From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/bible-forbidden
← Protestant or evangelicalWeren't Catholics forbidden to read the Bible?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minNo, there was never a ban for the whole Church. But at some times and places, Catholic leaders did restrict Bibles in everyday languages, mostly out of fear of false teaching. Today the Catholic Church urges everyone to read the , and says not knowing it is not knowing .
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 131–133
- Vatican II
- Dei Verbum, 22 and 25
- Vatican doctrine office
- Notification on the Index of Books
Many evangelicals grew up with this story. The Catholic Church kept the Bible chained up in Latin, where ordinary people couldn't read it. Then the Reformation set it free.
Some former Catholics say they never opened a Bible until they left.
That experience is real, and part of the story is true.
What really happened
Some of this history is hard to read.
In 1229, a local meeting of in Toulouse, France, banned ordinary people from owning the Bible, except the . It banned translations too.1 Other local meetings did similar things.2
In England in 1408, church leaders banned any English translation that bishops hadn't approved.3
Then came William Tyndale, an English scholar who translated the into English. In 1526 the Bishop of London had copies burned in public.4
In 1536 Tyndale was questioned by a Catholic inquisitor, a church investigator who hunted down false teaching. Then he was strangled and burned at the stake near Brussels. To be accurate, the charge was spreading 's ideas, not translating the Bible.4 But the burned Bibles came first.
After the Reformation, Rome tightened the rules. In 1559 it published its first official list of banned books, and it was so harsh it was soon replaced.2
Then, from 1564 until 1897, Catholics needed special permission to read even a Catholic Bible in their own language.2 That's more than 300 years.
What isn't true
But the popular story goes too far in one way. There was never a ban for the whole Church.
A Catholic encyclopedia from 1908 says so plainly: A general prohibition was never in existence.2
The rules from 1564 asked for permission. They didn't forbid every Bible outright. That was still a real barrier. But it's not the same as a ban on every Catholic reading the Bible.2
In some places the permission rule worked like a ban. In Italy, printing Bibles in Italian came to an abrupt halt.11
For the whole 1600s, the only new Italian translation was a Protestant one, printed in Geneva in 1607.11
And Bibles in everyday languages were printed before Luther, too. Germany had a printed Bible by 1466, and more than a dozen German editions came out before Luther's own.3
Why they did it
So why restrict the Bible at all? The first Catholic bans were aimed at groups using their own translations to back their own teaching.2
The worry was bad translations, and readings that split churches apart.
Think of it like this
Think of parents with small children and a cabinet full of medicine. The medicine isn't bad. It's there to make people well, and they know the kids will need it one day.
But they've heard stories. A child who took the wrong dose. A fake pill slipped into a real bottle. A neighbour's kid who got very sick. So they put the cabinet on the top shelf and lock it, and only the parents hold the key. When a child needs something, a parent measures it out.
You can see why they did it. You can also see the cost: the children grow up without ever learning what's in the cabinet or how to use it.
That was the thinking behind the rules, and that was the cost. Later, the Catholic Church decided the cabinet should be opened wide.
The fear wasn't only Catholic. In 1543, after England broke with Rome, its Parliament banned servants, apprentices, the poor, and women outside the upper classes from reading the Bible.5
But explaining isn't excusing.
Keeping people from God's word in their own language left generations of Catholics who barely knew the Bible.
That was a real failure, and many Catholics still feel it.
The cabinet opened wide
Today the Catholic Church says the opposite. In the 1960s the declared: Easy access to Sacred Scripture should be provided for all the Christian faithful.6
It asked for careful translations from the original Hebrew and Greek. It even said they could be made together with other Christians, so that all Christians will be able to use them.6
It didn't stop at permission. It urged everyone to read:
The Church "forcefully and specifically exhorts all the Christian faithful... to learn the surpassing knowledge of Jesus Christ, by frequent reading of the divine Scriptures. Ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ."
That last line goes back to the scholar who translated the Bible into Latin around AD 400.
In 2019 Francis quoted it again, when he set aside one Sunday every year as the Sunday of the Word of God.8
So do Catholics actually read the Bible at home now? The Church is asking them to. Francis even suggested that pastors give a Bible, or one of its books, to the whole congregation, so people learn to read, appreciate and pray daily with sacred Scripture.8
The old rules are gone. In 1966 the Vatican announced that the list of banned books no longer has the force of ecclesiastical law, meaning church law.9 It still asked Catholics to be careful with writings that could harm their faith.9
And the Catholic Church has even thanked Protestants for this. At a joint service with Lutherans in Sweden in 2016, Pope Francis said: With gratitude we acknowledge that the Reformation helped give greater centrality to sacred Scripture in the Church's life.10
Never a total ban, some real restrictions, and today an open invitation. Catholics are meant to know the Bible, because knowing it is how you come to know Christ.
Sources11
- 1Wikipedia, Council of Toulouse (1229)The local council that forbade lay people to own the Bible or any translation of it.
- 2Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), Censorship of BooksToulouse, Tarragona and Oxford restricted vernacular Bibles; no general prohibition; the 1559 Index and the 1564 rules, in force until 1897.
- 3Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), Versions of the BibleThe Synod of Oxford (1408); German Bibles printed from 1466; vernacular Bibles across Europe before the Reformation.
- 4Wikipedia, William TyndaleHis New Testament burned in London in 1526; arrested near Antwerp in 1535, convicted of Lutheran heresy and executed in 1536.
- 5Wikipedia, Act for the Advancement of True Religion (1543)Henry VIII's Parliament forbade many ordinary English people to read the Bible.
- 6Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (18 November 1965), 22 and 25Easy access to Scripture for all; translations, even with other Christians; frequent reading urged.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 131–133Access to Scripture open wide; ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ.
- 8Pope Francis, Aperuit illis (30 September 2019)Quotes Jerome; makes the Third Sunday in Ordinary Time the Sunday of the Word of God.
- 9Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Notification on the Index of Books (14 June 1966)The Index no longer has the force of church law.
- 10Pope Francis, Homily at the Ecumenical Prayer in Lund (31 October 2016)Thanks for the Reformation's gift of putting Scripture at the centre.
- 11Associazione Italiana Traduttori della Bibbia (AITB), History of the Bible in ItalyAfter the Index rules, printing Bibles in Italian met an abrupt halt; in the 1600s the only Italian translation was the Protestant Giovanni Diodati's (Geneva, 1607).
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.