VI / XI
787–1054

Monks and missions

Rome has fallen in the West, but the Church has not. Monks living by the rule Benedict wrote back in the 500s copy the old books and keep learning alive. Irish monks paint the Book of Kells.

Two Greek brothers, Cyril and Methodius, carry the faith to the Slavs in their own language.

In Kyiv, Prince Vladimir sends envoys to see how different peoples worship. The ones who stood in Hagia Sophia, the great church of Constantinople, come back saying they hadn’t known whether they were in heaven or on earth. In 988 Kyiv is baptised.

Meanwhile East and West drift apart. They speak different languages, Latin and Greek, and worship in different ways.

In 800 the pope crowns Charlemagne, king of the Franks, emperor in the West, while an emperor still reigns in Constantinople. Arguments grow over the pope’s authority and over words the West has added to the Creed, until the drift becomes a break.

The world: Fall of the West · barbarian kingdoms · Charlemagne · Vikings · High Middle Ages · Crusades
Approaching Skellig Michael, off the coast of Co. Kerry, Ireland, where an early medieval monastery stands
The Triumph of Orthodoxy icon, Constantinople, about 1400, showing the restoration of icons.
The Triumph of Orthodoxy, an icon of about 1400 celebrating the return of the images the council of 787 had defended.
787Revealed

Second Council of Nicaea

For about sixty years Byzantine emperors, fighting off Arab armies and convinced that images broke the commandment against idols, had ordered images of Christ and the saints destroyed, and persecuted the monks who defended them. In 787 the empress Irene called a council at Nicaea.

It ruled that images may be set up in churches and honoured, but not worshipped: the honour given to an image passes to the person it shows, and worship belongs to God alone. Iconoclasm returned for a time until 843.

It is the last council that Catholics and Orthodox both count as ecumenical.

“For the honour which is paid to the image passes on to that which the image represents, and he who reveres the image reveres in it the subject represented.”
Second Council of Nicaea (787): Decree on Images · Decree on Images
What the Church says

The Church counts it as the seventh ecumenical council, the last one Catholics and Orthodox both accept. Its teaching stands: images are honoured, not worshipped, and the honour passes to the one they show (CCC 2131–2132).

A fresco in an arch: a pope seated on the left watches soldiers drag half-stripped captives from the shore, with a harbour, a fortress and ships behind.
The victory over the Saracen fleet at Ostia in 849, as Raphael's workshop imagined it in 1514–15 for a room in the Vatican. Leo IV, seated on the left, is given the face of Leo X, the pope who paid for it.
846–1059Historical

Popes fighting to survive

In the 800s and 900s the popes ruled Rome and the lands around it but had little power to defend them. In 846 Muslim raiders, whom Italians called Saracens, landed at the mouth of the Tiber and stripped St Peter's and St Paul's, and Pope Leo IV built a wall around the Vatican.

Inside the city, noble families fought over the papacy and often chose the pope. A dead pope was put on trial in 897, a young noble became John XII in 955, and by 1046 three men claimed the office.

In 1059 a council gave the election of popes to the cardinals.

“As soon as Leo, much against his will, became pope , he began to take precautions against a repetition of the Saracen raid of 846.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Saint Leo IV' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Pope Saint Leo IV'
What the Church says

The Church doesn't claim its popes have all been good men. The Second Vatican Council teaches that the Church is ‘embracing in its bosom sinners, at the same time holy and always in need of being purified’ (*Lumen Gentium* 8).

Catholics believe the pope is kept from error only when he solemnly defines a teaching of faith or morals for the whole Church (CCC 891). That promise covers what he teaches, not how he lives or how he came to office.

Leo IV, who walled in the Vatican, is honoured as a saint, and his name is in the Roman Martyrology.

Saints of this age

One life among many