Cardinal Humbert, the pope’s envoy, and Patriarch Michael Cerularius excommunicate each other in Constantinople. The sentences fall on the men, not on their Churches, but the date becomes the symbol of a long estrangement.
Historical evidence✓ Quotes checked
In brief
For centuries the Greek East and the Latin West had drifted apart in language, politics and custom, including the West's addition of ‘and the Son’ to the creed. In the 1050s a reforming papacy wanted its authority felt everywhere, Patriarch Michael Cerularius was set on resisting Rome, and the Normans were seizing southern Italy and suppressing Greek church customs there. Cerularius hit back by closing the Latin churches in Constantinople.
Pope Leo IX, defeated and held by the Normans, sent Cardinal Humbert to Constantinople. Leo died in April 1054. On 16 July Humbert laid a bull excommunicating the patriarch on the altar of Hagia Sophia, and Cerularius excommunicated the legates in return.
Few thought it permanent at the time. The next 150 years, above all the sack of 1204, made it a lasting split, and the excommunications were only lifted in 1965.
Where we are
The situation
By the 1000s the Greek-speaking East and the Latin-speaking West had been drifting apart for centuries. They no longer shared a language or an empire. The West had added ‘and the Son’ to the creed, the statement of faith said at , and used unleavened bread for the , the bread and wine of .
In Rome a reform movement had taken hold of the papacy. Its leaders fought simony, the buying and selling of church posts, and priests who kept concubines. To clean up the Church, they made the 's authority much stronger and more central.
Pope Leo IX, elected in 1049, had himself been picked by the German emperor Henry III. But he wanted to free the see of , the pope's office, from serving the emperors.
He was a strong pope, and he meant his authority to be felt in the East too.
In Constantinople, the capital of the Eastern Roman (Byzantine) Empire, had been patriarch since 1043. A patriarch is the senior bishop of one of the great ancient churches. He was determined to resist any attempt by Rome to impose its will on the Eastern Church.
Between them sat southern Italy. Since about 1016 the Normans, warriors from northern France, had been conquering it from the Byzantines and local Lombard lords. Where they ruled, they suppressed the Greek customs of churches in a region long tied to Constantinople.
▸Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
01
The Normans, and the patriarch's answer
The Orthodox history traces the showdown to the Normans in southern Italy, who suppressed Greek practices there, and to Cerularius's retaliation against the Latin churches of Constantinople.
“The “showdown” came as a result of the Norman invasion of southern Italy beginning in 1016, and the subsequent suppression of Greek practices in the churches in this region where there was strong Byzantine influence. Patriarch Michael retaliated by trying to force the Latin churches in Constantinople to use Greek practices—especially leavened instead of unleavened bread (azymes) in the Eucharist.”
Vatican II describes the first millennium as separate ways within one brotherly union, with Rome acting as guide by common consent when disputes arose.
“For many centuries the Church of the East and that of the West each followed their separate ways though linked in a brotherly union of faith and sacramental life; the Roman See by common consent acted as guide when disagreements arose between them over matters of faith or discipline.”
The Council traces the difference to how the apostolic heritage was received in different places, and admits that lack of charity and understanding did the rest.
“However, the heritage handed down by the apostles was received with differences of form and manner, so that from the earliest times of the Church it was explained variously in different places, owing to diversities of genius and conditions of life. All this, quite apart from external causes, prepared the way for decisions arising also from a lack of charity and mutual understanding.”
The Council states solemnly that the Eastern Churches have the power to govern themselves by their own disciplines, a variety it calls an ornament rather than an obstacle.
“To remove, then, all shadow of doubt, this holy Council solemnly declares that the Churches of the East, while remembering the necessary unity of the whole Church, have the power to govern themselves according to the disciplines proper to them, since these are better suited to the character of their faithful, and more for the good of their souls.”
On the surface the quarrel was about customs: leavened or unleavened bread at the Eucharist, fasting on Saturdays, married priests. Underneath was a bigger question. Who has the last word in the Church?
Rome's reformers held that the pope, as Peter's successor, had authority over every church, East and West. The East saw the Church led by its five great patriarchs together, with Rome first in honour but not ruling the others.
Each side thought the other had changed something it had no right to change. To the Greeks, the West had altered the creed on its own. To the Latins, the Greeks were refusing the authority gave to Peter.
There was also a war on. The pope and the Byzantine emperor both needed each other against the Normans, so a break made no sense to either government. It came anyway, through the men they sent.
▸Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
01
Two theologies, one faith
The Council's way of putting the underlying problem: East and West studied revelation by different methods and came to express the same mysteries differently.
“In the study of revelation East and West have followed different methods, and have developed differently their understanding and confession of God's truth. It is hardly surprising, then, if from time to time one tradition has come nearer to a full appreciation of some aspects of a mystery of revelation than the other, or has expressed it to better advantage.”
In 1053 Leo IX led an army against the Normans, meaning to join a Byzantine force. On 18 June 1053 the Normans beat the pope's army at Civitate, before the Byzantines could join it. They held the pope at Benevento for almost nine months.
Meanwhile Cerularius answered what the Normans were doing to Greek churches. He tried to force the Latin churches in Constantinople to follow Greek customs, above all leavened bread, and closed the Latin churches in the city.
His ally Archbishop Leo of Ohrid wrote a long attack on Latin practices.
Emperor Constantine IX needed the pope against the Normans and pressed his patriarch to be more respectful. In early 1054 Leo sent envoys, called legates, led by Cardinal Humbert, a fierce critic of the Greeks.
Humbert refused the patriarch the usual courtesies, and Cerularius refused to deal with him.
Back in Italy, Leo IX died on 19 April 1054, which put the legates' authority in doubt. On 16 July Humbert walked into Hagia Sophia, the city's great cathedral, during a service.
He laid on the altar a bull, a formal papal document, excommunicating ‘Patriarch Michael and all his followers’.
Excommunication is a church penalty that cuts someone off from the until they reconcile; it is not a physical punishment. Humbert left the city a day or two later. Cerularius and his synod, the of around him, excommunicated the legates in return.
▸Go furtherFold· 6 notes, each with its source
01
A pope in Norman hands
After Civitate the pope was held at Benevento. The accounts differ on how harsh it was: papal sources say he gave himself up, Norman sources call him an honoured guest.
“He was treated respectfully but was imprisoned at Benevento for almost nine months, and forced to ratify a number of treaties favorable to the Normans.”
Even the pro-papal Catholic Encyclopedia records that the Greeks were asking Leo for help against the Normans, which is why the emperor leaned on his patriarch.
“The Greeks, fearful of being expelled from the peninsula altogether, begged Leo to co-operate with them against the common foe.”
What was actually pronounced, in the 1965 declaration's words
The joint declaration of 1965 names the parties: a sentence against the patriarch and two others by the Roman legates under Cardinal Humbert, answered by a sentence of the patriarch and his synod against the legates.
“there is the memory of the decisions, actions and painful incidents which in 1054 resulted in the sentence of excommunication leveled against the Patriarch Michael Cerularius and two other persons by the legate of the Roman See under the leadership of Cardinal Humbertus, legates who then became the object of a similar sentence pronounced by the patriarch and the Synod of Constantinople.”
Both Churches later judged that the censures overshot their authors' intentions and had consequences nobody foresaw.
“Thus it is important to recognize the excesses which accompanied them and later led to consequences which, insofar as we can judge, went much further than their authors had intended and foreseen.”
The Orthodox Church in America's history gives the same sequence as the 1965 declaration, with the detail that the bull was laid down during a service and named 'all his followers'.
“on July 16, 1054, Humbert strode into the great cathedral of Hagia Sophia during a service and placed on the altar a bull of excommunication against “Patriarch Michael and all his followers.” In a day or two, he and his fellow legates left for home. Michael, in his turn, excommunicated Humbert “and all those responsible” for the bull of excommunication against him.”
Leo IX was dead before the bull was laid down, which is why the legates' authority was doubtful. The Orthodox history adds the point the Catholic telling often leaves out: his successor Victor II could have disowned Humbert's act and chose not to.
“Very interestingly, Pope Leo IX died soon after Humbert left Rome for Constantinople, but before Humbert issued the bull of excommunication. And Leo's successor was not elected until near the end of the year. So it would seem that the next pope, Victor II (r. late 1054–1057), could easily have revoked Humbert's action, but he did not choose to do so.”
At the time, few people thought anything permanent had happened. Both sentences were aimed at persons, not at the other Church, and relations between some Eastern churches and Rome stayed friendly for a long time.
Leo's successor, Victor II, was not chosen until late 1054, and took office only in April 1055. He could have disowned what Humbert did, and he chose not to.
The split deepened slowly over the next 150 years. Crusading armies crossed Byzantine land from 1096, and in 1204 crusaders sacked Constantinople itself. After that the quarrel between leaders became a break felt by whole peoples.
On 7 December 1965 Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I of Constantinople removed the excommunications of 1054. In their joint declaration they ‘commit these excommunications to oblivion’. Communion, sharing one Eucharist and one church life, was not restored.
On 28 November 2025, at İznik, ancient Nicaea, Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew prayed the Nicene Creed together, without the words ‘and the Son’. The next day they signed a declaration hoping for between their Churches.
▸Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
01
Not meant to break communion
The 1965 reading of 1054: the censures were against persons and were not intended to sever the two sees.
“They had directed their censures against the persons concerned and not the Churches. These censures were not intended to break ecclesiastical communion between the Sees of Rome and Constantinople.”
The rupture came from many causes, before and after
The declaration places the real break in a longer chain of 'vexing events' driven by lack of understanding and trust.
“they deplore the preceding and later vexing events which, under the influence of various factors—among which, lack of understanding and mutual trust—eventually led to the effective rupture of ecclesiastical communion.”
A process, not an event: the Orthodox history agrees
The Orthodox account, like the 1965 declaration, treats 1054 as one step in a long deterioration, and names 1204 as the point after which the animosity became mutual and general.
“And while relations between some of the Eastern Churches with Rome continued to be relatively friendly for quite some time, the reality and extent of the schism gradually deepened and spread, until the sack of Constantinople and its conquest by the Latin knights of the Fourth Crusade in 1204 increased the mutual animosity”
Most timelines date the split between the Catholic and Churches to 1054. The real story shows how a war, a quarrel over customs and two hard-line men turned a long drift into a break.
It also shows what the break was not. Neither side excommunicated the other Church. Both Churches now say the sentences went much further than their authors intended.
And it shows what is still unsolved: how the pope's role fits with the Eastern way of governing the Church by councils of bishops. That question, more than the bread, is what Catholic and Orthodox theologians are still working through.
▸Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
01
Removed in 1965, remembered still
In 1965 both Churches 'committed to oblivion' the sentences of 1054. The footprint for that year gives the full text.
The Council's standard for what reunion would need
Vatican II asks that no burden beyond what is essential be imposed, and calls for dialogue on doctrine and on the pastoral problems of the day.
“It is the Council's urgent desire that, in the various organizations and living activities of the Church, every effort should be made toward the gradual realization of this unity, especially by prayer, and by fraternal dialogue on points of doctrine and the more pressing pastoral problems of our time.”
The Church does not treat 1054 as the day the Orthodox stopped being Church. On 7 December 1965 Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I removed the excommunications from memory (Joint Declaration, 1965).
The Second Vatican Council teaches that the Orthodox Churches have true sacraments, above all the priesthood and the Eucharist, and are joined to the Catholic Church in very close communion (Unitatis Redintegratio 15).
It also says that for the great separations of later centuries ‘often enough, men of both sides were to blame’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).
In plain terms
Think of it like this
A marriage that ends not in one row but in twenty years of not speaking, then a slammed door everyone later dates it from.
Two men excommunicated each other in 1054 and almost nobody noticed. The estrangement had been building for centuries in language, politics, bread, calendars and the wording of the Creed, and it hardened over the two centuries afterwards. We date the break from the slammed door because a date is easier to remember than a drift.
Read the text
“there is the memory of the decisions, actions and painful incidents which in 1054 resulted in the sentence of excommunication leveled against the Patriarch Michael Cerularius and two other persons by the legate of the Roman See under the leadership of Cardinal Humbertus, legates who then became the object of a similar sentence pronounced by the patriarch and the Synod of Constantinople.”
Humbert's bull is not quoted on the site yet. The 1965 declaration is the description of 1054 that both Churches signed, and it is the text this footprint rests on.
Other readings
Where people disagree
Who started it? Older Catholic histories put it on Cerularius. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1911 calls him ambitious and says that, ‘still entirely unprovoked, he closed all the Latin churches’ in the city.
The Orthodox telling puts the provocation first. The Normans had suppressed Greek practices in southern Italy, and Cerularius was retaliating. It describes Humbert as fiercely anti-Byzantine and quick to press Rome's claims as far as they would go.
Historians also question whether Humbert's bull was valid at all, since the pope who sent him was dead. The 1965 declaration doesn't assign blame. It says these events are now judged ‘more fairly and serenely’.
The deeper dispute is who changed the faith. The Orthodox name the papacy's claim to govern every church, and the , first used in Rome's worship in 1014. Catholics see both as rightful developments of what was always held.
▸Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
01
The old Catholic verdict: 'unprovoked'
Adrian Fortescue's 1911 article blames Cerularius alone. It does not mention the Normans' treatment of Greek churches, which the Orthodox account puts first.
“Still entirely unprovoked, he closed all the Latin churches at Constantinople, including that of the papal legate.”
An event that both sides now judge 'more fairly and serenely'
The 1965 declaration refuses to pretend 1054 did not happen, but says the events are now judged differently from how they were judged at the time.
“One cannot pretend that these events were not what they were during this very troubled period of history. Today, however, they have been judged more fairly and serenely.”
Who innovated: the Orthodox answer, in Orthodox words
The Orthodox Church in America's own history names one cause above the others: not the bread, but the papacy's claim to govern every church.
“From the Eastern Orthodox perspective, however, the biggest single reason for the Great Schism was the reassertion of Papal claims to have jurisdictional authority over all the Churches of Christendom.”
The same history dates Rome's own adoption of the Filioque in public worship to 1014, after two centuries of resisting it, and notes the irony that forty years later the Latins called the Greeks heretics for not using it.
“Then in 1014, the Roman Church, after resisting for over 200 years Germanic pressure to adopt the filioque ... finally used this addition to the Creed in public worship for the first time—at the coronation of Henry II as Holy Roman Emperor. Ironically, forty years later the Latin Christians would accuse the Greek Christians of being heretical for not using the filioque”
When Pius IX made overtures to the Orthodox in 1848, the Eastern patriarchs answered with an encyclical listing the Roman errors as they saw them, most especially the unilateral addition of the Filioque to the creed. The Orthodox history calls them errors 'the Orthodox have always rejected'.
“In 1848, in response to overtures directed to the Orthodox by Pope Pius IX, the Eastern Patriarchs issued an encyclical letter in which the understanding of the conciliar as well as the hierarchical nature of the Orthodox Church is clearly professed. This letter also includes a long list of Roman Catholic errors that the Orthodox have always rejected, most especially the unilateral addition of the filioque to the Nicene Creed.”
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
Claims behind this footprint
What this rests on
Each claim says one thing, shows the words it rests on, and says how far it has been checked. Long passages are folded; open them to read the whole text.
Vatican II says the Eastern Churches separated from Rome possess true sacraments, above all by apostolic succession the priesthood and the Eucharist, and are thereby linked with the Catholic Church "in closest intimacy".
“These Churches, although separated from us, possess true sacraments, above all by apostolic succession, the priesthood and the Eucharist, whereby they are linked with us in closest intimacy.”
Checked
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).
Go deeper
Official text✓ Checked against original 2026-09-22
You’ll be taken to the place on the Trail that answers it: a question already answered, a footprint on the River, a chapter, a country on the map.
Three written answers a day: each one costs a little, and the Trail is paid for by one person. The search, and the questions the Trail has already answered, are always free.
Try
Feedback
Step 1 of 3
How satisfied are you with the Trail so far?
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
Your rating is saved as soon as you choose it. Every question after this one is optional. Privacy notice. Only want to point something out?
ACG
Builds The Trail
Sorry to interrupt your reading.
I’m ACG, a Catholic in Singapore. I built the Trail so Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants can see that we all come from the same spring.
It’s entirely self-funded, built after my day job. Your support keeps it online each month.
And it brings me closer to a dream: to visit these churches in person, film their stories, and one day do this full time.
If it’s been worth your time, would you help keep it going? If not, thanks for reading. That means a lot too.