Did the lifting of the anathemas in 1965 end the schism of 1054?
No, and neither side said it did. In 1965 the pope and the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople, the senior bishop of the Orthodox world, cancelled the sentences of 1054 and regretted the wrongs on both sides. The split itself, and the questions behind it, are still being worked through.
Part 1 · What happened in 1054
The story most people know goes like this. In 1054 the leading of Rome and Constantinople, today's Istanbul, cut each other off.
And Christianity split in two: the Catholic Church in the West, and the Churches in the East.
Then in 1965 those sentences, the anathemas that cut each side off, were cancelled. So why aren't Catholics and Orthodox one Church again?
The answer starts with what really happened in 1054.
Picture the scene. Cardinal Humbert, sent by the , walked into Hagia Sophia during a service.
He laid a document on the altar cutting off Patriarch , the city's top bishop. Michael cut him off in return.
Being cut off, or excommunicated, meant you couldn't receive the , including , until you made peace.
And these sentences named persons, not whole Churches.
Even the timing was messy. The pope who had sent Humbert was already dead.
Most historians now see 1054 as one moment in a long drift apart.
What made the split real for ordinary people came later, in 1204.
Western crusaders, soldiers who had set out on a holy war, sacked Constantinople. They looted and wrecked it.
So cancelling the sentences of 1054 could never, on its own, end the split.
Part 2 · What 1965 actually said
On 7 December 1965 a joint statement was read out in Rome and Istanbul at the same time.
Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras of Constantinople *regretted the offensive words* and actions on both sides**.
They removed the old sentences from memory, and committed them to oblivion, to be forgotten for good.
Then they said clearly that this was not sufficient to end the differences between the two Churches.
So why does 1965 matter? Because it was done together, by a pope and a patriarch, each with his own authority.
They took back the penalties and named wrongs on both sides. Neither asked the other to admit sole guilt.
The Catholic Church teaches that the split is a wound, not a verdict on either side.
Its , its summary of beliefs, says that often enough, men of both sides were to blame.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of two best friends who fell out in front of the whole class.
Each said something unforgivable. Then they blocked each other on every app, and stopped speaking.
Years later, one of them sends a message. They meet, both take back those words, and both say sorry.
Their old friends, who were stuck choosing sides for years, finally breathe out. That matters a lot.
But it doesn't settle what they actually fought about. And it doesn't give back the years apart.
By now each has a different group of friends, different habits, and a different way of telling the story.
Saying sorry means they can talk again. But the real talking still has to happen.
In 1965, both sides said sorry like that. It cleared the way for the real conversation.
Part 3 · What still divides us
So what still divides us? Mainly two things. The first is the pope.
In 2007, at official Catholic-Orthodox talks in Ravenna, Italy, both sides agreed that Rome held first place among the ancient Churches.
They disagree on what powers came with that place, and whether it means authority over every other bishop.
The Russian Orthodox Church wasn't in the room.
Its delegation walked out on the first day, over a separate quarrel with Constantinople.
The Russian Church's leaders in Moscow said the text was adopted without consideration for her opinion. They later rejected its part on the pope's place.
The second is the Creed.
It grew out of meetings of bishops at Nicaea in 325 and Constantinople in 381, both in what is now Turkey.
The West later added the words and the Son: the comes from the Father and the Son.
The Catechism admits that's still a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches.
Part 4 · Why the talking goes on
Lifting the old penalties cleared the air, so those questions could be talked about honestly.
In 1979 the pope and the patriarch of the day launched official talks on belief between the two Churches. Those talks still meet.
Why keep at it? Because the Catholic Church believes the Orthodox are already very close.
The , the Catholic of the 1960s, said the Eastern Churches have true sacraments.
Sacraments are the Church's sacred rites, like and marriage.
Above all, the Council named the priesthood and the .
In 1995 went further, on the hardest question of all: his own job.
He asked other Church leaders to help him find a new way of being pope, in a patient and fraternal dialogue, talking as brothers.
In November 2025, sixty years on, Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, Athenagoras's successor, marked the anniversary together. They repeated the hope of 1965.
The hope is still the same: to live again as one Church, sharing one Communion.
East and West lived like that during the first thousand years of the life of the Church.
So 1965 didn't end the split. It ended the excuse for not talking.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 12
- Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration of Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I (7 December 1965) · Removes the 1054 excommunications and says plainly this is not enough to end the differences.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. III: The Great Schism · An Orthodox account of 1054: Humbert's bull, Leo IX's death, the drift that 1204 deepened.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 817 · Divisions came about with blame on both sides.
- Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 41 and 45 · Both sides agree Rome held first place; they disagree on what that meant, and on Vatican I.
- Moscow Patriarchate, Position on the Problem of Primacy in the Universal Church · Ravenna was adopted without the Russian Church, which disagreed with its section on primacy.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 247 · The filioque remains a point of disagreement with the Orthodox Churches.
- Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 15 · The Eastern Churches have true sacraments and are closely linked with the Catholic Church.
- John Paul II, Address to Patriarch Bartholomew I (29 June 2004) · Recalls the 1979 announcement of the theological dialogue with Patriarch Dimitrios I.
- Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew, Joint Declaration (29 November 2025) · Marks the 60th anniversary of 1965 and quotes its hope of full communion.
- John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 95–96 · The Pope asks other Churches to help find a new way of exercising the primacy.
- Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, Joint International Commission: 2007 Plenary Session (Ravenna) · The Vatican report: Moscow withdrew over the Estonian delegates despite a compromise offered by the other Orthodox.
- Fr Leonid Kishkovsky, "Primacy theme of Catholic-Orthodox dialogue" (Orthodox Church in America, Holy Synod statements, 2007) · An Orthodox account of why the Moscow delegation withdrew from Ravenna: the dispute with Constantinople over the Church in Estonia.