From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/what-about-the-bad-popes
← CatholicYes, there were bad , and in our own time church leaders failed abused children. Catholics don't deny it. The Catholic claim was never that popes would be good. It's that the faith they pass on would be kept from error.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Code of Canon Law
- canon 749
- Vatican I
- Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4
It's a fair question. If chose the pope to look after his people, how could some popes be so bad?
And the record is bad. Much of it was written down by Catholics themselves.
In 1045 one pope sold the job. He stepped down in return for a large sum of money, paid by his own godfather, who then became pope.1 Another, pope from 1492, had fathered at least four children after becoming a priest, says a Catholic encyclopedia from 1907.2
Worse, in our own time the victims were children. In 2009 an Irish government inquiry found that, until at least the mid-1990s, church leaders in Dublin put secrecy, avoiding scandal and protecting their name and money ahead of children.3
Ireland wasn't the only place. In 2018 Pope Francis wrote of many communities where abuse had happened, after another report on at least a thousand survivors abused by priests over about 70 years.5
In Mexico, a Vatican inquiry in 2010 found that Marcial Maciel, founder of a large religious order, had committed real crimes, including sexual abuse, and had built a system that kept the people around him silent.13
In 2019 Mexico's ' conference said it had records of 152 priests linked to probable abuse of minors, and told victims it pained and shamed them.14
In the Philippines, a US watchdog published a list in 2025 of 82 priests and brothers publicly accused of abusing minors. A Filipino cardinal answered by urging Catholics to report abusive clergy, whether in the civil or Church forums.15
Here's what surprises people.
Some of the harshest words came from popes themselves.
In 1523 a pope admitted the sickness in the Catholic Church had crept down from the head to the members, from the Popes to the hierarchy, its bishops and leaders.4 And Pope Francis wrote: We showed no care for the little ones; we abandoned them.5 That's an admission, not a defence.
So the question isn't whether popes and bishops sinned. They did. The question is what Christ actually promised, and whether the record broke that promise.
Nobody promised good popes
Catholic teaching never claimed popes would be good men. The Catholic Church says all its members, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners. In every one of us, it says, the weeds of stay mixed with the good wheat until the end of time.6
Jesus set it up that way himself. One of the twelve he chose was Judas, who betrayed him.
The says Christ working through a priest doesn't protect him from human weaknesses, the spirit of domination, error, even sin. But it's Christ who acts in the , so even the minister's sin cannot impede the fruit of .7 A corrupt pope can't spoil anyone else's or .
What was actually promised
What Catholics do claim is much smaller than people think. When a pope solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Church, Catholics believe God keeps him from error. That's called . It doesn't cover his letters, his politics, who he appoints, or his private life.8
The , which defined it in 1870, said the wasn't promised to popes so they could make known some new . It was so they could guard, and faithfully explain, the faith handed down from the .8
In other words, it's a promise about guarding the message, not about how popes behave.
Before the analogy below, one thing: the abuse of children isn't what it's for. Those are crimes against children, and they have their own answer here, on the abuse scandal.
Think of it like this
For the popes' own sins, like buying the job or fathering children, here's an analogy that might help. Think of a courier carrying a sealed letter across town to you. You've never met him and you never will. What matters to you is the letter.
The courier might be a terrible person: greedy, dishonest, a man you'd never trust with your own money. He might be sacked the next week.
But the letter is sealed. When it reaches you, you break the seal and read it exactly as it was written. The words, the ink, the signature: all just as the sender left them. His bad character doesn't change a single word inside.
Catholics believe that's what happened with the faith. Over 2,000 years, some of the men carrying it were bad, and a few were very bad. But the message stayed sealed.
The hardest case
Critics raise one pope more than any other: Honorius I. To see why, you need one belief first. Christians believe Jesus is fully God and fully human. And a real human has a human will: the power to want, to choose, to say yes or no.
The night before he died, Jesus prayed not my will but yours be done. Early Christian teachers read that as his human will freely saying yes to his Father.9
In the 630s Honorius wrote a letter that gave cover to a false teaching: that Jesus had only one will. That would make him less than fully human. In 681 a big meeting of bishops, a , rejected the idea and condemned Honorius by name.9
Catholics answer that the letter was careless and did harm, but didn't define anything or bind anyone.10 The pope who confirmed that council said Honorius failed to stamp out the false teaching and fostered it by his negligence: he let it spread.10
The reads it differently. For the Orthodox, a pope condemned by a council as a heretic, someone teaching against the faith, proves no pope is free from error.11
Catholics reply that, measured against the actual promise, the record holds. None of the bad popes, Honorius included, solemnly defined a false teaching.10
To be fair, that's a narrow test. And critics point out that Rome itself says which teachings count as solemnly defined. Isn't that circular?
The Catholic reply is that the conditions were set out in public in 1870, and can't be used quietly.8 Church law says no doctrine is understood as defined infallibly unless this is manifestly evident. A doubtful case doesn't count.17
So it's still a test that could have failed. One pope solemnly defining something that contradicted an earlier definition would break it. Catholics believe that has never happened.
Reform came late
In 2019 Francis made a law that clergy, and members of religious orders like monks and nuns, must report abuse quickly. It also covers bishops who try to block an investigation. And it says anyone can report.12 Every diocese must also have a public, stable and easily accessible way to make a report.12
That came decades after the harm. Only years of results will show if it works.
If anyone ever abuses you or someone you know, a priest or anyone else, tell a parent or another adult you trust. You can go to the police too: the Church's rules don't replace your country's law.12 And it's never the child's fault.
To report to the Church as well, look for your diocese's safeguarding or child-protection office, or ask at a parish office. In the Philippines, for example, every diocese must have one, and the bishops have a national office too.16 In Mexico, the bishops set up a national team for protecting minors in 2019.14
None of this excuses the sins. On the abuse of children there's no defence to offer, only the duty to protect children now and to tell the truth about the past.
So, the bad popes? Real. The faith was kept anyway, often by men who weren't worthy of it.
Sources17
- 1Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Gregory VI'Benedict IX gives up the papacy to his godfather, who pays him a large sum of money and becomes pope as Gregory VI.
- 2Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Pope Alexander VI'Alexander VI's four children, and his life as pope.
- 3Commission of Investigation, Report into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin (2009), 1.15The archdiocese put secrecy and its reputation ahead of children's welfare.
- 4Ludwig Pastor, The History of the Popes, vol. IX, pp. 134–135Adrian VI's instruction of 1522–23 admitting corruption from the popes downward.
- 5Pope Francis, Letter to the People of God (20 August 2018)The Pope's admission of the Church's failure to protect children, written after a report on at least a thousand survivors.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 827All members of the Church, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1550Christ's presence in his ministers does not preserve them from error or sin; their sin cannot block the sacraments.
- 8First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (18 July 1870), chapter 4Defines papal infallibility narrowly: guarding the faith handed down, not new doctrine.
- 9Third Council of Constantinople (680–681), sentence against the MonothelitesThe council confesses two natural wills in Christ, reads 'not my will but yours' as his human will, and condemns Pope Honorius by name.
- 10Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I'His letter defined nothing and bound no one; Leo II blamed his negligence.
- 11Ecumenical Patriarchate, Reply to the Papal Encyclical of Leo XIII on Reunion (1895), 18The Orthodox reading: Honorius, condemned as a heretic by a council, shows no pope is infallible.
- 12Pope Francis, Vos estis lux mundi (7 May 2019), articles 1, 2, 3, 6 and 19Obliges clergy and religious to report abuse; anyone may report; covers bishops who obstruct investigations; state law still applies.
- 13Communiqué of the Holy See regarding the Apostolic Visitation of the Legionaries of Christ (1 May 2010)Marcial Maciel's actions confirmed as real crimes; his system of silence; his victims.
- 14ACI Prensa, Iglesia en México: Nos duele y avergüenza abuso sexual de menores (February 2019), in SpanishMexico's bishops: records of 152 priests linked to probable abuse of minors; a national team for protecting minors set up in January 2019.
- 15National Catholic Register (CNA), Filipino Cardinal Urges Catholics to Report Clerical Abuse to Church and Civil Authorities (3 February 2025)A database of 82 priests and brothers publicly accused in the Philippines; the cardinal urges reports to Church and civil authorities.
- 16Radio Veritas Asia, CBCP Reaffirms Commitment to Safeguarding and Accountability (May 2025)The Philippine bishops' national Office for the Protection of Minors and Vulnerable Persons; every diocese mandated to have its own.
- 17Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 749§3: no doctrine is understood as defined infallibly unless this is manifestly evident.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.