X / XI
1650–1900

Revolutions and missions

In Europe the Enlightenment teaches many to trust reason over religion, and revolutions turn on the Church. Revolutionary France takes its lands, kills hundreds of priests who refuse to swear to a church run by the state, and holds Pope Pius VI prisoner until he dies in 1799. Rome answers by closing ranks.

Meanwhile the faith spreads across Asia, Africa and the Americas. In Korea, lay people who had read Christian books from China start a church of their own in the 1780s, before any priest arrives.

In Britain and America, new movements of the Spirit, revivals and the freedom of the frontier give birth to new churches: Quakers, Methodists, Brethren, Adventists and the Salvation Army. The channels keep dividing.

In 1870, with Italian armies taking the last of the pope’s lands, the First Vatican Council defines papal infallibility under strict conditions: it covers only the pope’s solemn definitions on faith and morals, not everything he says.

The world: Enlightenment · revolutions · Industrial age · empires
The nave of Saint Peter's Basilica, Rome
A rocky outcrop on a grassy fellside at dusk, with a small white plaque fixed to the rock.
Fox’s Pulpit on Firbank Fell, the rock where George Fox sat to preach in 1652, with the memorial plaque Friends later fixed to it.
1652Historical

George Fox preaches on Firbank Fell

In the 1640s England fought a civil war. Bishops were abolished, the king was beheaded in 1649, and new groups sprang up everywhere.

George Fox, a weaver's son from Leicestershire, left home at nineteen to search for God and found no minister who could help him. He came to believe that Christ gives his light to every person and ‘was come to teach people himself’.

On Sunday 13 June 1652, at Firbank in Westmorland, Fox sat on a rock beside a chapel and spoke for about three hours to what was judged ‘above a thousand people’. The congregation's own preachers joined him.

Within two years about sixty travelling preachers had gone out from the north, and the Quakers, the Religious Society of Friends, had begun.

“It was judged there were above a thousand people; amongst whom I declared God’s everlasting truth and word of life freely and largely, for about the space of three hours, directing all to the Spirit of God in themselves, that they might be turned from darkness to the light, and believe in it, that they might become the children of it”
The Journal of George Fox, vol. 1 (Friends' Tract Association edition, 1901) · Journal of George Fox (1901 ed.), vol. 1, ch. V (1652), Firbank chapel
What the Church says

The Catholic Church honours the Friends’ faith in Christ, and does not hold today’s Friends responsible for the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). There is no formal Catholic–Quaker dialogue, so its view follows from its general teaching.

That teaching counts the shared bond between Christians from baptism with water in the name of the Trinity (UR 22; Ecumenical Directory 93).

A baptised Friend shares that bond. A Friend who has never been baptised is not yet inside it, in the Church’s eyes, though their love for Christ is real, and the Church also teaches that God himself is not bound by the sacraments (CCC 1257).

The Church judges the persecution of Friends by one rule: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That condemns the jails of Puritans and Anglicans, the Puritan gallows in Boston, and the Inquisition’s cells at Malta and Rome.

On peace, the Council praises ‘those who renounce the use of violence in the vindication of their rights’ and asks the law to provide for conscientious objectors (Gaudium et Spes 78–79). It stops short of the Friends’ full peace testimony: governments keep ‘the right to legitimate defense’.

1652

Real but non-sacramental communionfrom the Anglican channel

England in the 1640s and 1650s was in turmoil: civil war, a king beheaded in 1649, and new churches springing up everywhere. Some people, called Seekers, had given up on every church and waited together in silence for God.

George Fox, a weaver’s son apprenticed to a shoemaker, left home in 1643, aged nineteen, to search for God. For four years he went from minister to minister.

Then, he wrote, he heard a voice: “There is one, even Christ Jesus, that can speak to thy condition”.

What we still share
  • Faith in Christ, “who enlightens, and gives grace, and faith, and power” (Fox, *Journal*).
  • The Bible, and “faith, hope and charity, with the other interior gifts of the Holy Spirit”, which Vatican II says can exist outside the Catholic Church’s visible boundaries (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 3).
  • Some Evangelical Friends in Africa, Latin America and Asia baptise with water in the name of the Trinity. Those Friends share the bond of baptism itself (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • Refusing violence: Vatican II praises “those who renounce the use of violence in the vindication of their rights” (*Gaudium et Spes* 78).
How they describe it

Friends see themselves as a people gathered by Christ, who, in George Fox’s words, “was come to teach people himself” by his Spirit in their hearts, with no outward rites and no separate clergy.

What it cost
  • Nearly 400 dead in prison, 1650 to 1689Between Protestants
  • James Nayler branded and his tongue bored, 1656Between Protestants
  • The Quaker Act, 1662Between Protestants
  • Four hanged at Boston, 1659 to 1661Between Protestants
  • Friends in the Inquisition’s prisons, Malta and RomeSuffered by Protestants
  • Taken for Jesuits, 1655 onward
  • Penn’s freedom stops short of Catholics, 1670 to 1682Suffered by Catholics
  • Pennsylvania shuts Catholics out of office, 1705Suffered by Catholics
Channels that rejoined

Nine unions with Rome

1653–63 to 1861
1653–63from the Church of the East channel

After the Coonan Cross

After the Synod of Diamper in 1599, the St Thomas Christians of India were ruled by Portuguese Jesuit archbishops who latinised their liturgy and cut back the power of their own archdeacon. On 3 January 1653 the archdeacon, the clergy and most of the people swore an oath, at a cross known as the Coonan Cross, against the Jesuit archbishop and his missionaries.

Read the full footprint→
1698–1700from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The union of Transylvania

In 1687 the Habsburg emperor drove the Turks out of Transylvania and took it over. Most of its people were Orthodox Romanians, and they did not have full civil rights; the Hungarians were mostly Calvinist and the Germans Lutheran.

Read the full footprint→
1724from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The double election at Antioch

By the early 1700s the ancient Patriarchate of Antioch, whose Byzantine-rite Christians lived mostly in Syria and Lebanon, was split between a party leaning towards Rome, strong in Damascus, and a party looking to Constantinople. Catholic missionaries had worked in Syria for about a century.

Read the full footprint→
1741from the Oriental Orthodox channel

A bishop, a vicariate, and a patriarchate twice begun

The Coptic Church of Egypt left communion with Rome and Constantinople when it rejected the Council of Chalcedon in 451. A union signed at the Council of Florence in 1442 had no effect in Egypt.

Read the full footprint→
1742from the Oriental Orthodox channel

The patriarchate at Bzommar

The Armenian Apostolic Church did not accept the Council of Chalcedon. Two earlier unions with Rome, one in the crusader-era kingdom of Cilicia in 1198 and one at the Council of Florence in 1439, had lapsed.

Read the full footprint→
1782from the Oriental Orthodox channel

Michael Jarweh declares himself Catholic

The Syriac Orthodox Church, like the Copts and Armenians, rejected the Council of Chalcedon. Catholic missionaries worked among its people at Aleppo from 1626, and a Catholic patriarch was elected in 1662, but that line died out in 1702, and the Ottoman government backed the Orthodox against the Catholics.

Read the full footprint→
1846from the Oriental Orthodox channel

After the union that was expelled

Ethiopia has been Christian since the 300s and out of communion with Rome since Chalcedon. When Muslim armies threatened the Christian kingdom in the 1500s, Portugal sent troops, and Jesuit missionaries came with them.

Read the full footprint→
1856from the Eastern Orthodox channel

A mission in Constantinople

Until 1829 Ottoman law made it impossible to set up a Catholic community of the Byzantine rite inside the empire. In 1856 Fr John Marangos began missionary work among the Greek Orthodox of Constantinople and gathered a very small group of Greek Catholics who kept the Byzantine liturgy.

Read the full footprint→
1861from the Eastern Orthodox channel

The archimandrite who disappeared

In 1767 the Bulgarian Orthodox were put directly under the Greek patriarch of Constantinople, and by the 1800s they wanted a Church of their own back. Some saw union with Rome as the way out.

Read the full footprint→
1784

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Anglican channel

Methodism began as a revival inside the Church of England, not as a new church. John Wesley and his brother Charles were Church of England priests.

At Oxford around 1729, other students mocked their prayer and study group as “the holy club” and “the Methodists”.

On 24 May 1738 John went, “very unwillingly”, to a meeting in Aldersgate Street, London, where someone was reading Luther. “I felt my heart strangely warmed,” he wrote. “I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone, for salvation”.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the creeds and the Bible.
  • Baptism, which the Catholic Church recognises (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • A daily Christian life “nourished by their faith in Christ and strengthened by the grace of Baptism and by hearing the word of God” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 23).
  • **Since 2006**, agreement on how a sinner is made right with God: the World Methodist Council affirmed the Catholic–Lutheran *Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification*.
How they describe it

Methodists see themselves as a movement for scriptural holiness that became a church out of necessity, not by choice.

What it cost
  • Shut out of the pulpits, 1739 to 1740Between Protestants
  • The Wednesbury mob, 20 October 1743
  • Cork: the mayor stands aside, May 1750
  • Wesley backs the Protestant Association; the Gordon Riots, 1780Suffered by Catholics
  • Black Methodists pulled from their knees, Philadelphia, 1787Between Protestants
A two-part engraving: above, men with pikes and sabres cut down priests in a convent courtyard; below, a crowd kills prisoners in front of a prison.
Priests who refused the oath are killed at the Carmes convent in Paris in the September massacres of 1792, engraved that same week for the Paris paper Révolutions de Paris.
1790–1801Historical

The Revolution turns on the Church

Before 1789 the Catholic Church in France was rich and bound up with the king. Its clergy formed the first of the kingdom's three legal ranks, it owned about six per cent of the land, and it collected tithes.

When revolution came, the new Assembly abolished the tithes, took the Church's property and, in 1790, passed the Civil Constitution of the Clergy: bishops and priests would be elected by voters and cut off from the pope.

Every priest was ordered to swear to it. Pius VI condemned it, only 7 of 135 bishops swore, and about half the parish clergy refused. Refusing priests were exiled, jailed or killed, more than 200 of them in the September massacres of 1792.

Churches were closed or turned into Temples of Reason. In 1798 French troops took Rome, and Pius VI died a prisoner at Valence in 1799. Napoleon's Concordat of 1801 brought the Church back, under the state's control.

“No one shall be disquieted on account of his opinions, including his religious views, provided their manifestation does not disturb the public order established by law.”
Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (26 August 1789) · Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (26 August 1789), Article 10
What the Church says

The Church honours those killed for refusing the oath as martyrs. In 1926 Pius XI beatified priests killed in the September massacres, and in December 2024 Pope Francis declared the sixteen Carmelite nuns of Compiègne, guillotined in 1794, saints.

It also teaches that the Church ‘is not identified in any way with the political community nor bound to any political system’, and ‘does not place her trust in the privileges offered by civil authority’ (Gaudium et Spes 76).

Its rule on force cuts both ways: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

That condemns the Revolution's persecution of priests and nuns. It equally condemns the old Catholic monarchy's treatment of French Protestants, which the Council's admission of ‘a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12) covers.

Black-and-white photograph of a two-storey log meeting house with a shingled roof, among bare winter trees.
Barton Stone's log meeting house at Cane Ridge, Kentucky, photographed in 1934; the Springfield Presbytery signed its Last Will at Cane Ridge in 1804.
1804Historical

The Springfield Presbytery dissolves itself

In 1801 a huge revival meeting at Cane Ridge, Kentucky, brought Presbyterian, Methodist and Baptist preachers together before tens of thousands. Afterwards some Presbyterian ministers, among them Barton W. Stone, were accused of preaching against their church's statement of faith.

In September 1803 five of them broke with their synod, the regional council of ministers and elders, and set up a presbytery of their own.

Within a year they decided it ‘savored of a party spirit’, the very thing they had set out to escape. On 28 June 1804, at Cane Ridge, the six members signed a document written as a will: ‘that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large’. From then on they called themselves simply Christians.

In 1832 they united with the followers of Alexander Campbell, who also wanted to restore the church of the New Testament, and from that union came the Churches of Christ and the Disciples of Christ.

“We will, that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large; for there is but one body, and one Spirit, even as we are called in one hope of our calling.”
The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, with the Witnesses' Address · Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, Caneridge, 28 June 1804, first item (Imprimis)
What the Church says

The Catholic Church shares the Last Will’s starting point: division among Christians ‘openly contradicts the will of Christ’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 1).

It counts the members of the Stone–Campbell churches as brothers and sisters in Christ. Those born into these churches ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (UR 3), and their baptism, by immersion in the name of the Trinity, is valid and ‘establishes a sacramental bond of unity’ (UR 22; Ecumenical Directory 95).

Since 1977 the Church has held a formal dialogue with the Disciples of Christ. Its first report affirmed ‘the mutual recognition of baptism’ and named the real difference.

The Disciples refused creeds for the sake of unity, while Rome ‘holds to the creeds and the Petrine ministry for the same purpose’.

The Petrine ministry means the pope’s role as Peter’s successor. The goal both name is ‘full visible unity’.

An oval black-and-white photograph of John Nelson Darby in a dark buttoned coat and white collar, a trellis behind him.
John Nelson Darby, the former Church of Ireland curate who shaped the Brethren, in a photograph its Swiss Brethren publisher dated to Geneva, 1840.
1827–31Historical

The Brethren break bread without clergy

In Dublin in the late 1820s a few Protestants, most of them members of the Church of Ireland, began meeting in private rooms to ‘break bread’, their name for the Lord's Supper, every Sunday. No clergyman led it; any man present might pray, read the Bible or give thanks.

Anthony Norris Groves first proposed it, John Nelson Darby gave it a theology, and from 1831 a meeting at Plymouth gave the movement its name.

Darby taught that the visible church was in ruins and that believers should simply gather round the Lord's Table. He also taught that Christ would take the Church to heaven before the last great tribulation, the ‘rapture’, an idea that later spread to many American evangelical churches.

In 1848 the movement split into Open Brethren, where each assembly decides for itself, and Exclusive Brethren. Brethren assemblies now meet worldwide, Singapore among them.

“In a word, we find His death is the centre of communion till His coming again, and in this rests the whole power of truth. Accordingly, the outward symbol and instrument of unity is the partaking of the Lord's supper”
Considerations on the Nature and Unity of the Church of Christ · Considerations on the Nature and Unity of the Church of Christ (Dublin, 1828), Collected Writings vol. 1, p. 25
What the Church says

The Catholic Church does not hold today's Brethren responsible for the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (UR 3).

Baptism in water by immersion or pouring, in the name of the Trinity, is valid of itself (Ecumenical Directory 95a). So a Brethren believer baptised this way is truly joined to Christ (UR 22).

The Council also said that when such communities ‘commemorate His death and resurrection in the Lord's Supper’ they look to His coming in glory. It adds that, without the sacrament of Orders, the ordination of bishops and priests, they have not kept ‘the proper reality of the eucharistic mystery in its fullness’ (UR 22).

Against the idea that the Church lies in ruins, the Church teaches that Christ built one Church ‘for all ages’, which ‘subsists in the Catholic Church’ (LG 8), and that the apostles ‘took care to appoint successors’ (LG 20). There is no formal dialogue, since the Brethren have no central body to hold one.

Where Brethren and other evangelicals suffered for their faith, as in Catholic Tuscany in 1851, the Church's teaching now is plain: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

1829

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Anglican channel

In 1820s Ireland the Church of Ireland, the Anglican church, was established by law, though most Irish people were Catholics. In Dublin, earnest Protestants met in private rooms to pray, troubled that believers were split into rival churches.

Their question was simple: if all true believers are one body in Christ, why can they not share the Lord’s Supper? Around 1827 Anthony Norris Groves, a dentist studying for Anglican orders, suggested that believers “were free to break bread together” every Sunday.

From November 1829 a few met weekly in a house in Fitzwilliam Square, with no ordained minister. They had named a real wound, division; the cure they chose was to leave every church and start again.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible, and Christ crucified and risen.
  • Baptism in water, by immersion in most Open assemblies. Given in the name of the Trinity, the Catholic Church recognises it (Ecumenical Directory 95; *Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • The Lord’s Supper every Sunday. In it, Vatican II says, such communities “look forward to His coming in glory” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
How they describe it

Brethren see themselves not as a denomination but as believers gathered simply in the name of the Lord Jesus, as the first Christians met, with no clergy between them and Christ.

What it cost
  • Cronin shut out by Dublin's chapels, late 1820sBetween Protestants
  • Driven out of Vaud, 1845
  • Darby's circular cuts off Bethesda, 1848Between Protestants
  • Seven arrested at a Bible reading, Florence, 1851Suffered by Protestants
  • Families divided by Exclusive discipline, 19th centuryBetween Protestants
  • Shunning before the Charity Commission, 2012 to 2016
1804–32

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Presbyterian channel

On the American frontier around 1800, settlers were scattered, churches few, and great revival meetings drew crowds from every church. In August 1801 a camp meeting at Cane Ridge, Kentucky, drew, by one reckoning, between twenty and thirty thousand people.

Barton W. Stone, the Presbyterian minister there, and four other preachers taught that Christ died for all and any sinner could believe and be saved at once. Defenders of the Presbyterian statement of faith, the Westminster Confession, said this denied its Calvinist teaching. In 1803 the five withdrew from their synod.

Within a year they felt their own new body “savored of a party spirit”. On 28 June 1804 they dissolved it and took the name Christian alone.

What we still share
  • Faith in Christ and the Bible, and baptism “in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit” (Disciples–Catholic report, 1981).
  • Baptism by immersion, which the Catholic Church holds valid when given in the name of the Trinity (Ecumenical Directory 95).
  • The Lord’s Supper every Sunday: “Disciples and Catholics celebrate the Eucharist at least every Sunday” (report of 2013).
  • A founding passion for unity: “The union of Christians is essential to the conversion of the world” (Alexander Campbell).
How they describe it

Members see themselves not as a denomination but as Christians only, restoring the church of the New Testament so that all believers can unite on the Bible alone.

What it cost
  • Suspended by the Synod of Kentucky, 1803Between Protestants
  • Thomas Campbell tried and turned away, 1807 to 1810Between Protestants
  • Put out by the Baptists, about 1830 to 1832Between Protestants
  • Campbell debates Bishop Purcell, Cincinnati, January 1837Suffered by Catholics
  • No split over slavery, and no rule against slaveholders, 1845
  • The movement divides, 1849 to 1906Between Protestants
  • Separate seats and segregated colleges, to the 1960s
A crowded printed chart of the prophecies of Daniel and Revelation, with a great statue, winged beasts, a crucifix and columns of dates that add up to 1843.
The Millerite chart of the visions of Daniel and John, published in Boston by Joshua V. Himes, which works the prophecies out to the year 1843; this copy is a later reproduction.
1844Historical

The Great Disappointment

William Miller, a Baptist farmer and preacher in New York State, read the prophecy of Daniel 8:14 as a timetable and concluded that Christ would return around 1843. His followers, the Millerites, came from many Protestant churches.

When the spring of 1844 passed, one of their preachers, Samuel Snow, fixed the day at 22 October 1844, the Day of Atonement by one Jewish reckoning.

Shops closed, some farmers left crops in the fields, and believers gathered to wait. Christ did not come. ‘We wept, and wept, till the day dawn,’ wrote Hiram Edson, a farmer among them. Most Millerites gave up.

A small group decided the date had been right but the event wrong: Christ had entered the inner room of a sanctuary in heaven. They took up the Saturday Sabbath and the visions of a young believer, Ellen White, and in 1863 became the Seventh-day Adventist Church.

“Our fondest hopes and expectations were blasted, and such a spirit of weeping came over us as I never experienced before. It seemed that the loss of all earthly friends could have been no comparison. We wept, and wept, till the day dawn.”
Hiram Edson: Disappointed Millerite – Part 1 · Hiram Edson, undated manuscript, as printed in George Knight, William Miller and the Rise of Adventism (2010), p. 185, and quoted by Brian E. Strayer
What the Church says

The Church does not hold today’s Adventists guilty of the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).

Their baptism, by immersion in the name of the Trinity, is valid (Ecumenical Directory 95), and it truly joins them to Christ, though the Church holds that these communities lack the sacrament of Orders, the ordination of bishops and priests (UR 22).

On the date, the Catechism teaches that Christ’s coming has been close at hand since the Ascension, though ‘it is not for you to know times or seasons which the Father has fixed by his own authority’ (CCC 673).

Adventists jailed for working on Sunday, and Vladimir Shelkov, leader of a Soviet Adventist group, who died in a labour camp in 1980, suffered what the Church now condemns: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Here Adventists and the Council stand together. The Adventist liberty association calls religious freedom ‘a basic right for every human being’.

1863

Real but imperfect communionfrom the Baptist channel

In the early 1800s a wave of American revivals stirred wide interest in the Bible and in Christ’s Second Coming. William Miller, a Baptist farmer in New York state, studied the Bible for two years and concluded in 1818 that Christ would return “in about twenty-five years”.

He read the 2,300 days of Daniel 8:14 as years, counted them from 457 BC, and reached 1843. He did not set out to found a church: his followers, the Millerites, stayed in their own Baptist, Methodist and other churches.

When 1843 passed, a preacher, Samuel Snow, fixed on 22 October 1844. An Adventist historian puts the number who accepted the date at between 50,000 and 100,000. The day passed like any other.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible and Christ: “one God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, a unity of three coeternal Persons” (Fundamental Beliefs 2).
  • Baptism by immersion in “the threefold name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit” (Church Manual), which the Catholic Church holds valid (Ecumenical Directory 95; *Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • Hope in Christ’s return in glory. Catholics too believe it could come at any time, though no one knows when (Catechism 673).
How they describe it

Seventh-day Adventists see themselves as the faithful remnant called in the last days to keep God’s commandments, the Sabbath among them, and to announce that Christ is coming soon.

What it cost
  • Put out of their churches, 1843 to 1844Between Protestants
  • Jailed and put on chain gangs for Sunday work, 1885 to 1896Between Protestants
  • The 1914 split over bearing armsBetween Protestants
  • Members of Jewish origin abandoned, 1933 to 1945
  • Vladimir Shelkov dies in a Soviet camp, 1980
  • The papacy named as the beast of Revelation, 1888 and afterSuffered by Catholics
1878

Real but non-sacramental communionfrom the Methodist channel

William Booth grew up a devoted Methodist in Nottingham and became a minister of a small Methodist church. His wife Catherine defended a woman’s right to preach, and from 1860 preached herself.

In 1861 Booth left his church so that he could travel as an evangelist.

In 1865, in London’s poor East End, he preached to crowds outside the Blind Beggar pub and in a tent in an old burial ground. He came home and told Catherine: “O Kate, I have found my destiny!”

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity, the Bible as “the Divine rule of Christian faith and practice”, and Christ “truly and properly God and truly and properly man” (Salvation Army Doctrines).
  • Faith, hope and love, which Vatican II says “can exist outside the visible boundaries of the Catholic Church” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 3).
  • Care for the poor, which Pope Francis called “an evident and credible sign of evangelical love” (2019).
How they describe it

Salvationists describe The Salvation Army as “an evangelical part of the universal Christian Church”, raised up by God to preach Christ and to meet human need without discrimination.

What it cost
  • Mobs and Skeleton Armies, 1880 to 1882
  • Jailed for disturbing the peace, 1880s
  • Preached against by bishops and canons, 1880 to 1882Between Protestants
  • Turned away from Communion, about 1882Between Protestants
  • Heads broken in Bolton's Catholic quarter, 1882Suffered by Protestants
  • Banned in Switzerland, jailed at Neuchâtel, 1883
A contemporary painting of the First Vatican Council in session in St Peter’s, 1870.
The First Vatican Council in session in the north transept of St Peter’s, 1870.
1870Revealed

First Vatican Council

For a thousand years popes had ruled a state in central Italy, and since the French Revolution liberal governments across Europe had been taking church lands, schools and monasteries. By 1860 the armies uniting Italy had seized almost all the Papal States; only Rome and the land around it were left, guarded by French troops. Pope Pius IX called a council there in 1869.

A strong party wanted the pope's infallibility defined; a minority of bishops, many of them French and German, thought it unwise or badly worded.

On 18 July 1870, with most of the minority gone home, the council defined that the pope has full authority over the whole Church, and that when he solemnly defines a teaching of faith or morals for the whole Church he is protected from error. The next day France went to war with Prussia and pulled its troops out of Rome.

On 20 September Italian troops took the city, and the council never resumed.

“We teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that when the Roman pontiff speaks ex cathedra … he possesses … that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals. Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.”
Pastor Aeternus, First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of Christ · Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4
What the Church says

Its definition of the pope's primacy and infallibility is Catholic doctrine (CCC 891). The Second Vatican Council set it within the teaching that the bishops, as a college united with the pope, share responsibility for the whole Church (Lumen Gentium 22).

The Church no longer asks for a state of its own beyond the small Vatican City. The Council said that the Church ‘does not place her trust in the privileges offered by civil authority’ (Gaudium et Spes 76).

A printed notice headed The Christian Mission, under the superintendence of the Rev. William Booth, is a Volunteer Army, with quotations from the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Earl of Shaftesbury.
A Christian Mission notice of 1878 calling the mission 'a Volunteer Army', the phrase Booth rewrote as Salvation Army.
1878Historical

Booth's mission becomes The Salvation Army

In 1865 William Booth, a former Methodist minister, and his wife Catherine began preaching to the poor of London's East End. Their Christian Mission meant to send its converts to the churches, but the churches did not take them, so it kept them and slowly became a church of its own.

In August 1878 a deed made Booth its sole leader, and that year he crossed out Volunteer in the phrase ‘a Volunteer Army’ and wrote Salvation.

Preachers became officers, members became soldiers and Booth became the General. Women preached and led as equals. Mobs attacked the marches, and magistrates jailed Salvationists for breaking the peace.

In 1883 Booth stopped the Army holding baptism and the Lord's Supper, the two rites most churches hold Jesus himself commanded. It works today in 134 countries, and in Singapore since 1935.

“shall be always hereafter under the oversight direction and control of some one person who shall be the General Superintendent and thereof whose duty it shall be to determine and enforce the discipline and laws and superintend the operations of the said Christian Mission and to conserve the same to and for the objects and purposes for which it was first …”
'The Foundation Deeds have never failed': The Salvation Army Acts deconstructed · Deed of Constitution of the Christian Mission, 7 August 1878, as quoted by the Army's International Heritage Centre
What the Church says

In 2014 Pope Francis told the Army’s leaders that the differences between them ‘need not impede the witness of our shared love of God and love of neighbour’. He also owned an older Catholic narrowness: in 1940, he said, ‘it was thought that all Protestants went to hell.’

The Catholic–Salvation Army conversations, whose report was signed in May 2012, found ‘encouraging degrees of consensus’ and ‘areas of sincerely held difference’, among them ‘the role of the sacraments in Christian life’.

That difference is real.

The Church teaches that baptism ‘constitutes the foundation of communion among all Christians’ (Catechism 1271), so the sacramental bond it recognises reaches Salvationists who were baptised in another church.

But faith, hope and charity live outside the Church’s visible boundaries too (UR 3), and ‘God has bound salvation to the sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments’ (Catechism 1257).

On the mobs and the jailings, the Second Vatican Council’s rule is plain: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Saints of this age

16 lives, among many

Signs in this age
  • Benoîte Rencurel, a shepherdess born in 1647, said that from May 1664 a ‘belle dame’, a beautiful lady, appeared to her daily for four months, and then at Le Laus, where she was told to have a chapel built. By her account the apparitions continued for fifty-four years, until her death in 1718.

    Not established: Any witness but Benoîte.

  • On 14 August 1730 thieves stole a pyx holding 351 consecrated hosts from San Francesco in Siena. The hosts were found three days later in an alms box in a nearby church, among dust and cobwebs, and were kept rather than consumed.

    Not established: The famous 1914 quotation may not be the commission’s.

  • Between July and December 1830 Catherine Labouré, a novice of the Daughters of Charity, told her confessor that the Virgin had appeared to her three times in the house chapel on the rue du Bac, and in November had shown her an oval image with the words ‘O Mary conceived without sin, pray for us who have recourse to you’, to be struck as a medal.

    Not established: The seer was never questioned.

  • On 19 September 1846 two cowherds, Mélanie Calvat, fourteen, and Maximin Giraud, eleven, said they had seen a weeping Lady on the mountain above La Salette, who spoke of the neglect of Sunday and of blasphemy, warned of famine and failing crops, and gave each child a secret.

    Not established: Anything beyond the children’s word.

  • Between 11 February and 16 July 1858 Bernadette Soubirous, fourteen, reported eighteen appearances of a young woman at the grotto of Massabielle. She said the figure told her to dig where a spring then flowed, asked for a chapel and processions, and on 25 March named herself, in the local dialect, the Immaculate Conception, a title defined as dogma four years earlier.

    Not established: The apparitions rest on one witness.

  • In October 1859 Adele Brise, a twenty-eight-year-old Belgian immigrant, said a lady ‘dressed in dazzling white’ appeared to her three times near Robinsonville, Wisconsin, standing between two trees on the path she walked to Mass. The lady asked her to pray for sinners and to ‘gather the children’ and teach them. Adele spent the rest of her life doing so.

    Not established: That the fire stopped for the prayers.

  • On the evening of 17 January 1871, with the Prussian army advancing on Laval, two brothers working in their father’s barn, Eugène and Joseph Barbedette, said they saw a Beautiful Lady in a blue robe sown with stars in the sky above the village. Two other children said they saw her too; the adults who gathered, including the parish priest, saw nothing.

    Not established: Anything seen by an adult.

  • From 27 June to 16 September 1877 two girls from poor Polish families, Justyna Szafryńska, thirteen, and Barbara Samulowska, twelve, reported apparitions of the Virgin above a maple in front of the parish church of Gietrzwałd, in Prussian Warmia. The Virgin spoke to them in Polish, ‘in the language they speak in Poland’, as the priest-historian Franz Hipler put it, in the years of Bismarck’s Kulturkampf against the Catholic Church.

    Not established: That the setting explains nothing.

  • On the rainy evening of 21 August 1879 fifteen people of Knock, aged about five to seventy-five, reported seeing three motionless figures at the south gable of the parish church: the Virgin, St Joseph and St John, beside an altar with a lamb and a cross, surrounded by angels and light. They watched for about two hours and said the rosary.

    Not established: Neither commission’s report has been published.