The Brethren break bread without clergy
In Dublin from the late 1820s, and at Plymouth from 1831, Protestants who had left the Church of Ireland and other churches began to break bread every Sunday with no ordained minister, and became the Brethren.
In Dublin in the late 1820s a few Protestants, most of them members of the Church of Ireland, began meeting in private rooms to ‘break bread’, their name for the Lord's Supper, every Sunday. No clergyman led it; any man present might pray, read the Bible or give thanks.
Anthony Norris Groves first proposed it, John Nelson Darby gave it a theology, and from 1831 a meeting at Plymouth gave the movement its name.
Darby taught that the visible church was in ruins and that believers should simply gather round the Lord's Table. He also taught that Christ would take the Church to heaven before the last great tribulation, the ‘rapture’, an idea that later spread to many American evangelical churches.
In 1848 the movement split into Open Brethren, where each assembly decides for itself, and Exclusive Brethren. Brethren assemblies now meet worldwide, Singapore among them.
The situation
In the 1820s the Church of Ireland was the Anglican church established by law, paid for by tithes, though most of the Irish were Catholics.
Among its own members an evangelical revival was under way, and meetings in Dublin drawing rooms were, in one historian's phrase, ‘quite the rage with all serious minds’.
John Nelson Darby, a barrister turned curate, an assistant clergyman, in the Wicklow mountains, had been a strict High Churchman, meaning an Anglican who prized and .
By his own account he ‘thought much of Rome’ and held fully to , the belief that bishops carry on the ' authority in an unbroken line.
Then William Magee, the Archbishop of Dublin, made converts from Catholicism swear oaths of loyalty to the Crown as head of the Church. Darby protested that this tied souls to the state rather than to .
It led him, the 1911 Britannica says, to the idea that ‘established churches are as foreign to the spirit of Christianity as the papacy is’.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Darby before the break
Darby later described the churchmanship he held as a young clergyman, before he turned against every established church.
“I held apostolic succession fully, and the channels of grace to be there only. I held thus Luther and Calvin and their followers to be outside.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. I: The Beginnings of Brethrenism—The Dublin Movement · ch. I, quoting Darby's Analysis of Newman's Apologia - 02
Converts from Rome, by Darby's count
Darby blamed Archbishop Magee's oath for ending a wave of conversions in his diocese. The figure is his own, written thirty-eight years later.
“just at that time the Roman Catholics were becoming Protestants at the rate of 600 or 800 a week.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. I: The Beginnings of Brethrenism—The Dublin Movement · ch. I, quoting Darby - 03
The curate in the cabins
Francis Newman, brother of the future Cardinal Newman, spent fifteen months in Ireland as a tutor and described Darby at work among the Catholic poor of Wicklow.
“Such a phenomenon intensely excited the poor Romanists, who looked on him as a genuine ‘saint’ of the ancient breed.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. III: The Expansion of Brethrenism—The Movement in England · ch. III, quoting F. W. Newman's Phases of Faith
What was at stake
Darby's question was simple. If all true believers are one body in Christ, why can they not eat the Lord's Supper together?
His 1828 pamphlet answered that ‘the true Church of God has no avowed at all’. Believers were scattered through rival bodies. The Supper, he wrote, is the outward sign and instrument of unity.
Groves reached the practical answer first. If Scripture requires no to preach, believers may meet and break bread with no minister at all.
The diagnosis was right: division wounds the Church. The cure they chose was to leave every church and begin again.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Every label antichristian
Darby's 1828 pamphlet did not spare the Protestant churches either.
“So far as men pride themselves on being Established, Presbyterian, Baptist, Independent, or anything else, they are antichristian.”
Considerations on the Nature and Unity of the Church of Christ · Collected Writings vol. 1, p. 31 - 02
No ordination required
Groves had hoped to go out as a lay missionary of the Church Missionary Society, but it would not let him celebrate the Lord's Supper when no minister was near. Then, he wrote, a new thought came to him.
“ordination of any kind to preach the gospel is no requirement of Scripture. To me it was the removal of a mountain.”
Memoir of Anthony Norris Groves, compiled chiefly from his journals and letters · Memoir (3rd ed., 1869), ch. III, pp. 42-43
The event
Groves, an Exeter dentist studying in Dublin to become an Anglican clergyman, proposed around 1827 that believers were free to break bread every Lord's Day. Edward Cronin, a medical student, was refused communion by Dublin's chapels unless he joined one, and began breaking bread with a friend.
In November 1829 Francis Hutchinson opened a room in his house in Fitzwilliam Square to a regular Sunday meeting. No ordained minister presided: the was held to lead, and any brother might pray or speak.
In May 1830 the meeting moved to a hired room in Aungier Street. That summer Darby met Benjamin Wills Newton at Oxford and went with him to Plymouth, where breaking of bread began in 1831.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
A walk down Lower Pembroke Street
Bellett remembered the moment, towards the end of 1828, when Groves put the idea to him in a Dublin street.
“This I doubt not is the mind of God concerning us—we should come together in all simplicity as disciples, not waiting on any pulpit or ministry, but trusting that the Lord would edify us together by ministering as He pleased and saw good from the midst of ourselves”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. I: The Beginnings of Brethrenism—The Dublin Movement · ch. I, quoting J. G. Bellett's recollections - 02
Saturday evenings in Aungier Street
Cronin recalled getting the hired room ready each week after the meeting moved there in May 1830.
“while removing the furniture aside, and laying the simple table with its bread and wine, on Saturday evenings—seasons of joy never to be forgotten”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. I: The Beginnings of Brethrenism—The Dublin Movement · ch. I, quoting Edward Cronin's Retrospect
The outcome
The Plymouth meeting soon had over a thousand members, and outsiders called them the Plymouth Brethren. Darby carried the movement to Switzerland, France and Germany. Groves carried it as a missionary to Baghdad and India.
Then Darby quarrelled with Newton, over authority in 1845 and over his teaching on Christ's sufferings in 1847. In 1848 Bethesda Chapel in Bristol, led by George Müller, who ran large orphanages in the city, received two of Newton's friends.
Darby's circular of 26 August 1848 cut off Bethesda and every assembly that received anyone from it. A movement founded to unite all believers divided within twenty years.
Open Brethren let each assembly judge for itself. Exclusive Brethren bound all to one discipline, and split again and again.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
Groves's warning to Darby, 1836
Held up by weather at Milford Haven before sailing again for India, Groves wrote to Darby that the Brethren were drifting from receiving all whom Christ had received.
“You will be known more by what you witness against than what you witness for, and practically this will prove that you witness against all but yourselves as certainly as the Walkerites or the Glassites: your Shibboleth may be different, but it will be as real.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. III: The Expansion of Brethrenism—The Movement in England · ch. III, quoting Groves to Darby, 10 March 1836 - 02
The line drawn in 1848
Darby's circular closed with his own rule of conduct. Exclusive discipline grew from it.
“For my own part I should neither go to Bethesda in its present state, nor while in that state go where persons from it were knowingly admitted.”
The Bethesda Circular · The Bethesda Circular, closing paragraph - 03
The rapture, in Darby's words
Darby opened one of his papers on the subject by stating the two doctrines that went together in his scheme.
“The rapture of the saints to meet the Lord in the air, before His manifestation to the earth, and the existence of a Jewish remnant, in whom the Spirit of God is graciously working, before the Lord manifests Himself to them for their deliverance, is happily attracting the attention of Christians.”
The Rapture of the Saints and the Character of the Jewish Remnant · Collected Writings vol. 11, p. 118 - 04
Across the Atlantic
Cyrus Scofield's Reference Bible of 1909 printed dispensational notes on the same page as the Bible text. The non-denominational evangelical channel tells what followed.
“Largely through the influence of Scofield's notes, many fundamentalist Christians in the United States adopted a dispensational theology.”
- 05
Singapore, from 1864
The Brethren reached Singapore with a merchant who later founded Robinson & Company. His assembly became Bethesda on Bras Basah Road.
“Upon his arrival in Singapore in 1857, Philip Robinson and seven other believers pioneered the Brethren movement in Singapore.”
Bethesda Serangoon Church · Roots.sg, Bethesda Serangoon Church
For the trail
The Brethren tried, more fully than anyone, an idea some Protestants held: go back to the Bible alone and rebuild the Church from it, with no clergy and no tradition. Most churches kept their ministers and creeds.
The historian William Blair Neatby said they treated ‘the garnered experience of eighteen Christian centuries’ as though it were not.
Brethren themselves disagree about how it turned out. Open Brethren point to assemblies that have kept the faith and sent missionaries round the world for nearly two centuries. Among the Exclusive Brethren, though, with no recognised authority, Darby's personal authority became the rule.
The Catholic reading is that Christ provided against this. The apostles, given a mission that lasts ‘until the end of the world’, appointed successors, and Christ's Church ‘subsists in the Catholic Church’ (LG 8, 20).
The Brethren kept something precious, though: the Lord's Supper every Lord's Day, as , a Christian teacher in Rome, described Christian Sunday worship around 155.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
A fresh start without the centuries
Neatby named the experiment plainly at the start of his history.
“The Brethren sought to effect a fresh start without authority, precedent, or guidance beyond the letter of Holy Scripture. For them, essentially, the garnered experience of eighteen Christian centuries was as though it were not.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. I: The Beginnings of Brethrenism—The Dublin Movement · ch. I, opening pages - 02
The Council on their Supper
The Second Vatican Council's words fit the Brethren breaking of bread closely: real faith and real hope, though without the sacrament of Orders.
“nevertheless when they commemorate His death and resurrection in the Lord's Supper, they profess that it signifies life in communion with Christ and look forward to His coming in glory.”
Unitatis Redintegratio, Decree on Ecumenism · Unitatis Redintegratio 22 - 03
Authority removed, authority returns
In his final chapter Neatby judged where rejecting every form of church government had led.
“of even the simplest form of constituted government,—with the inevitable result of slipping under the irresponsible yoke of any who combined the power and the will to impose it.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. XVI: A General Review of the Movement · ch. XVI, A General Review of the Movement
What the Church says
The Catholic Church does not hold today's Brethren responsible for the break: those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (UR 3).
Baptism in water by immersion or pouring, in the name of the Trinity, is valid of itself (Ecumenical Directory 95a). So a Brethren believer baptised this way is truly joined to Christ (UR 22).
The Council also said that when such communities ‘commemorate His death and resurrection in the Lord's Supper’ they look to His coming in glory. It adds that, without the sacrament of Orders, the ordination of bishops and priests, they have not kept ‘the proper reality of the eucharistic mystery in its fullness’ (UR 22).
Against the idea that the Church lies in ruins, the Church teaches that Christ built one Church ‘for all ages’, which ‘subsists in the Catholic Church’ (LG 8), and that the apostles ‘took care to appoint successors’ (LG 20). There is no formal dialogue, since the Brethren have no central body to hold one.
Where Brethren and other evangelicals suffered for their faith, as in Catholic Tuscany in 1851, the Church's teaching now is plain: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
“In a word, we find His death is the centre of communion till His coming again, and in this rests the whole power of truth. Accordingly, the outward symbol and instrument of unity is the partaking of the Lord's supper”
Darby wrote this while still a Church of Ireland clergyman, and the pamphlet asks believers to ‘commune one with another’ rather than to leave. It is sharp all the same: ‘So far as men pride themselves on being Established, Presbyterian, Baptist, Independent, or anything else, they are antichristian.’
Where people disagree
Who founded the Brethren is argued among themselves. Neatby gave Groves the largest early share and thought Cronin's claim ‘much better than Darby's’. Darby's followers made him the founder.
The 1848 split is argued too. Open Brethren see Darby's circular as a sentence passed without fair inquiry. Exclusives see a faithful defence of Christ's person, and Neatby, no friend of Darby, granted that the charge against Newton ‘was at last a true one’.
The is the sharpest dispute with Catholic teaching. Darby and most Brethren after him read it in 1 Thessalonians 4: believers caught up to meet the Lord in the air before the last tribulation.
The Catholic Encyclopedia called the scheme ‘a break with all Christian tradition’. The teaches that before Christ comes again the Church ‘must pass through a final trial’ (CCC 675).
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Darby's charge was true
Neatby, severe on Darby's methods, still conceded the substance. Newton had taught that Christ, by His human birth, came under Adam's ‘federal headship’ and in some sense under Israel's curse. Newton withdrew the first point in November 1847.
“With whatever exaggerations and misconstructions Darby urged the charge, the charge he was urging was at last a true one.”
A History of the Plymouth Brethren, ch. VII: The Doctrinal Controversy at Plymouth · ch. VII, The Doctrinal Controversy at Plymouth - 02
An insider's verdict
The Catholic Encyclopedia quotes W. H. Dorman, one of Darby's followers, writing after he separated from him.
“No religious movement, perhaps, ever so thoroughly succeeded in defeating its own ends; instead of union it has produced the most hopeless and heartless contentions and divisions that perhaps ever passed current under the specious pretense of zeal for Christ and care for the truth.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Plymouth Brethren', closing paragraph - 03
The Church's ultimate trial
Against a rapture that takes the Church away before the tribulation, the Catechism teaches this.
“Before Christ's second coming the Church must pass through a final trial that will shake the faith of many believers.”
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 668-682 · Catechism of the Catholic Church 675
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- John Nelson Darby · 1828 · Dublin, 1828; Collected Writings of J. N. Darby, ed. William Kelly, vol. 1 (STEM Publishing transcription)
- William Blair Neatby · 1901 · Hodder and Stoughton, London (Wikisource transcription)
- John Nelson Darby · 1848-08-26 · Collected Writings of J. N. Darby (STEM Publishing transcription)
- Edwin Hubert Burton · 1911 · Robert Appleton Company (Wikisource transcription)
- Harriet Groves (compiler), with Groves's autobiography and letters · 1869 · James Nisbet & Co., London (Internet Archive OCR text)