The RiverRevolutions and missionsUnion
1698–1700

Romanian Greek Catholic Church

The union of Transylvania

In 1698–1700 the Orthodox Romanians of Transylvania, under Habsburg rule, entered communion with Rome. Within fifty years about half had gone back to Orthodoxy.

Byzantine tradition · a channel rejoining the main stream from the Eastern Orthodox

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

In 1687 the Habsburg emperor drove the Turks out of Transylvania and took it over. Most of its people were Orthodox Romanians, and they did not have full civil rights; the Hungarians were mostly Calvinist and the Germans Lutheran.

The Habsburgs wanted the Orthodox to become Catholics of their own Eastern rite, and Jesuit missionaries began working among them in 1693.

In 1698 Atanasie, the metropolitan, or senior Orthodox bishop, of Transylvania, accepted union with Rome, and a synod he called confirmed it on 4 September 1700. At first most of the province's Romanians came with him.

In 1744 a monk named Visarion led an uprising back to Orthodoxy that troops could not put down, and about half returned.

In 1948 the communist state outlawed the Greek Catholic Church and imprisoned its bishops. It came back after 1989.

Where we are

The situation

Transylvania, now part of Romania, had belonged to Hungary and then come under Ottoman control. Most of its people were Romanians, but the Orthodox didn't have full civil rights. The Hungarians were mostly Calvinist and the Germans Lutheran.

In 1687 the Catholic Habsburg emperor Leopold I drove the Turks out and took the province. His policy was to bring his Orthodox subjects into the Catholic Church, keeping their Eastern rite.

Jesuit missionaries began working among the Romanians in 1693.

The problem

What was at stake

Three pressures met. The emperor wanted Catholic subjects. The Orthodox were denied full civil rights. And Protestantism was spreading around them, which worried the Orthodox clergy.

A union meant entering with Rome, sharing faith and with the , while keeping their Byzantine and their own priests. It came with a promise of religious and civil rights they had never had.

What happened

The event

In 1698 Atanasie, the Orthodox metropolitan of Transylvania, its senior , accepted union with Rome. A synod he called concluded it on 4 September 1700.

At first most of the province's Romanian Orthodox came with him.

What came of it

The outcome

The rights promised at the union proved hard to get in practice.

In 1744 an Orthodox monk, Visarion, led a popular uprising back to Orthodoxy. The government tried to enforce the union, even with troops, but resistance was too strong.

In 1759 Empress Maria Theresa reluctantly allowed an Orthodox bishop for Transylvania. About half the Romanians went back to Orthodoxy. One Church had become two.

Two centuries later the costs ran the other way. In 1948 the communist government outlawed the Greek Catholic Church and handed its churches to the Orthodox. All its bishops were imprisoned.

It came back after 1989, and disputes with the Orthodox over the confiscated churches followed. Today the Romanian Greek Catholic Church is in full with Rome; the Romanian Orthodox Church is not, though it takes part in the official dialogue.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Half of them went back, and troops could not stop it

    The uprising of 1744 and its result, in the reference work's own words. An empress conceding an Orthodox bishop is the measure of how far the union had failed.

    “But in 1744, the Orthodox monk Visarion led a popular uprising that sparked a widespread movement back to Orthodoxy. In spite of government efforts to enforce the union with Rome – even by military means – resistance was so strong that Empress Maria Theresa reluctantly allowed the appointment of a bishop for the Romanian Orthodox in Transylvania in 1759. In the end, about half of the Transylvanian Romanians returned to Orthodoxy.”
    Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Romania, Greek Catholic Church of'
  2. 02

    Pope Francis at Blaj, 2019

    At the beatification of seven bishops of this Church, the pope described what the communist years did to it.

    “All the Bishops and faithful of the Greek-Catholic Church and those of the Latin-rite Catholic Church were persecuted and imprisoned.”
    Divine Liturgy with the Beatification of 7 Greek-Catholic Martyr Bishops, Blaj · Homily at the Divine Liturgy with the beatification of seven Greek-Catholic martyr bishops, Blaj, 2 June 2019
Why it matters

For the trail

Transylvania is the union where the state's hand is plainest. When a government denies civil rights to one Church and offers them to another, a religious choice becomes a civil one.

But the Church born from it later kept its faith through prison under communism. In 2019 Pope Francis beatified seven of its bishops at Blaj, its historic centre.

What still divides the two Churches is what divides Catholics and Orthodox everywhere: mainly the pope's authority, which the official dialogue has been working on since 2006.

The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

Like every Eastern Catholic Church, it is ==equal in dignity to the Latin Church==, with its own liturgy and the right to govern itself (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 3, 5 and 6).

In 1993, at Balamand in Lebanon, Catholics and Orthodox agreed that unions like this one, bringing part of a Church over to Rome on its own, ==must not be used again==, and that the Eastern Catholic Churches that exist have every right to exist and to look after their people.

In 2019 Pope Francis beatified seven Romanian Greek Catholic bishops who were persecuted and imprisoned under communism, at Blaj, the Church's historic centre.

In plain terms

Think of it like this

A door held open on one side of a corridor, and civil rights only on the other side.

Nobody was compelled by law to enter the union in Transylvania. Nobody outside it had full civil rights either. When the incentive was removed, and a monk gave the resistance a leader, about half the province walked back out.

Read the text
“It was his policy to encourage the Orthodox within his realm to become Greek Catholic, and so the Jesuits began to work as missionaries among the Transylvanian Romanians in 1693. Their efforts, combined with the denial of full civil rights to the Orthodox and the spread of Protestantism in the area, which caused growing concern among the Orthodox clergy, contributed to the acceptance of a union with Rome by Orthodox Metropolitan Atanasie of Transylvania in 1698. he later convoked a synod which formally concluded the agreement on 4 September 1700.”
Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Christian East · entry 'Romania, Greek Catholic Church of'

The lower-case 'he' is the reference work's own typography, which drops capitals after some line breaks. This is a Catholic encyclopaedia listing the denial of civil rights to the Orthodox among the causes of a Catholic union.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Romanian Orthodox historians read 1698–1700 as Habsburg religious policy. A Catholic reference work itself lists denied civil rights among the causes.

In 1993 the two Churches reacted to Balamand in opposite ways. The Romanian Orthodox synod accepted it within days. The Greek Catholic bishops denounced it.

As they saw it, the union had freed them from domination by the Orthodox hierarchy and given them strength to resist the communists. They rejected the dialogue's verdict on , the old method of bringing one part of a Church over to Rome on its own.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The heirs of this union rejected Balamand

    Written by a Catholic who served on the staff of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity. The Romanian Greek Catholic bishops did not receive the dialogue's verdict on uniatism quietly.

    “But the next day, on 8 July, the Greek Catholic bishops sent a letter to Pope John Paul II fiercely denouncing Balamand. They took strong exception to its rejection of uniatism as a method of achieving unity with the Orthodox”
    Balamand and Beyond: The State of Catholic-Orthodox Relations, ONE Magazine · Section on local reactions, paragraph on Romania
  2. 02

    The Romanian Orthodox answer to Balamand

    The same report that records the Greek Catholic bishops' rejection records the Orthodox synod's acceptance, days earlier.

    “Meeting on 6-7 July 1993, only a few days after the Balamand meeting, the Holy Synod of the Romanian Orthodox Church formally accepted the document and pledged to continue to participate in the dialogue with Rome if the principles elaborated in the document were adopted by the Holy See and applied in Romania.”
    Balamand and Beyond: The State of Catholic-Orthodox Relations, ONE Magazine · Section on local reactions, paragraph on Romania

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Claims behind this footprint

What this rests on

Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Habsburg policy after the annexation of Transylvania in 1687 was to encourage the Orthodox of the realm to become Greek Catholic. Jesuit missionaries began work among the Transylvanian Romanians in 1693; their efforts, the denial of full civil rights to the Orthodox, and the spread of Protestantism contributed to Orthodox Metropolitan Atanasie's acceptance of union in 1698, and a synod formally concluded it on 4 September 1700. After the uprising led by the monk Visarion in 1744, about half of the Transylvanian Romanians returned to Orthodoxy.

Rests on
  • entry 'Romania, Greek Catholic Church of'
    “It was his policy to encourage the Orthodox within his realm to become Greek Catholic, and so the Jesuits began to work as missionaries among the Transylvanian Romanians in 1693. Their efforts, combined with the denial of full civil rights to the …”
    Read the full passage
    “It was his policy to encourage the Orthodox within his realm to become Greek Catholic, and so the Jesuits began to work as missionaries among the Transylvanian Romanians in 1693. Their efforts, combined with the denial of full civil rights to the Orthodox and the spread of Protestantism in the area, which caused growing concern among the Orthodox clergy, contributed to the acceptance of a union with Rome by Orthodox Metropolitan Atanasie of Transylvania in 1698. he later convoked a synod which formally concluded the agreement on 4 September 1700.”
  • entry 'Romania, Greek Catholic Church of'
    “But in 1744, the Orthodox monk Visarion led a popular uprising that sparked a widespread movement back to Orthodoxy. In spite of government efforts to enforce the union with Rome – even by military means – resistance was so strong that Empress Maria …”
    Read the full passage
    “But in 1744, the Orthodox monk Visarion led a popular uprising that sparked a widespread movement back to Orthodoxy. In spite of government efforts to enforce the union with Rome – even by military means – resistance was so strong that Empress Maria Theresa reluctantly allowed the appointment of a bishop for the Romanian Orthodox in Transylvania in 1759. In the end, about half of the Transylvanian Romanians returned to Orthodoxy.”
Limits
  • 'About half' is the reference work's estimate and carries no figure or source behind it on the page read.
  • The claim states the causes the reference work names. It does not establish the interior motives of Metropolitan Atanasie or of anyone who followed him.
  • The Romanian Greek Catholic Church was later suppressed under communism and its bishops imprisoned. Nothing in this claim about how the union was made bears on that.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

02HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Balamand was not received uniformly by either Church. The Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem and the Orthodox churches of Georgia, Serbia, Bulgaria, Greece and the Czech and Slovak republics were not present. Representatives of the twenty monasteries of Mount Athos denounced the document in a letter dated 8 December 1993, and in December 1994 the Holy Synod of the Church of Greece rejected it, because it does not condemn the existence of the Eastern Catholic churches and because it prematurely implies Orthodox recognition of the Catholic Church and its sacraments. In Romania the Orthodox synod accepted it on 6-7 July 1993, while the Greek Catholic bishops denounced it from the opposite direction on 8 July. The Orthodox/Roman Catholic Consultation in the United States welcomed it on 15 October 1994.

Rests on
  • Balamand and Beyond, paragraph on the 1993 session
    “The Orthodox delegation, however, was incomplete. For various reasons, the Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem and the Orthodox churches of Georgia, Serbia, Bulgaria, Greece and the Czech and Slovak republics were not present.”
  • Balamand and Beyond, section on local reactions, paragraph on Greece and Mount Athos
    “The Orthodox Church of Greece, which did not send a delegation to Balamand, has judged the document unacceptable from the Orthodox point of view. In December 1994 the Holy Synod in Athens sent a letter to the Ecumenical Patriarch rejecting Balamand …”
    Read the full passage
    “The Orthodox Church of Greece, which did not send a delegation to Balamand, has judged the document unacceptable from the Orthodox point of view. In December 1994 the Holy Synod in Athens sent a letter to the Ecumenical Patriarch rejecting Balamand because it does not condemn the existence of the Eastern Catholic churches and because it prematurely implies a recognition by the Orthodox of the ecclesial reality of the Catholic Church and the validity of its sacraments.”
  • Balamand and Beyond, section on local reactions, paragraph on Romania
    “Meeting on 6-7 July 1993, only a few days after the Balamand meeting, the Holy Synod of the Romanian Orthodox Church formally accepted the document and pledged to continue to participate in the dialogue with Rome if the principles elaborated in the …”
    Read the full passage
    “Meeting on 6-7 July 1993, only a few days after the Balamand meeting, the Holy Synod of the Romanian Orthodox Church formally accepted the document and pledged to continue to participate in the dialogue with Rome if the principles elaborated in the document were adopted by the Holy See and applied in Romania. But the next day, on 8 July, the Greek Catholic bishops sent a letter to Pope John Paul II fiercely denouncing Balamand. They took strong exception to its rejection of uniatism as a method of achieving unity with the Orthodox”
  • Letter to the Ecumenical Patriarch, dated December 8, 1993; Section I, paragraph beginning 'The gravest matter'
    “The gravest matter, however, is the unacceptable change in the position of the Orthodox that arises from the joint statement at the June, 1993, Balamand Conference of the mixed commission for the dialogue between Roman Catholics and Orthodox. It …”
    Read the full passage
    “The gravest matter, however, is the unacceptable change in the position of the Orthodox that arises from the joint statement at the June, 1993, Balamand Conference of the mixed commission for the dialogue between Roman Catholics and Orthodox. It adopted anti-Orthodox positions, and it is mainly to this that we call the attention of Your All Holiness.”
  • Letter to the Ecumenical Patriarch, signature
    “Signed by: All Representatives and Presidents of the Twenty Sacred Monasteries of the Holy Mountain of Athos”
  • Response of the Orthodox/Roman Catholic Consultation in the United States, §17 (closing paragraph), dated Brighton, MA, October 15, 1994
    “While pointing out some shortcomings of the Balamand Document, we nevertheless regard it to be a strong and positive contribution to the theological dialogue between our churches.”
Other readings
  • Orthodox critics of the dialogue, the Athonite monks among them, read the absences and rejections as proof that the dialogue does not speak for Orthodoxy.
  • Ecumenically minded Orthodox and Catholics point to the North American consultation and the Romanian Orthodox synod's acceptance of 6-7 July 1993 as proof that the rejections were not universal either.
  • The Romanian Greek Catholic bishops, as Roberson summarises their letter, credited the very "uniatism" Balamand rejected with freeing them from Orthodox domination and giving them strength to resist the communists. Not every Eastern Catholic leader agreed: Roberson also reports that the head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, Cardinal Lubachivsky, welcomed the text.
Limits
  • The single best source here for who was absent and who objected is a magazine article by a Catholic specialist who served on the staff of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity from 1988 to 1992. It is informed journalism by an interested party, not peer-reviewed scholarship, and it was retrieved through the Internet Archive.
  • The Athos letter is hosted on an openly anti-ecumenist site, in an English translation by George S. Gabriel first printed in The Ark (August 1994), and the page's own endnote notes an apparent typographical error in the Greek as printed. Athonite monasteries are not a synod and cannot be cited as the position of any Orthodox Church.
  • The Romanian Greek Catholic bishops' letter of 8 July 1993 was not retrieved; it is known here only through Roberson's 1995 summary. The chapter therefore reports that Eastern Catholic case at second hand, which is a real gap.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

Go deeper
Questions people ask next