Part XII · Chapter 30
How does someone become a canonised saint?

Who actually decides that someone is a saint, and on what evidence? From outside it can look as if Rome names its heroes quickly when it wants to, and the miracles are a formality.

10 scenes · about 26 min read

The short answer

The decides, but last, after an investigation that can stop at any stage. The Catholic Church doesn't claim to make saints. It declares it is certain that a person is in and worth imitating.

Today it runs in five steps. A opens a local inquiry, which must hear doubters as well as admirers. In Rome, historians and theologians weigh a written life, and if the pope accepts it, the person is called Venerable.

A first healing, judged by doctors and then by theologians, makes the person Blessed; need none. A second makes them a Saint. A healing that fails the doctors three times can never come back.

The process has said no, and made people wait. Padre Pio was restricted for years before he was canonised.

The strongest objection is speed. In 1983 made the process simpler, and critics say he weakened its checks. For years the money was barely supervised.

John Paul II's own cause was fast-tracked, though he had trusted a cardinal later dismissed from the priesthood for abuse. A canonisation isn't a verdict that every decision was right.

Follow the trail

Ten scenes, from a rebuke in Carthage to a teenager canonised in 2025, following real people through the investigation.

c. AD 300Historical2 min read

A bone that had not been approved

Optatus of Milevis, telling the story of Lucilla of Carthage

Around AD 300, in Carthage in North Africa, a church official rebuked a rich woman named Lucilla. She had kissed the bone of a man the church had not yet accepted as a martyr.

IWhat was going on

In the early Church, a martyr was someone killed for refusing to deny . Christians gathered at martyrs' tombs on the anniversary of their death, which they called their birthday into heaven, and asked for their prayers.

The emperor Diocletian's great persecution, from 303, made many martyrs in North Africa. It also brought people who claimed the title without earning it.

IIWhat was at stake

If anyone could be honoured as a martyr, the Church's memory could fill up with frauds, or with people who died for the wrong reasons.

So local churches kept watch. A martyr had to be acknowledged, recognised by the local church, before he could be honoured in public.

IIIWhat happened

In Carthage, in today's Tunisia, lived a wealthy and influential lady named Lucilla. She used to kiss a bone of a supposed martyr just before receiving , the bread and wine Christians share at worship.

Caecilian, the archdeacon, rebuked her. He was the bishop's chief assistant. The dead man, he said, had not been acknowledged as a martyr. Lucilla was furious.

IVWhat came of it

Caecilian later became bishop of Carthage. Lucilla, still resentful, helped fund the bishops who set up a rival bishop against him.

That split became the Donatist , a breakaway church in North Africa that lasted for over a century.

Optatus, bishop of Milevis in today's Algeria, told the story late in the 300s. He wrote it in a book against the Donatists, to blame her for how they began.

VRead the source
It was said that she kissed a bone of some martyr or other—if he was a martyr—before she received the spiritual Food and Drink. Having then been corrected for thus touching—before she touched the Sacred Chalice—the bone of a dead man (if he was a martyr, at least he had not yet been acknowledged as such)
Against the Donatists, Book I (English translation) · Against the Donatists, Book I, 16 (O. R. Vassall-Phillips translation, 1917)

Why it matters

Optatus had his own reasons for telling the story. But it still shows the rule at work, centuries before Rome got involved: no public honour without the church's judgement.

The Catholic process today grew out of that same caution.

31 January 993Historical2 min read

The first saint declared by a pope

Pope John XV, at a church meeting in Rome

On 31 January 993 a church meeting in Rome, led by Pope John XV, declared Ulrich of Augsburg a saint. It is the first canonisation by a pope on record: the first time a pope declared someone a saint.

IWhat was going on

For the Church's first thousand years, saints were recognised locally. The people honoured someone, and the local bishop approved it, often by moving the body to a place of honour in a church.

Ulrich was bishop of Augsburg, in southern Germany, for fifty years. When Magyar raiders from what is now Hungary besieged the city in 955, he led its defence. He died in 973, and people reported miracles at his grave.

IIWhat was at stake

A local bishop could approve a saint for his own diocese, the area he leads. But what about the whole Church?

As more saints were proclaimed, some on thin grounds, people looked for a higher authority whose word would carry everywhere.

IIIWhat happened

On 31 January 993 Pope John XV held a synod, a church meeting, in Rome. It met at the Lateran, the popes' home at the time.

The synod solemnly declared Ulrich a saint. On 3 February the pope announced it to the bishops of France and Germany in a bull, a formal papal letter.

IVWhat came of it

Local recognition carried on for another two centuries alongside papal canonisations.

The Orthodox Church in America, part of the Eastern Orthodox family of Churches, also names Ulrich, in 993, as the first canonisation of this Roman kind.

The Orthodox never adopted it. They still recognise saints through their bishops and their synods.

VRead the source
At a Roman synod held in the Lateran on 31 January, 993, Bishop Ulrich of Augsburg was solemnly canonized, an event which the pope announced to the French and German bishops in a Bull dated 3 February. This was the first time that a solemn canonization had been made by a pope.
Pope John XV (XVI) (Catholic Encyclopedia) · Catholic Encyclopedia (about 1910), Pope John XV (XVI)

Why it matters

It's the first step from a local judgement to a judgement for the whole Church.

Catholics see it as natural growth: a saint honoured everywhere should be confirmed by someone who speaks for everyone. The Orthodox see a step towards central control that they never needed.

1159-1181Historical1 min read

Miracles are not enough

Pope Alexander III

In the late 1100s some people began honouring as a saint a man who had been killed while drunk. Pope Alexander III told them to stop. Even if miracles happened, he wrote, they needed Rome's authority first.

IWhat was going on

Alexander III, pope from 1159 to 1181, spent much of his reign in conflict with the German emperor Frederick Barbarossa.

He was also building up the Church's system of law. Bishops across Europe wrote to Rome with hard cases. His answers, called decretals, became rulings for everyone.

IIWhat was at stake

Popular devotion could grow around almost anyone. In one case reported to him, people had begun to honour as a saint a man who had been killed while drunk.

If reports of miracles were enough to make a saint, then anyone with keen supporters could become one.

IIIWhat happened

Alexander wrote that they must not presume to honour the man. Even if miracles were worked through him, that would not let them revere him as a saint without the authority of the Roman Church.

Alexander himself canonised Thomas Becket in 1173. Becket was the archbishop of Canterbury, murdered in his own cathedral.

IVWhat came of it

Theologians still disagree over whether Alexander made new law or confirmed an old custom.

Either way, in 1234 his ruling went into the Church's lawbook, the Decretals of Pope Gregory IX. From then on, declaring a saint was reserved to the pope: no one else could do it.

VRead the source
For the future you will not presume to pay him reverence, as, even though miracles were worked through him, it would not allow you to revere him as a saint unless with the authority of the Roman Church
Beatification and Canonization (Catholic Encyclopedia) · Catholic Encyclopedia (about 1907), Beatification and Canonization, History, quoting the decretal of Alexander III

Why it matters

Miracles are not enough. A person's life has to be examined too.

That principle is still at the heart of the process. The Catholic Church asks first whether someone lived the Christian life heroically, and only then looks at the signs.

1233Historical2 min read

Witnesses sworn in 1233, a saint in 2012

Investigators sent by Pope Gregory IX

In 1233 investigators sent by the pope took sworn evidence at the German monastery of Hildegard of Bingen. Her inquiry never finished. Only in 2012 was she declared a saint for the whole Church.

IWhat was going on

Hildegard of Bingen was a German abbess, the head of a community of Benedictine nuns. She died in 1179.

She was a mystic who recorded her visions, and a composer whose music is still sung today. She wrote on medicine and nature, and she preached and wrote to popes and emperors.

After her death, people near her monastery honoured her as a saint and reported miracles at her tomb.

IIWhat was at stake

By then, declaring a saint was reserved to the pope, and a pope needed evidence.

So a formal inquiry had to be made. Witnesses had to be found, questioned and recorded, and the record sent to Rome.

IIIWhat happened

Under Pope Gregory IX, investigators went to Hildegard's monastery in 1233. They took evidence on oath from her nuns and others, about her life, her reputation for holiness and her miracles.

The papers went to Rome and were sent back for more work. Three later popes, Innocent IV, Clement V and John XXII, ordered or repeated inquiries. None of them finished.

IVWhat came of it

Hildegard was never formally canonised in the Middle Ages. But her name went into the Roman Martyrology, the Church's official list of saints, and a few German dioceses kept her feast day.

On 10 May 2012 Pope Benedict XVI extended her feast to the whole Church. This is called an equivalent canonisation: recognising a long-standing devotion instead of running a new process.

That October he also named her a Doctor of the Church, a saint whose teaching the whole Church learns from.

VRead the source
Gregory IX (1227-41) and Innocent IV (1243-54) ordered a process of information which was repeated by Clement V (1305-14) and John XXII (1316-34). No formal canonization has ever taken place, but her name is in the Roman Martyrology
St. Hildegard (Catholic Encyclopedia) · Catholic Encyclopedia (about 1910), St. Hildegard

Why it matters

Even a famous, holy person can wait centuries if the paperwork stalls. The process isn't a fast track for the popular.

Hildegard's case also shows a second route the Catholic Church still uses: confirming what generations of believers have already done.

1726Historical2 min read

The official objector says no, twice

Prospero Lambertini, Promoter of the Faith

In 1726 Prospero Lambertini, whose job in Rome was to find the weak points in every case for a saint, rejected five claimed cures in one case. It was the second time he had turned them down.

Painted portrait of Cardinal Prospero Lambertini in red robes and a white lace rochet, seated at a desk covered with open books, a pen in his hand.
Cardinal Prospero Lambertini, later Pope Benedict XIV, at his books. Portrait by Giuseppe Maria Crespi.
IWhat was going on

In 1588 Pope Sixtus V set up the Congregation of Rites, a Roman office that handled causes, the cases for declaring someone a saint.

In these causes an official called the Promoter of the Faith argued against each one, looking for flaws in the evidence. People nicknamed him the devil's advocate.

In the 1620s and 1630s Pope Urban VIII also forbade any public honour to a person before Rome's verdict. Causes now ran like a court case.

IIWhat was at stake

Every cause needed miracles, usually healings. But how do you tell a miracle from a sudden recovery that doctors simply can't explain yet?

If Rome accepted every surprising cure, the miracles would prove nothing.

IIIWhat happened

Prospero Lambertini, a church lawyer from Bologna, was Promoter of the Faith from 1708, for about twenty years.

One cause was for Fourier, a priest from Lorraine, in eastern France. He had founded a teaching order of nuns. In 1726 Lambertini rejected five proposed cures for the second time.

A cure being sudden and complete, he argued, did not prove it was a miracle.

IVWhat came of it

Fourier was beatified, declared Blessed, in 1730. That is the step before sainthood. He was canonised much later, by Pope Leo XIII in 1897.

Lambertini wrote a huge book on how to beatify and canonise saints. It governed causes for almost two centuries. In 1740 he was elected pope, as Benedict XIV.

VRead the source
It happened in the novae animadversiones (1726) of Peter Fourier's beatification process.... Here Lambertini, as Promoter of the Faith, after having denied for the second time the miraculous nature of five cures, concludes by saying that none of the cures exceeded the power of angels, since all the alleged miracles were just sudden and instantaneous cures, as a result of which they could not be classified as miracles.
Revising the Supernatural: Prospero Lambertini's Reconsideration of the Concept of Miracle · Alessandro Laverda, "Revising the Supernatural", Church History 90 (2021), section III

Why it matters

The Catholic Church built skepticism into the process on purpose, with a senior official paid to say no.

Lambertini's caution about miracles also shaped today's rule. Doctors are asked only whether science can explain a healing. Theologians decide the rest.

1914-1925Historical2 min read

Twenty-eight years under the old rules

Thérèse of Lisieux, and three popes

Thérèse of Lisieux, a young French nun, died in 1897, aged twenty-four. Her life story spread around the world. Under the old, slow rules, she was declared a saint twenty-eight years later, in 1925.

Old printed photograph of the nave of St Peter's Basilica lit with chandeliers and packed with people, as a banner of Thérèse of Lisieux is carried up the central aisle towards the altar.
The banner of Thérèse of Lisieux carried into St Peter's on the day of her canonisation, 17 May 1925.
IWhat was going on

Thérèse Martin entered the Carmel of Lisieux, in Normandy, at fifteen. It was a convent of Carmelite nuns who lived shut away from the world. She died of tuberculosis at twenty-four.

She was unknown outside her convent. Then her autobiography, Story of a Soul, was published the year after her death, and it spread around the world.

IIWhat was at stake

Her holiness was hidden and ordinary: small acts of love done for God, which she called her little way. There were no great deeds to point to.

Could the Catholic Church's slow, legal process recognise a saint like that? And would it hurry for anyone?

IIIWhat happened

Letters poured into Lisieux from people who said they'd been helped by her prayers. Pope John Paul II later called the response to her life quick, universal and constant.

Pope Pius X formally opened her cause, the case for making her a saint, on 10 June 1914. Benedict XV declared her virtues heroic in 1921.

Pius XI beatified her, declaring her Blessed, in 1923. He canonised her before an immense crowd in St Peter's on 17 May 1925.

IVWhat came of it

Pius XI named her patron of the missions, the Church's work of spreading the faith abroad, in 1927. She had never left her convent.

In 1997 John Paul II declared her a Doctor of the Church, a saint whose teaching the whole Church learns from. She was the youngest ever named.

VRead the source
on 10 June 1914 Pius X signed the decree introducing her cause of beatification; on 14 August 1921 Benedict XV declared the heroic virtues of the Servant of God, giving an address for the occasion on the way of spiritual childhood; and Pius XI proclaimed her blessed on 29 April 1923. Shortly afterwards, on 17 May 1925, the same Pope canonized her before an immense crowd in St Peter's Basilica
Divini Amoris Scientia (19 October 1997) · John Paul II, Divini Amoris Scientia (19 October 1997), 2

Why it matters

Speed didn't begin in 1983. A worldwide reputation for holiness moved even the old system.

And the Church declared that an unknown nun's ordinary life of love was as heroic as any martyr's.

1922-2002Historical2 min read

Investigated as a problem, canonised as a saint

Padre Pio and the Vatican's Holy Office

Padre Pio was an Italian friar who drew crowds. From 1922 Rome investigated him as a problem and restricted him for years. After he died in 1968, the Church examined his life again, and canonised him in 2002.

Black and white photograph of a bearded young Capuchin friar in a hooded habit, arms folded, with dark marks visible on the backs of both hands.
Padre Pio in 1919, showing the marks on his hands that the Holy Office later investigated. Photograph by Placido Bux.
IWhat was going on

Padre Pio, born Francesco Forgione in southern Italy in 1887, was a Capuchin friar, a member of a strict branch of the Franciscans. From 1916 he lived at San Giovanni Rotondo.

On 20 September 1918 he received the stigmata, wounds like Christ's on his hands, feet and side. Crowds began to come, and stories of healings and visions spread.

IIWhat was at stake

The Catholic Church is cautious about such reports. They can be holy, or they can be illness, fraud or mass hysteria. And crowds around a living man can turn into a cult.

The Holy Office, the Vatican department that guards Catholic teaching, had to decide what to make of him.

IIIWhat happened

Between 1922 and 1923 the Holy Office said it could not establish anything supernatural. It ordered him not to answer letters, and not to say , the Catholic Church's main service, in public.

In 1931 he was barred from all ministry. For two years he could say Mass only privately, inside the friary, and could not hear confessions, the work that had filled his days. A man crowds had travelled to see now prayed behind a closed door.

The restrictions came and went. In 1933 he could say Mass in public again, and the next year hear confessions. Only in 1964 was he told he could freely carry out his work as a priest again.

IVWhat came of it

Through all of it he obeyed. He spent long hours hearing confessions, where Catholics tell a priest their and receive God's forgiveness. He founded a hospital, the House for the Relief of Suffering, which opened in 1956.

He died on 23 September 1968. His cause was opened and two healings were approved. Pope John Paul II beatified him in 1999 and canonised him on 16 June 2002.

VRead the source
Between 1922 and 1923 he was the object of the first measures taken by the Holy Office. It declared that it did not ascertain any “supernatural character of the facts” and imposed on the friar not to celebrate Mass in public and not to answer letters sent him – either personally or through others.
Saint Pio da Pietralcina, Capuchin priest · Felice Accrocca, Saint Pio da Pietralcina (Capuchin Order, from Sulle orme dei santi, 2000)

Why it matters

The same Church that held him at arm's length later declared him a saint. The process can change its mind, after a proper look.

Its verdict wasn't about the stigmata. It was about his life: his prayer, his obedience under restrictions, and his care for the suffering.

25 January 1983Historical2 min read

A simpler process, on purpose

Pope John Paul II and his 1983 law

In 1983 Pope John Paul II rewrote the Catholic Church's law on how saints are declared. He made the process simpler on purpose. Critics say it lost its strongest check.

IWhat was going on

By the 1980s causes, the cases for making someone a saint, could take decades and cost a great deal.

Most saints came from Europe and from religious orders, communities of monks, nuns and friars. They could afford long cases in Rome.

John Paul II wanted the Church to recognise more holy people from more places, including lay people and local Churches far from Rome.

IIWhat was at stake

Bishops around the world had asked for a simpler process. But a simpler process might also be a weaker one.

The question was how to speed things up without making the verdict less trustworthy.

IIIWhat happened

On 25 January 1983 John Paul II issued a law called Divinus Perfectionis Magister. Bishops now gather the evidence in their own dioceses.

In Rome a relator, an official given the cause, writes a critical history of each candidate. It tests the sources; it isn't a tribute. Theologians, with historians where needed, vote on it.

The Promoter of the Faith, the official objector, now chairs the theologians' meeting. He no longer contests the cause at every stage. The number of miracles needed was also reduced.

IVWhat came of it

Causes moved much faster. John Paul II canonised 482 saints.

In 2016 Rome tightened the rules on money, after reports that funds for causes were barely supervised.

VRead the source
Most recent experience, finally, has shown us the appropriateness of revising further the manner of instructing causes and of so structuring the Congregation for the Causes of Saints that we might meet the needs of experts and the desires of Our Brother Bishops, who have often called for a simpler process while maintaining the soundness of the investigation in matter of such great import.
Divinus Perfectionis Magister (25 January 1983) · Divinus Perfectionis Magister (25 January 1983), preamble

Why it matters

The 1983 law swapped a courtroom for a historian's study. Supporters say that's a better way to find the truth about a life.

Critics answer that the simpler process lost its strongest check: the official who argued against every cause. Both views are set out below.

2005-2014Historical2 min read

Sainthood now, and a doubted miracle

John Paul II's own cause

When Pope John Paul II died in 2005, the crowd at his funeral chanted Santo subito, sainthood now. His own cause was fast-tracked, and he was canonised nine years later, in 2014.

The façade of St Peter's Basilica hung with large portraits of John Paul II and John XXIII, while the canonisation Mass is celebrated on the steps below.
Tapestries of John Paul II and John XXIII on St Peter's during their canonisation Mass, 27 April 2014.
IWhat was going on

John Paul II died on 2 April 2005 after almost twenty-seven years as pope. Millions came to Rome for his funeral.

The rules require a five-year wait after death before a cause can open. It lets enthusiasm cool and gives time for a sober look.

IIWhat was at stake

The crowd wanted him declared a saint at once. Benedict XVI, his successor and close colleague, had to decide whether to bend the rule for him.

Any shortcut would let critics say the Church was making saints of its own.

IIIWhat happened

Within weeks, on 9 May 2005, Benedict XVI waived the five-year wait so the cause could begin immediately.

The first healing put forward was a French nun's recovery from Parkinson's disease. It was publicly doubted in 2010. The Vatican's board of doctors still judged that science could not explain it.

He was beatified, declared Blessed, on 1 May 2011.

IVWhat came of it

The second miracle was a Costa Rican woman's recovery from a brain aneurysm, on the day of his beatification. He was canonised on 27 April 2014, together with Pope John XXIII.

In 2020 a report by the Holy See, the pope's central government, found that he had trusted Theodore McCarrick. He believed McCarrick's denials and promoted him.

McCarrick, an American cardinal, was found guilty of abuse by a Vatican process in 2019 and dismissed from the priesthood. He died in 2025.

VRead the source
has dispensed the five-year waiting period following the death of the Servant of God John Paul II (Karol Wojtyła), Supreme Pontiff, so that the cause of Beatification and Canonization of the same Servant of God can begin immediately.
Rescript on the cause of beatification and canonisation of John Paul II (9 May 2005) · Rescript of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints, 9 May 2005

Why it matters

Even the fastest cause still had a local inquiry, a decree on his virtues and two healings passed by doctors.

A canonisation says a person is in heaven and worth imitating. It isn't a verdict that every decision they made was right.

2006-2025Historical2 min read

A teenager, two healings and a postponed Mass

Carlo Acutis

Carlo Acutis, an Italian teenager, died of leukaemia in 2006, aged fifteen. After two healings were approved, Pope Leo XIV declared him a saint in Rome in September 2025. The date had been postponed when Pope Francis died.

IWhat was going on

Carlo Acutis was born in London in 1991 and grew up in Milan. He loved computers. He spent hours in prayer before the , the bread that Catholics believe is Jesus himself.

He built a website and an exhibition on about 136 Eucharistic miracles, the same stories examined in another chapter here. In October 2006 he fell ill with an aggressive leukaemia, and he died in Monza, near Milan, aged fifteen.

IIWhat was at stake

Could a modern teenager, with an ordinary life cut short, be shown to have lived the Christian virtues heroically?

And would the healings claimed through his prayers stand up to the doctors?

IIIWhat happened

His cause opened in Milan in 2013. In 2018 he was declared Venerable, recognised as having lived heroic virtue.

A small Brazilian boy, Matheus Lins Vianna, recovered from a severe malformation of the pancreas after prayers before Carlo's picture. That healing led to Carlo's beatification, the step before sainthood, at Assisi in 2020.

A Costa Rican student's recovery from a severe head injury was approved as the second miracle in 2024.

IVWhat came of it

His canonisation was set for 27 April 2025. Pope Francis died six days earlier, and it was postponed.

On 7 September 2025 Pope Leo XIV canonised him in St Peter's Square. Pier Giorgio Frassati, a young Italian who died in 1925, was canonised with him.

VRead the source
The first occurred in 2010 in Campo Grande, when Matheus Lins Vianna—then 6 years old—was healed of a severe pancreatic malformation after prayers before an image of Carlo in the Chapel of São Sebastião.
Faithful in Brazil venerate relic of Carlo Acutis in Campo Grande · Vatican News, September 2025

Why it matters

Carlo is often called the first millennial saint. Many pilgrims, a lot of them young, visit his tomb in Assisi.

His cause also shows the modern process at work: an inquiry, a decree on his virtues, two healings judged by doctors and theologians, and a pope's decision last.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church doesn't claim to make saints. It claims to recognise them.

The , the Church's official summary of teaching, says that by canonising some believers the Church holds them up as models and as people who pray for us.

The formula the pope uses declares that a person is a saint, to be honoured by the whole Church.

Holiness is God's work; the process only asks whether the Church can be sure of it. That's why it is built like an investigation, not an award.

The procedure grew because unchecked devotion went wrong. In Carthage a church official rebuked a woman for honouring a martyr the church hadn't confirmed. Pope Alexander III stopped people honouring a man killed while drunk.

Pope Urban VIII forbade public honour before a verdict, and that rule still binds every bishop.

In 1531 a Lutheran defence of their faith, the Apology, complained that nobody searched the saints' lives for true accounts. Since 1983 Catholic law has required exactly that: a critical history of each candidate, checked by theologians and, where needed, by historians.

Miracles are the part outsiders find hardest. On the Catholic view a miracle is God's own confirmation, a sign no committee can manufacture. So the Church doesn't rely only on its own reading of a person's heart.

The medical and religious questions are kept apart. Doctors, who may include non-believers, say only whether science can explain a healing. Theologians then ask whether it followed prayer to this person.

A skeptic will rightly say that unexplained is not the same as supernatural. Medicine has explained many things it once couldn't. The Catholic Church agrees that the step isn't a scientific one.

What it adds is the setting. A sudden, complete and lasting cure, of a serious illness, right after people asked one particular person to pray for it, is read as a sign pointing to that person. That is a judgement of faith made on evidence, and the Church says so; it doesn't claim the doctors proved it.

Martyrs need no miracle to be beatified, the step before sainthood, because their death is the evidence.

On speed, the Catholic answer is that the core requirements survived even in the fastest cause.

John Paul II's cause still needed a local inquiry and a decree on his virtues. It also needed two healings passed by the Vatican's board of doctors, the second one unanimously.

Under the old rules Thérèse of Lisieux was canonised within twenty-eight years, while Hildegard waited more than eight centuries.

The 1983 law kept the Promoter of the Faith, the official objector. The Dicastery, the Vatican office for causes, says he's still commonly known as the devil's advocate. What changed was the method: a critical history instead of a courtroom.

A canonisation says two things: this person is in heaven, and this life is worth imitating. It doesn't say that every decision was wise.

The Vatican's office for treats canonisations as truths to be held definitively, settled for good. But this has never been defined as a , a formally declared article of faith.

John Paul II trusted Theodore McCarrick, a cardinal later dismissed from the priesthood for abuse. He believed McCarrick's denial, and the Holy See's own report says so. The Catholic claim is that a saint can misjudge people and still have loved God heroically.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

For the first thousand years, the in America writes, saints were recognised without any formal ceremony. Local churches remembered them, asked for their prayers and visited their , their bodily remains.

No Orthodox Church built a procedure as detailed and legal as Rome's, and the Orthodox tradition sees one as undesirable. Canonisation, in its words, doesn't make anybody a saint. It recognises that someone already was one.

Today a request goes through the bishop, a commission studies the life, and the Holy Synod, the Church's of bishops, decides.

Miracles may prompt a glorification, the Orthodox word for canonisation, but they aren't required. Holiness of life and sound teaching are.

Anglican

Anglicans, the Church of England and its sister churches, honour saints and heroes of the faith through their churches' calendars of feast days.

In 1958 the Lambeth Conference, the gathering of Anglican bishops from around the world, made a request. Only people whose historical character and devotion are beyond doubt should be remembered.

Controversial names should wait until history puts them in perspective. A new name should come from a widespread wish in a region over a reasonable length of time.

Each province, a national or regional Anglican church, revises its own calendar through the body that revises its prayer book.

Lutheran

The Apology of the , written in 1531 to defend the Lutherans' founding statement of faith, approves three ways of honouring the saints. Thank God for them. Be strengthened in faith by their example. Imitate their faith and virtues.

It rejects invoking them, asking them to pray for us, because Scripture gives no command, promise or example of it.

It also complains that the saints' lives had been filled with fables, while nobody searched out true accounts of what they actually did. On this view a church can remember holy people without any formal verdict on them.

A secular critic: Christopher Hitchens

The journalist Christopher Hitchens was interviewed as a witness in the cause of Mother Teresa of Calcutta. In 2003 he criticised the process itself.

The five-year wait, he wrote, had existed to guard against popular enthusiasm for dubious characters. It had been set aside for her.

He reported that the doctor of Monica Besra, whose healing was approved for Mother Teresa's beatification, said it came from prescription medicine. His own interview, he said, was a formality, a show of consulting doubters.

He quoted George Orwell: saints should be presumed guilty until proved innocent.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
The documents, laid out in order12 steps

The same ground with the documents on the table, in date order: the laws, the critics, the money and the mistakes.

  1. Rome builds an office for saints

    1588

    Pope Sixtus V set up the Congregation of Rites, a Roman office, and gave it the causes of saints.

    In 1634 Pope Urban VIII made beatification, declaring someone Blessed, a decision for Rome alone, as canonisation already was. His decrees forbade public honour to anyone before a verdict.

    That rule still binds. A bishop sending a cause to Rome today must attach a statement that Urban VIII's rules against early public honour were kept.

    “With the Constitution "Immensa Aeterni Dei" of January 22, 1588, Sixtus V created the Sacred Congregation of Rites and entrusted to it the task of regulating the exercise of divine worship and of dealing with the Causes of Saints.”
    HistoricalCongregation for the Causes of Saints: ProfileCongregation for the Causes of Saints, Profile (vatican.va)The evidence ↓
  2. Doctors enter the process

    1743

    Pope Benedict XIV, the former Promoter of the Faith, created a guild of doctors to examine claimed cures.

    His book on beatification and canonisation is dated 1734 to 1738, and he finished it while archbishop of Bologna. It served as the Congregation's rule book for almost two centuries.

    Today's medical board, the Vatican's panel of doctors, traces its history back to that guild. Its rules also claim that miracles were always examined with the strictest rigour. That is the Holy See's own assessment.

    “The miracle, required for the Beatification of Servants of God and for the Canonization of those Beatified, was always examined with the strictest rigor. Already in medieval times recourse was made to Medical Experts for whom on September 17, 1743 Benedict XIV created a specific Guild.”
    HistoricalRegulations of the Medical Board of the Congregation for the Causes of SaintsRegulations of the Medical Board of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints (2016), preambleThe evidence ↓
  3. The old courtroom

    1907

    The Catholic Encyclopedia, a reference work of about 1907, describes the process before the reform. The Promoter of the Faith filed written objections at each stage, and the cause's advocate had to answer them.

    A candidate who wasn't a martyr needed at least two proved miracles for beatification, and more if the witnesses were weaker. Canonisation needed two more. For martyrs the rules on miracles were looser.

    The article admits that causes took a very long time.

    “In each case, before proceeding to the subsequent meeting, a majority of the consultors must decide that the difficulties of the promotor of the Faith have been satisfactorily solved.”
    HistoricalBeatification and Canonization (Catholic Encyclopedia)Catholic Encyclopedia (about 1907), Beatification and Canonization, The beatification of confessorsThe evidence ↓
  4. The objector's new job

    1983

    Under the 1983 law the Promoter of the Faith is also called the Prelate Theologian. He chairs the theologians' meeting, with a vote, and writes its report. He attends the meeting of cardinals and bishops without a vote.

    He is no longer the lone opponent of the whole cause.

    The journalist John L. Allen Jr. summed up the reform as quicker, cheaper and less of a contest between two sides, with fewer miracles required.

    “The Sacred Congregation is to have one Promotor of the Faith or Prelate Theologian. His responsibility is: 1. to preside over the meeting of the theologians, with the right to vote; 2. to prepare the report on the meeting itself; 3. to be present as an expert at the meeting of the Cardinals and Bishops, although without the right to vote.”
    HistoricalDivinus Perfectionis Magister (25 January 1983)Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), II, 10The evidence ↓
  5. Definitive, but not a dogma

    1998

    Whether a canonisation can be mistaken has never been settled by a solemn definition.

    In 1998 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office that guards Catholic teaching, issued a commentary signed by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger.

    It gave canonisations as an example of truths to be held definitively, as settled for good, though not declared revealed by God.

    It said Catholics owe these truths the same full and final acceptance as truths God has revealed. Only the reason for it is different.

    The author of the 1907 Catholic Encyclopedia article held that only one thing is defined: that the saint is in heaven.

    “With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the Supreme Pontiff or of the celebration of an ecumenical council, the canonizations of saints (dogmatic facts)”
    InferenceDoctrinal Commentary on the concluding formula of the Professio fideiCongregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the concluding formula of the Professio fidei (29 June 1998), 11The evidence ↓
  6. Witnesses against, by rule

    2007

    Sanctorum Mater is the 2007 instruction for bishops' inquiries. It requires the postulator, the person who presents the cause, to name witnesses who could cast doubt on the candidate's reputation.

    The life submitted must not leave out what tells against the cause, and damaging discoveries must not be hidden. Any celebration suggesting the outcome is certain is forbidden.

    The journalist Christopher Hitchens, called to give evidence about Mother Teresa, said his own interview was a formality.

    “a list of the persons who can contribute to ascertaining the truth on the virtues or the martyrdom of the Servant of God, as well as on the reputation of holiness or of martyrdom, and on the reputation of intercessory power, not omitting those who could call such a reputation into question”
  7. One miracle short, by papal decision

    2014

    Pope Francis canonised John XXIII with one approved miracle instead of two.

    The Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, today's Vatican office for causes, calls this a particular decision a pope may always take. It rests on a reputation for holiness spread over decades.

    John Thavis, a longtime Vatican watcher, called it an ancient practice, though a controversial one among the Vatican's saint-makers.

    Francis also waived the second miracle for the Jesuit priest Peter Faber, whose cause had waited since 1872. Rules that can be waived are a point of pressure.

    ““But Francis was actually using an ancient practice when he waived the second miracle requirement for John XXIII, recognizing that the faithful already know him to be a saint.””
    HistoricalJohn Paul II and John XXIII: Rush to Sainthood?Josephine McKenna, Religion News Service, 22 April 2014, quoting John ThavisThe evidence ↓
  8. The critic's case

    2014

    Kenneth Woodward was religion editor of Newsweek for 38 years. He argued that the 1983 reform removed the check that mattered.

    Without the devil's advocate as an opponent, he said, everyone involved had a reason to want a yes. And because the process is secret, nobody outside could tell.

    In 2020, after the McCarrick report, he called John Paul II's canonisation much too hasty, but his place among the saints secure.

    The Dicastery, for its part, says the Promoter of the Faith still exists to pick holes in testimony and documents.

    ““Everyone involved in a canonization process now has a stake in its positive outcome,” Woodward said. He said that could result in the process being manipulated and an unworthy candidate canonized. “Without the devil’s advocate, who can prevent such an outcome? And without some means of making the process public, who would know?””
    Historical2 popular popes fast-tracked to sainthoodNicole Winfield, Associated Press, 25 April 2014 (Seattle Times)The evidence ↓
  9. Five votes out of seven

    2016

    New rules for the medical board raised the bar. First, two doctors report on the case separately. If both say no, the postulator may ask for a third. If that one also says no, the case stops.

    The seven-member board then needs at least five votes to call a healing beyond what science can explain. A case that fails three times can never return.

    The doctors may have no contact with the people promoting the cause. The meetings are secret, so outsiders can't check the reasoning.

    “The case may proceed further if the conclusions of the meeting of the Medical Board are affirmative with a qualified majority of at least five out of seven Experts or of four out of six Experts present at the same meeting.”
    HistoricalRegulations of the Medical Board of the Congregation for the Causes of SaintsRegulations of the Medical Board (24 August 2016), art. 15The evidence ↓
  10. Following the money

    2016

    A commission set up by Pope Francis in 2013 found little or no oversight of the money raised for causes. Some 400 postulators' accounts at the Vatican bank were frozen.

    Gerard O'Connell of America, a Jesuit magazine, reported something known in Rome under John Paul II: money had been an important factor in advancing some causes.

    Rules approved on 4 March 2016, for a three-year trial, require each cause to keep a fund. A bishop or the head of a religious order checks its yearly budgets. A solidarity fund helps causes that cannot pay their way.

    “In early August 2013, Francis received alarming reports from the commission on this matter, and he immediately ordered the blocking of some 400 accounts of the postulators of the causes of beatification and canonization held at the Institute for the Works of Religion (commonly called the Vatican Bank).”
  11. A third road to the altar

    2017

    Pope Francis added a new path to beatification: the offering of life. It sits beside the two older paths, martyrdom and a life of heroic virtue.

    It covers someone who freely accepted a certain and early death out of love for others, without being killed for the faith.

    It is not a shortcut. A miracle is still required for beatification. The person must also have practised the Christian virtues before the offering and until death.

    “The offer of life is a new cause for the beatification and canonization procedure, distinct from the causes based on martyrdom and on the heroism of virtues.”
    HistoricalMaiorem hac dilectionem, on the offer of life (11 July 2017)Francis, Maiorem hac dilectionem (11 July 2017), art. 1The evidence ↓
  12. The Holy See on a saint's mistake

    2020

    Six years after John Paul II's canonisation, the Holy See, the pope's central government, published its report on Theodore McCarrick.

    Three times the Holy See had judged it unwise to move him to another diocese. Then John Paul II, who had been told of the allegations, personally chose him for Washington in 2000.

    Why did he choose him? The report gives several likely reasons. Three of four American bishops had given inaccurate information. McCarrick had written a denial. And the Pope had his own experience of false accusations in Poland.

    McCarrick was later dismissed from the clerical state, removed from the priesthood.

    “Archbishop McCarrick was appointed to Washington in late 2000 and created cardinal in early 2001. The evidence shows that Pope John Paul II personally made the decision to appoint McCarrick and did so after receiving the counsel of several trusted advisors on both sides of the Atlantic.”
    HistoricalReport on the Holy See's Institutional Knowledge and Decision-Making Related to Former Cardinal Theodore Edgar McCarrick (1930 to 2017)Secretariat of State, Report on the Holy See's institutional knowledge and decision-making related to former Cardinal Theodore Edgar McCarrick (10 November 2020), Executive Summary 2.bThe evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on12 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

For roughly the first thousand years there was no central process for recognising a saint. The local bishop judged whether a martyr had truly died for the faith and allowed the cult, and neighbouring churches could adopt it. Optatus of Milevis records that a Carthaginian woman, Lucilla, was rebuked shortly before a persecution, around AD 300, for kissing the bone of a man not yet acknowledged as a martyr, which shows a local check already at work.

Rests on
  • Against the Donatists, Book I, 16 (O. R. Vassall-Phillips translation, 1917, p. 32)
    “It was said that she kissed a bone of some martyr or other—if he was a martyr—before she received the spiritual Food and Drink. Having then been corrected for thus touching—before she touched the Sacred Chalice—the bone of a dead man (if he was a martyr, at least he had not yet been acknowledged as such)”
  • Translator's note 141.2 to Book I, 16 (Vassall-Phillips, 1917)
    “Catholics in Africa were strictly forbidden to honour with religious worship any martyrs who had not been recognised as such (id est canonised = vindicati).”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
    “The decision as to the martyr having died for his faith in Christ, and the consequent permission of worship, lay originally with the bishop of the place in which he had borne his testimony.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
    “St. Optatus of Mileve, writing at the end of the fourth century, tells us (De Schism, Donat., I, xvi, in P.L., XI, 916-917) of a certain noble lady, Lucilla, who was reprehended by Caecilianus, Archdeacon of Carthage, for having kissed before Holy …”
    Read the full passage
    “St. Optatus of Mileve, writing at the end of the fourth century, tells us (De Schism, Donat., I, xvi, in P.L., XI, 916-917) of a certain noble lady, Lucilla, who was reprehended by Caecilianus, Archdeacon of Carthage, for having kissed before Holy Communion the bones of one who was either not a martyr or whose right to the title was unproved.”
  • Canonization (Orthodox Church in America, from the 1970 book for the canonisation of St Herman of Alaska)
    “For the first thousand years of the history of the Church saints were recognized without any formal rite of canonization.”
Other readings
  • Orthodox writers read the same early evidence as showing that recognition by the faithful was itself the canonisation, and regard the later Roman procedure as a legal overlay that the East never needed.
  • A skeptical reader can take the Lucilla story as a quarrel about church politics, since Optatus tells it to blame her for starting the Donatist schism.
Limits
  • Optatus was writing against the Donatists and presents Lucilla as the villain of their schism, so the story is told by a hostile witness.
  • The date is approximate: Optatus places the rebuke before the persecution that followed, not in a given year.
  • One anecdote shows that a check existed in Carthage; it does not show how every church handled its martyrs.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The first canonisation by a pope in the sources is that of Ulrich of Augsburg, declared a saint at a Roman synod on 31 January 993 under John XV. Alexander III (pope 1159-1181) forbade the veneration of a man killed while drunk, even if miracles were reported, without the authority of the Roman Church, and his ruling passed into the Decretals that Gregory IX made law in 1234. Sixtus V gave the causes of saints to his new Congregation of Rites on 22 January 1588, and Urban VIII in 1634 reserved beatification, as well as canonisation, to the Holy See.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), Pope John XV (XVI)
    “At a Roman synod held in the Lateran on 31 January, 993, Bishop Ulrich of Augsburg was solemnly canonized, an event which the pope announced to the French and German bishops in a Bull dated 3 February. This was the first time that a solemn canonization had been made by a pope.”
  • Canonization (Orthodox Church in America, 1970)
    “In the 10th century, in the west, the then-Orthodox Church of Rome began to insist that saints be formally and officially “registered” as such with the Roman authorities. The first recorded canonization of this type was that of Ulrich of Augsburg, canonized in 993 by John XV.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), St. Ulrich
    “As morning dawned on 4 July, 973, Ulrich had ashes strewn on the ground in the shape of a cross; the cross sprinkled with holy water, and he was placed upon it. His nephew Richwin came with a message and greeting from the Emperor Otto II as the sun rose, and immediately upon this, while the clergy sang the Litany, St. Ulrich passed away.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History; the decretal is cited there as c. i, X. III, xlv
    “For the future you will not presume to pay him reverence, as, even though miracles were worked through him, it would not allow you to revere him as a saint unless with the authority of the Roman Church”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
    “Theologians do not agree as to the full import of this decretal. Either a new law was made (Bellarmine, De Eccles. Triumph., I, viii), in which case the pope then for the first time reserved the right of beatification, or a pre-existing law was confirmed.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), Corpus Juris Canonici
    “In 1230 Gregory IX ordered St. Raymund of Pennafort to make a new collection, which is called the "Decretals of Gregory IX" (Decretales Gregorii IX). To this collection he gave force of law by the Bull "Rex pacificus", 5 Sept., 1234.”
  • Congregation for the Causes of Saints, Profile (vatican.va)
    “With the Constitution "Immensa Aeterni Dei" of January 22, 1588, Sixtus V created the Sacred Congregation of Rites and entrusted to it the task of regulating the exercise of divine worship and of dealing with the Causes of Saints.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
    “Urban VIII published, in 1634, a Bull which put an end to all discussion by reserving to the Holy See exclusively not only its immemorial right of canonization, but also that of beatification.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, The beatification of confessors
    “Processes de non cultu are instituted to prove that the decrees of Urban VIII regarding the prohibition of public worship of servants of God before their beatification have been obeyed”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), I, 2.6
    “Furthermore, the Bishop is to attach a declaration on the observance of the decrees of Urban VIII regarding the absence of cult.”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox Church in America's account accepts the same starting point, Ulrich in 993, and describes what followed as the West developing a very legalistic method that no Orthodox Church wished to copy.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that theologians disagree whether Alexander III made new law or confirmed an older one.
Limits
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia articles date from about 1907 to 1912.
  • The link between Alexander III's letter and the Decretals of Gregory IX rests on the Catholic Encyclopedia's citation of the letter in that collection.
  • The sources do not say which earlier papal acts, if any, historians have proposed as papal canonisations before 993.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Medieval canonisation was already an inquiry on oath, and it could stall for centuries. In 1233, by papal mandate under Gregory IX, commissioners went to Hildegard of Bingen's monastery and took sworn testimony on her life, reputation, merits and miracles. Inquiries under Gregory IX, Innocent IV, Clement V and John XXII never produced a canonisation. On 10 May 2012 Benedict XVI extended her cult to the whole Church by equivalent canonisation, and on 7 October 2012 he declared her a Doctor of the Church.

Rests on
  • Acta inquisitionis (1233), section 1 (Migne edition via la.wikisource.org)
    “Nos igitur hujus auctoritate mandati ad monasterium Sancti Ruperti personaliter accedentes, testes fide dignos recepimus, in hunc modum de vita, conversatione, fama, meritis et signis, ac aliis circumstantiis beatae Hildegardis”
  • Acta inquisitionis (1233), section 1: the first witness, the magistra Elsa, on oath
    “Magistra Sancti Ruperti in Pinguia, Elsa nomine, jurata”
  • Acta inquisitionis (1233), section 11, dating clause
    “Datum anno Domini millesimo ducentesimo tricesimo tertio”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), St. Hildegard
    “Gregory IX (1227-41) and Innocent IV (1243-54) ordered a process of information which was repeated by Clement V (1305-14) and John XXII (1316-34). No formal canonization has ever taken place, but her name is in the Roman Martyrology”
  • Catholic Culture news, reporting L'Osservatore Romano, May 2012
    “The Pope’s May 10 announcement was a case of “equivalent canonization,” the Vatican newspaper explained. The process was established in the 18th century by Pope Benedict XIV. It takes place “when the Pope enjoins the Church as a whole to observe the …”
    Read the full passage
    “The Pope’s May 10 announcement was a case of “equivalent canonization,” the Vatican newspaper explained. The process was established in the 18th century by Pope Benedict XIV. It takes place “when the Pope enjoins the Church as a whole to observe the veneration of a Servant of God not yet canonized by the insertion of his feast into the liturgical calendar of the universal Church, with Mass and the Divine Office.”
  • Benedict XVI, Apostolic Letter proclaiming St Hildegard a Doctor of the Church, 7 October 2012, section 7
    “I declare Saint John of Avila, diocesan priest, and Saint Hildegard of Bingen, professed nun of the Order of Saint Benedict, to be Doctors of the Universal Church.”
Other readings
  • A critic can read Hildegard's case as showing that the process depended on paperwork and papal attention more than on holiness, since her reputation never changed while the inquiry sat unfinished.
Limits
  • The 1233 record survives in a nineteenth-century printed edition (Migne) and is quoted from a digital transcription.
  • The sources give no reason why each medieval inquiry failed to finish.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Congregation of Rites had a Promoter of the Faith whose task was to raise objections to the evidence for a cause and its miracles. Prospero Lambertini held the office from 1708 for twenty years, and in 1726 he rejected, for the second time, five cures proposed in the cause of Peter Fourier. As archbishop of Bologna he completed De servorum Dei beatificatione (1734-1738), which served as the Congregation's rule for almost two centuries; as Pope Benedict XIV he set up a guild of medical experts on 17 September 1743. Under the rules described in 1907, a cause could not move to its next meeting until a majority of consultors judged the Promoter's objections answered.

Rests on
  • Alessandro Laverda, Church History 90 (2021), section III
    “In 1708, Lambertini was nominated Promoter of the Faith, a position which he held for twenty years.”
  • Laverda, Church History 90 (2021), section III
    “The task of the Promoter of the Faith was to supervise the inquiry into the virtues of the candidate for sainthood and the investigation into alleged miracles that occurred after his or her death. He raised critical issues about the reports made by …”
    Read the full passage
    “The task of the Promoter of the Faith was to supervise the inquiry into the virtues of the candidate for sainthood and the investigation into alleged miracles that occurred after his or her death. He raised critical issues about the reports made by the lawyer promoting the cause and by the medical experts, who had the role of understanding whether a supposed miracle had surpassed the forces of nature or not.”
  • Laverda, Church History 90 (2021), section III
    “It happened in the novae animadversiones (1726) of Peter Fourier's beatification process.... Here Lambertini, as Promoter of the Faith, after having denied for the second time the miraculous nature of five cures, concludes by saying that none of the …”
    Read the full passage
    “It happened in the novae animadversiones (1726) of Peter Fourier's beatification process.... Here Lambertini, as Promoter of the Faith, after having denied for the second time the miraculous nature of five cures, concludes by saying that none of the cures exceeded the power of angels, since all the alleged miracles were just sudden and instantaneous cures, as a result of which they could not be classified as miracles.”
  • Laverda, Church History 90 (2021), abstract
    “De servorum Dei beatificatione et beatorum canonizatione (On the Beatification of the Servants of God and the Canonization of the Blessed, 1734–1738)”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), preamble
    “Worthy of special mention are those of Urban VIII,(4) which Prosper Lambertini (later Benedict XIV), drawing upon the experiences of time past, handed down to later generations in a work entitled De Servorum Dei beatifιcatione et de Beatorum …”
    Read the full passage
    “Worthy of special mention are those of Urban VIII,(4) which Prosper Lambertini (later Benedict XIV), drawing upon the experiences of time past, handed down to later generations in a work entitled De Servorum Dei beatifιcatione et de Beatorum canonizatione. This work served as the rule of the Sacred Congregation of Rites for almost two centuries.”
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (2016), preamble
    “The miracle, required for the Beatification of Servants of God and for the Canonization of those Beatified, was always examined with the strictest rigor. Already in medieval times recourse was made to Medical Experts for whom on September 17, 1743 Benedict XIV created a specific Guild.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, Present procedure
    “In each case, before proceeding to the subsequent meeting, a majority of the consultors must decide that the difficulties of the promotor of the Faith have been satisfactorily solved.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), The beatification of confessors
    “The miracles now remain to be proved, of which two of the first class are required in case the practice of virtues in the heroic degree has been proved”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), The canonization of confessors or martyrs
    “The canonization of confessors or martyrs may be taken up as soon as two miracles are reported to have been worked at their intercession, after the pontifical permission of public veneration as described above.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Expenses
    “the canonization by Leo XIII, of Saints Anthony Maria Zaccaria and Peter Fourier”
Other readings
  • Laverda shows that Lambertini's objection in 1726 turned on a theological puzzle, whether angels could produce sudden cures, so the refusal was not purely medical skepticism.
Limits
  • The office is popularly called the devil's advocate; that nickname is not used in these sources for the eighteenth century.
  • Peter Fourier was later canonised, by Leo XIII, so Lambertini's refusal delayed the cause rather than ending it.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Thérèse of Lisieux died on 30 September 1897; Pius X introduced her cause on 10 June 1914, Benedict XV declared her virtues heroic on 14 August 1921, and Pius XI beatified her on 29 April 1923 and canonised her on 17 May 1925. Padre Pio was investigated first as a problem: in 1922-23 the Holy Office declared that it could not establish any supernatural character in the facts and forbade him to say Mass in public, with further restrictions in 1931 and 1960 before he was freed in 1964. After his death on 23 September 1968 the Holy See granted his cause its nihil obstat in 1982; his heroic virtue was decreed on 18 December 1997; two healings were approved; he was beatified on 2 May 1999 and canonised on 16 June 2002.

Rests on
  • Divini Amoris Scientia (19 October 1997), 2
    “on 10 June 1914 Pius X signed the decree introducing her cause of beatification; on 14 August 1921 Benedict XV declared the heroic virtues of the Servant of God, giving an address for the occasion on the way of spiritual childhood; and Pius XI …”
    Read the full passage
    “on 10 June 1914 Pius X signed the decree introducing her cause of beatification; on 14 August 1921 Benedict XV declared the heroic virtues of the Servant of God, giving an address for the occasion on the way of spiritual childhood; and Pius XI proclaimed her blessed on 29 April 1923. Shortly afterwards, on 17 May 1925, the same Pope canonized her before an immense crowd in St Peter's Basilica”
  • Divini Amoris Scientia (1997), 4
    “intensify to the moment of her death on the afternoon of 30 September 1897.”
  • Divini Amoris Scientia (1997), 2
    “The reception given to the example of her life and Gospel teaching in our century was quick, universal and constant.”
  • Saint Pio da Pietralcina (Capuchin Order, from Sulle orme dei santi, 2000)
    “Between 1922 and 1923 he was the object of the first measures taken by the Holy Office. It declared that it did not ascertain any “supernatural character of the facts” and imposed on the friar not to celebrate Mass in public and not to answer letters sent him – either personally or through others.”
  • Saint Pio da Pietralcina (Capuchin Order, 2000)
    “In 1931 he was not permitted to exercise any ministry at all, but could only celebrate Mass privately. However in 1933 he was permitted to celebrate Mass in public again and the following year his faculty to hear confessions was restored. In 1960 …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 1931 he was not permitted to exercise any ministry at all, but could only celebrate Mass privately. However in 1933 he was permitted to celebrate Mass in public again and the following year his faculty to hear confessions was restored. In 1960 another apostolic visit placed new restrictions of Padre Pio. However in 1964 Cardinal Ottaviani communicated that Padre Pio could freely exercise his ministry again.”
  • Padre Pio da Pietrelcina, biography (Holy See, for the canonisation of 16 June 2002)
    “Sister Death took him well-prepared and serene on 23 September 1968 at the age of eighty-one.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “After examining the case, the Holy See, in accordance with the norm of the Motu Proprio “Sanctitas Clarior”, granted the nihil obstat on 29 November 1982. The Archbishop of Manfredonia was thus enabled to introduce the Cause and set up the …”
    Read the full passage
    “After examining the case, the Holy See, in accordance with the norm of the Motu Proprio “Sanctitas Clarior”, granted the nihil obstat on 29 November 1982. The Archbishop of Manfredonia was thus enabled to introduce the Cause and set up the informative process (1983- 1990). On 7 December 1990, the Congregation for the Causes of Saints recognized its juridical validity.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “On 18 December 1997, in the presence of Pope John Paul II, the Decree on heroic virtue was promulgated.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “On 2 May 1999, in the course of a solemn concelebrated Mass in St Peter's Square, Pope John Paul II by his apostolic authority beatified the Venerable Servant of God Padre Pio of Pietrelcina, naming 23 September as the date of his liturgical feast.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “For the Beatification of Padre Pio, the Postulation presented to the competent Congregation the healing of Signora Consiglia De Martino of Salerno. The regular canonical process on this case was held at the Ecclesiastical Tribunal of the Archdiocese …”
    Read the full passage
    “For the Beatification of Padre Pio, the Postulation presented to the competent Congregation the healing of Signora Consiglia De Martino of Salerno. The regular canonical process on this case was held at the Ecclesiastical Tribunal of the Archdiocese of Salerno-Campagna-Acerno from July 1996 to June 1997. On 30 April 1998 at the Congregation for the Causes of Saints the Medical Board examined the miracle, and on 22 June 1998 the Special Meeting of Theological Consultors gave its judgement.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “For the canonization of Blessed Padre Pio of Pietrelcina the Postulation presented to the competent Dicastery the cure of the young Matteo Pio Colella of San Giovanni Rotondo.”
  • Padre Pio biography (Holy See, 2002)
    “Canonization (June 16, 2002)”
Other readings
  • Critics of Padre Pio, from the Holy Office's own visitors to the historian Sergio Luzzatto, read the early inquiries as a warning ignored; his defenders read his obedience under restriction as part of the evidence for his holiness.
Limits
  • The Capuchin account is written by his own order.
  • These sources give the dates of the decisions, not the reasoning of the Holy Office in the 1920s.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 25 January 1983 John Paul II's constitution Divinus Perfectionis Magister rebuilt the procedure. Bishops gather the evidence; in Rome a relator prepares a critical history of the candidate, the positio; and the Promoter of the Faith, also called the Prelate Theologian, chairs the theologians' vote rather than arguing against the cause at every stage. The constitution says bishops had asked for a simpler process that kept the investigation sound. Critics, among them the journalist Kenneth Woodward, argue that removing the adversarial exchange left everyone involved with a stake in a positive outcome; the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints still describes the Promoter of the Faith as the official who picks holes in the testimony and documents.

Rests on
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), preamble
    “Most recent experience, finally, has shown us the appropriateness of revising further the manner of instructing causes and of so structuring the Congregation for the Causes of Saints that we might meet the needs of experts and the desires of Our …”
    Read the full passage
    “Most recent experience, finally, has shown us the appropriateness of revising further the manner of instructing causes and of so structuring the Congregation for the Causes of Saints that we might meet the needs of experts and the desires of Our Brother Bishops, who have often called for a simpler process while maintaining the soundness of the investigation in matter of such great import.”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), II, 10
    “The Sacred Congregation is to have one Promotor of the Faith or Prelate Theologian. His responsibility is: 1. to preside over the meeting of the theologians, with the right to vote; 2. to prepare the report on the meeting itself; 3. to be present as an expert at the meeting of the Cardinals and Bishops, although without the right to vote.”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), III, 13.2
    “the Relator, then, together with a collaborator from outside the Congregation, will prepare the Position on virtues or on martyrdom according to the rules of critical hagiography.”
  • Congregation for the Causes of Saints, Profile (vatican.va)
    “The Apostolic Constitution "Divinus Perfectionis Magister" of January 25, 1983, and the respective "Normae servandae in inquisitionibus ab episcopis faciendis in causis sanctorum" of February 7, 1983, made possible both a profound reform in procedure for canonization causes and the restructuring of the congregation.”
  • John L. Allen Jr., Newsweek, 17 April 2011
    “In 1983, John Paul overhauled the sainthood process to make it quicker, cheaper, and less adversarial, eliminating the office of "Devil's advocate" and dropping the required number of miracles. His aim was to lift up contemporary role models of holiness in order to show a jaded secular world that sanctity is alive in the here and now.”
  • Nicole Winfield, Associated Press, 25 April 2014 (Seattle Times)
    ““Everyone involved in a canonization process now has a stake in its positive outcome,” Woodward said. He said that could result in the process being manipulated and an unworthy candidate canonized. “Without the devil’s advocate, who can prevent such an outcome? And without some means of making the process public, who would know?””
  • Kenneth L. Woodward, First Things, 27 November 2020
    “The practical effect, however, is that there is now no one involved in the process who does not have a vested interest, if only of his time, in its positive outcome.”
  • Kenneth L. Woodward, First Things, 27 November 2020
    “I also agree with critics who argue that John Paul II’s canonization was much too hasty.”
  • Kenneth L. Woodward, First Things, 27 November 2020
    “Saints are not perfect, but they must exhibit the virtues expected of a Christian to an extraordinary degree. John Paul II did that and his place in the canon of saints is secure.”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, I passi del cammino verso la santità: approfondimenti
    “Colui che è incaricato di “fare le pulci” a testimonianze e documenti è invece il Promotore della Fede (comunemente noto come “avvocato del diavolo”).”
Other readings
  • Woodward and John L. Allen Jr. describe the reform as making the process quicker, cheaper and less adversarial, and Allen links it directly to the number of saints John Paul II named.
  • The Holy See presents the reform as a move from a courtroom contest to a critical history judged by historians and theologians, with the bishops more closely involved.
  • Woodward himself, writing after the 2020 McCarrick report, judged John Paul II's canonisation much too hasty yet his place among the saints secure, and granted that there were good reasons for the reform.
Limits
  • The sources do not measure whether causes after 1983 were in fact weaker than causes before it.
  • Woodward's 2014 words are quoted as the Associated Press reported them; his 2020 words are from his own essay in First Things.
  • Allen, Woodward and Hitchens speak of the devil's advocate as eliminated or abolished. The 1983 constitution keeps the office, as Promoter of the Faith or Prelate Theologian, but changes its task from opposing the cause at every stage to chairing the theologians' vote.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

John Paul II died on 2 April 2005. In an audience on 28 April 2005 Benedict XVI dispensed the five-year wait, as a rescript dated 9 May 2005 records, and the diocesan inquiry opened on 28 June 2005. The first proposed miracle, the recovery of a French nun, Sister Marie Simon-Pierre, from Parkinson's disease, was questioned in public in 2010; the Medical Board judged it scientifically inexplicable on 21 October 2010, and he was beatified on 1 May 2011. The second, the disappearance of a Costa Rican woman's brain aneurysm on the day of the beatification, was approved unanimously by the Medical Board on 28 February 2013, and Francis canonised him with John XXIII on 27 April 2014. In November 2020 the Holy See's report on Theodore McCarrick found that the Holy See had three times judged it imprudent to transfer McCarrick, and that John Paul II then personally decided to appoint him to Washington in 2000, after the allegations against him had been summarised and shared with the Pope, and that McCarrick's written denial was believed. McCarrick was later found guilty of sexual misconduct with minors and adults and dismissed from the clerical state.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Critics, among them John L. Allen Jr. in 2011, argued that the speed of the cause left too little time to weigh John Paul II's handling of the abuse crisis.
  • The postulator, Monsignor Slawomir Oder, said in 2014 that a specific inquiry into the Maciel case found no sign of the Pope's personal involvement.
Limits
  • The McCarrick report was published six years after the canonisation, so the cause could not weigh it.
  • The report judges that the Pope's experience in Poland probably played a role while saying there is no direct evidence of it.
  • The 2010 doubt about the diagnosis was a newspaper report; the medical reasoning that answered it is secret.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Carlo Acutis died on 12 October 2006, aged fifteen. The Milan inquiry into his life opened on 12 October 2013 and closed on 24 November 2016, and Francis declared him Venerable on 5 July 2018. The healing of a Brazilian boy, Matheus Lins Vianna, from a pancreatic malformation was approved for his beatification at Assisi on 10 October 2020. The cardinals and bishops judged the recovery of Valeria, a Costa Rican student in Florence, a miracle on 7 May 2024. His canonisation, set for 27 April 2025, was postponed when Francis died on 21 April 2025, and Leo XIV canonised him with Pier Giorgio Frassati on 7 September 2025.

Rests on
  • Carlo Acutis, Biografia
    “La morte cerebrale avvenne l’11 ottobre 2006, il suo cuore smise di battere alle ore 6:45 del 12 ottobre.”
  • Vatican News, 10 October 2020
    “He was only 15 years old when he died in a hospital in Monza, Italy, in 2006”
  • Carlo Acutis, Iter della causa
    “L’Inchiesta diocesana sulla vita, virtù e fama di santità, iniziata il 12 ottobre 2013 nel Palazzo Arcivescovile di Milano, si è conclusa il 24 novembre 2016. La Congregazione delle Cause dei Santi ha riconosciuto validi gli atti processuali con il …”
    Read the full passage
    “L’Inchiesta diocesana sulla vita, virtù e fama di santità, iniziata il 12 ottobre 2013 nel Palazzo Arcivescovile di Milano, si è conclusa il 24 novembre 2016. La Congregazione delle Cause dei Santi ha riconosciuto validi gli atti processuali con il decreto del 26 maggio 2017. Preparata la Positio super virtutibus, la Causa ha affrontato con esito felice il Congresso peculiare dei Consultori Teologi il 17 aprile 2018. La Sessione Ordinaria dei Cardinali e Vescovi, Membri del Dicastero, ha poi riconosciuto l’esercizio eroico delle virtù da parte del Servo di Dio, il 3 luglio 2018. Il 5 luglio 2018 Papa Francesco ha autorizzato il Dicastero delle Cause dei Santi a promulgare il Decreto riguardante le virtù eroiche di Carlo Acutis, dichiarandolo così Venerabile.”
  • Vatican News, September 2025
    “The first occurred in 2010 in Campo Grande, when Matheus Lins Vianna—then 6 years old—was healed of a severe pancreatic malformation after prayers before an image of Carlo in the Chapel of São Sebastião.”
  • Carlo Acutis, Iter della causa
    “Il rito di beatificazione si svolse, nella Basilica Superiore di San Francesco in Assisi, il 10 ottobre 2020, presieduto dal Cardinale Agostino Vallini, Legato Pontificio per le Basiliche di San Francesco e di Santa Maria degli Angeli in Assisi, in rappresentanza di Papa Francesco.”
  • Vatican News, May 2024
    “On July 8, 2022, Liliana prayed at Blessed Carlo’s tomb in Assisi, leaving a letter describing her plea. Six days earlier, on July 2, her daughter Valeria had fallen from her bicycle in Florence, where she was attending university. She had suffered severe head trauma”
  • Carlo Acutis, Iter della causa
    “I Cardinali e i Vescovi nella Sessione Ordinaria del 7 maggio 2024 giudicarono il caso in esame un vero miracolo, attribuito all’intercessione di Carlo.”
  • Vatican News, September 2025
    “Initially scheduled for 27 April, during the Jubilee for Adolescents, the ceremony was postponed due to the death of Pope Francis.”
  • America, 7 September 2025
    “Pope Francis had intended to declare Carlo Acutis (1991-2006) as the first millennial saint on April 27, the Jubilee of Adolescents, and Pier Giorgio Frassati (1901-1925) a saint at the Jubilee for Youth at the end of August, but the Argentine pope …”
    Read the full passage
    “Pope Francis had intended to declare Carlo Acutis (1991-2006) as the first millennial saint on April 27, the Jubilee of Adolescents, and Pier Giorgio Frassati (1901-1925) a saint at the Jubilee for Youth at the end of August, but the Argentine pope died on April 21. And so today, four months to the day on which he entered the conclave that elected him pope, Leo XIV declared them saints together— the first of his pontificate.”
  • Leo XIV, Homily at the canonisation of Pier Giorgio Frassati and Carlo Acutis, 7 September 2025
    “In this setting, today we look to Saint Pier Giorgio Frassati and Saint Carlo Acutis: a young man from the early 20th century and a teenager from our own day, both in love with Jesus and ready to give everything for him.”
Other readings
  • Skeptics note that his life is known largely through his mother and the association founded in 2011 to promote his cause, and that the 2025 canonisation came nineteen years after his death.
Limits
  • The medical files on the two healings are secret; the sources give the diagnoses and dates only.
  • Vatican News spells the Costa Rican student's name Valerie in one report and Valeria in another; the earlier report is followed.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

In the canonisation formula the pope declares and defines that a Blessed is a saint and orders that he or she be venerated by the whole Church; the Catechism says canonisation proposes the saints as models and intercessors. Whether a canonisation is infallible has never been defined as a dogma. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1907 records general agreement among theologians that it is, most of them holding it theologically certain rather than a matter of faith, and in 1998 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith listed the canonisations of saints among truths to be held definitively though not declared divinely revealed, adding that the assent owed to such truths is no less full and irrevocable. On the view the 1907 article gives, what is defined is that the person is in heaven, not that every decision of their life was right.

Rests on
  • Formula of Canonization, English text (EWTN library)
    “For the honour of the Blessed Trinity, the exaltation of the Catholic faith and the increase of the Christian life, by the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul, and our own, after due deliberation and frequent …”
    Read the full passage
    “For the honour of the Blessed Trinity, the exaltation of the Catholic faith and the increase of the Christian life, by the authority of our Lord Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Apostles Peter and Paul, and our own, after due deliberation and frequent prayer for divine assistance, and having sought the counsel of many of our brother Bishops, we declare and define Blessed [name] to be a Saint and we enroll him among the Saints, decreeing that he be venerated as such by the whole Church.”
  • CCC 828
    “By canonizing some of the faithful ... the Church recognizes the power of the Spirit of holiness within her and sustains the hope of believers by proposing the saints to them as models and intercessors.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Papal infallibility and canonization
    “Theologians generally agree as to the fact of papal infallibility in this matter of canonization, but disagree as to the quality of certitude due to a papal decree in such matter. In the opinion of some it is of faith (Arriaga, De fide, disp. 9, p. …”
    Read the full passage
    “Theologians generally agree as to the fact of papal infallibility in this matter of canonization, but disagree as to the quality of certitude due to a papal decree in such matter. In the opinion of some it is of faith (Arriaga, De fide, disp. 9, p. 5, no 27); others hold that to refuse assent to such a judgment of the Holy See would be both impious and rash, as Francisco Suárez (De fide, disp. 5 p. 8, no 8); many more (and this is the general view) hold such a pronouncement to be theologically certain, not being of Divine Faith as its purport has not been immediately revealed, nor of ecclesiastical Faith as having thus far not been defined by the Church.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Papal infallibility and canonization
    “my own opinion is that nothing else is defined than that the person canonized is in heaven.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), quoting Thomas Aquinas, Quodlibet IX, a. 16
    “Since the honour we pay the saints is in a certain sense a profession of faith, i.e., a belief in the glory of the Saints [quâ sanctorum gloriam credimus] we must piously believe that in this matter also the judgment of the Church is not liable to error.”
  • Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the concluding formula of the Professio fidei (29 June 1998), n. 11
    “With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the …”
    Read the full passage
    “With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the Supreme Pontiff or of the celebration of an ecumenical council, the canonizations of saints (dogmatic facts)”
  • Doctrinal Commentary (1998), n. 8
    “With regard to the nature of the assent owed to the truths set forth by the Church as divinely revealed (those of the first paragraph) or to be held definitively (those of the second paragraph), it is important to emphasize that there is no …”
    Read the full passage
    “With regard to the nature of the assent owed to the truths set forth by the Church as divinely revealed (those of the first paragraph) or to be held definitively (those of the second paragraph), it is important to emphasize that there is no difference with respect to the full and irrevocable character of the assent which is owed to these teachings.”
Other readings
  • Thomas Aquinas, as the Catholic Encyclopedia quotes him, held that the Church's judgement here is to be piously believed, which is a weaker claim than a dogma of faith.
  • Protestant and Orthodox readers do not accept a papal declaration of this kind as binding at all.
Limits
  • The 1998 text is a doctrinal commentary on the profession of faith, which says its examples are given without any intention of completeness; it is not a papal definition.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia author gives his view of what is defined as his own opinion, in his words.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Under the current rules a cause normally cannot open until five years after death, unless the pope dispenses. The postulator must not hide what tells against the candidate, and the list of witnesses must include those who could call the reputation for holiness into question. A candidate becomes Servant of God when the cause opens; Venerable when the pope approves a decree on heroic virtue, martyrdom or, since 2017, the offering of life; Blessed after one approved miracle, except that a martyr needs none; and Saint after a second miracle that happens after beatification. The pope can also confirm a long-established cult without a miracle, and can dispense from the rules, as Francis did for John XXIII's second miracle.

Rests on
  • Sanctorum Mater (2007), art. 25 §2
    “The libellus may be presented to the Bishop no sooner than five years after the death of the Servant of God”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, approfondimenti, Fase diocesana
    “Il processo di beatificazione, salvo una particolare dispensa papale, non può iniziare prima che siano passati almeno 5 anni dalla morte del candidato.”
  • Sanctorum Mater (2007), art. 17 §2
    “He is to take care not to hide eventual discoveries contrary to the reputation of holiness or of martyrdom and to the reputation of intercessory power enjoyed by the Servant of God”
  • Sanctorum Mater (2007), art. 37, 3 a
    “a list of the persons who can contribute to ascertaining the truth on the virtues or the martyrdom of the Servant of God, as well as on the reputation of holiness or of martyrdom, and on the reputation of intercessory power, not omitting those who could call such a reputation into question”
  • Sanctorum Mater (2007), art. 4 §2
    “The Catholic whose cause of beatification and canonization has been initiated is called Servant of God.”
  • Maiorem hac dilectionem (11 July 2017), art. 1
    “The offer of life is a new cause for the beatification and canonization procedure, distinct from the causes based on martyrdom and on the heroism of virtues.”
  • Maiorem hac dilectionem (2017), art. 2 a
    “a) a free and voluntary offer of life and heroic acceptance propter caritatem of a certain and untimely death;”
  • Maiorem hac dilectionem (2017), art. 2 c
    “c) the exercise, at least as ordinarily possible, of Christian virtues before the offer of life and, then, unto death;”
  • Maiorem hac dilectionem (2017), art. 2 e
    “e) the necessity of a miracle for beatification, occurring after the death of the Servant of God and through his or her intercession.”
  • Josephine McKenna, Religion News Service (America), 22 April 2014
    “John XXIII is even more controversial since Pope Francis approved his canonization with evidence of only one miracle — instead of the two normally required.”
  • Josephine McKenna, Religion News Service (America), 22 April 2014, quoting John Thavis
    ““It’s controversial among the saint makers at the Vatican, who consider themselves sticklers when it comes to the miracle requirement,” said longtime Vatican watcher John Thavis”
  • Josephine McKenna, Religion News Service (America), 22 April 2014
    ““But Francis was actually using an ancient practice when he waived the second miracle requirement for John XXIII, recognizing that the faithful already know him to be a saint.””
  • Josephine McKenna, Religion News Service (America), 22 April 2014
    “Last year, he also waived the second miracle requirement for his favorite fellow Jesuit, Peter Favre, who died in 1546 and whose sainthood cause has languished since 1872.”
  • Sanctorum Mater (2007), art. 88
    “It is of extreme importance always to refrain from every act (e.g., liturgical celebrations, panegyric speeches in honor of the Servant of God, etc.), inside and outside of churches, that could mislead the faithful into thinking wrongly that the …”
    Read the full passage
    “It is of extreme importance always to refrain from every act (e.g., liturgical celebrations, panegyric speeches in honor of the Servant of God, etc.), inside and outside of churches, that could mislead the faithful into thinking wrongly that the initiation of the Inquiry necessarily implies the beatification and canonization of the Servant of God”
  • Christopher Hitchens, Slate, 20 October 2003
    “(As it happens, I myself was interviewed by them but only in the most perfunctory way. The procedure still does demand a show of consultation with doubters, and a show of consultation was what, in this case, it got.)”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, approfondimenti, Beatificazione
    “Se il candidato viene dichiarato martire, diventa subito Beato, altrimenti è necessario che venga riconosciuto un miracolo, dovuto alla sua intercessione. Questo evento miracoloso in genere è una guarigione ritenuta scientificamente inspiegabile, …”
    Read the full passage
    “Se il candidato viene dichiarato martire, diventa subito Beato, altrimenti è necessario che venga riconosciuto un miracolo, dovuto alla sua intercessione. Questo evento miracoloso in genere è una guarigione ritenuta scientificamente inspiegabile, giudicata tale da una Commissione Medica convocata dal Dicastero delle Cause dei Santi e composta da specialisti, sia credenti sia non credenti.”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, approfondimenti, Canonizzazione
    “Perché arrivi alla canonizzazione, ossia affinché possa essere dichiarato Santo, si deve attribuire al Beato l’intercessione efficace in un secondo miracolo avvenuto successivamente alla beatificazione.”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, approfondimenti, equipollenza
    “Vi sono casi che procedono per equipollenza, applicata sia ai casi di beatificazione che di canonizzazione; si tratta di una procedura mediante la quale il Papa, dopo le dovute verifiche, approva un culto esistente da tempo, senza attendere il riconoscimento di un miracolo.”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, approfondimenti, decisioni particolari
    “Papa Francesco lo ha fatto nei confronti di Giovanni XXIII, che è diventato Santo per la sua fama di santità, diffusa da decenni in tutto il mondo, senza che gli venisse riconosciuto un secondo miracolo. Una procedura straordinaria è stata seguita …”
    Read the full passage
    “Papa Francesco lo ha fatto nei confronti di Giovanni XXIII, che è diventato Santo per la sua fama di santità, diffusa da decenni in tutto il mondo, senza che gli venisse riconosciuto un secondo miracolo. Una procedura straordinaria è stata seguita anche da Benedetto XVI nei confronti di S. Giovanni Paolo II, la cui Causa di canonizzazione si aprì poche settimane dopo la morte, senza aspettare i cinque anni previsti.”
Other readings
  • Critics point to the dispensations, the five-year wait for John Paul II and the second miracle for John XXIII, as evidence that the rules bend for popular or powerful candidates.
Limits
  • These are the rules as the Holy See publishes them; they do not show how strictly any one diocese applies them.
  • The Dicastery's summary pages are in Italian; translations are given in the verification note.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

A proposed healing is judged in separate stages by different people. Two doctors chosen by the Dicastery write independent opinions; if both are negative, the postulator may ask for a third, and if that one is negative too, the case stops. A board of seven medical experts, forbidden any contact with the cause's promoters, must then find the healing scientifically inexplicable by at least five votes to two, and a case that fails three times cannot be presented again. Only after that do theologians judge whether the healing followed prayer to the candidate, then the cardinals and bishops, and last the pope. The board's discussions and each member's vote are secret.

Rests on
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (24 August 2016), art. 9 §2
    “When the ex officio expert opinions are both negative, the Undersecretary notifies the Postulator of the Cause so that he may decide whether to seek the opinion of a third ex officio Expert who is nominated according to the norm of Art. 8 § 1. If this is also negative the case may not proceed ad ulteriora.”
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (2016), art. 6 §1
    “Any contact with the Promoter and the Postulator of the Cause under examination is prohibited to those Doctors nominated.”
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (2016), art. 15
    “The case may proceed further if the conclusions of the meeting of the Medical Board are affirmative with a qualified majority of at least five out of seven Experts or of four out of six Experts present at the same meeting.”
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (2016), art. 18
    “A case, examined three times by the Medical Board with a suspended or negative conclusion may not be presented again.”
  • Regulations of the Medical Board (2016), art. 19
    “The Medical Experts, the Postulators and the Promoters of the Cause are obliged to keep secret everything regarding the presumed miracle under examination, especially if the person healed is a minor.”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), III, 14
    “The Relator assigned to this task is to prepare a Position on alleged miracles. They are discussed in a meeting of experts (in the case of healings, in a meeting of physicians), whose votes and conclusions are set forth in an accurate report. 2. …”
    Read the full passage
    “The Relator assigned to this task is to prepare a Position on alleged miracles. They are discussed in a meeting of experts (in the case of healings, in a meeting of physicians), whose votes and conclusions are set forth in an accurate report. 2. Then the miracles are to be discussed in the special meeting of the theologians and, finally, in that of the Cardinals and Bishops.”
  • Divinus Perfectionis Magister (1983), III, 15
    “The results of the discussions of the Cardinals and Bishops are reported to the Supreme Pontiff, who alone has the right to declare that public cult may be given by the Church to Servants of God.”
  • Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, Giovanni Paolo II, Iter della causa (a)
    “La Consulta Medica del 21 ottobre 2010 la ritenne scientificamente inspiegabile e i Consultori Teologi, radunati nel Congresso Peculiare del 14 dicembre 2010, diedero parere favorevole, attribuendo tale guarigione alla sua intercessione. I Padri …”
    Read the full passage
    “La Consulta Medica del 21 ottobre 2010 la ritenne scientificamente inspiegabile e i Consultori Teologi, radunati nel Congresso Peculiare del 14 dicembre 2010, diedero parere favorevole, attribuendo tale guarigione alla sua intercessione. I Padri Cardinali e Vescovi nella Sessione Ordinaria dell’11 gennaio 2011, la giudicarono vero mira­colo.”
Other readings
  • A secular critic answers that 'scientifically inexplicable' means only unexplained with present knowledge, and that secrecy prevents outside doctors from checking the board's reasoning.
  • Christopher Hitchens reported that the doctor who treated Monica Besra, whose healing was approved for Mother Teresa's beatification, said the illness had been cured by medicine.
Limits
  • The rules describe the procedure; because the board's proceedings are secret, the sources cannot show how many healings are rejected each year.
  • The medical board judges only whether a healing is unexplained by science; the judgement that it was a miracle through a particular person's intercession is theological.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

12HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

John Paul II proclaimed 1,338 blesseds and 482 saints, according to the Holy See's biography of him. John L. Allen Jr. in Newsweek and the Associated Press reported this as more than all his predecessors combined, and Allen recorded the nickname saint-making factory. Causes cost money: after a commission Francis set up in 2013 found little oversight of the funds, about 400 postulators' accounts at the Vatican bank were frozen, and on 4 March 2016 Francis approved new norms, for a trial of three years, requiring budgets, accounts checked by bishops or superiors, and a solidarity fund for poor causes. The journalist Gianluigi Nuzzi put the average cost of a cause at about $550,000; American church officials had used $250,000 as a benchmark.

Rests on
  • Biographical profile of John Paul II (vatican.va)
    “Pope John Paul II celebrated 147 beatifications, during which he proclaimed 1,338 blesseds, and 51 canonizations, for a total of 482 saints.”
  • John L. Allen Jr., Newsweek, 17 April 2011
    “John Paul notoriously presided over what wags called a "saint-making factory" during his almost 27 years atop the Catholic Church. He produced more beatifications (1,338) and canonizations (482) than all previous popes combined—and since Catholic …”
    Read the full passage
    “John Paul notoriously presided over what wags called a "saint-making factory" during his almost 27 years atop the Catholic Church. He produced more beatifications (1,338) and canonizations (482) than all previous popes combined—and since Catholic tradition acknowledges 263 previous popes stretching back nearly 2,000 years, that's no mean feat.”
  • Associated Press, 25 April 2014 (Seattle Times)
    “John Paul declared more saints — 482 — than all of his predecessors combined.”
  • Associated Press, 25 April 2014 (Seattle Times)
    “He also beatified a record number: 1,338.”
  • Gerard O'Connell, America, 23 March 2016
    “In early August 2013, Francis received alarming reports from the commission on this matter, and he immediately ordered the blocking of some 400 accounts of the postulators of the causes of beatification and canonization held at the Institute for the Works of Religion (commonly called the Vatican Bank).”
  • Gerard O'Connell, America, 23 March 2016
    “The commission’s report revealed that the system approved by St. John Paul II in 1983 lacked effective oversight and failed to prevent abuses. John Paul II beatified 1,138 persons and declared 482 saints, and it was known in Rome during his pontificate that money had been an important factor in advancing some of them.”
  • Norms regarding the Administration of Temporal Goods in the Causes of Beatification and Canonization (7 March 2016), rescript
    “The Supreme Pontiff Francis, in an Audience granted to the undersigned Cardinal Secretary of State on the 4th of March in the Year of Our Lord 2016, approved the new “Norms regarding the Administration of the Temporal Goods of the Causes of …”
    Read the full passage
    “The Supreme Pontiff Francis, in an Audience granted to the undersigned Cardinal Secretary of State on the 4th of March in the Year of Our Lord 2016, approved the new “Norms regarding the Administration of the Temporal Goods of the Causes of Beatification and Canonization”, repealing those previously approved by St John Paul II on 20 August 1983.”
  • Norms (2016), Premise
    “In what pertains to the Roman phase, given that Causes by their unique nature are a public good, the Apostolic See covers all expenses, in which the other Parties participate by way of contribution, and is vigilant that the costs be contained such that they do not hinder the development of the Cause.”
  • Norms (2016), n. 22
    “In the event of real difficulty in meeting the costs of a cause in its Roman phase, the Petitioner may request a contribution from the Congregation for the Causes of Saints through the competent Ordinary. The latter must verify the …”
    Read the full passage
    “In the event of real difficulty in meeting the costs of a cause in its Roman phase, the Petitioner may request a contribution from the Congregation for the Causes of Saints through the competent Ordinary. The latter must verify the economic-financial status of the fund and the impossibility of providing other subsidies before submitting any such request. The Congregation for the Causes of Saints will evaluate these requests on a case-by-case basis.”
  • Crux, 23 September 2016
    “In his book “Merchants in the Temple,” Italian journalist Gianluigi Nuzzi charged the congregation was among the most reluctant Vatican offices to cooperate with new transparency measures imposed as part of Francis’s project of Vatican reform, and asserted that the average cost of a sainthood cause was about $550,000.”
  • Crux, 23 September 2016
    “U.S. Catholic officials traditionally have used $250,000 as a benchmark for the cost of a cause from the initial investigation on a diocesan level, to a canonization Mass in St. Peter’s Square at the Vatican,”
  • Norms (2016), rescript
    “establishing that the same enter into force ad experimentum for three years starting from the date of approval”
Other readings
  • Allen reports John Paul II's own aim as showing a secular world that holiness is alive in the present, so the numbers were deliberate policy rather than carelessness.
  • O'Connell reports that it was known in Rome that money had been an important factor in advancing some causes; the Holy See's norms describe the costs as the ordinary expenses of a complex investigation.
Limits
  • The claim that John Paul II named more saints than all his predecessors combined is the journalists' comparison; no Holy See count of earlier canonisations was compared.
  • America (O'Connell) gives 1,138 blesseds where the Holy See's biography, John L. Allen Jr. and the Associated Press all give 1,338; the Holy See's figure is used and 1,138 looks like a slip.
  • Nuzzi's average cost comes from a leaked commission report quoted by journalists, not from a published audit.
  • The 2016 norms were approved ad experimentum for three years; the saved pages do not say whether they were later confirmed or replaced.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next