Every claim on The Trail says what kind of claim it is, what it rests on, and how far it has been checked. This page shows how that works, how the Catholic Church weighs its own evidence, what AI does and doesn’t do, and every source behind the site.
Two labels on every claim, a status that says how far it has got, and the scripts that hold the line.
Every claim on the site lives in its own small file. It holds one sentence, the source behind it, the exact words quoted from that source, and where in the source to find them.
The file also holds what the claim can’t show, and how other Christians or historians read the same evidence. The best case against a claim is kept with the claim, not left out.
What kind of claim is it?
A council’s decree, a bishop’s letter and a vision at a shrine are different kinds of thing. So every claim carries one of four evidence labels.
Revealed / dogmatic
What the Catholic Church teaches as part of revealed faith.
For example: The Resurrection. Mary's Assumption (defined 1950).
For example: Justin Martyr's description of Sunday worship around AD 155.
Theological inference
Conclusions reached by putting Scripture and Tradition together.
For example: Mary as the New Eve or the Ark of the Covenant.
Devotional
Apparitions, relics, the Shroud, Eucharistic miracles. Catholic faith does not depend on their authenticity.
For example: Our Lady of Fatima. The Shroud of Turin.
The rule that follows: never mix the kinds up. Mary’s Assumption is a defined dogma. Fatima is an approved private revelation that no Catholic has to believe. The Shroud of Turin is an object whose origin is still argued over.
They’re never written with the same certainty.
The oldest surviving piece of the New Testament: a scrap of John’s Gospel copied around AD 125–175. Historical evidence, not a doctrine.
How sure can anyone be?
A second label says how much weight the evidence can carry. There are seven, from settled Church teaching down to a claim still being investigated.
1Established Catholic teaching. What the Church asks Catholics to hold, quoted from the Catechism, a council or a pope.
2Strong historical evidence. Several early sources agree, or there’s one from the time that nobody seriously disputes.
3Probable historical reconstruction. The best reading of patchy evidence. Historians could fairly differ on the details.
4Disputed. Serious scholars, or serious Christians, disagree. The site says so and gives both sides.
5Devotional tradition. Held with love for centuries, but not something the Church defines.
6Private revelation. An apparition the Church allows devotion to. No Catholic is required to believe it.
7Extraordinary claim under investigation. Miracles, relics, unexplained events. Held to the strictest standard on the site.
How far has it been checked?
The third mark is a status. It moves one step at a time, and a claim can’t skip a step.
Where the 341 claims stand today
Research
Idea0
A question worth checking.
Researching0
Sources being found and saved.
Draft0
Written, but a quote or a fact isn’t traced yet. You see it marked “Quotes not yet checked”.
Quotes checked341
Every quote found, word for word, in a saved copy of its page.
Review
Doctrinal review0
Read against Catholic teaching.
Historical review0
Read to a historian’s standard.
Adversarial review0
Read by someone looking for what’s unfair or weak.
Language edit0
Put into plain words without changing the meaning.
Sign-off
Approved0
Signed off by the reviewers. AI can never give this.
Today 341 claims have their quotes checked and 0 are drafts. None has gone past that step yet, so none is approved.
Quotes checked means the quoted words were found in a saved copy of the page. It doesn’t mean the claim is right. A quote can be perfect and the conclusion drawn from it still wrong.
The steps after it are planned: three separate readings (one for Catholic teaching, one for the history, one by someone from another tradition), a plain-language edit, and a priest, theologian or historian before launch. None of them has happened yet.
The scripts that hold the line
Good intentions aren’t a method. So before anything is called done, scripts check the files.
Every quote has a saved page. Each quotation must be found in a copy of its page saved when it was fetched. One that can’t be traced is treated as written from memory: you’re shown it as unchecked, and its claim stays a draft.
Every reference leads somewhere. Every source a page cites is in the list at the end of this page, every claim it names exists, and every picture has a credit.
No stress on a source’s words. The site’s highlight marks are never allowed inside a quotation.
Every sentence has a note. In the saints’ lives and the country and diocese histories, every paragraph points to a note and every note carries a quote. A year in the text has to appear in a quote it cites. A file that says more than its quotes is held at draft.
The checks have caught real mistakes. In September 2026 they found eight quotations written from memory in one session, and a stray footnote number stuck in the middle of a Catechism quote.
What the scripts can’t see
A script can show that a quote is real. It can’t show that the sentence around it says only what the quote says.
Spot checks in September 2026 found about one sentence in five saying more than its quote. So the saints’ lives and the histories get a second reading, sentence by sentence, beside their quotes, and each is marked by whether it has had one.
And no script notices what’s missing. A page can quote every source correctly and still mislead by never raising the awkward question.
Not everything Catholics believe carries the same weight. The Church has its own rules for telling the levels apart, and for testing the extraordinary.
The site’s labels follow lines the Catholic Church draws for itself. A Catholic isn’t asked to hold every Church statement in the same way.
A defined dogma, a pope’s speech, a theologian’s idea and a vision at a shrine sit at very different levels. Knowing which level a statement sits at is half of reading it fairly.
Five levels of teaching
The Vatican set out the levels in 1998, in a commentary on the profession of faith that some Church office holders make. Church law draws the same lines.
How firmly a Catholic is asked to hold it
1
DogmaFaith
Revealed by God, and set out by the Church as revealed.
For example, the articles of the Creed, or Mary’s Assumption, defined in 1950.
What popes and bishops teach without making it final.
Much of what popes write in encyclicals, their teaching letters.
“While the assent of faith is not required, a religious submission of intellect and will is to be given”Canon law 752 ↗
4
Theological opinionFree to disagree
Questions the Church hasn’t settled. Theologians argue them out.
Open questions can close later: Pius XII added that many “no longer now admit of discussion”.
“Popes generally leave theologians free in those matters which are disputed in various ways by men of very high authority in this field”Humani generis 19 (1950) ↗
5
Private revelationFree not to believe
Apparitions and messages, even ones the Church allows devotion to.
Lourdes and Fatima are the best known.
“They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith.”Catechism 67 ↗
The site’s labels are coarser than this scale. Revealed covers the top of it and Devotional the bottom. Established Catholic teaching can mean any of the top three levels, so the claim’s own words say which.
Scripture, Tradition and the teaching office
Catholics believe God’s message reaches us in two ways: the Bible, and the teaching handed down from the apostles, which the Church calls Tradition.
The Second Vatican Council’s document on revelation, Dei Verbum (1965), says both come “flowing from the same divine wellspring”.
Most Protestants hold Scripture as the final authority, with creeds and teachers to help. The Orthodox, like Catholics, hold Scripture and Tradition together. The site gives each view in its own words where it comes up.
Dei Verbum also limits the Church’s own teachers, the pope and bishops. Their teaching office “is not above the word of God, but serves it”, teaching “only what has been handed on”. The Church claims to guard the message, not to add to it.
It also asks readers to notice what kind of writing they’re reading. Truth is put “differently in texts which are variously historical, prophetic, poetic, or of other forms of discourse”. A psalm isn’t read like a census.
Faith and reason
The Church says faith rests on God’s word, not on proofs. But it doesn’t ask anyone to switch their mind off. The Catechism calls faith “by no means a blind impulse of the mind”.
It points to signs that support faith, which it calls “motives of credibility”: miracles, prophecies, and the Church’s growth and holiness down the centuries.
And it says the two can’t really clash: “Though faith is above reason, there can never be any real discrepancy between faith and reason.” On that view, if history seems to contradict the faith, something has been misread on one side or the other.
On the Church’s own terms, an honest look at the evidence can’t hurt the truth.
That’s why the site can show evidence that cuts against the Catholic case, and does.
Apparitions: the 2024 rules
Someone says Mary appeared to them. What does the Church do? Since May 2024 it follows new rules, the Norms, from the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office that guards Catholic teaching.
The biggest change: as a rule, the Church no longer declares an apparition supernatural at all. The most it gives is a nihil obstat, Latin for nothing stands in the way.
Even that comes “without expressing any certainty about the supernatural authenticity of the phenomenon itself”. Quoting Benedict XVI, the Norms call the devotion “a help which is proffered, but its use is not obligatory”.
There are six possible outcomes, from go ahead to proven false:
1Nihil obstat (nothing stands in the way). Signs of the Holy Spirit at work, and nothing seriously wrong found so far. The bishop may encourage it, even pilgrimages.
2Prae oculis habeatur (keep it in view). Real good signs, with some confusion or risk. The bishop watches closely and may need to clarify the messages.
3Curatur (being looked after). Serious problems, but it has spread widely and done real good. Not banned, and not encouraged.
4Sub mandato (under instruction). The event itself is fine, but some people around it are misusing it, for money for instance. The bishop takes charge.
5Prohibetur et obstruatur (forbidden and blocked). The risks are very serious. The bishop says publicly that following it isn’t allowed, and explains why.
6Declaratio de non supernaturalitate (declared not supernatural). Proven false, for instance when a visionary admits to lying. The decision “must be based on facts and evidence that are concrete and proven.”
Why the change? One case from the 1950s swung between “not supernatural” and approval and back again. The Norms say it “took about seventy excruciating years” to settle.
In September 2024 the same office gave Medjugorje a nihil obstat for its spiritual life, while saying Catholics aren’t obliged to believe in it and its messages are to be called “alleged messages”.
Before someone is declared a saint, the Church normally asks for a miracle for beatification (the step before sainthood) and another for canonisation.
A reported healing is examined first by doctors, then by theologians and bishops, and decided by the pope.
1The local bishop. gathers the evidence. “The inquiry into alleged miracles is to be conducted separately from the inquiry into virtues or martyrdom.”
2Seven doctors. swear “to examine the case according to science and conscience”. Each gives a diagnosis, the likely outcome, the treatment and how the healing happened. The case goes on only with “a qualified majority of at least five out of seven Experts”.
3Theologians. then discuss the case.
4Cardinals and bishops. discuss it in their turn, and vote.
5The pope. decides. He “alone has the right to declare that public cult may be given”: that the person may be honoured publicly, with a feast day.
Shrines keep doctors too. At Lourdes, more than 7,000 healings have been reported since the apparitions of 1858. The Church has recognised 72 as miraculous, the latest in April 2025.
In that last case the doctors voted on one question: was she cured “in an unexpected, complete, lasting and unexplained manner according to medical knowledge”? After that, in the shrine’s own words, it is “up to the bishop” to decide whether to declare a miracle.
Doctors can say a healing has no explanation they know of. Calling it a miracle is a judgement of faith, made by the Church.
The Church, in short, sorts its claims by weight and tests the extraordinary ones slowly. The site tries to do the same, which leaves the question of who, or what, does the testing here.
▸Check it yourselfThe 3 claims this chapter rests on, with their sources and status
The Catechism teaches that no new public revelation is to be expected before Christ's return, and that "private" revelations, even when recognised by the Church, do not belong to the deposit of faith; their role is to help live by Christ's definitive Revelation, not to improve or complete it.
“Throughout the ages, there have been so-called "private" revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ's definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history.”
Checked
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).
The Catechism teaches that Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture flow from the same divine well-spring and form one thing, and that the Church does not derive her certainty about all revealed truths from Scripture alone; both must be accepted with equal devotion.
“Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture, then, are bound closely together, and communicate one with the other. For both of them, flowing out from the same divine well-spring, come together in some fashion to form one thing, and move towards the same …”
Read the full passageFold the passage
“Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture, then, are bound closely together, and communicate one with the other. For both of them, flowing out from the same divine well-spring, come together in some fashion to form one thing, and move towards the same goal. ... the Church ... does not derive her certainty about all revealed truths from the holy Scriptures alone.”
Other readings
Protestant traditions holding sola scriptura affirm that Scripture alone is the final infallible rule of faith, while most still value tradition as a secondary authority.
Checked
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).
The Catechism, quoting Dei Verbum, teaches that authentic interpretation of the Word of God is entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church, and that this Magisterium is not superior to the Word of God but its servant, teaching only what has been handed on.
“This teaching office is not above the word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been handed on, listening to it devoutly, guarding it scrupulously and explaining it faithfully”
Checked
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).
III4 min read
Where AI does the work
What the AI does, what the scripts check, and what a person has and hasn’t read.
The Trail is built by one person, ACG, with a great deal of help from AI. Saying so plainly is part of the method.
AI does most of the searching, saving, drafting and coding. Scripts check its work against saved copies of the sources. A person reads the result, but no expert has reviewed it yet.
How a claim gets made
AI
A script (code, no judgement)
A person
1Find. AI research agents (Claude, made by Anthropic) look for the documents a question needs. For Church documents they may use Magisterium AI’s search to find the right paragraph, but only as a finder: the words always come from the document itself.
2Save. A script downloads each page and keeps it as plain text, with its web address at the top. Pages that block automated visits are taken from the Internet Archive’s copy. More than 30,000 pages are saved so far.
3Write. An agent writes the claim or paragraph, copies the quote from the saved text (never from memory or a search summary), and picks the labels by the rules in chapter I. Where a source isn’t in English, the agent also writes the English translation shown beside it.
4Match. Scripts look for every quote in the saved pages, word for word, setting aside capitals, punctuation and spacing. A quote that isn’t found is shown to you as unchecked, and its claim is held at draft. A translation can’t be matched this way; only the original words can.
5Audit. A second agent, not the one that wrote it, reads each sentence beside its quote and cuts whatever says more. This has been done for every saint’s life, every diocese history and the Catholic history of every country. The Orthodox and Protestant stories on the country pages haven’t had it yet, and the chapters and FAQ answers don’t carry that mark yet.
6Read. ACG reads the pages, mostly on his phone, and sends back what’s unclear, unfair or wrong. He’s a designer, not a priest, theologian or historian.
7Review. Outside review by a priest, theologian or historian, the only way a claim becomes “approved”. Not started. No AI is allowed to mark anything approved.
The saved copies stay in the project’s own files rather than on the site, because they belong to the sites they came from. Every source in the list at the end links to the original.
When you ask a question
The Ask box on every page answers questions about the site. It uses Google’s Gemini, with tight limits on what it can say.
1Search. Your question is matched against the site’s own pages.
2Point. If a page already answers it, the model only points to the right paragraphs, and you’re shown them word for word.
3Write. If not, it writes a short answer from those paragraphs and, when it’s switched on, from passages of Church documents found through Magisterium AI’s search. Nothing else.
4Check. Every sentence has to stand on a passage: its names, numbers and quotes must be in it. A sentence that doesn’t is dropped. If nothing survives, you get the search results alone.
No person reads these answers before you do. They can still get the emphasis wrong, so each one shows the places it was taken from.
On the map, a church’s pin can show a line or two on how it began. Gemini writes it from that church’s own Wikipedia article, in whatever language it has, and says nothing when the article doesn’t say. Those lines aren’t checked by a script or a person.
What AI doesn’t do
It isn’t the source of any quote. Every quote has to be found in a saved page first.
It doesn’t decide what the Church teaches. That has to be quoted from the Church’s own documents.
It can’t approve anything. That step belongs to people, and it hasn’t started.
It doesn’t get to hide a miss. A quote that can’t be traced is shown to you as unchecked.
What a script can’t catch is judgement: a label that’s slightly off, a translation that leans, an awkward fact left out. That is what the outside review is for.
Here is one claim, followed all the way through.
IV3 min read
One claim, start to finish
Ignatius of Antioch on the Eucharist: from a letter written around AD 107 to a step in four chapters.
Around AD 107, on his way to be executed in Rome, Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, wrote to the Christians of Smyrna (today’s İzmir, in Turkey).
He warned them about people who stayed away from the Eucharist, the Christian meal of bread and wine that Catholics believe becomes Christ’s body and blood. Here’s how one sentence of that letter reached the site.
1
The source
Ignatius, Letter to the Smyrnaeans, chapter 7, in the English translation of the Ante-Nicene Fathers, as put online by New Advent.
They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer , because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ , which suffered for our sins , and which the Father , of His goodness, raised up again.
The odd spaces before the commas come from the links on the web page. The saved copy keeps them; the check ignores them.
3
The claim
The claim file puts the sentence in the site’s words, with the quote, where to find it, and its three marks.
Ignatius says certain people abstain from the Eucharist "because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins".
“They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins”
Smyrnaeans 7 · checked 2026-09-21
4
The match
Both are set plain, in lower case and without punctuation, and the script looks for the quote inside the saved page.
The quote, set plain
they abstain from the eucharist and from prayer because they confess not the eucharist to be the flesh of our saviour jesus christ which suffered for our sins
The saved page, set plain
they abstain from the eucharist and from prayer because they confess not the eucharist to be the flesh of our saviour jesus christ which suffered for our sins and which the father of his goodness raised up again
✓ Found word for word
5
The label
It’s labelled Historical, not Revealed. The letter is a witness: it shows what one bishop believed and taught around AD 107.
It doesn’t prove the doctrine on its own. What the Catholic Church teaches about the Eucharist has its own claims, quoted from its own documents.
The file keeps the other reading too. The people Ignatius opposed denied that Jesus had a real body at all, so the passage is first of all about the Incarnation, God becoming human.
6
On the site
The same claim backs a step in 4 chapters and a footprint on the River:
In each chapter the claim is listed, with its source and status, under “Check it yourself” at the foot of the page.
7
What’s still open
No person has reviewed this claim yet. The translation dates from the 1800s. And scholars still debate when Ignatius’s letters were written.
Every source the site leans on is listed below in the same way, with a link to the original.
V2 min read
Every source
1,182 documents, sorted by how much weight they can carry.
These are the 1,182 documents behind the chapters, the River and the questions page. Each title opens the original.
They’re sorted into five kinds, from the most weight to the least. Catholic teaching has to rest on official texts, and history starts with first-hand sources. The other kinds help find things but never carry a claim alone.
1,176 of 1,182 were fetched and checked against the original page. The ones still waiting say so.
The saints’ lives and the country and diocese histories cite their own pages in notes beside the text, so those aren’t repeated here.
Official texts
323
Scripture; the Catholic Church’s councils, popes, Catechism and Vatican offices; and the founding and official texts of other churches, in their own words. Catholic teaching has to rest here.
Ignatius of Antioch · c. AD 107-110✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
New Advent, reproducing Roberts and Donaldson, Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1 (Buffalo, 1885)
Chapter 5 is the earliest surviving Christian text linking marriage to the authority of the bishop; it cannot show that a marriage rite existed, only that episcopal approval was expected.
Francesco Petrarca · dated by the anthology 1340-1353✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University, from J. H. Robinson, Readings in European History (Boston, 1904), p. 502
Period opinion of the highest literary profile about the Avignon curia. It settles what an educated fourteenth-century Catholic was willing to write about the papal court; it settles nothing factual, since no addressee, manuscript or critical edition is given.
Raimon de Cornet, fourteenth-century troubadour · 14th century✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University, from J. H. Robinson, Readings in European History (Boston, 1904), pp. 375-377
Vernacular satire showing that the charge of trafficking in benefices and pardons was common currency outside clerical circles. It cannot settle any fact about Avignon.
Harper & Brothers; Christian Classics Ethereal Library
A Protestant church historian writing within seven years of the council; hostile to the definition but documented from Friedberg, Friedrich and Quirinus.
Henry Denzinger, trans. Roy J. Deferrari (The Sources of Catholic Dogma) · 1274 (text); Deferrari translation 1957✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
Sensus Fidelium (web reproduction)
Carries the 1274 sevenfold list, which is absent from Tanner's edition of the Lyons II constitutions; it can establish that the list was professed at Lyons but not that the council legislated it, and the hosting site is a devotional aggregator, not a critical edition.
Henry Denzinger, trans. Roy J. Deferrari (The Sources of Catholic Dogma) · 1546 (text); Deferrari translation 1957✓ Checked 2026-10-08MoreLess
Sensus Fidelium (web reproduction)
A second English translation of Trent's Session IV decree, independent of Waterworth; the hosting site is a devotional aggregator, not a critical edition.
Henry Denzinger, trans. Roy J. Deferrari (The Sources of Catholic Dogma) · 1551 (text); Deferrari translation 1957✓ Checked 2026-10-08MoreLess
Sensus Fidelium (web reproduction)
A second English translation of Trent's definition of transubstantiation, independent of Waterworth; the hosting site is a devotional aggregator, not a critical edition.
Jerome and later revisers; Clementine recension · 1592 (Clementine edition)✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
drbo.org (Douay-Rheims Bible Online)
Gives the traditional Latin reading of Ephesians 5:32, 'Sacramentum hoc magnum est', which is the textual basis of the medieval argument for marriage as a sacrament; drbo.org is a devotional site, not a critical edition.
John Wesley · 1749-07-18✓ Checked 2026-09-24MoreLess
Good News Magazine (reproduction)
An irenic letter by Wesley to Irish Catholics, reproduced by a Methodist renewal magazine. Settles that Wesley also wrote in this conciliatory voice; the text was not checked against a scholarly edition of the Works.
A Victorian art historian quoting John Bale's lament for the monastic libraries in the original spelling. It carries Bale's words at second hand and does not name Bale's work or its date, so it settles what Bale is reported to have written, not the scale of the loss.
Attributed to Hippolytus of Rome; translated by Kevin P. Edgecomb · Traditionally c. AD 215; translation c. 2000s✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
bombaxo.com (site now defunct); retrieved via the Internet Archive Wayback Machine, snapshot of 13 December 2015
The only complete English text of the Apostolic Tradition I could retrieve this session; the translator describes it himself as 'a simplified one for ease of reading, directed primarily towards the non-expert', so it can illustrate the shape of the rites but cannot carry a doctrinal or philological argument.
Stuart Chessman (editor), translation by Nicholas Salazar · 2017-11✓ Checked 2026-09-23MoreLess
The Society of St Hugh of Cluny (sthughofcluny.org)
An unpublished, non-scholarly English translation of the opening paragraphs of the Consilium, useful only as an independent cross-check on Olin's rendering of the key 'lord of all benefices / cannot be guilty of simony' passage. It settles nothing on its own.
Wikipedia contributors · revision 1359967169✓ Checked 2026-09-27MoreLess
Wikimedia Foundation
Used only for Rebiba's role in bringing the Roman Inquisition to Naples, which it cites to H. C. Lea.
Who made each picture, film and piece of music, and the licence it’s used under, is on Picture credits.
Ask the Trail
Ask in your own words.
You’ll be taken to the place on the Trail that answers it: a question already answered, a footprint on the River, a chapter, a country on the map.
Three written answers a day: each one costs a little, and the Trail is paid for by one person. The search, and the questions the Trail has already answered, are always free.
Try
Feedback
Step 1 of 3
How satisfied are you with the Trail so far?
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
Your rating is saved as soon as you choose it. Every question after this one is optional. Privacy notice. Only want to point something out?
ACG
Builds The Trail
Sorry to interrupt your reading.
I’m ACG, a Catholic in Singapore. I built the Trail so Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants can see that we all come from the same spring.
It’s entirely self-funded, built after my day job. Your support keeps it online each month.
And it brings me closer to a dream: to visit these churches in person, film their stories, and one day do this full time.
If it’s been worth your time, would you help keep it going? If not, thanks for reading. That means a lot too.