From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/orthodox-not-catholics-without-pope
← OrthodoxAren't the Orthodox just Catholics without the pope?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minNo. The share most of the faith with Catholics, but they see themselves as the one Church of , with their own worship, ways of thinking and leadership, not as Catholics missing a piece. The Ecumenical Patriarch is first in honour, not an Orthodox .
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Vatican II
- Unitatis Redintegratio, 14–18
- Vatican doctrine office
- Dominus Iesus, 17
Maybe a Catholic friend has said it to you: you're basically Catholics without the pope. They usually mean it kindly. It's meant to show how close the two are: the same , the same early councils, the same love for Mary and the saints. The closeness is real.1
But to Orthodox ears it sounds like you're us, minus the boss. It treats the pope as the only thing that matters.
How the Orthodox see themselves
Flip it around. In 2016 from most Orthodox Churches met at a great on the island of Crete. They said the Orthodox Churches together are the one Church of Christ, not a loose group of Churches.2,3
In their eyes, it was Rome that changed. They believe the pope's power grew in the West over the centuries, and they never signed up to it.4
And ask an Orthodox Christian what makes them Orthodox, and they probably won't start with the pope. They'll talk about the Divine Liturgy, with at its heart.2 The hymns to Mary, the , and to the saints.5
The fasting, confession and prayer that get them ready for Communion.6 And the monks, whose way of life the West itself first learned from the East.5
You can disagree with them about Rome and still see this isn't someone missing a piece.
Think of it like this
Think of twins separated as babies when their parents split up. One grows up in one country, the other in another. Same DNA, same baby photos, kept in two different albums.
Thirty years later they finally meet. One cooks with butter, the other with olive oil. Each dreams in a different language, prays with different words, and has their own friends and habits. Yet within an hour they find they hum the same songs their mother used to sing.
Now imagine someone introducing one of them as the other twin, minus the accent. It isn't exactly false. But it misses who they are. Each has a whole life of their own, and each sees themselves as the real thing, not a copy.
That's what Catholics without the pope sounds like to Orthodox ears. Same family, but not a copy with a piece missing.
More than one difference
The pope is the biggest issue, but not the only one. You can hear another in the Creed said at every Liturgy. The Western Church added the words and the Son to the line about the . The Orthodox never did.7
East and West also grew different ways of thinking and talking about God.5 And the Orthodox don't accept what Rome defined about the pope's authority on its own, after the split, in 1870.4,8
Is there an Orthodox pope?
There isn't an Orthodox pope in the Catholic sense. The Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Alexandria still carries the old title Pope, but he has no say over the other Churches.13
The Orthodox Church is a family of self-governing Churches, which they call autocephalous, Greek for having their own head.4
Bartholomew, the Ecumenical Patriarch, is first in honour among their leaders. A patriarch is the senior bishop of one of the great old Churches.
His city is Constantinople, today's Istanbul. He calls the others together, but he isn't their boss.3,4
What that first place means, the Orthodox argue about among themselves. The Russian Church says there has never been a single administrative center for the whole Orthodox world.4 Constantinople sees its role as stronger: it says it can hear appeals from anywhere in the Orthodox world.9
So how do they settle things without a pope? Each Church's bishops meet in a synod for their own affairs.4
What touches all of them goes to a council of all the Churches, the way the great councils of the first thousand years worked.2,4
Councils have real strengths. No one bishop can impose something on everyone, and for centuries councils have held the Orthodox together in one faith.
The hard part is getting everyone to the table. Four Churches, Russia's among them, stayed away from the great council of 2016, held on Crete. Russia said the council couldn't speak for all the Orthodox without the others there.3
Then in 2018 Constantinople recognised an independent Church for Ukraine, using what it calls its right to hear appeals.9
Moscow, which counts Ukraine's Orthodox as part of the Russian Church, said Constantinople had no right to hear appeals from other Churches.10
And it broke communion. Its clergy no longer celebrate the Liturgy with Constantinople's, and its people may not receive the sacraments there.10
Since then, a few other Churches have sided with Constantinople, and Moscow has broken with their leaders too.14
Who's right is for the Orthodox to work out. But the quarrel shows both sides of how Orthodoxy works. No single bishop can step in and settle it.
Orthodoxy settles things by councils, not by one bishop.
2 But a council needs the Churches at one table, and this quarrel hasn't found one yet.
What the Catholic Church says
The Catholic Church doesn't see the Orthodox as a breakaway group. It sees true Churches, with real bishops and a real Communion.11
Every Catholic bishop stands in a line going back to the , and so does every Orthodox bishop.11
It also says the East is no junior partner. At the , the Catholic bishops said the West has drawn heavily on the East's treasury of worship, prayer and law.5
The great councils that first spelled out who God is and who Jesus is were held in the East.5
gave it a picture people still quote:
In this perspective an expression which I have frequently employed finds its deepest meaning: the Church must breathe with her two lungs!
In Catholic eyes, without the Orthodox, the West is missing something too. A body breathing with one lung is alive, but it isn't well.
Where the pope fits
The Catholic Church does still believe that full unity includes the pope's role, as the successor of , the leader of Jesus's twelve apostles.11 Catholics believe each pope carries on Peter's job of keeping the whole Church together as one.
The Orthodox honour Peter too, and agree the early Church gave Rome the first place of honour.4 Where Catholics and Orthodox differ is whether that means authority over every other bishop.
But the two Churches' official talks are asking how Catholic teaching on the pope should be understood and lived in the light of the first thousand years, when East and West were one.8
In the Catholic view, unity wouldn't make the Orthodox Western. It would make both lungs breathe together.
Sources14
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 838Communion with the Orthodox is so deep it lacks little for a shared Eucharist.
- 2Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church, Message (Crete, 2016)The Orthodox Churches as the one Church, not a federation; unity expressed in council.
- 3Wikipedia, Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church (2016)Four Churches stayed away; Antioch said the decisions didn't bind it.
- 4Moscow Patriarchate, Position on the Problem of Primacy in the Universal ChurchConstantinople first among equals in honour; no single administrative centre.
- 5Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 14–18The East's liturgy, Marian hymns, saints and monasticism; the West's debt to its treasury; the councils held in the East.
- 6Fr John Breck, Why Not Open Communion? (Orthodox Church in America)Orthodox life before Communion: prayer, fasting, confession and the ascetic discipline of the Church.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 247The filioque is a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches.
- 8Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 45How Vatican I's teaching on primacy should be understood in light of the first millennium.
- 9Ecumenical Patriarchate, Announcement of the Holy and Sacred Synod (11 October 2018)Autocephaly for Ukraine; the 1686 letter revoked; Ukrainian bishops received on appeal under Constantinople's claimed prerogatives.
- 10Russian Orthodox Church, Statement of the Holy Synod on the encroachment of the Patriarchate of Constantinople (Minsk, 15 October 2018)Moscow's case: the 1686 act cannot be reviewed, Constantinople has no right of appeal, and Eucharistic communion is broken.
- 11Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (2000), 17The Orthodox are true particular Churches, but lack full communion over the primacy.
- 12John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 54The Church must breathe with her two lungs.
- 13Wikipedia, List of Greek Orthodox patriarchs of AlexandriaThe Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Alexandria carries the title Pope.
- 14Wikipedia, 2018 Moscow–Constantinople schismThe Churches of Greece, Alexandria and Cyprus recognised the Ukrainian Church; Moscow broke communion with their leaders.
- Does the Catholic Church see the Orthodox Churches as true Churches, or as breakaways?
- The Orthodox give Rome first place of honour. Why does Rome claim more than that?
- Did Rome change the Creed without a council of the whole Church?
- If we reunited, would the Orthodox have to accept everything Rome defined after 1054?
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.