The Revolution turns on the Church
Revolutionary France takes the Church's lands, makes priests swear to a church run by the state, and kills hundreds who refuse. Pope Pius VI dies a prisoner of France in 1799.
Before 1789 the Catholic Church in France was rich and bound up with the king. Its clergy formed the first of the kingdom's three legal ranks, it owned about six per cent of the land, and it collected tithes.
When revolution came, the new Assembly abolished the tithes, took the Church's property and, in 1790, passed the Civil Constitution of the Clergy: bishops and priests would be elected by voters and cut off from the pope.
Every priest was ordered to swear to it. Pius VI condemned it, only 7 of 135 bishops swore, and about half the parish clergy refused. Refusing priests were exiled, jailed or killed, more than 200 of them in the September massacres of 1792.
Churches were closed or turned into Temples of Reason. In 1798 French troops took Rome, and Pius VI died a prisoner at Valence in 1799. Napoleon's Concordat of 1801 brought the Church back, under the state's control.
The situation
In 1789 almost everyone in France was Catholic, and the Church was part of the old order.
Its clergy formed the First Estate, the first of the kingdom's three legal ranks. It owned about six per cent of the land and collected the tithe, a tenth of the harvest.
That wealth paid for churches, schools, hospitals and care for the poor. But were usually noblemen, while many parish priests lived almost as poorly as their people.
The Church had also served the king's power. In 1685 Louis XIV revoked the Edict of Nantes that had protected Protestants, and perhaps 200,000 French Protestants fled abroad.
Writers of the Enlightenment, Voltaire among them, attacked the Church as the enemy of reason and freedom. Many educated French people agreed with them.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Six per cent of France
A modern survey on what the Church owned, and what it did with it.
“The Church used the six percent of the land they owned for a multitude of purposes which included churches, monasteries, convents, schools, hospitals, and other establishments which served the people of France.”
Civil Constitution of the Clergy · Civil Constitution of the Clergy (tertiary), Background - 02
1685: the Protestants' charter revoked
The Catholic Encyclopedia's own account of Louis XIV's decision, and of the approval it won.
“Trusting in the number and sincerity of these conversions, Louis XIV thought it no longer necessary to observe half measures with the Huguenots, and consequently revoked the Edict of Nantes on 18 October, 1685.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Huguenots' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Huguenots'
What was at stake
The revolutionaries wanted a nation of equal citizens with no privileged orders, and the state badly needed money.
On the night of 4 August 1789 the Assembly abolished the privileges of the clergy and nobility, tithes included. In late 1789 it took the Church's property and sold it to back a new paper currency.
Then it went further. The Civil Constitution of the Clergy, passed in July 1790, redrew the dioceses, had voters elect parish priests and bishops, and forbade bishops to seek confirmation from Rome.
Its authors, among them lawyers of the Jansenist movement, a strict Catholic current long at odds with Rome, saw it as reform: a national church, cleaned up and loyal to the nation. To the it made the Church a department of the state, cut off from .
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
What the Civil Constitution did
A Catholic historian of 1909 sums up the law that split the French Church.
“Without referring to the pope , it set up a new division into diocese, gave the voters, no matter who they might be, a right to nominate parish priests and bishops , ordered metropolitans to take charge of the canonical institution of their suffragans, and forbade the bishops to seek a Bull of confirmation in office from Rome .”
France (section on the Revolution) · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'France', The Revolution
The event
The Assembly ordered every priest to swear to obey the Civil Constitution. In March and April 1791 Pius VI condemned it and forbade the oath. Only 7 of 135 bishops swore, and about half the parish clergy refused.
France split in two. Priests who refused, the ‘refractory’ clergy, lost their posts and then were ordered out of the country. In September 1792 mobs broke into the Paris prisons; among those killed were more than 200 priests and bishops who had refused the oath.
In October 1793 a law made every priest who had refused the oath, and anyone who hid him, liable to death. Some revolutionaries set out to wipe out Christianity itself. Notre-Dame became a Temple of Reason, churches were closed, and the calendar was remade to abolish Sunday.
In the west, in the Vendée, Catholic peasants rose in revolt, and the civil war that followed killed perhaps 200,000 people. Most were Vendéens, many of them civilians killed by republican troops sent to crush the region.
On 17 July 1794 sixteen Carmelite nuns of Compiègne went to the guillotine in Paris singing hymns.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The oath of January 1791
How the clergy answered.
“Among the higher ranks of the church the response was much more negative; only 7 of the 135 sitting bishops took the oath.”
Civil Constitution of the Clergy · Civil Constitution of the Clergy (tertiary), The oath - 02
September 1792
The prison massacres in Paris, as a modern survey counts the clergy among the dead.
“Among the victims were 223 nonjuring Catholic priests and bishops who refused to submit to the Civil Constitution of the Clergy; 81 Swiss Guards; and 40–80 political suspects”
September massacres · September massacres (tertiary), Victims - 03
The Carmelites of Compiègne
Their last journey through Paris, 17 July 1794.
“On the day of their execution, the sisters were transported through the streets of Paris in open carts, enduring insults from the gathered crowd. Undeterred, they sang the Miserere , Salve Regina , and Veni Creator Spiritus as they approached the scaffold.”
Pope Francis declares French Martyrs of Compiègne saints via equipollent canonization · Catholic World Report, 18 December 2024
The outcome
The persecution reached Rome. French troops took the city in February 1798 and proclaimed a republic. Pius VI, over eighty and ill, was carried off a prisoner across the Alps, and died at Valence in France on 29 August 1799.
A new pope, Pius VII, was elected the next year, in Venice.
In 1801 Napoleon, now ruling France, made a Concordat, a treaty with the pope. Catholic worship returned to France, but the state named the bishops, paid the clergy and kept the confiscated lands. The bishops once again received their office from the pope, the link the Civil Constitution had cut.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Pius VI, prisoner
The Catholic Encyclopedia on the pope's last journey.
“Because the pope refused to submit, he was forcibly taken from Rome on the night of 20 Feb., and brought first to Siena and then to Florence.”
Pope Pius VI · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Pope Pius VI' - 02
The Concordat of 1801
The first article, as agreed between Napoleon's envoys and the pope's.
“The Catholic , Apostolic and Roman Religion shall be freely exercised in France . Its worship shall be public while conforming to such police regulations as the government shall consider necessary to public tranquillity.”
The French Concordat of 1801 · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The French Concordat of 1801', The stipulations
For the trail
For the next century the Church remembered the Revolution as proof of what liberal ideas could do to it. That memory explains much of its mood in the 1800s: the Syllabus of Errors, Pius IX's 1864 list of modern ideas he condemned; the defence of the Papal States, the pope's own territory in central Italy; and the of 1869–70.
It also helps explain why Gregory XVI in 1832 condemned the claim that ‘liberty of conscience must be maintained for everyone’. The Revolution had spoken of liberty while it killed priests.
The Church came to a different view only in 1965, when it taught that religious freedom is a right of every person. That teaching protects believers and unbelievers alike, and it condemns both the Revolution's persecution and the old regime's.
What the Church says
The Church honours those killed for refusing the oath as martyrs. In 1926 Pius XI beatified priests killed in the September massacres, and in December 2024 Pope Francis declared the sixteen Carmelite nuns of Compiègne, guillotined in 1794, saints.
It also teaches that the Church ‘is not identified in any way with the political community nor bound to any political system’, and ‘does not place her trust in the privileges offered by civil authority’ (Gaudium et Spes 76).
Its rule on force cuts both ways: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
That condemns the Revolution's persecution of priests and nuns. It equally condemns the old Catholic monarchy's treatment of French Protestants, which the Council's admission of ‘a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12) covers.
“No one shall be disquieted on account of his opinions, including his religious views, provided their manifestation does not disturb the public order established by law.”
The Revolution began by promising religious freedom. Within four years priests who would not swear to the state's church were being exiled and killed.
Where people disagree
Historians still argue over how far the Revolution meant to destroy Christianity and how far it was punishing a Church it saw as the king's ally.
Its first aim was to control the Church, not abolish it. The campaign to wipe out Christianity came later, and not everyone in power backed it.
The numbers are argued too. Of everyone condemned by the revolutionary courts, one estimate puts the clergy at about 6 per cent; most victims were workers and peasants.
And the old Church's own record is part of the story. It had been rich and privileged under a king who persecuted Protestants. The Revolution's anger did not come from nowhere, even though what it did to priests and nuns was wrong.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Who died in the Terror
One estimate of those condemned by the revolutionary courts.
“According to one estimate, among those condemned by the revolutionary tribunals about 8 percent were aristocrats , 6 percent clergy, 14 percent middle class, and 70 percent were workers or peasants accused of hoarding, evading the draft, desertion, rebellion, and other purported crimes.”
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution · Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution (tertiary), Reign of Terror - 02
Never wholly suppressed
Even the 1909 Catholic Encyclopedia, no friend of the Revolution, grants this.
“According to the locality in which they happened to be, the propagandists either encouraged or hindered this violence against religion; but even in the every bitterest days of the terror, there was never a moment when Catholic worship was suppressed throughout France.”
France (section on the Revolution) · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'France', The Revolution
This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.
- Georges Goyau · 1909 · New Advent, from the Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 6
- Wikipedia contributors · 2026 · Wikipedia
- Michael Ott · 1911 · New Advent, from the Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 12
- Georges Goyau · 1908 · New Advent, from the Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 4
- Catholic News Agency · 2024-12-18 · Catholic World Report