From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/where-is-the-pope-in-the-bible
← Protestant or evangelicalWhere is the pope in the Bible?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minACG works this question through in his own story. Read that part of his story: Who decides? · 4 min
The word isn't in the , and Catholics don't claim the job appeared fully formed. What they find there is , the leader of Jesus's twelve . Jesus called him the rock, gave him the keys, and told him to feed his sheep. Catholics believe Peter's role carried on in the of Rome, the city where he died.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 880–882 and 891
- Vatican I
- Pastor Aeternus, chapters 2 and 4
It's a fair question. If the pope matters this much, you'd expect a whole chapter on him.
But the never uses the word pope. It never calls Peter the bishop of Rome either.
Catholics agree. No first-century text calls Peter bishop of Rome. One respected Catholic historian, Francis Sullivan, even concluded there wasn't a single bishop leading the church in Rome back then.8
But he also found the apostles did pass their work of leading the churches on to others. At first, it seems, they passed it to a group of leaders rather than one.8
And when Jesus said he'd build his church on this rock, Lutherans and many other Protestants read the rock as Peter's faith in Jesus, not Peter himself.1
So the Catholic case doesn't rest on one word. It rests on three things: what Jesus gave Peter, Peter's death in Rome, and how the church in Rome acted after him.
What Jesus gave Peter
Start with a name. Jesus renames a fisherman called Simon. He calls him Peter, which means rock.
Then he says upon this rock I will build my church, and promises him the keys to the kingdom of .2
Why keys? The notes in the New American Bible, a Catholic translation, point to 22:22. There, the king's chief steward, the man who ran the royal household, is handed the key of the House of David. The key went with the job, and passed from one man to the next.2
The same notes say that in Jesus's language it was probably the same word twice: You are the Rock and upon this rock. So the church will have Peter as its solid foundation.2
But his job as the rock, the notes say, is to be a witness to who Jesus is. That's his faith.2 So the Catholic and readings are closer than they sound.
Later Jesus tells Peter, you must strengthen your brothers.3 And after rising from the dead, he asks him three times to feed his sheep.4
Think of it like this
Think of a farmer who runs a big family farm. One day he has to leave on a long journey, and he doesn't know exactly when he'll be back.
Before he goes, he calls one of his sons over and puts the heavy ring of keys in his hand: the house, the barns, the storeroom. He tells him: look after your brothers, settle their quarrels, and make sure everyone gets fed.
Years go by. The son grows old, and the farmer still hasn't come back. So what happens to the keys? Nobody thinks they get buried with the son. The farm still needs running. They pass to whoever takes up the job next.
Catholics read Jesus's words to Peter like that: a real job in God's household, handed on until the owner returns. Lutherans read it differently: one of their founding documents says the keys are given alike to all the apostles. Both readings come from the same verses.
Peter wasn't perfect
And here's something the Bible doesn't hide. Peter denied even knowing Jesus, three times, on the night Jesus was arrested.
Later says of Peter: I opposed him to his face because he clearly was wrong.5
Peter's role was never a promise that he'd always behave well, and the same goes for popes.
Why would the job carry on?
The Catholic Church teaches that made Peter the leader of the apostles. And it teaches that this role carries on in the bishop of Rome, to keep the Church united.9 Its , the summary of Catholic beliefs, says the pope has full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church.9
But why should a job given to one man carry on? To be honest, no verse says Peter's keys pass on. It's an inference.
Remember the king's steward in Isaiah 22? The key went with the office and passed to the next steward.2 Catholics read Peter's keys the same way.
The need carries on. Jesus built his Church to last until he returns, and the flock still needs a shepherd after the first one dies.
Why Rome?
Why Rome, and not Jerusalem, where Peter started out? Catholics answer that the role went with Peter, and most historians accept that Peter died in Rome. Even historians who denied he was ever its bishop accepted that.11
Around AD 96, the church in Rome wrote to the church at Corinth, in Greece, where a group had pushed out its leaders. It even said sorry for being slow to answer.6
Around AD 180, a bishop called described Rome as the church founded and organized by Peter and Paul. He wrote that every Church should agree with this Church.7
To be honest, scholars still argue over what he meant. The Latin word he used can mean agree with, or just come to. So some think he only meant that Christians from everywhere came to Rome.11
And neither text describes a pope like today's. But both show Rome speaking to other churches early, and expecting to be heard.
Irenaeus also wrote down a list of Rome's leaders. The apostles, he says, committed into the hands of Linus the office of the episcopate, the job of bishop, and he names each leader after him.7 Catholics count Peter as the first pope, and Linus as the second.11
Irenaeus was writing long after those first leaders, though. Historians like Sullivan ask whether each of them led the church in Rome alone.8
What a pope is not
A pope doesn't get new messages from God. In 1870 the said the was promised to Peter's successors not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new , but so they could guard what the apostles handed on.10
That's what the famous word infallible is about, and it's narrower than people think. It doesn't mean a pope can't or get things wrong. It means that when he solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Church, Catholics believe God keeps that definition from error.10
And it reaches only as far as what God has already revealed.9 He doesn't rule alone, either. The Catechism says the pope and the bishops are joined as one team, the way Peter and the other apostles were.9
Catholics accept that the office grew into its later shape over centuries. It's like the word , which came after the Bible, but Christians believe it names what the Bible teaches.
The question isn't whether the first century looked like today. It's whether today grew from what Jesus gave Peter.
Sources11
- 1Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope (1537), 25 (Book of Concord)The Lutheran reading: the Church is built on the ministry of Peter's confession.
- 2Matthew 16, with notes (New American Bible)The rock and the keys (16:18–19); the note links the keys to Eliakim in Isaiah 22.
- 3Luke 22 (New American Bible)Jesus prays for Peter: strengthen your brothers (22:32).
- 4John 21 (New American Bible)Tend my sheep, feed my sheep (21:15–17).
- 5Galatians 2 (New American Bible)Paul opposes Peter at Antioch (2:11).
- 6Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians (c. 96)The Roman church answers Corinth on the points it was consulted about.
- 7Irenaeus of Lyon, Against Heresies III.3 (c. 180)Rome founded by Peter and Paul; every church should agree with it.
- 8David Fiensy, review of Francis A. Sullivan, From Apostles to Bishops (2001), Catholic Books ReviewNo single bishop in Rome in the first century; the apostles did pass on their ministry to successors.
- 9Catechism of the Catholic Church, 880–882 and 891Peter and the apostles as one college; the pope as Peter's successor; the limits of infallibility.
- 10First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (18 July 1870), chapters 2 and 4Peter's primacy passes to his successors; the Holy Spirit is not promised for new doctrine.
- 11Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), The PopePeter's martyrdom in Rome accepted even by Harnack, who denied he was its bishop; the dispute over how to translate Irenaeus III.3.2.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.