The mosaic of Christ Pantocrator in gold in the apse of Monreale Cathedral, Sicily, with his name in Greek letters.
VII / XI
1054–1300

Christendom divided

By the 1050s the Greek East and the Latin West disagree over two big things. One is the pope’s role: the West sees him as head of the whole Church, the East as first in honour among the patriarchs, not ruler over every bishop.

The other is the filioque, the words ‘and the Son’ that the West added to the Creed, saying the Holy Spirit comes from the Father and the Son.

In 1054 the pope’s envoy, Cardinal Humbert, and the patriarch of Constantinople, Michael Cerularius, excommunicate each other, a church penalty that cuts a person off from the sacraments. The sentences fall on the men, not on their Churches, and few at the time think the break is final.

What makes it feel permanent is 1204, when crusaders bound for Egypt and Jerusalem storm Constantinople and loot it for three days.

In the West these are also the centuries of the great cathedrals and the first universities. Francis of Assisi, a rich young man who gave everything away, sends his brothers out to live poor among the poor.

Thomas Aquinas, a Dominican friar, shows how faith and reason fit together.

The world: High Middle Ages · Crusades
Christ Pantocrator, apse of Monreale Cathedral, Sicily, 1180s: a Latin cathedral decorated in the Byzantine manner.
Coloured section of Hagia Sophia drawn as the Byzantine church: the gold dome, mosaic angels and saints, and Justinian's column outside.
1054 · Hagia Sophia, Constantinople
Rome
the Latin West
Constantinople
the Greek East
Hagia Sophia, Constantinople, in section: Wilhelm Salzenberg's reconstruction of the Byzantine church, published in 1854. The papal legates laid their bull on its altar in 1054.
1054Historical

Mutual excommunications

For centuries the Greek East and the Latin West had drifted apart in language, politics and custom, including the West's addition of ‘and the Son’ to the creed. In the 1050s a reforming papacy wanted its authority felt everywhere, Patriarch Michael Cerularius was set on resisting Rome, and the Normans were seizing southern Italy and suppressing Greek church customs there. Cerularius hit back by closing the Latin churches in Constantinople.

Pope Leo IX, defeated and held by the Normans, sent Cardinal Humbert to Constantinople. Leo died in April 1054. On 16 July Humbert laid a bull excommunicating the patriarch on the altar of Hagia Sophia, and Cerularius excommunicated the legates in return.

Few thought it permanent at the time. The next 150 years, above all the sack of 1204, made it a lasting split, and the excommunications were only lifted in 1965.

“there is the memory of the decisions, actions and painful incidents which in 1054 resulted in the sentence of excommunication leveled against the Patriarch Michael Cerularius and two other persons by the legate of the Roman See under the leadership of Cardinal Humbertus, legates who then became the object of a similar sentence pronounced by the patriarch …”
Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration of Pope Paul VI and Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I · Joint Declaration of Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I, 7 December 1965, §2
What the Church says

The Church does not treat 1054 as the day the Orthodox stopped being Church. On 7 December 1965 Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I removed the excommunications from memory (Joint Declaration, 1965).

The Second Vatican Council teaches that the Orthodox Churches have true sacraments, above all the priesthood and the Eucharist, and are joined to the Catholic Church in very close communion (Unitatis Redintegratio 15).

It also says that for the great separations of later centuries ‘often enough, men of both sides were to blame’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).

1054

Very deep but wounded communion

For a thousand years East and West were one Church, led from five great cities: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem. But the Roman Empire had broken in two.

The West spoke Latin and the East Greek, and fewer and fewer people could read both.

Each half grew its own habits. The popes, the bishops of Rome, claimed authority over every church as successors of Peter. The East saw its patriarchs, the senior bishops, as brothers who governed together, with Rome first in honour.

What we still share
  • The faith of the seven councils both sides count, from Nicaea in 325 to the second council of Nicaea in 787, and the Creed they handed down.
  • Bishops, priests and deacons in an unbroken line from the apostles. Vatican II said these Churches “possess true sacraments, above all - by apostolic succession - the priesthood and the Eucharist” (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 15).
  • All seven sacraments, the Mass at the centre. The Orthodox call it the Divine Liturgy.
  • Mary as Mother of God, the saints, icons and relics.
How they describe it

The Orthodox see their Churches as the undivided Church of the first thousand years, kept faithful. In their account Rome changed, adding to the Creed and claiming power over all the churches, which the early councils never gave it.

A manuscript painting of a church packed with bishops and nobles in rows before the pope on a high throne, with a block of French text and a line of knights below.
Urban II at the Council of Clermont in 1095, as the illuminator Jean Colombe imagined it around 1474, in Sébastien Mamerot's Passages d'Outremer (BnF Fr. 5594).
1095–99Historical

The First Crusade

In 1071 the Seljuk Turks crushed the Byzantine army at Manzikert, and by the 1090s they held nearly all of Asia Minor. Pilgrims to Jerusalem told of tolls and attacks on the road.

In 1095 the Byzantine emperor Alexios I asked Pope Urban II for soldiers, and at Clermont Urban called Western knights to go east, granting an indulgence to those who went.

In 1096 some of the crowds on their way murdered Jews in the Rhineland. The armies took Antioch in 1098 and Jerusalem on 15 July 1099, and killed a large part of the city's Muslims and Jews.

The Church today confesses the violence done in Christ's name and asks forgiveness for it.

“For your brethren who live in the east are in urgent need of your help, and you must hasten to give them the aid which has often been promised them.”
Urban II: Speech at the Council of Clermont, 1095 — six versions, with Urban II's Letter of Instruction to the Crusaders, December 1095 · Fulcher of Chartres, account of Urban II's speech at Clermont, 27 November 1095
What the Church says

The Church doesn't defend what was done at Jerusalem or in the Rhineland. It teaches that in any war ‘Non-combatants, wounded soldiers, and prisoners must be respected and treated humanely’, and that orders to kill them excuse no one (CCC 2313).

Preparing the Day of Pardon in 2000, the Church's theologians named the Crusades among the hard cases. They called Catholics to repent of the times when ‘doubtful means were employed in the pursuit of good ends’ (*Memory and Reconciliation* 5.3).

On the Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000, John Paul II asked God's forgiveness for Christians who ‘have sometimes used methods not in keeping with the Gospel’, and for the sins of Christians against the Jewish people.

The Second Vatican Council ‘decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone’, and urges Christians and Muslims to put past hostilities behind them and work for mutual understanding (*Nostra Aetate* 3–4).

Channels that rejoined

One Church that holds it never left

no union act
no union actno act of union

The claim never to have left

The Maronites of Lebanon take their name from the monastery of St Maron in Syria. Its monks stood by the Council of Chalcedon in a region that mostly rejected it, and in 517 they wrote to the pope about violence done to them for it.

Read the full footprint→
Eugène Delacroix, The Entry of the Crusaders into Constantinople, 1840.
The Crusaders enter Constantinople, 12 April 1204. Delacroix, 1840.
1204Historical

Crusaders sack Constantinople

In 1202 the Fourth Crusade, meant for Egypt and Jerusalem, could not pay Venice for its ships. To clear the debt it attacked Zara, a Catholic city, and Pope Innocent III excommunicated the army.

Then a Byzantine prince, Alexios, promised money, soldiers and church union if the crusaders put his deposed father back on the throne of Constantinople.

They did, in 1203, but the money never came. On 12 April 1204 they stormed the city and looted it for three days: killing civilians, stripping churches, carrying off relics, and setting up a Latin empire that lasted until 1261.

Innocent condemned the sack, and for the Greek people it turned the split with the West into lasting hatred. John Paul II expressed Catholic regret in 2001 and 2004.

“As for those who were supposed to be seeking the ends of Jesus Christ, not their own ends, whose swords, which they were supposed to use against the pagans, are now dripping with Christian blood … she sees in the Latins only an example of perdition and the works of darkness.”
Letter of Innocent III on the sack of Constantinople (Register 8:126) · Register 8:126, to Peter Capuano
What the Church says

In Athens on 4 May 2001 John Paul II said: ‘It is tragic that the assailants, who had set out to secure free access for Christians to the Holy Land, turned against their own brothers in the faith. The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.’

In the same address he asked God's forgiveness for the times Catholics ‘have sinned by action or omission against their Orthodox brothers and sisters’. In 2004 he told Patriarch Bartholomew I that Catholics share Innocent III's ‘indignation and sorrow’.

Fresco portrait of Pope Innocent III at the Sacro Speco, Subiaco.
Innocent III, painted at Subiaco in his own lifetime.
1215Historical

Fourth Lateran Council

Pope Innocent III was the most powerful pope of the Middle Ages. In the south of France the Cathars taught that matter was evil and rejected the Church; after his envoy was murdered in 1208 Innocent called a crusade against them, and at Béziers in 1209 crusaders killed much of the town.

In November 1215 he gathered 404 bishops in Rome to reform the whole Church.

Its 70 canons used the word ‘transubstantiation’ for the change of bread and wine into Christ's body and blood, and required every Catholic to confess at least once a year and receive Communion at Easter, which is still the rule. The same council ordered rulers to drive out heretics and forced Jews and Muslims to wear clothing that marked them out, which local synods soon turned into badges.

“All the faithful of both sexes shall after they have reached the age of discretion faithfully confess all their sins at least once a year to their own (parish) priest and perform to the best of their ability the penance imposed, receiving reverently at least at Easter the sacrament of the Eucharist.”
Canons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) · Canon 21
What the Church says

Two parts of this council stand. Annual confession and Easter Communion are still the Church's rule (CCC 2042), and its teaching on the Eucharist is Catholic faith.

Its canons against Jews and Muslims, and its order that rulers drive heretics out of their lands, belong to what the Church has since rejected. The Second Vatican Council teaches that no one may be forced to act against their conscience in religion (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Vatican II's declaration on other religions says the Church ‘decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone’ (Nostra Aetate 4).

On the Day of Pardon in 2000, John Paul II asked forgiveness for Christians who ‘have at times given in to intolerance’ in defending the truth, and for sins against the Jewish people.

An engraving of Thomas Aquinas dying at Fossanova on his way to the Second Council of Lyon.
Aquinas dying on the road to Lyon, 1274, from a seventeenth-century engraved life.
1274Historical

Second Council of Lyon

In 1261 the Byzantine emperor Michael VIII won Constantinople back from the Latins. Charles of Anjou, king of Sicily and brother of the French king, planned to retake it, and only the pope could hold him back.

So Michael offered that the Greek Church would accept the pope's authority. Pope Gregory X wanted reunion and a new crusade.

At a council in Lyon in 1274 the emperor's envoys accepted Latin teaching, including that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. Thomas Aquinas died on his way there.

At home the Greek clergy and people rejected the union; the emperor removed the patriarch who refused it, a later pope excommunicated the emperor, and after Michael's death in 1282 the union was renounced.

“We profess faithfully and devotedly that the holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father and the Son, not as from two principles, but as from one principle.”
Second Council of Lyons (1274): Constitution on the procession of the Holy Spirit · Constitution II
What the Church says

The Church counts Lyon II as the fourteenth ecumenical council, and its teaching that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son ‘as from one principle’ is Catholic doctrine.

Since Vatican II the Church has said that Eastern and Western ways of expressing the faith can complement each other rather than conflict (Unitatis Redintegratio 17). It no longer seeks unity through unions imposed from above; Catholic and Orthodox now talk as sister Churches in an official theological dialogue.

Saints of this age

12 lives, among many

Signs in this age
  • On Easter Sunday, 28 March 1171, the prior of Santa Maria in Vado, Pietro da Verona, celebrating with three confreres, is said to have seen blood spurt from the host at the fraction and spatter the small vault above the altar.

    Not established: Anything from 1171.

  • A young woman of Alatri, told by a sorceress that a consecrated host would make a love potion, kept the host in her mouth at communion and hid it in a cloth. Three days later, the story goes, she found it turned to flesh, and both women confessed to the bishop.

    Not established: What was in the cloth.

  • A woman of Santarém, troubled by an unfaithful husband, is said to have carried a consecrated host out of the church of Santo Estêvão to give to a sorceress, and to have found it bleeding into her veil on the way. It was returned in procession and is said to have bled for three days.

    Not established: The year cannot be fixed within forty years.

  • Tradition holds that in 1263 a priest travelling to Rome, later named as Peter of Prague and said to doubt the Real Presence, saw blood come from the host onto the corporal while saying Mass at Santa Cristina in Bolsena. The stained cloth was carried to Pope Urban IV at Orvieto.

    Not established: That Bolsena caused the feast.

  • This is a different, later story from Lanciano, the town of the famous 8th-century miracle, and its relics ended up in Offida. In 1273, the story goes, a woman named Ricciarella, advised by a witch, put a consecrated host to cook in an earthenware jar; it turned to bleeding flesh, and she buried jar and host under the manure of the stable.

    Not established: Anything earlier than 1788 in writing.