Part VI · Chapter 17
Heresies force Christians to define things

If the faith never changes, why do the definitions keep getting longer?

5 scenes · about 13 min read

The short answer

Because nobody defines what nobody disputes. Christians didn't write out the of the , one God as Father, Son and , for the fun of it.

They wrote it because around 318 a respected priest in Alexandria, Egypt, began teaching that the Son was a creature. Almost every phrase about the Son could be read his way.

The same thing kept happening. A serious teacher gives a serious answer to a real question. The answer turns out to break something else. Then the reply with a precision nobody had needed before.

Catholics call this clarifying, not inventing. The test is whether the new words protect something the earliest sources already show. That test can be failed, which is why the early texts keep being put on the table.

Follow the trail

Five early arguments about Jesus, and what each one forced the Church to say out loud.

1st–2nd c.Historical2 min read

Was Jesus's body real?

Ignatius of Antioch and Irenaeus of Lyon, against the Docetists and Gnostics

Around AD 107, , bishop of Antioch, wrote against teachers who said Jesus only seemed to have a body. Around AD 180, , bishop of Lyon, argued against them too. Both pointed to the , the bread and wine Christians share at worship, as evidence that his body was real.

IWhat was going on

In the late first and second centuries, many people in the Roman world were shaped by Greek philosophy. They thought matter was low, and the body a prison for the soul.

Some Christian teachers, later called Gnostics, from gnosis, Greek for knowledge, taught that a lesser god made the material world. Salvation, they said, came through secret knowledge.

A related idea, Docetism, from dokein, Greek for to seem, said that Jesus only seemed to have a body.

IIWhat was at stake

To them, a God who was born, got hungry, bled and died was embarrassing, even impossible. So the first big challenge wasn't that Christ was too human. It was that he wasn't human at all.

But if Jesus's body wasn't real, then neither was his death on the cross, nor his rising from the dead. Nothing real would have been saved.

IIIWhat happened

Around AD 107, Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, was on his way to Rome to be executed. On the way he wrote against these teachers.

He pointed out that they stayed away from the Eucharist. They wouldn't confess it to be the flesh of Jesus Christ, who suffered for our .

Around AD 180, Irenaeus, bishop of Lyon, wrote five books called Against Heresies. If the flesh can't be saved, he argued, then the bread of the Eucharist can't be Christ's body either.

IVWhat came of it

The Church held to the plain story. Jesus was born of the Virgin Mary and suffered under , the Roman governor who had him .

Those phrases went into the early creeds, the short statements of faith said at . They are still in the Apostles' Creed today.

Gnostic groups faded over the following centuries. In 1945 a library of their writings was found buried at Nag Hammadi in Egypt.

VRead the source
They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins.
Letter to the Smyrnaeans (shorter recension) · Smyrnaeans 7

Why it matters

It's the first time the Church had to say out loud that God really became flesh, and that the body matters.

That's also why Christians bury the dead and hope for the of the body. The faith isn't an escape from the material world. It's the rescue of it.

c. 318Historical2 min read

Arius: was the Son of God created?

Arius, a priest in Alexandria

Around 318, Arius, a respected priest in Alexandria, Egypt, began teaching that the was the highest of all created beings. But he was still a creature: there was a time when he did not exist.

IWhat was going on

Alexandria, in Egypt, was one of the great cities of the Roman Empire and a centre of learning. Arius was a priest there: popular, serious, and good at putting theology into songs people sang.

In 313 the emperor had made Christianity legal, after centuries of persecution. The Church now had peace, and time to argue.

IIWhat was at stake

Christians believed in one God. They also worshipped Jesus as Lord. How do those fit together?

Arius's answer was tidy. Only the Father is truly God, without beginning. The Son was made by the Father before everything else, and everything else was made through him.

That protected the belief in one God. But it made the Son a creature that Christians were worshipping.

IIIWhat happened

Around 320, Alexander, the bishop of Alexandria, called a meeting of Egyptian bishops. It condemned Arius's teaching and excommunicated him: it cut him off from the until he changed his mind.

Arius wrote to a powerful friend, Eusebius, bishop of Nicomedia, near the emperor's court. In that letter, he complains of being persecuted for saying that the Son has a beginning.

IVWhat came of it

Bishops across the East took sides. Ordinary Christians argued about it in the streets and markets.

In 324 Constantine had just become ruler of the whole empire, and he wanted one united Church. He sent letters urging peace.

When that failed, he called the bishops to a council at Nicaea, a meeting of bishops from across the empire.

VRead the source
We are persecuted, because we say that the Son has a beginning, but that God is without beginning. This is the cause of our persecution, and likewise, because we say that He is of the non-existent.
Church History · Church History 1.5

Why it matters

Arius wasn't a crank. He was trying to protect something true: that there is one God. And almost every Bible verse about the Son could be read his way.

That's exactly why the Church had to find words that couldn't be read his way. Nobody writes a definition for something nobody is arguing about.

325Revealed2 min read

A word no follower of Arius could sign

The Council of Nicaea

In 325, around 300 bishops met at Nicaea, today İznik in Turkey. They said the Son is of one substance with the Father. The word isn't in the Bible. They chose it because no follower of Arius could sign it.

IWhat was going on

In the summer of 325, around 300 bishops met at Nicaea, today İznik in Turkey, near the emperor's palace. gives the number as 318.

Most came from the East. Sylvester sent two priests to represent Rome.

Many of the bishops had been imprisoned or tortured in the persecutions only a few years before. Some still bore the scars.

IIWhat was at stake

The bishops first tried to use Bible words: the Son is from God, the Word, the image of God. But the followers of Arius could agree to all of those, by reading them their own way. Everything, after all, is from God.

The council needed words that said plainly what the Bible meant, and that a follower of Arius could not twist.

IIIWhat happened

They chose a Greek word, homoousios: of one substance, or one being, with the Father. Whatever the Father is as God, the Son is too.

They wrote it into a creed, a short statement of faith. Then they added an anathema, a solemn declaration that a teaching is outside the faith. It was aimed at anyone who said there was a time when the Son was not.

Almost all the bishops signed. Arius and two bishops refused, and Constantine sent them into exile.

IVWhat came of it

Nicaea didn't end the argument. For over fifty years emperors favoured one side or the other, and bishops were exiled and brought back.

In 381 the Council of Constantinople confirmed Nicaea's faith and added more on the Holy Spirit. The result is the Nicene Creed, said at , the Catholic service, every Sunday.

The West later added that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, the filioque. The reject that addition.

On 28 November 2025, at İznik, Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew prayed it together for its 1,700th anniversary. Bartholomew holds the first place of honour among Orthodox bishops.

VRead the source
being of one substance with the Father … And whosoever shall say that there was a time when the Son of God was not … the Catholic and Apostolic Church anathematizes them.
The Creed of the Council of Nicaea (325) · Creed of Nicaea

Why it matters

The Creed is shared by Catholics, Orthodox and most Protestants. It's the one text that holds most of the world's Christians together.

It also shows how doctrine grows. It doesn't grow by inventing something new. It grows by finding a sharper word to protect what was already believed.

c. 350Historical1 min read

Why use a word that isn't in the Bible?

Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria

Around 350 , bishop of Alexandria, answered critics who said Nicaea had used words not found in the Bible. He had been at the council himself as a young man. The complaint is as old as the council, and so is the answer.

IWhat was going on

Athanasius was a young at Nicaea, an assistant to Bishop Alexander. In 328 he became bishop of Alexandria himself.

He spent the rest of his life defending Nicaea. Emperors who favoured the other side sent him into exile five times.

Around 350 he wrote a letter known as De Decretis, On the Decrees. It explains why the council worded its creed as it did.

IIWhat was at stake

Opponents of Nicaea said: you've added to Scripture. Of one substance is a philosopher's word. Why should Christians accept a test the Bible never used?

It's still a fair question. It's the main objection to any doctrine defined by a council.

IIIWhat happened

Athanasius answers in two steps. First, the Arians, the followers of Arius, had used phrases that aren't in the Bible either, such as out of nothing and there was when he was not.

Second, the bishops had tried Bible words first. The Arians agreed to them while meaning something else. So the bishops were forced to say the sense of Scripture more distinctly.

So from the substance of God spells out what from God means when the Bible says it of the Son: he comes from God's own being, not made the way a creature is.

IVRead the source
Why did the Fathers at Nicæa use terms not in Scripture, 'Of the essence' and 'One in essence?'
Defence of the Nicene Definition (De Decretis) · De Decretis 1

Why it matters

Athanasius's answer is the Catholic idea of development of doctrine in its earliest form: new words to keep an old meaning safe.

The test is whether the new words protect what the earlier sources already show, or add something they don't. That test can be failed, which is why it matters to keep the early texts in view.

431 and 451Revealed2 min read

How are God and man joined in Jesus?

The Councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon, against Nestorius and Eutyches

In 431 at Ephesus, and in 451 at Chalcedon near Constantinople, bishops answered two opposite errors. One split Christ in two. The other swallowed up his humanity. Chalcedon said he is one person in two natures, God and man.

IWhat was going on

After Nicaea, everyone in the main Church agreed that the Son is fully God. The next question was how God and man are joined in Jesus.

Two great churches thought about it differently. Antioch, in Syria, stressed that Jesus was fully human. Alexandria, in Egypt, stressed that he is one person, God the Son.

Each was afraid of the other's extreme.

IIWhat was at stake

Two men stand at the centre, twenty years apart.

The first was Nestorius, bishop of Constantinople. He objected to calling Mary Theotokos, Greek for God-bearer. She was mother of the man Jesus, he said, not of God.

To his critics that split Christ into two: God and a man. In 431 the rejected his teaching and kept the title.

The second was Eutyches, an elderly abbot, the head of a monastery outside Constantinople. In 448 he taught the opposite: after the union, Christ had only one nature, one way of being. So his humanity was no longer like ours.

IIIWhat happened

Pope Leo I answered Eutyches in a letter known as his Tome: Christ is one person in two natures. A rival council at Ephesus in 449 cleared Eutyches amid violence, and Leo called it a robber council.

In 451 a new council met at Chalcedon, near Constantinople. It read Leo's Tome and defined Christ as one person in two natures, without confusion, change, division or separation.

IVWhat came of it

Rome, Constantinople and most of the empire accepted Chalcedon. But the churches of Egypt, Syria and Armenia rejected its wording, because to them it divided Christ.

They condemned Eutyches too. But they kept the phrase of Cyril, an earlier bishop of Alexandria: one nature of God the Word made flesh.

They became the Oriental Orthodox Churches, among them the Coptic, Syriac, Armenian and Ethiopian Churches.

VRead the source
in two natures, unconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably united, and that without the distinction of natures being taken away by such union.
Council of Chalcedon (451): Definition of the Faith · Definition of the Faith

Why it matters

Chalcedon's four words, without confusion, change, division or separation, mark the edges of the road on both sides. Christ is truly God and truly man: one person, not two, and not a blend.

The split was painful and long. But since 1973, popes and Oriental Orthodox leaders have signed joint declarations. They say both confess the same faith in Christ, in different words.

In 1994 Pope John Paul II signed a similar declaration with the , which had never accepted the Council of Ephesus.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Catholics call this development of doctrine: the Church understanding its own faith more clearly over time. The classic book on it is the Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine by John Henry Newman, an English Anglican priest and scholar who became a Catholic as he finished it in 1845, and later a cardinal.

The idea is that a living body understands itself more precisely over time without becoming a different body. A child grows up and is still the same person.

The test for real development is whether the later wording keeps the earlier principle, or replaces it. That is a real test, and it can be failed.

That's why the early texts are put in front of the reader again and again, instead of simply claiming that nothing has changed.

It also explains how the Catholic Church treated heretics, the teachers whose ideas it rejected. At its best, the attitude was not contempt but seriousness.

At its worst, in later centuries, heretics were put to death. In 2000 asked God's forgiveness for the violence Christians had used in the service of truth.

, Nestorius and Eutyches were all trying to say something true about . The councils said: not that way, and here is why.

Seventeen centuries on, the words Nicaea fought for still bring divided Christians together. On 28 November 2025, at İznik, Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew prayed them side by side.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Protestant readers

Most Protestants accept the first four councils and their definitions, because they judge them faithful to Scripture, not because a said so. But they deny that the same process makes later Catholic doctrines legitimate.

One example is the , the Catholic teaching that Mary was taken body and soul into .

The question they press is what stops development from becoming addition.

Non-Chalcedonian churches

The , among them the Coptic, Syriac, Armenian and Ethiopian Churches, rejected 's wording as dividing Christ.

They have held ever since to the phrase of Cyril of Alexandria: one nature of God the Word made flesh.

Joint declarations since 1973 say both families of Churches confess the same faith in different words.

Critical historians

The strongest form of this view comes from Walter Bauer, a German scholar, in 1934. In several regions, he argued, the forms of Christianity later called heresy came first. 'Orthodoxy' was one stream among many, the one centred on Rome, and it won.

Bart Ehrman, an American scholar, put the case to a wide public in Lost Christianities (2003): the winners wrote the creeds and buried the losers' books.

They point to the emperor's pressure at Nicaea and the violence at Ephesus. The heroes weren't gentle either. Athanasius's opponents brought a string of charges against him, from bribery to violence, and a council at Tyre in 335 deposed him.

The documents themselves show both: the arguments and the politics.

Catholics answer on three points. Bauer's critics showed his evidence was thin for several regions, and that a shared core, a rule of faith, was already being taught to converts by about 180, when Irenaeus wrote it out.

The losers weren't silenced either: Arius's own letters survive, among them his complaint to Eusebius told above. And power sat on both sides. For decades after 325 emperors favoured the other side, and Athanasius was exiled five times.

Nicaea's words held through all of it, and were confirmed at Constantinople in 381.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself5
The pattern, five times over5 steps

Each time, the same steps came round: a question, an answer, something breaks, a definition. The definitions get longer because the questions get sharper.

  1. A real question

    Each heresy, a teaching the Church went on to reject, began as an attempt to make Christian beliefs fit together. Usually it came from a respected teacher.

    “The first heresies denied not so much Christ's divinity as his true humanity (Gnostic Docetism).”
  2. A plausible answer

    Arius could quote Scripture. That's why the crisis lasted sixty years and won emperors over.

    “the Son is not unbegotten, nor in any way part of the unbegotten.”
    HistoricalChurch HistoryChurch History 1.5
  3. Something breaks

    If the Son is a creature, then a creature saves us. And Christians who worship him are worshipping something made, which is idolatry.

    “the first ecumenical council of Nicaea in 325 confessed in its Creed that the Son of God is “begotten, not made, of the same substance (homoousios) as the Father”, and condemned Arius.”
  4. A new word protects an old belief

    Here is the Catholic Church's own account of how it happened, in plain words.

    “During the first centuries the Church sought to clarify her Trinitarian faith, both to deepen her own understanding of the faith and to defend it against the errors that were deforming it.”
  5. And it happens again, with Mary's title

    The Council of Ephesus was settling a question about Christ. It did so through a title for his mother: Mother of God.

    “the Council of Ephesus proclaimed in 431 that Mary truly became the Mother of God by the human conception of the Son of God in her womb.”
Every claim this chapter leans on3 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Ignatius says certain people abstain from the Eucharist "because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins".

Rests on
  • Smyrnaeans 7
    “They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins”
Other readings
  • The people Ignatius opposes are Docetists who denied Christ had real flesh at all; the passage is primarily about the Incarnation, which is why it is also evidence about the Eucharist.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).

02RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Council of Nicaea (325) confessed the Son to be of one substance (homoousios) with the Father and anathematised the claim that there was a time when he was not.

Rests on
  • Creed of Nicaea
    “Of the substance of the Father, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father … And whosoever shall say that there was a time when the Son of God was not, or that before he was begotten he was not … the Catholic and Apostolic Church anathematizes them.”
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

03RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Council of Chalcedon (451) defined one and the same Christ in two natures, without confusion, change, division or separation, the property of each nature preserved in one person.

Rests on
  • “This one and the same Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God must be confessed to be in two natures, unconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably united, and that without the distinction of natures being taken away by such union, but rather …”
    Read the full passage
    “This one and the same Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God must be confessed to be in two natures, unconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably united, and that without the distinction of natures being taken away by such union, but rather the peculiar property of each nature being preserved and being united in one Person and subsistence.”
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

Questions people ask next