luther meant to reform the Church, not divide it. It calls him a witness to the gospel.1
And on the question that started it all, how a sinner is put right with God, Catholics and Lutherans now agree on the basics. In 1999 they signed a joint statement saying we're accepted by God through grace and faith in , not through anything we've earned.5
How can the Catholic Church say all this without giving up its own beliefs? Because it believes Christ summons the Church to continual reformation, all the way through its journey on earth.6 Admitting faults in how the faith was lived and explained isn't the same as changing the faith.
In 2016, Pope Francis and the Lutheran World Federation, the worldwide family of Lutheran churches, signed a joint statement in Lund, Sweden. It says thank you and sorry in one breath:
While we are profoundly thankful for the spiritual and theological gifts received through the Reformation, we also confess and lament before Christ that Lutherans and Catholics have wounded the visible unity of the Church.
Luther's dark side
To be honest, there's another side to Luther, and Lutherans say it themselves. They're ashamed of his vicious and degrading statements against Jews.1
They regret his violent attacks on the peasants who rebelled in his day, and his backing for the persecution of Anabaptists, Christians who only adults.1
Did every Protestant church come from Luther?
Not directly. Luther's protest opened the door in the 1500s, but many churches began later, with other leaders and other revivals.
Baptist churches, for example, began in 1609, among English Christians who had fled to Amsterdam.9
Pentecostal churches are younger still. They began in the early 1900s, in revivals in the US. Most of the first Pentecostals came from Methodist and Baptist churches, two other Protestant families.10
In 1901, at a small Bible college in Kansas, a student began to speak in tongues: praying aloud in a language never learned.10
In 1906 a revival, a burst of new faith, broke out on Azusa Street in Los Angeles, and spread around the world.10
Many who spoke in tongues were pushed out of their old churches, so they formed their own.10
So are Pentecostals part of what Luther started? Only in a way. They're counted among the Protestant churches, but began almost 400 years after him.10 The River, the timeline on this site, tells their story in full.
Why still two churches?
So if Catholics and Lutherans agree on grace, why are they still two churches? Because how a person is saved isn't the only question. They still differ on what the Church is, who speaks for it, how it stays one, who may lead it, and the sacraments, including .5
Because of those differences, Catholics and Lutherans still can't share Communion. The Lund statement calls that this wound in the Body of Christ, and asks for it to be healed.7
So Catholics don't celebrate the split. They can thank God for Luther's question, and still pray for the day they share one table.
Sources10
- 1Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), 6, 22, 29, 41, 50–51, 229, 234The joint Lutheran-Catholic account of Luther, the events of 1517–1521, and what each side regrets.
- 2Council of Trent, Session 25 (1563), Decree on IndulgencesOrders that “all evil gains” from indulgences be abolished, keeps indulgences, and condemns calling them useless.
- 3Pope Francis, in-flight press conference from Armenia (26 June 2016)Informal remarks: Luther's intentions “were not mistaken”.
- 4Benedict XVI, address to the Council of the Evangelical Church in Germany, Erfurt (23 September 2011)The pope on Luther's question about the grace of God.
- 5Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church, Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999), 15, 41, 43Agreement on justification, the old condemnations in a new light, and the questions still open.
- 6Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (21 November 1964), 6The Church is called to continual reformation.
- 7Joint Statement on the occasion of the Joint Catholic-Lutheran Commemoration of the Reformation, Lund (31 October 2016)Gratitude for the Reformation's gifts, lament for wounded unity, and longing for one Eucharist.
- 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1473What an indulgence is: a release from the temporal punishment of sins already forgiven, which follows from the nature of sin itself.
- 9Catholic Encyclopedia, “Baptists” (1907)The first Baptist church formed among English exiles in Amsterdam in 1609.
- 10J. Gordon Melton, "Pentecostalism", Encyclopaedia Britannica (updated 15 December 2024; archived copy)Holiness roots, Topeka 1901, the Azusa Street revival of 1906, and how the first Pentecostal churches formed.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.