The nave of Chartres Cathedral.
VIII / XI
1300–1517

Crisis and calls for reform

The 1300s begin with the popes leaving Rome. From 1309 they live at Avignon, in France, for almost seventy years, and many Christians see them as too close to the French king.

Catherine of Siena, a young laywoman, writes to the pope begging him to go back, and in 1377 he does.

While the popes are at Avignon, the Black Death of 1347–51 kills perhaps a third of Europe’s people, priests among them. Then a disputed election in 1378 gives the Church two rival popes, and later three. The Council of Constance ends the split in 1417.

The same council condemns the Czech preacher Jan Hus, who had come under the king’s promise of safe conduct, and he is burned in 1415. From his heirs comes the Moravian Church.

In 1439 a reunion with the Orthodox is signed at Florence, then rejected in the East. The printing press arrives, and calls for reform grow louder from inside the Church itself.

The world: Black Death · Renaissance · printing · Age of exploration · wars of religion
Chartres Cathedral, built 1194–1220.
The broken stone arches of the Pont Saint-Bénézet run into the Rhône, with Avignon's walls, cathedral and the towers of the popes' palace on the rock behind.
Avignon on the Rhône today. Behind the old Pont Saint-Bénézet rise the cathedral and the fortress-palace the popes built here in the 1300s.
1309–77Historical

The popes live at Avignon

Around 1300 Pope Boniface VIII clashed with King Philip IV of France over the king's power to tax and judge the clergy. In 1303 Philip's men seized the pope at Anagni, and he died weeks later. Rome itself was torn by feuding noble families.

In 1305 the cardinals elected a Frenchman, Clement V, who settled at Avignon in 1309. Seven popes in a row, all French, lived there for nearly 70 years, close to the French crown.

Urged by Catherine of Siena, Gregory XI returned to Rome in January 1377 and died there in 1378.

“Here reign the successors of the poor fishermen of Galilee; they have strangely forgotten their origin.”
Letter Criticizing the Avignon Papacy · Petrarch, letter to a friend, 1340–1353
What the Church says

The Church counts the seven Avignon popes as true popes: being bishop of Rome doesn't depend on where the pope lives.

It honours Catherine of Siena, the laywoman who pressed Gregory XI to go home, as a saint. In 1970 Paul VI declared her a Doctor of the Church, a title for saints whose teaching has special value for everyone.

Vatican II teaches that ‘Christ summons the Church, as she goes her pilgrim way, to that continual reformation of which she always has need’ (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 6).

The Palace of the Popes at Avignon.
1378–1417
The Western Schism
1pope
The Palais des Papes, Avignon, seat of one of the rival lines during the Western Schism.
1378–1417Historical

The Western Schism

From 1309 the popes lived at Avignon in France. Gregory XI brought the papacy back to Rome and died there in 1378.

Under pressure from a Roman crowd, the cardinals elected an Italian, Urban VI; months later most of them said the vote was forced and elected Clement VII, who went back to Avignon.

Europe split between them, and even saints took different sides. A council at Pisa in 1409 added a third pope.

The Council of Constance ended it in 1417, removing or accepting the resignation of all three and electing Martin V. Its claim that a council stands above a pope was argued for a century.

“First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith, the eradication of the said schism and the general …”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 5 (6 April 1415), Haec sancta
What the Church says

The Church has never solemnly ruled which line was lawful, but its official list of popes counts the Roman line (Urban VI, Boniface IX, Innocent VII, Gregory XII) as the true popes of the Schism.

The idea that grew out of Constance, that a council stands above a pope, was not accepted. The Church teaches that no council is ecumenical unless Peter's successor confirms it, and that the pope has ‘full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church’ (CCC 882, 884).

A fifteenth-century chronicle painting of Jan Hus standing in the flames outside the walls of Constance while an executioner stokes the fire and townspeople watch.
Jan Hus in the fire at Constance, painted seventy years later for Diebold Schilling’s Spiezer Chronik (1485).
1415Historical

Jan Hus burned at Constance

Jan Hus was a Czech priest and master of Prague's university who preached in Czech against the sins of the clergy, at a time when two and then three men claimed to be pope. He followed much of the English theologian John Wyclif, whose teaching had been condemned.

In his book On the Church he taught that the true Church is the number of those God has chosen for salvation, so that a wicked pope is no true head of it.

In 1414 he went to the Council of Constance under a safe-conduct from King Sigismund, hoping to be heard. Within weeks he was arrested.

On 6 July 1415 the council condemned him as a heretic and handed him to the secular authorities, who burned him outside the city that day. Bohemia rose in revolt, and from his followers came the Unity of the Brethren, today's Moravian Church.

“This holy synod of Constance, seeing that God’s church has nothing more that it can do, relinquishes John Hus to the judgment of the secular authority and decrees that he is to be relinquished to the secular court.”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 15 (6 July 1415), sentence condemning J. Hus to the stake (Tanner, Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils)
What the Church says

In 1999 John Paul II expressed ‘deep regret for the cruel death inflicted on John Hus, and for the consequent wound of conflict and division’. In 2015 Francis said Hus ‘has become a reason for dialogue’. Neither withdrew the council's judgement on his teaching about the Church.

On the burning itself the Church has changed course. It teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2), and in 2000 asked forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.

The same teaching judges the Hussite killings of priests and monks. Moravians born into their church ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3), and their baptism truly joins them to Christ (UR 22).

Pisanello’s medal of the Byzantine emperor John VIII Palaiologos, made at the council of 1438–39.
Pisanello’s medal of the emperor John VIII, struck while the Greeks were in Italy for the council.
1439Historical

Council of Florence

By the 1430s the Ottoman Turks had nearly surrounded Constantinople. Emperor John VIII and Patriarch Joseph II came to Italy with some 700 Greeks, hoping that church union would bring Western soldiers.

For over a year at Ferrara and Florence, Greek and Latin theologians argued over the Holy Spirit, purgatory, the bread of the Eucharist and the pope's authority.

On 6 July 1439 a decree of union was read in Greek and Latin in Florence cathedral. Every Greek bishop but Mark of Ephesus signed, yet at home clergy and people rejected it.

Western help failed at Varna in 1444, and on 29 May 1453 Constantinople fell to the Ottomans. Today 23 Eastern Catholic Churches are in communion with Rome; the Orthodox Churches are not, divided still over the pope's role and the Filioque.

“that the holy Spirit is eternally from the Father and the Son, and has his essence and his subsistent being from the Father together with the Son, and proceeds from both eternally as from one principle and a single spiration. ... We define also that the explanation of those words “and from the Son” was licitly and reasonably added to the creed for the sake …”
Council of Florence: Laetentur caeli, Bull of Union with the Greeks (1439) · Council of Florence, session 6 (6 July 1439), Laetentur caeli, decree of union with the Greeks
What the Church says

The Church counts Florence as the seventeenth ecumenical council. Its teaching on the Holy Spirit, purgatory and the pope's primacy remains Catholic doctrine, and the First Vatican Council built on its decree on the papacy.

The Church no longer seeks unity by bringing parts of Eastern Churches over one at a time. Since the Balamand statement of 1993 it seeks full communion with the Orthodox through dialogue between sister Churches, while upholding the Eastern Catholic Churches' right to exist (Balamand Document 12, 3).

1457–67

Real but imperfect communion

Around 1400 the Western Church had two, then three, rival popes, and many Czechs resented a rich, worldly clergy. Jan Hus, a Prague priest and university teacher, preached in Czech against the sins of clergy and nobles, drawing on the English theologian John Wyclif, whose teaching had been condemned.

In 1414 Hus went to the Council of Constance, trusting a safe-conduct from King Sigismund. He was arrested within weeks and burned as a heretic on 6 July 1415. Bohemia took it as an insult to the whole Czech nation.

Bohemia rose. Pope Martin V proclaimed a crusade in 1420, and armies came again and again until 1431; the Hussites beat them every time. Peace came in 1436, and lay people kept the cup at Communion as well as the bread.

What we still share
  • Faith in the Trinity: “With the whole of Christendom we share faith in God the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit” (*Ground of the Unity*, the Moravian statement of faith).
  • Baptism in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit, usually of babies, which the Catholic Church recognises as true baptism (*Unitatis Redintegratio* 22).
  • The ancient creeds, received as “the thankful acclaim of the Body of Christ” (*Ground of the Unity*).
How they describe it

Moravians see their church as the Unity of Brethren (*Unitas Fratrum*) begun by the heirs of Hus in 1457 and renewed at Herrnhut in 1727, “called in faith to serve humanity by proclaiming the Gospel of Jesus Christ”.

What it cost
  • Hus and Jerome burned at Constance, 1415 and 1416Suffered by Protestants
  • Crusades against the Hussites, 1420 to 1431Suffered by Protestants
  • Prague’s councillors thrown from the windows, 30 July 1419Suffered by Catholics
  • Monasteries burned and monks killed, 1420 to 1431Suffered by Catholics
  • Hussite against Hussite: Houska, the Adamites and Lipany, 1421 and 1434Between Protestants
  • The Brethren persecuted by a Hussite king, 1461 to 1468Between Protestants
  • A Brother at the second defenestration, 1618Suffered by Catholics
  • The Day of Blood and the choice between Catholicism and exile, 1621 to 1628Suffered by Protestants
Saints of this age

3 lives, among many

Signs in this age
  • A dying man in a house on the Kalverstraat received viaticum, the last Communion given to the dying, vomited, and the vomit was thrown on the fire. Next morning, the account says, the host was found whole in the ashes. It was taken to the parish church and twice returned of itself to the house.

    Not established: The date.

  • The story as the Acutis exhibition tells it (the chronicler Jan Długosz first wrote it down more than a century after 1345): thieves broke into a church near Kraków, stole a monstrance with consecrated hosts, found it was not gold and threw it into a marsh. Lights were seen over the marsh at night; the bishop ordered three days of fasting and led a procession that recovered the monstrance and the hosts.

    Not established: Anything beyond the church itself.

  • A linen cloth 4.4 m by 1.1 m bearing the faint front-and-back image of a naked, scourged and crucified man, kept in Turin since 1578 and owned by the Holy See since 1983.

    Not established: A settled date.

  • Oswald Milser, lord of Schlossberg, is said to have demanded at the Holy Thursday Mass of 1384 to be given the celebrant’s large host rather than a layman’s small one. When he received it the floor sank under him; he grasped the altar, the priest took the host back from his mouth, and it was found to be bleeding.

    Not established: That the host has been examined.

  • The exhibition’s account: in 1411, at Mass in the castle chapel at Ludbreg, a priest doubted that the wine truly became Christ’s blood, and the wine in the chalice turned into blood. Not knowing what to do, he walled the relic up behind the altar, swore the workman to silence, and told no one until he was dying.

    Not established: That wine became blood.

  • On 30 November 1433, after days of rain, the Sorgue and the Rhône flooded Avignon. The Grey Penitents, a lay confraternity, had left the Blessed Sacrament exposed in their chapel by the Sorgue.

    Not established: That the memory is unshaped.

  • During the war between Savoy and René of Anjou, soldiers sacked the church at Exilles in the Susa valley. One loaded the monstrance and host into a bag on a mule and rode to Turin.

    Not established: Anything the chapter acts would show.