Popes fighting to survive
Raiders strip St Peter's, and Rome's noble families make and unmake popes. In 1059 the reformers hand the election to the cardinals.
In the 800s and 900s the popes ruled Rome and the lands around it but had little power to defend them. In 846 Muslim raiders, whom Italians called Saracens, landed at the mouth of the Tiber and stripped St Peter's and St Paul's, and Pope Leo IV built a wall around the Vatican.
Inside the city, noble families fought over the papacy and often chose the pope. A dead pope was put on trial in 897, a young noble became John XII in 955, and by 1046 three men claimed the office.
In 1059 a council gave the election of popes to the cardinals.
The situation
Since the 700s the had been more than the of Rome. With the backing of the Frankish kings, he also ruled the city and the lands around it, the Papal States.
By the 800s that backing was falling apart. Charlemagne's empire was divided among his heirs, who fought each other for Italy. Rome had only a small militia, and its enemies could come by sea.
From the 820s Muslim raiders from North Africa, whom Italians called Saracens, were conquering Sicily and attacking the Italian coast. Some Italian princes even hired them against their rivals.
Inside Rome, the great noble families saw the papacy as a prize. Whoever made the pope controlled the city, its lands and its income. For long stretches, popes were chosen by whichever family was strongest.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Strife after the empire broke up
The Catholic Encyclopedia places the papacy of the late 800s in the power struggle that followed the end of Charlemagne's empire.
“The pontificate of this pope belongs to that era of strife for political supremacy in Italy , which succeeded the disruption of the Carlovingian empire.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Formosus' · Pope Formosus - 02
Who the raiders were
A modern summary of the background to 846. Tertiary source, used for the general picture only.
“In the 820s, the Aghlabids of Ifriqiya (known by medieval Italians as the Saracens ) began their conquest of Sicily .”
Arab raid against Rome · Background
What was at stake
A pope is meant to be the shepherd of the whole Church, a bishop chosen freely to serve. But a pope who couldn't defend his city, or who owed his office to a family or a king, wasn't free to be anyone's shepherd.
The danger came from two sides. Raiders could burn the churches. Nobles and emperors could choose the man.
For about two hundred years, popes lived with both. Some fought back bravely. Some were the creatures of the families that made them.
The event
In 846 a Saracen fleet landed at the mouth of the Tiber. Rome's walls held, but St 's and St 's stood outside them. The raiders stripped both basilicas, including the church over Peter's tomb.
The people feared another attack, so the next pope, Leo IV, was consecrated, meaning made bishop, in 847 without waiting for the Frankish emperor's consent. He built a wall around the Vatican hill, finished in 852; the walled area is still called the Leonine City.
In 849 a new Saracen fleet was destroyed off Ostia by the ships of Rome, Naples, Amalfi and Gaeta, and by a storm. In 916 Pope John X led an Italian army himself and beat the Saracens at the Garigliano river.
Inside the city it got darker. In 897 Pope Stephen VI had the body of Formosus, pope until the year before, dug up and put on trial before a synod, a meeting of clergy.
The corpse was condemned, stripped and thrown into the Tiber; months later Stephen was strangled.
Then the family of Theophylact, a Roman noble, ran Rome. His daughter Marozia had John X imprisoned, and he died there in 928. Her son became John XI, and in 955 her grandson Octavius became John XII at about eighteen.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Basilicas outside the walls
Rome's ancient walls protected the city, but the great pilgrim churches outside them were open to the raiders.
“In 846, Arab raiders plundered the outskirts of the city of Rome , sacking the basilicas of Old St Peter's and St Paul's-Outside-the-Walls , but were prevented from entering the city itself by the Aurelian Walls .”
Arab raid against Rome · Lead - 02
Consecrated in a hurry
Leo IV's election shows how afraid the Romans were.
“as the alarming attack of the Saracens on Rome in 846 caused the people to fear for the safety of the city, he was consecrated (10 April, 847) without the consent of the emperor.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Pope Saint Leo IV - 03
The trial of a corpse
The Catholic Encyclopedia suggests Stephen VI may have been pushed into it by the emperor Lambert and his mother, but calls it what it was.
“The corpse was then stripped of its sacred vestments , deprived of two fingers of its right hand, clad in the garb of a layman , and ultimately thrown into the Tiber.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Pope Stephen (VI) VII - 04
A pope chosen by oath
Marozia's son Alberic, ruler of Rome, made the nobles swear that his own son would be the next pope.
“Before his death he administered an oath (954) to the Roman nobles in St. Peter's , that on the next vacancy of the papal chair his only son, Octavius, should be elected pope .”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope John XII' · Pope John XII
The outcome
Threatened by an Italian king, John XII called in the German king Otto I and crowned him emperor in 962. Otto's decree said popes were to be elected by the Church's own rules, but German emperors now expected a say in who became pope.
Roman families kept fighting for the office. In 1032 the young Benedict IX was put on the throne by his family, and by 1046 three men claimed to be pope. One of them, Gregory VI, had paid to resign, hoping to be rid of him.
The German king Henry III had all three removed at councils at Sutri and Rome in 1046, and was then crowned emperor by the pope he chose. The reformers who came after drew the lesson.
In 1059 a under Pope Nicholas II ruled that popes would be chosen by the cardinals, the senior clergy of Rome, with the rest of the clergy and the people consenting. In 1179 a later council left the choice to the cardinals alone, by a two-thirds vote, and the cardinals still elect the pope today.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
The 1059 election law
The Catholic Encyclopedia summarises the decree of Nicholas II's Lateran synod.
“At the death of the pope , the cardinal-bishops are to confer among themselves concerning a candidate, and, after they have agreed upon a name, they and the other cardinals are to proceed to the election. The remainder of the clergy and the laity enjoy the right of acclaiming their choice.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Pope Nicholas II' · Pope Nicholas II - 02
Buying out a bad pope
Gregory VI paid Benedict IX to step down, meaning well, and it made matters worse.
“Desirous of ridding the See of Rome on such an unworthy pontiff, John Gratian in all good faith and simplicity paid him the money and was recognized as pope in his stead.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Gregory VI' · Pope Gregory VI
For the trail
This is the age behind the worst stories about popes, and many of them are true. A corpse put on trial, a pope made at eighteen, the office passed around one family. The Catholic Church's own historians tell these stories plainly.
But the stories make more sense with the background. These popes were trying to hold a city with no real army against raiders, and to keep their office from men who wanted it for land and money. Many failed.
It also explains the next century. The reforming popes of the 1050s fought hard for Rome's freedom and authority, against Roman families, against emperors, and in their dealings with Constantinople in 1054.
What the Church says
The Church doesn't claim its popes have all been good men. The Second Vatican Council teaches that the Church is ‘embracing in its bosom sinners, at the same time holy and always in need of being purified’ (*Lumen Gentium* 8).
Catholics believe the pope is kept from error only when he solemnly defines a teaching of faith or morals for the whole Church (CCC 891). That promise covers what he teaches, not how he lives or how he came to office.
Leo IV, who walled in the Vatican, is honoured as a saint, and his name is in the Roman Martyrology.
Think of it like this
A town hall that the strongest family in town keeps filling with its own sons.
In 10th-century Rome, being pope meant ruling the city, so the families who wanted the city wanted the papacy. Whoever had the most armed men and the best marriages chose the man. The reformers' answer was to take the choice out of the families' hands altogether.
“As soon as Leo, much against his will, became pope , he began to take precautions against a repetition of the Saracen raid of 846.”
Where people disagree
Much of the worst gossip comes from one writer, Liutprand of Cremona, who wrote decades later and disliked the Romans. Even the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia, which is not soft on these popes, rejects some of his stories as slander.
One example: that Pope Sergius III fathered Marozia's son, the later John XI. Hostile writers said so; the Catholic Encyclopedia calls the claim ‘highly doubtful’.
Historians also differ over the emperors. To some, Otto I and Henry III rescued the papacy from Roman gangs. To others, they swapped Roman control for German control, which the reformers then had to fight off too.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
A hostile witness
On Liutprand's story about Pope John X, the Catholic Encyclopedia is blunt about its source.
“This statement is, however, generally and rightly rejected as a calumny . Liutprand wrote his history some fifty years later, and constantly slandered the Romans, whom he hated .”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope John X' · Pope John X - 02
Rescue or takeover?
The Catholic Encyclopedia's own verdict on the reform: the papacy had to be freed from both the Roman factions and the emperor.
“they should be freed from the nefarious influence of the Roman factions and the secular control of the emperor, hitherto less disastrous but always objectionable.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Pope Nicholas II' · Pope Nicholas II
This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.
- Horace K. Mann · 1910 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- Horace Mann · 1912 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- J. P. Kirsch · 1910 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- N. Weber · 1911 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent