The Catholic Church teaches that at the consecration the whole substance of the bread and wine is changed into the body and blood of Christ while the appearances of bread and wine remain, so the Real Presence cannot be detected by the senses or by a laboratory and rests on faith in Christ's words. No Catholic is obliged to believe any Eucharistic miracle, even one a bishop has recognised. Under the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith's 2024 norms, no Church authority will as a rule declare such a phenomenon supernatural, and an alleged Eucharistic miracle is to be kept in a confidential place while it is examined.
- Council of Trent, Session XIII (11 October 1551), Decree on the Eucharist, chapter IV (Waterworth translation, 1848)
“by the consecration of the bread and of the wine, a conversion is made of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood; which conversion is, by the holy Catholic Church, suitably and properly called Transubstantiation.”
- Session XIII, canon II
“the species Only of the bread and wine remaining”
- CCC 1381, citing Thomas Aquinas
“That in this sacrament are the true Body of Christ and his true Blood is something that 'cannot be apprehended by the senses,' says St. Thomas, 'but only by faith, which relies on divine authority.'”
- Raffaello Martinelli, 'Eucharistic miracles: limits and positivity', presentation to the international exhibition, section 1 'Limits'
“A Christian is not obliged to believe in Eucharistic miracles. These miracles do not bind the faithful to believe in them, even if they are officially recognised by the Church.”
- Norms for proceeding in the Discernment of alleged Supernatural Phenomena (17 May 2024), Introduction, paragraph 23
“it is reaffirmed that, as a rule, neither the Diocesan Bishop, nor the Episcopal Conferences, nor the Dicastery will declare that these phenomena are of supernatural origin”
- Norms (2024), Part II, Art. 7 § 4
“When it involves an alleged Eucharistic miracle, the consecrated species must be kept in a confidential place and in an appropriate manner.”
- Smalcald Articles, Part III, Article VI, paragraphs 1 and 5 (Triglot Concordia translation on bookofconcord.org)
“Sacrament of the Altar we hold that bread and wine in the Supper are the true body and blood of Christ ... As regards transubstantiation, we care nothing about the sophistical subtlety by which they teach that bread and wine leave or lose their own …”
Read the full passage“Sacrament of the Altar we hold that bread and wine in the Supper are the true body and blood of Christ ... As regards transubstantiation, we care nothing about the sophistical subtlety by which they teach that bread and wine leave or lose their own natural substance, and that there remain only the appearance and color of bread, and not true bread.”
- Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter XXIX, section VI (Schaff, Creeds of Christendom III)
“That doctrine which maintains a change of the substance of bread and wine, into the substance of Christ's body and blood (commonly called transubstantiation) by consecration of a priest, or by any other way, is repugnant, not to Scripture alone, but …”
Read the full passage“That doctrine which maintains a change of the substance of bread and wine, into the substance of Christ's body and blood (commonly called transubstantiation) by consecration of a priest, or by any other way, is repugnant, not to Scripture alone, but even to common-sense and reason; overthroweth the nature of the sacrament; and hath been, and is the cause of manifold superstitions, yea, of gross idolatries.”
- Luther, An Open Letter to the Christian Nobility (1520), proposal 20 (trans. C. M. Jacobs, Works of Martin Luther II, Philadelphia 1915)
“That miracles are done at these places does not help things, for the evil spirit can do miracles, as Christ has told us in Matthew 24:24.”
- Lutherans confess that the bread and wine are the true body and blood of Christ but reject transubstantiation as a 'sophistical subtlety'; bread remains bread. Luther in 1520 wanted the pilgrim shrines of bleeding hosts, Wilsnack among them, torn down, and held that miracles at such places prove nothing.
- The Westminster Confession holds that the bread and wine remain truly and only bread and wine, and calls transubstantiation the cause of 'manifold superstitions'. On that reading, cults of bleeding hosts are the predictable fruit of a mistaken doctrine.
- The 2024 norms govern procedure. They do not re-judge older cases, and they allow that the Pope can authorise a special procedure.
- Martinelli's presentation is the view of a Curia official printed in the exhibition's own material, not a magisterial document; the norms (paragraph 12) say the same thing about phenomena granted a nihil obstat.
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

