The Springfield Presbytery dissolves itself
At Cane Ridge, Kentucky, the six members of a presbytery that had broken away from its Presbyterian synod sign its last will, so that it may 'die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large'.
In 1801 a huge revival meeting at Cane Ridge, Kentucky, brought Presbyterian, Methodist and Baptist preachers together before tens of thousands. Afterwards some Presbyterian ministers, among them Barton W. Stone, were accused of preaching against their church's statement of faith.
In September 1803 five of them broke with their synod, the regional council of ministers and elders, and set up a presbytery of their own.
Within a year they decided it ‘savored of a party spirit’, the very thing they had set out to escape. On 28 June 1804, at Cane Ridge, the six members signed a document written as a will: ‘that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large’. From then on they called themselves simply Christians.
In 1832 they united with the followers of Alexander Campbell, who also wanted to restore the church of the New Testament, and from that union came the Churches of Christ and the Disciples of Christ.
The situation
Kentucky around 1800 was frontier country, newly settled after the American Revolution. Camp meetings, open-air revivals lasting several days, drew settlers from miles around.
Its Presbyterians were governed by church courts. Ministers and elders of an area formed a presbytery, and presbyteries answered to a synod. Every minister accepted the Westminster Confession, the church's statement of faith, with its teaching that God chooses whom he will save.
Barton Stone accepted it at his in 1798 only ‘as far as I see it consistent with the word of God’. Then revival swept the region.
At Cane Ridge in August 1801, Presbyterian, Methodist and Baptist preachers worked side by side for six or seven days. Witnesses put the crowd at twenty to thirty thousand.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
A Methodist's count at Cane Ridge
James B. Finley came from Ohio determined not to be moved, was converted at the meeting, and became a leading Methodist minister. He wrote this account in 1852.
“A vast crowd, supposed by some to have amounted to twenty-five thousand, was collected together. The noise was like the roar of Niagara.”
The Cane Ridge Meeting-House · p. 60, quoting James B. Finley (1852) - 02
Stone's condition at his ordination
In 1798 Stone told the two leading ministers of his presbytery that he had doubts about the Confession, the Trinity among them, and meant to decline ordination. They asked how far he could accept it.
“They asked me how far I was willing to receive the confession? I told them, as far as I saw it consistent with the word of God.”
What was at stake
The revival preachers told the crowds that Jesus died for all, and that any sinner could believe and be saved now. To them this was simply the gospel.
Defenders of the Confession heard a denial of its teaching that God chooses the saved. To them the revival was sliding toward error, and the church courts existed to stop exactly that. One respected minister warned that ‘every departure from Calvinism was an advance to atheism’.
In September 1803 the Synod of Kentucky took up the case of Richard McNemar. Stone and four colleagues saw their own fate in it. They withdrew, in Stone's words, ‘from their jurisdiction, but not from their ’, and formed the Springfield Presbytery. The Synod suspended them.
But a new presbytery was one more party, and division was what they had set out to overcome.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
The Synod's best argument
The Synod sent a committee to bring the five back. One member was convinced by them and joined them. Stone records the main argument of the most respected member, the veteran minister David Rice.
“that every departure from Calvinism was an advance to atheism”
The event
On 28 June 1804 the Springfield Presbytery, ‘sitting at Caneridge’, made its last will. The first item willed ‘that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of at large’.
Other items gave up its name and ‘Reverend title’, ended its power to make church laws, and left each congregation to choose its own preacher. They told the people to ‘take the as the only sure guide to ’.
Robert Marshall, John Dunlavy, Richard McNemar, Barton Stone, John Thompson and David Purviance signed. They kept no name but Christian, the name first given to the at Antioch.
Their reasons were printed with it. The Witnesses' Address blamed Christian divisions on ‘human creeds and forms of government’.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Why the presbytery had to die
The Witnesses' Address, printed with the Will, gives the signers' reasons.
“With deep concern they viewed the divisions, and party spirit among professing Christians, principally owing to the adoption of human creeds and forms of government.”
The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, with the Witnesses' Address · The Witnesses' Address - 02
No warrant for synods
While writing a pamphlet on church government, the signers concluded that the whole Presbyterian structure had no basis in Scripture.
“they soon found that there was neither precept nor example in the New Testament for such confederacies as modern Church Sessions, Presbyteries, Synods, General Assemblies, etc.”
The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery, with the Witnesses' Address · The Witnesses' Address - 03
A name from Antioch
Stone explains why they dropped the Springfield name after a year.
“With the man-made creeds we threw it overboard, and took the name Christian — the name given to the disciples by divine appointment first at Antioch.”
The Cane Ridge Meeting-House · p. 172, reprinting Stone's autobiography
The outcome
Stone later wrote that ‘from this period I date the commencement of that reformation’. Churches calling themselves simply Christian spread through Kentucky and Ohio.
The signers did not hold together. Missionaries of the Shakers, a sect that asked converts to give up marriage, won over McNemar and Dunlavy. Marshall and Thompson wanted ‘to embody a few fundamental truths’ as a creed, and when the others refused they went back to the Presbyterians.
Of the five ministers who had left the Synod, only Stone remained. In 1832 his Christians united with the Reformers, the followers of Alexander Campbell, who also wanted to restore the church of the . From that union came the Churches of Christ, the Disciples of Christ and the Christian Churches.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The Shakers arrive
Shaker missionaries from the East told converts to confess their sins to them and give up marriage. Stone names the preachers who went over.
“among whom were three of our preachers, Matthew Houston, Richard M'Nemar, and John Dunlavy.”
- 02
Two go back
Marshall and Thompson came to think the movement needed a short written creed. When the others would not adopt one, they returned to the Presbyterian Church.
“that there was a necessity, at this time, to embody a few fundamental truths, and to make a permanent and final stand upon them.”
The Cane Ridge Meeting-House · pp. 188–189, reprinting Stone's autobiography, ch. IX - 03
The handshake at Lexington, 1832
At the union meeting, 'Raccoon' John Smith spoke for Campbell's followers and ended with this appeal. Stone rose, agreed, and gave him his hand.
“Let us, then, my brethren, be no longer Campbellites or Stoneites, New Lights or Old Lights, or any other kind of lights, but let us all come to the Bible, and to the Bible alone, as the only book in the world that can give us all the Light we need.”
For the trail
The Last Will is the charter of a new idea: a church that refuses to be a denomination. Its heirs are the Churches of Christ, the Disciples and, by one modern account, the non-denominational churches of North America.
It also raises the question every channel on the River faces. The signers were right that Christians are called to be one body. Their answer was to give up every structure but the Bible, and trust Christ and his word to keep believers one.
The Catholic Church holds that Christ gave his Church a visible bond as well as a book: the successors of the , the , gathered round the successor of .
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Thomas Campbell's first proposition, 1809
Five years later in Pennsylvania, the Declaration and Address stated the same conviction as a principle.
“That the Church of Christ upon earth is essentially, intentionally, and constitutionally one; consisting of all those in every place that profess their faith in Christ and obedience to him in all things according to the Scriptures”
- 02
The same aim, opposite means
The first report of the Catholic–Disciples dialogue put the difference between the two churches in two sentences.
“the Disciples of Christ, called into being as an instrument of unity among divided Christians, have refused to make creeds the definitive faith in order to promote unity and communion among Christians. The Roman Catholic Church, on the other hand, holds to the creeds and the Petrine ministry for the same purpose.”
- 03
What one table means
Both churches celebrate the Lord's Supper every Sunday. The fourth report explains why they still cannot share it.
“The founders of the Disciples, notably Alexander Campbell and Barton Warren Stone, taught that the communion service demonstrated the oneness of all believers. For Catholics, sharing the Eucharist signifies full communion in Christ’s body, the Church, which means sharing agreement on the content of faith, the sacraments and ministry of the Church, and structures of authority (see LG §14).”
- 04
Ancestor of non-denominational churches
Wikipedia's article on non-denominational Christianity names this movement as its starting point in North America. The article elsewhere says the 18th century; the movement began in the 19th.
“In North America, non-denominational Christianity arose in the 19th century through the Stone-Campbell Restoration Movement”
Wikipedia, 'Nondenominational Christianity' · lead section (tertiary)
What the Church says
The Catholic Church shares the Last Will’s starting point: division among Christians ‘openly contradicts the will of Christ’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 1).
It counts the members of the Stone–Campbell churches as brothers and sisters in Christ. Those born into these churches ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (UR 3), and their baptism, by immersion in the name of the Trinity, is valid and ‘establishes a sacramental bond of unity’ (UR 22; Ecumenical Directory 95).
Since 1977 the Church has held a formal dialogue with the Disciples of Christ. Its first report affirmed ‘the mutual recognition of baptism’ and named the real difference.
The Disciples refused creeds for the sake of unity, while Rome ‘holds to the creeds and the Petrine ministry for the same purpose’.
The Petrine ministry means the pope’s role as Peter’s successor. The goal both name is ‘full visible unity’.
“We will, that this body die, be dissolved, and sink into union with the Body of Christ at large; for there is but one body, and one Spirit, even as we are called in one hope of our calling.”
The Will goes on to bequeath 'that our name of distinction, with its Reverend title, be forgotten' and that 'the people may have free course to the Bible'. It is signed by Robert Marshall, John Dunlavy, Richard McNemar, B. W. Stone, John Thompson and David Purviance.
Where people disagree
Was the Last Will a step toward unity or the birth of one more sect? In 1810 the Presbyterian Synod of Pittsburgh said such plans ended ‘by promoting divisions instead of union’. The 1909 Catholic Encyclopedia agreed, more harshly.
The movement's heirs reply that they founded no church. The Catholic–Disciples dialogue notes that the movement ‘had nothing to do with a deliberate break from the Roman Catholic Church’.
The movement did divide, into three streams. Its members answer that quarrels over whether to use organs in worship and whether to form missionary societies show human failure, not a false principle.
Catholics answer, in the dialogue's words, that the bishops in communion with Rome are ‘a necessary means of preserving the Church in continuity with the apostles’.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
A Presbyterian synod's warning, 1810
Refusing to receive Thomas Campbell, the Synod of Pittsburgh gave its reasons against all such plans.
“by promoting divisions instead of union, by degrading the ministerial character, by providing free admission to any errors in doctrine”
Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, vol. 1 · vol. 1, p. 327 (minute of the Synod of Pittsburgh, 4 October 1810) - 02
The Catholic Encyclopedia's verdict, 1909
Writing of Thomas Campbell's aim, a Catholic reference work of 1909 judged the whole idea harshly. The Church's later dialogue with the Disciples speaks very differently.
“the hallucination of so many noble minds, the only outcome of which must always be against the will of the Founder, to increase the discord of Christendom by the creation of a new sect”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Disciples of Christ', first paragraph - 03
No break with Rome
The dialogue's second report points out what makes this partner unusual among Protestants.
“The Disciples movement emerged out of nineteenth-century Protestantism but it had nothing to do with a deliberate break from the Roman Catholic Church and lacked the memories of sixteenth and seventeenth-century controversies.”
- 04
Stone and the Trinity
Stone admitted doubts about the Trinity as the Westminster Confession taught it, and in 1832 some Reformers suspected his Christians of Arianism, the ancient denial that the Son is fully God. The 1911 Britannica says the Disciples are "not Unitarian in fact or tendency", and the 2002 dialogue report says their target was later confessions, not the ancient creeds.
“I stumbled at the doctrine of Trinity as taught in the Confession”
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Springfield Presbytery (Robert Marshall, John Dunlavy, Richard McNemar, Barton W. Stone, John Thompson, David Purviance) · 1804-06-28 · Wikisource transcription (Witnesses' Address from C. A. Young, Historical Documents Advocating Christian Union, 1904)
- Barton W. Stone; additions by John Rogers · 1847 · Cincinnati: J. A. & U. P. James; Internet Archive OCR text
- Thomas Campbell · 1809 · Wikisource transcription
- Disciples of Christ-Roman Catholic International Commission for Dialogue · 1981 (published 1982) · christianunity.va
- unsigned · 1911 · Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th edition, vol. 8; Wikisource transcription