The RiverChristendom divided
1095–99

The First Crusade

Byzantium asks the pope for soldiers against the Turks. Urban II calls Western knights east; they take Jerusalem in 1099 and kill much of its people.

Historical evidence Quotes not yet checked
In brief

In 1071 the Seljuk Turks crushed the Byzantine army at Manzikert, and by the 1090s they held nearly all of Asia Minor. Pilgrims to Jerusalem told of tolls and attacks on the road.

In 1095 the Byzantine emperor Alexios I asked Pope Urban II for soldiers, and at Clermont Urban called Western knights to go east, granting an indulgence to those who went.

In 1096 some of the crowds on their way murdered Jews in the Rhineland. The armies took Antioch in 1098 and Jerusalem on 15 July 1099, and killed a large part of the city's Muslims and Jews.

The Church today confesses the violence done in Christ's name and asks forgiveness for it.

Where we are

The situation

For centuries Christians from the West had travelled to Jerusalem as pilgrims, to pray at the tomb of Jesus in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Muslim rulers had held the city since the 600s, and for long stretches pilgrims came and went.

Then it got harder. In 1009 the Fatimid caliph of Egypt, al-Hakim, ordered the Holy Sepulchre destroyed. In the 1070s the Seljuk Turks took Jerusalem, and pilgrims came home with stories of tolls, attacks and kidnappings on the road.

The bigger danger was to the Byzantine Empire, the Greek-speaking Christian empire ruled from Constantinople. In 1071 the Turks crushed its army at Manzikert, in today's eastern Turkey, and captured the emperor. By the 1090s they held nearly all of Asia Minor.

In 1095 Emperor Alexios I Komnenos sent envoys to Urban II asking for soldiers. Rome and Constantinople had quarrelled bitterly in 1054, but they still saw each other as fellow Christians.

Urban had reasons of his own. He hoped that helping the East might heal that quarrel. And he wanted Western knights, who spent their lives fighting each other, to turn their swords to something he believed was holy.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The Turks' advance, in a Catholic history of 1908

    The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of the Crusades starts with the Seljuk conquests: Jerusalem, the emperor's defeat at Manzikert, and Asia Minor and Syria lost.

    “The rise of the Seljukian Turks, however, compromised the safety of pilgrims and even threatened the independence of the Byzantine Empire and of all Christendom . In 1070 Jerusalem was taken, and in 1071 Diogenes, the Greek emperor, was defeated and made captive at Mantzikert.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Crusades, I. Origin of the Crusades
  2. 02

    The emperor asked first

    The Fordham editors' introduction to the speeches puts the Byzantine request at the start of the story.

    “In 1094 or 1095, Alexios I Komnenos, the Byzantine emperor, sent to the pope, Urban II, and asked for aid from the west against the Seljuq Turks, who taken nearly all of Asia Minor from him.”
  3. 03

    Pilgrims on the road

    A modern summary of the danger pilgrims faced under the Seljuks. It is a tertiary source, used here for the general picture only.

    “In principle, the Seljuks allowed pilgrims access to Jerusalem, but they often imposed huge tariffs and condoned local attacks.”
    First Crusade · Historical context: Persecution of Christians
The problem

What was at stake

Christians in the East were losing their lands and their lives, and the holiest city of the faith was held by rulers who had once torn down its great church. The question was what Christians in the West owed them.

Urban's answer joined two things that had always been separate: a pilgrimage and a war. Marching to free Jerusalem would be a holy journey, made as penance for . Those who vowed to go wore a cloth cross, which is where the later word crusade comes from.

To go with it he granted an : a release from the penance still owed for sins already confessed and forgiven. For knights who lived by violence and knew how much they owed, that mattered.

The danger was built in. Once killing was called penance, it was very hard to say where it should stop, or to hold back crowds who heard the call and made their own war.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    What the pope promised, in his own letter

    Urban's letter to the Flemish crusaders, written in December 1095, is the one text on the page from the pope's own hand. It presents the journey as a preparation for the remission of sins.

    “We solemnly enjoined upon them at the council of Auvergne (the accomplishment of) such an undertaking, as a preparation for the remission of all their sins.”
  2. 02

    Turning private wars outward

    Fulcher's version ties the crusade to the Church's efforts to stop knights fighting each other at home.

    “Although, O sons of God, you have promised more firmly than ever to keep the peace among yourselves and to preserve the rights of the church, there remains still an important work for you to do.”
What happened

The event

On 27 November 1095, at a (a meeting of ) at Clermont in France, Urban came out to speak to a huge crowd. He told them of Christians in the East killed and churches destroyed. The crowd shouted back, one account says, Deus vult, ‘God wills it’.

The first to march were crowds of the poor, stirred up by preachers like the Hermit. In the Rhineland in 1096, some of these bands, the worst led by a local count, Emicho, murdered Jews in Speyer, Worms and Mainz, though the bishops of those cities tried to shelter them.

The main armies, led by great lords from France, Germany and Norman Italy, reached Constantinople in 1096–97. Alexios, alarmed at their size, made most of the leaders swear to hand back any former Byzantine lands they took.

They won Nicaea for the emperor in 1097, then Antioch in June 1098 after a long siege and near-starvation. Bohemond, one of the leaders, kept Antioch for himself. Meanwhile, in 1098, the Fatimids of Egypt had taken Jerusalem back from the Turks.

On 15 July 1099 the crusaders broke into Jerusalem. They killed a large part of the people inside, Muslims and Jews, men, women and children. One crusader wrote that they ‘waded in blood up to their ankles’.

Go further· 4 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A Catholic history names the murders

    The Catholic Encyclopedia doesn't soften what the first popular bands did on their way east.

    “on all sides sprang up disorganized, undisciplined, penniless hordes, almost destitute of equipment, who, surging eastward through the valley of the Danube, plundered as they went along and murdered the Jews in the German cities.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Crusades, II. Foundation of Christian states in the East
  2. 02

    The bishops who tried to protect the Jews

    In Speyer, Worms and Mainz the bishops sheltered Jews, with mixed success. At least 800 were killed at Worms and at least 1,100 at Mainz. Tertiary source, used for dates and figures.

    “The bishop of Worms also attempted to shelter Jews, but the crusaders broke into his episcopal palace and killed the Jews inside on May 18.”
  3. 03

    An eyewitness at Jerusalem

    The anonymous Gesta Francorum, written by a crusader, describes the entry into the city.

    “Our men followed, killing and slaying even to the Temple of Solomon, where the slaughter was so great that our men waded in blood up to their ankles....”
    The Fall of Jerusalem, 1099: eyewitness accounts · Gesta Francorum, the fall of Jerusalem
  4. 04

    How a priest in the army saw it

    Raymond d'Aguilers, a chaplain with the southern French army, called the slaughter God's judgement. His words show how the crusaders understood what they had done.

    “men rode in blood up to their knees and bridle reins. Indeed, it was a just and splendid judgment of God that this place should be filled with the blood of the unbelievers”
    The Fall of Jerusalem, 1099: eyewitness accounts · Raymond d'Aguilers, the fall of Jerusalem
What came of it

The outcome

The crusaders chose Godfrey of Bouillon to rule Jerusalem, as ‘Defender of the Holy Sepulchre’. Four small crusader states grew up along the coast: Edessa, Antioch, Tripoli and the Kingdom of Jerusalem.

Pope Urban II died on 29 July 1099, two weeks after Jerusalem fell, before the news could reach him.

The crusader states didn't last. Saladin took Jerusalem back in 1187, and the last crusader city, Acre, fell in 1291. Popes kept calling crusades long after, against new enemies and sometimes against Christians.

For the Greeks the help came at a cost. Alexios got Nicaea back, but the armies at his gates and the broken oaths left Greeks and Latins trusting each other less, and that distrust broke open in 1204.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Godfrey's title

    The Catholic Encyclopedia records how the leaders chose Jerusalem's first ruler.

    “Having accomplished their pilgrimage to the Holy Sepulchre , the knights chose as lord of the new conquest Godfrey of Bouillon , who called himself "Defender of the Holy Sepulchre ".”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Crusades, II. Foundation of Christian states in the East
  2. 02

    Urban never heard

    The pope who called the crusade died before the news of Jerusalem reached Rome.

    “On 15 July, 1099, Jerusalem fell before the attack of the crusaders , but Urban did not live to hear the news.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Pope Blessed Urban II
  3. 03

    Seeds of distrust

    Even a sympathetic Catholic history admits the crusaders' arrival at Constantinople damaged relations between Greeks and Latins for good.

    “The appearance of the crusading armies at Constantinople raised the greatest trouble, and helped to bring about in the future irremediable misunderstandings between the Greeks and the Latin Christians .”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Crusades, II. Foundation of Christian states in the East
Why it matters

For the trail

Most people's picture of the medieval Church starts with the Crusades. The first one shows why both its defenders and its critics have a point.

It began as an answer to a real call for help. Eastern Christians were losing their homes, and many who went believed they were giving their lives for their brothers and for . Many of them died on the road.

It also put Christ's name on slaughter: Jews murdered in German cities before the armies even left, and the people of Jerusalem killed when it fell. A holy aim didn't make those killings holy.

And it set a pattern that lasted for centuries: popes calling wars and promising spiritual rewards to those who fought in them.

Go further· 1 note, each with its source
  1. 01

    The question the Church asked itself in 2000

    Memory and Reconciliation names the Crusades when it asks whether today's Church can rightly ask forgiveness for the past, and how to judge people of another age fairly.

    “Can today’s conscience be assigned ‘guilt’ for isolated historical phenomena like the Crusades or the Inquisition? Isn’t it a bit too easy to judge people of the past by the conscience of today”
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Church doesn't defend what was done at Jerusalem or in the Rhineland. It teaches that in any war ‘Non-combatants, wounded soldiers, and prisoners must be respected and treated humanely’, and that orders to kill them excuse no one (CCC 2313).

Preparing the Day of Pardon in 2000, the Church's theologians named the Crusades among the hard cases. They called Catholics to repent of the times when ‘doubtful means were employed in the pursuit of good ends’ (*Memory and Reconciliation* 5.3).

On the Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000, John Paul II asked God's forgiveness for Christians who ‘have sometimes used methods not in keeping with the Gospel’, and for the sins of Christians against the Jewish people.

The Second Vatican Council ‘decries hatred, persecutions, displays of anti-Semitism, directed against Jews at any time and by anyone’, and urges Christians and Muslims to put past hostilities behind them and work for mutual understanding (*Nostra Aetate* 3–4).

In plain terms

Think of it like this

A friend asks you to lend him a few men to guard his shop, and a crowd turns up with plans of its own.

Alexios asked for soldiers to serve under him. What came was a movement: tens of thousands of people sure that God had called them to Jerusalem, following their own lords and keeping some of what they won. Help that big and that certain of itself was hard for the emperor, or the pope, to control.

Read the text
“For your brethren who live in the east are in urgent need of your help, and you must hasten to give them the aid which has often been promised them.”

No text of the speech was kept at the time. Fulcher probably heard it and wrote it down years later; four other accounts, by writers who may not all have been there, differ from his.

Other readings

Where people disagree

The acts of the council of Clermont don't survive. We have five accounts of Urban's speech, all written years afterwards. Fulcher of Chartres was probably there; for the others it's less certain, and they don't agree word for word.

Historians argue over what Alexios wanted. The 1908 Catholic Encyclopedia says he had only asked for knights to serve in his own army. What came instead was an army with its own aims, and it alarmed the Greeks.

The death toll at Jerusalem is argued too. The Muslim historian Ibn al-Athir, writing about a century later, gave 70,000; historians today think that far too high for the city's size, and estimates run from about 3,000 to 40,000.

A Muslim chronicler says the Jews of Jerusalem were burned inside their synagogue; a Jewish letter written soon after confirms the synagogue was burned, but not that anyone was inside. No eyewitness says the crusaders killed the city's Eastern Christians: the Fatimid governor had expelled them before the siege.

Why ordinary knights went is argued as well. Some, like Bohemond, clearly wanted land of their own. Many others went with their kin, and historians weigh faith, family loyalty and gain differently.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Did Alexios want a crusade?

    The 1908 Catholic Encyclopedia argues that the emperor asked only for mercenaries and that the movement itself came from the pope.

    “Of course it is possible that in order to swell his forces, Alexius Comnenus solicited assistance in the West; however, it was not he but the pope who agitated the great movement which filled the Greeks with anxiety and terror.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crusades' · Crusades, I. Origin of the Crusades
  2. 02

    How many died

    A modern summary of the debate over the numbers. Tertiary source, used for the range only.

    “Historian Conor Kostick says that the number of people killed is a matter of debate, with the figure of 70,000 given by the Muslim historian Ibn al-Athir (writing c. 1200) considered to be a significant exaggeration; 40,000 is plausible”
  3. 03

    The Eastern Christians of Jerusalem

    Eastern Christian chroniclers don't accuse the crusaders of killing Christians in the city; they had already been expelled.

    “No eyewitness source refers to Crusaders killing Eastern Christians in Jerusalem”
    Siege of Jerusalem (1099) · Aftermath: Eastern Christians

This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next