← Catholic
What you have to believe

What does papal infallibility actually cover?

Read it as an illustrated story · 8 min

Much less than most people think. Catholics believe the is kept from error only when he solemnly settles a question of faith or morals for the whole Church. It doesn't mean he's sinless or always right. And it can't add anything new, only guard what the handed on.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
889–892

The word sounds like the pope can't be wrong. To a lot of people that sounds arrogant.

And some Catholics treat every word a pope says, even in an interview on a plane, as beyond question. Both have it wrong.

The real thing is much smaller than either side thinks.

Three conditions, all at once

Pope Pius IX and the Catholic of the world defined it in 1870, at the . It says the pope is kept from error only when, as teacher of all Christians, he settles a question of faith or morals for the whole Church.2

He must speak in his official role, not give his own opinion. It must be about faith or morals, not science or politics. And he must be settling it for good.

Take away any one of those, and it isn't an infallible statement.

When a pope does it, the wording leaves no doubt. In 1950, in the clearest case since 1870, Pius XII said he would pronounce, declare, and define that Mary was taken body and soul into . Even then, he first asked the world's bishops what their people believed.3

Most of what popes write isn't like this. It's ordinary teaching, the everyday kind. Catholics are still asked to accept it, with what the calls religious assent. It isn't the firm yes of faith, it says, but it's nonetheless an extension of it.1 An interview on a plane counts for less still.

So how many times has a pope done it? Nobody keeps an official count. When the Vatican gave examples of teaching held for certain in 1998, it said its list wasn't meant to be complete.10

Theologians generally agree on two: 1950, and 1854, when Pius IX defined that Mary was kept free from , the wound everyone is born with, from the first moment of her life.11

But one Catholic church historian, Klaus Schatz, counted 7 in a 1985 study: those two, plus 5 older papal documents going back to 449. There's still no complete list everyone accepts.12

That doesn't leave everything else up for grabs. Councils of the world's bishops can settle questions this way too, like the Council of Nicaea in 325, which declared Jesus of the same substance as God the Father.11 Solemn definitions are rare. They've usually come when a question was hotly disputed and needed settling.11

It can't add anything new

Here's the limit most people never hear about. The 1870 definition says the was promised to popes not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new .2

He was promised so they could guard and explain what the apostles handed on, which it calls the : everything God revealed, left in the Catholic Church's care.2

So a pope can't use to invent anything. He can only guard what the apostles handed on.

The Catechism puts the boundary in one line: This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.1

But what about the two beliefs about Mary, from 1854 and 1950? Don't they look like new teachings? Catholics say the exact words were new, but the beliefs behind them were old. Other Christians question that.

Think of it like this

Think of a family recipe, the one your great-grandmother made for every big occasion. Everyone cooks it a little differently. One cousin adds too much chilli, another forgets a step. Nobody panics. That's normal family cooking.

Then, once in a long while, a real argument breaks out over what the recipe actually says. Half the family swears there's cinnamon in it. The other half says never. So the aunt who keeps the original card, in great-grandma's own handwriting, reads it out, and from then on it's settled.

But notice what she can't do. She can't add a new ingredient and claim great-grandma wrote it. She can't swap the dish for a different one. She can only say what was already on the card.

That's infallibility in Catholic belief. Rare, formal, and only ever guarding what God already gave.

Not sinless, not always right

Infallibility doesn't mean popes are good men, or that they never teach badly.

In 681 a of the whole Church met in Constantinople. It condemned Pope Honorius for going along with a false idea about Jesus: that he had only one will, God's, and not a human will as well.6 Catholics answer that he never solemnly settled anything.6 But it shows a pope can get teaching badly wrong.

To a skeptic, that answer can sound convenient. But the three conditions were written down in 1870, so anyone can check a statement against them.

Why Catholics believe it

So why believe it at all? For Catholics, it isn't a superpower for one man. It's a promise about the whole Church.

The Catholic Church teaches that gave his Church a share in his own infallibility, so that God's people as a whole can't lose the faith the apostles handed on.1

Catholics point to what Jesus said to , the leader of his twelve apostles, at the Last Supper. Later that night, Peter denied three times that he even knew Jesus.5

But first, Jesus told him: I have prayed that your own faith may not fail; and once you have turned back, you must strengthen your brothers.5

Turned back means coming back after that denial. The verse is about Peter himself. Catholics believe his job, strengthening the rest, passed to the bishops of Rome after him.

Their reason: the Church would need that strengthening for as long as it lasts, not only while Peter lived. And by about AD 96, , a bishop of Rome, was already writing to settle a quarrel in the church at Corinth, in Greece.15

To be fair, this is the step other Christians question most. The verse names Peter, not his successors.

And they point to what happens without a final word. Every generation could reopen whether Jesus is God, and nobody could ever settle it. Many Protestants answer that the is that final word, with creeds and teachers to help. Catholics ask who decides when honest readers disagree.

The early Church settled questions like that by bringing its bishops together. Catholics believe the bishops share the same gift: when, united with the pope, they agree something must be held for good, above all at a council of the whole Church. And they see the pope as the one who strengthens the rest in their faith.4

Infallibility also covers teachings closely tied to what God revealed, like declaring someone a saint. Catholics hold those as final, trusting the Holy Spirit to keep the Church from getting them wrong.10

What the Orthodox ask

Christians see it differently. For the first thousand years, councils of bishops settled the big disputes, and the whole Church accepted them.

But the 1870 council said a pope's solemn rulings are final on their own, without needing the rest of the Church to agree: in its words, not by the consent of the church.2 That's the sticking point.

To be honest, 1870 wasn't smooth. The final vote was 433 to 2, but only after many bishops had gone home. They thought it the wrong time to define it, and accepted it afterwards. A group in Germany refused it and broke away, becoming the Old Catholics.9

An Orthodox history says 1870 made it a for the first time in history.7 In 1895 the Orthodox Church of Constantinople answered that the Church knows no one infallible upon earth except Christ.13

Take 1950. The Orthodox believe something very close: Mary truly died, and then her Son raised her up.14 What they question is one bishop defining it for everyone. Limiting what a pope can define doesn't answer their real question: who decides?

In 1995 asked other Christians to help him find a new way of being pope that keeps what's essential but is open to a new situation.8

So the Catholic claim is narrow on purpose. It isn't that the pope is always right. It's that God won't let his Church lose the .

Sources15
  1. 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 889–892The Church shares in Christ's infallibility; its forms and limits; ordinary teaching asks religious assent, distinct from faith.
  2. 2First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (18 July 1870), chapter 4 (Tanner's English translation, on Papal Encyclicals Online)The definition of papal infallibility and its purpose: to guard, not to reveal anything new.
  3. 3Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1 November 1950), 11–12, 44The bishops consulted in 1946; the solemn definition of the Assumption.
  4. 4Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 25Infallibility of the bishops with the pope and in council; no new public revelation.
  5. 5Luke 22 (New American Bible Revised Edition, USCCB)Jesus prays that Peter's faith may not fail.
  6. 6John Chapman, "Pope Honorius I", Catholic Encyclopedia (1910)The council of 681 condemned Honorius; Leo II confirmed it; no definition ex cathedra was involved.
  7. 7Orthodox Church in America, Church History: Roman Catholicism (19th century)An Orthodox account of Vatican I and the Old Catholic break.
  8. 8John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (25 May 1995), 95–96The pope asks other Christians to help find a new way of exercising the primacy.
  9. 9Johann Peter Kirsch, "Vatican Council", Catholic Encyclopedia (1912)The vote of 18 July 1870, the minority bishops' later acceptance, and Döllinger's followers forming the Old Catholics.
  10. 10Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio fidei (1998), 6, 11Truths connected to revelation, such as canonisations, are held definitively.
  11. 11Kenneth Doyle, "Question corner", Catholic Standard, Archdiocese of Washington (27 April 2022)Theologians agree a pope alone has used infallibility twice, in 1854 and 1950; councils such as Nicaea also teach infallibly.
  12. 12"Papal infallibility", Wikipedia (instances of infallible declarations)Klaus Schatz's 1985 list of seven papal documents he counts as ex cathedra, from 449 to 1950; no complete list exists.
  13. 13Ecumenical Patriarchate, Reply to the Papal Encyclical of Leo XIII on Reunion (1895)The Orthodox Church knows no one infallible on earth except the Son and Word of God.
  14. 14Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2: Dormition of the TheotokosThe Orthodox belief: Mary truly died and was raised by her Son.
  15. 15Clement of Rome, Letter to the Corinthians (c. 96)The church of Rome writes to settle the quarrel in the church at Corinth.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.