Who decides?
This is about who settles a dispute over what the Bible means, Peter and Rome, and the corrupt popes.
This chapter is my own opinion, not a finding of the research. I’ve kept it separate on purpose, so nothing else on the site depends on it.
I didn’t come back to the Catholic Church because I grew up in it.
Plenty of people raised Catholic walk away, and for years I was basically one of them.
I came back because I put the Catholic Church through the same tests I had put every other belief through.
Does it make sense? Does it fit the history? Does it explain the world, and people? Does it change lives? It held.
The more I read, the more I saw that the real question underneath all the others is authority.
It isn’t whether the is God’s word, because almost every Christian agrees it is.
The real question is this: when two sincere Christians read the same Bible and come away with opposite answers, who settles it?
When two sincere Christians read the same Bible and disagree, who do you think settles it?
Pick an answer below.
Here’s an example that made it click for me.
In Acts, the Bible’s book about the first Christians, cloths that had touched , the great early preacher, were taken to the sick, and they were healed.
So one church looks at a saint’s , such as a bone or a piece of their clothing, and says God’s grace, his help, can flow through something like this.
Another church looks at the same relic and calls it idolatry, which means worshipping a thing instead of God. Both are holding a Bible. Both are sincere. So who’s right?
Or go further back. In the early 300s a priest called taught that Jesus wasn’t fully God.
He quoted Scripture too, and a lot of people followed him.
What settled it wasn’t one man’s opinion.
It was the of the Church, its leaders, meeting at Nicaea, a town in what is now Turkey, in 325.
The creed that came out of it, the short statement of what Christians believe, was finished at a second in 381.
It’s the one we still say at , the Catholic Sunday service.
That’s the point for me. Without one way of settling disputes that everyone accepts, you get what we see today.
There aren’t thousands of different gospels, but there are thousands of separate churches.
Many began when sincere people disagreed over what the Bible means, and saw no way forward except to start their own.
Every time we lean on our own understanding instead of what God handed down, we end up disagreeing.
And what God handed down is the Bible, and , which is what the , Jesus’s closest followers, handed on through their teaching and their way of life.
In the Catholic Church, both are guarded by its teaching office: the bishops together with the (the bishop of Rome), the point where unity holds.
And human disagreement is almost impossible to fix, because each of us is sure we’re the one who is right.
That isn’t a problem or a Catholic problem. It’s a human problem.
What the Catholic Church has is a way of ending an argument.
Disputes get taken to councils of bishops, prayed over, and argued out, sometimes for years.
Then the pope, the bishop of Rome, confirms what the council decided. His job is to keep the whole Church together as one.
Jesus gave , the leader of his twelve apostles, the keys of the kingdom of , a sign of authority.
After he rose from the dead, Jesus told Peter three times: feed my sheep.
Catholics believe the bishops of Rome carry on Peter’s job. The and most Protestants read those words differently.
Settling things this way is slow, and it’s often ugly to watch.
After Nicaea, the fight over Arius’s teaching ran on for more than 50 years, with bishops sent into exile and emperors taking sides.
But it finishes.
And Rome’s role isn’t something Catholics made up later.
Around AD 96, when the church in Corinth, in Greece, threw out its leaders, it was the church in Rome that wrote to set it right.
And it expected to be listened to.
Even the Bible came to us this way.
It was bishops meeting in councils at the end of the 300s who confirmed the list of books that belong in it.
The corrupt popes were a big one for me, and I went looking for the worst of it on purpose.
I found popes who lived like princes, sold for money, and abuse that bishops covered up.
An indulgence is a release, granted through the Church, from the leftover punishment for God has already forgiven.
I’m not going to pretend any of that away, and neither does this site.
Honestly, I love studying the Church’s failures, because they show exactly what happens when one part of the Church tries to put itself above the others.
Do the corrupt popes count against the Catholic Church?
Pick an answer below.
Here’s what surprised me. The pope isn’t above God’s word. He serves it. The Bible, Tradition and the Church’s teaching office keep each other in check.
So when a pope went wrong, he could be called out from Scripture and from what the Church had always taught, and in time it was put right.
Often it was ordinary people who called a pope out: saints, nuns, priests.
Catherine of Siena, an Italian woman in the 1300s, wrote to a pope living in Avignon, in what is now France, without softening a word.
She begged him to come back to Rome and clean up the clergy, and he came back.
The Church has stood for two thousand years, and the way I see it, that isn’t because of any pope or bishop.
It’s because the structure checks itself. To me that points to God’s design, not ours.
It says something about who he is: unchanging, and faithful even when we are not.
I’m still a skeptic, even here. But being a skeptic doesn’t mean I start by assuming the Church is wrong.
When something doesn’t sit right with me, my first question is: am I missing the full picture?
Papal was one of those. It sounded like Catholics believe the pope can’t make mistakes. He can, and he can sin like anyone else.
What it actually means is that the , God himself, guards the Church from teaching error when it solemnly defines what we believe.
Once I understood that, it became a different thing. It’s not about trusting that the pope is infallible. It’s about trusting that God is. Simple as that.