A page of Codex Vaticanus showing Matthew 1:22–2:18.
V / XI
313–787

The age of councils

In 313 Christianity becomes legal, and by the 390s it is the empire’s official religion. Now the big arguments about who Jesus is can be settled in the open, by councils, meetings of bishops from across the Church.

Is the Son truly God? At Nicaea in 325 the bishops say yes, against a priest named Arius, and Athanasius of Alexandria spends years in exile defending that answer.

Can Mary be called Mother of God? At Ephesus in 431 the answer is yes, because her son is one person, and that person is God.

Is Christ fully God and fully human? At Chalcedon in 451 the answer is one person in two natures, as Pope Leo had written.

Each answer also leaves a wound, over how to describe Christ, not over whether he is God. The Church of the East, already mostly beyond the empire’s eastern border in Persia, drifts away after 431.

After 451 so do the Oriental Orthodox Churches of Egypt, Syria, Armenia and Ethiopia.

The world: Roman Empire · Fall of the West · barbarian kingdoms · Islamic expansion
Codex Vaticanus, a fourth-century Greek Bible, open at Matthew 1–2.
The colossal marble head of Constantine in the Capitoline Museums, Rome.
313 · Milan
“When we, Constantine and Licinius, emperors, had an interview at Milan, and conferred together with respect to the good and security of the commonweal, it seemed to us that, among those things that are profitable to mankind in …”
On the Deaths of the Persecutors, chapter 48 (the letter of Constantine and Licinius, 313) · On the Deaths of the Persecutors 48
The colossal head of Constantine, Capitoline Museums, Rome.
313Historical

Edict of Milan

From 303 the emperors Diocletian and Galerius ran the worst persecution Christians had faced: churches torn down, Scriptures burned, clergy tortured. It failed.

In 312 Constantine, who credited the Christian God with his victory at the Milvian Bridge, took Rome, and in 313 he met his co-emperor Licinius at Milan.

They issued a letter giving Christians, and everyone else, freedom to worship as they chose, and ordered confiscated church buildings returned. Christianity went from illegal to legal, then to favoured. Twelve years later the emperor called the Council of Nicaea.

What the Church says

The Church welcomed freedom of worship for Christians. Its own teaching, stated in 1965, goes further: freedom from being forced in religion belongs to every person, Christian or not, because of human dignity (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

Icon of the First Council of Nicaea with the text of the Creed in Greek.
325 · Nicaea · Council of Nicaea
“Of the substance of the Father, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father … And whosoever shall say that there was a time when the Son of God was not, or that before he was begotten he was not … the Catholic and Apostolic Church anathematizes them.”
The Creed of the Council of Nicaea (325) · Creed of Nicaea
Icon of the Council of Nicaea, 325, with the Creed written out in Greek.
325Revealed

Council of Nicaea

A priest of Alexandria named Arius taught that the Son of God was a created being: the highest of creatures, but not God as the Father is God. He meant to protect God’s oneness; his bishop said a created Christ could not save.

The argument split the Eastern churches, and in 325 the emperor Constantine called the bishops to Nicaea, in modern Turkey.

About 300 came. They wrote a creed saying the Son is ‘of one substance’ with the Father, rejected Arius’s phrases, and fixed how to date Easter. Arianism kept imperial support for another fifty years before the council of 381 confirmed Nicaea.

In 2025, 1,700 years on, the pope and the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople, first in honour among Orthodox bishops, prayed the creed together at the site.

What the Church says

Nicaea is the first of the twenty-one councils the Catholic Church counts as ecumenical, and its creed is the faith of the Church. Catholics profess it, in the form completed at Constantinople in 381, at Mass every Sunday.

A bishop in a gold cope and mitre stands on the church steps, holding back an emperor in armour and a red cloak while soldiers and clergy look on.
Ambrose bars Theodosius from Milan's cathedral, as Anthony van Dyck imagined it around 1620. The scene at the church door is a later legend; Ambrose's own letter shows he wrote to the emperor privately.
380–392Historical

Christianity becomes the empire's religion

In 380 the emperor Theodosius ordered all his subjects to hold the faith of the bishops of Rome and Alexandria, the faith of Nicaea. Over the next twelve years his laws banned pagan sacrifice and closed the temples.

Within 80 years of the last persecution, Christianity had gone from a crime to the empire’s official religion.

The same emperor learned that bishops could stand up to him. After he ordered a massacre at Thessalonica in 390, Ambrose, bishop of Milan, refused to celebrate the Eucharist in his presence until he repented, and Theodosius did public penance.

“He made known by this law his intention of leading all his subjects to the reception of that faith which Peter, the chief of the apostles , had, from the beginning, preached to the Romans, and which was professed by Damasus, bishop of Rome , and by Peter, bishop of Alexandria.”
Ecclesiastical History, Book VII · Church History 7.4
What the Church says

The Church honours Ambrose as a saint and a Doctor of the Church, a title for saints whose teaching has served the whole Church. Its own teaching today rejects using the state to force faith: no one is to be forced to act against their beliefs in religion, privately or publicly (Dignitatis Humanae 2).

A ninth-century miniature of the Council of Constantinople from the Homilies of Gregory of Nazianzus, Paris gr. 510.
The council of 381 as painted about 880 in the Paris Gregory manuscript.
381Revealed

Council of Constantinople

By 381 the emperor Theodosius had restored the faith of Nicaea after decades of emperors who favoured its opponents, but a new argument had started over whether the Holy Spirit is God.

About 150 Eastern bishops met at Constantinople. They added the lines on the Holy Spirit to the creed, ‘the Lord, the giver of life, who proceeds from the Father’, which is the creed said at Mass today.

They also ranked Constantinople second after Rome, which planted a rivalry with Alexandria and, later, with Rome.

“And [we believe] in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver-of-Life, who proceeds from the Father, who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified, who spoke by the prophets. And [we believe] in one, holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. We acknowledge one Baptism for the remission of sins, [and] we look for the resurrection of the dead and …”
First Council of Constantinople (381): Creed and Canons · The Creed of the 150 Fathers (381), third article
What the Church says

The Church counts it as the second ecumenical council, and the creed it completed is professed at Mass. The Latin Church later added ‘and the Son’ to the article on the Holy Spirit, which became a lasting point of dispute with the East.

Two half-naked warriors haul a white marble statue off its plinth with ropes while others loot a Roman street around them.
The Visigoths sack Rome in 410, as Joseph-Noël Sylvestre imagined it in 1890.
410–476Historical

Rome falls in the West

In 410 the Visigoths, who were Christians but Arians, meaning they did not believe the Son was fully God, sacked Rome for three days, the first time the city had fallen to an enemy in 800 years. Pagans blamed the Christians for abandoning the old gods. In North Africa, Augustine began his answer, The City of God.

The western empire never recovered. In 476 a Germanic general, Odoacer, removed the last western emperor, a boy named Romulus Augustulus.

Germanic kings now ruled the West, the emperor ruled on in Constantinople, and in many cities the bishop became the person people turned to.

“The reliquaries of the martyrs and the churches of the apostles bear witness to this; for in the sack of the city they were open sanctuary for all who fled to them, whether Christian or Pagan .”
The City of God, Book I · City of God I.1
What the Church says

The Church honours Augustine as a saint and a Doctor of the Church. His City of God, written in answer to the sack of Rome, shaped the Christian belief that the Church does not depend on any empire.

Ruins of the Church of Mary at Ephesus.
The Church of Mary at Ephesus, where the council of 431 met.
431Revealed

Council of Ephesus

Nestorius, the new bishop of Constantinople, objected to calling Mary ‘Theotokos’, God-bearer. Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, wrote letters arguing that he was wrong, and Rome sided with Cyril.

In 431 a council met at Ephesus. Cyril opened it before the bishops from Antioch arrived and removed Nestorius in a single day; the Antiochenes held a rival council, and two years later the two sides agreed a formula of reunion. ‘Theotokos’ stood.

The churches in the Persian Empire did not accept the council and became the Church of the East.

“And since the holy Virgin brought forth corporally God made one with flesh according to nature, for this reason we also call her Mother of God.”
Council of Ephesus (431): Cyril's Second Letter to Nestorius and the sentence against Nestorius · Cyril, Second Letter to Nestorius
What the Church says

The Church counts Ephesus as the third ecumenical council and holds its teaching that Mary is truly Mother of God, because her son is one divine person (CCC 495).

431

Very deep but wounded communion

In the 400s, Christians lived on both sides of a hostile border. To the west was the Roman Empire, now Christian. To the east was the Persian Empire, in today’s Iraq and Iran, mostly Zoroastrian and often at war with Rome.

The church in Persia was old: since about 300 its bishops had answered to the bishop of the royal capital. But being a Christian there was dangerous. Rome was the enemy and Rome was Christian, so Persian kings often persecuted their Christians as Rome’s friends.

In 431 the Council of Ephesus, a meeting of the Empire’s bishops, removed Nestorius, bishop of Constantinople, for refusing to call Mary *Theotokos*, God-bearer. The Persian church had learned its theology from his side, the school of Antioch.

What we still share
  • The Nicene Creed, the summary of the faith agreed at the councils of 325 and 381. In 1994 both Churches confessed it as received “from the Apostles as formulated by our common Fathers”.
  • Bishops, priests and deacons in an unbroken line from the apostles, which each side recognises in the other: “the sacrament of Ordination to the ministerial priesthood in the apostolic succession” (1994).
  • Baptism, the Eucharist and the other sacraments, the signs through which Christians believe Christ himself acts (1994; Vatican II, *Unitatis Redintegratio* 15).
  • A Mass Rome accepts as real. Its Eucharistic prayer of Addai and Mari, one of the most ancient there is, does not tell Jesus’s words at the Last Supper as one story. Even so, in 2001 the Vatican **concluded that it “can be considered valid”**.
How they describe it

The Assyrian Church of the East sees itself as the apostolic Church of Thomas, Thaddeus and Bartholomew, which kept the faith of Nicaea: Christ is Son of God and Son of Man, “two qnome united in one Sonship”. It asks not to be called Nestorian, a name long used as an insult.

451

Very deep but wounded communion

After Ephesus (431) the argument about how Jesus is both God and man went on. Alexandria in Egypt, Cyril’s city, stressed that he is one: God the Word made flesh.

A monk at Constantinople, Eutyches, went further and taught that Christ’s humanity was swallowed up by his divinity.

In 449 a council at Ephesus, run by Dioscorus, bishop of Alexandria, backed Eutyches. Pope Leo called it the Robber Council: Flavian, the bishop of Constantinople, was roughly treated there and died soon after.

What we still share
  • One God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, as taught by the first three councils: “in conformity with the early three ecumenical councils, we confess one faith in the One Triune God” (Pope Paul VI and Coptic Pope Shenouda III, 1973).
  • ==The same faith in Christ, in different words.== In 1973 the two popes confessed him “perfect God with respect to His divinity, perfect man with respect to His humanity”.
  • Bishops in an unbroken line from the apostles: “the same succession of apostolic ministry” (Pope John Paul II and Armenian Catholicos Karekin I, 1996).
  • “The seven sacraments of Christ in His Church” (1973), the signs through which Christians believe Christ acts: baptism, the Eucharist, confession and the rest.
How they describe it

They hold that they kept the faith of Cyril of Alexandria, whom Catholics also honour, when Chalcedon’s “two natures” seemed to divide Christ. They are not “monophysites” like Eutyches: they confess “the one incarnate nature of the Word of God”, fully God and fully man.

Vasily Surikov’s 1876 painting of the Fourth Ecumenical Council at Chalcedon.
The Council of Chalcedon as painted by Vasily Surikov in 1876.
451Revealed

Council of Chalcedon

A monk named Eutyches taught that Christ had only one nature, his humanity absorbed into his divinity. A council at Ephesus in 449, run by Dioscorus of Alexandria with soldiers in the church, cleared him and removed his accuser.

Pope Leo called it a ‘robber council’ and sent a letter, the Tome, teaching two natures in one person.

In 451 several hundred bishops met at Chalcedon, accepted Leo’s letter, and defined Christ as one person in two natures, without confusion or separation. The churches of Egypt, Syria and Armenia heard the wording as Nestorian, meaning it split Christ in two, and separated.

They are the Oriental Orthodox churches; since 1973 their leaders and popes have said they share the same faith in Christ, though communion is not restored.

“This one and the same Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God must be confessed to be in two natures, unconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably united, and that without the distinction of natures being taken away by such union, but rather the peculiar property of each nature being preserved and being united in one Person and subsistence.”
Council of Chalcedon (451): Definition of the Faith · Definition of the Faith
What the Church says

The Church counts Chalcedon as the fourth ecumenical council, and its definition of Christ as one person in two natures is Catholic faith.

Since 1973 popes and Oriental Orthodox patriarchs have signed common declarations saying they share the same faith in Christ, though they word it differently.

The Abbey of Monte Cassino.
Monte Cassino, founded by Benedict in 529, rebuilt after 1944.
529Historical

Benedict founds Monte Cassino

Italy in the early 500s was falling apart: the Western empire had ended, Gothic kings ruled, and war was coming. Benedict, who had left Rome in disgust and lived as a hermit, founded a monastery on the hill of Monte Cassino around 529 and wrote a short rule for it.

Prayer at fixed hours, work, reading, staying in one place, obedience to an abbot the monks elect, every guest received as Christ. Over the next centuries Benedictine houses spread across Europe, copying books, farming, teaching, and sending missionaries to England and Germany.

“Idleness is the enemy of the soul. And therefore, at fixed times, the brothers ought to be occupied in manual labour; and again, at fixed times, in sacred reading.”
The Rule of Saint Benedict · Rule of St Benedict 48
What the Church says

The Church honours Benedict as a saint, and in 1964 Paul VI named him patron of Europe. His Rule is still lived by Benedictine monks and nuns around the world.

Saint Gregory the Great by José de Ribera.
Gregory the Great. José de Ribera, 17th century.
590Historical

Gregory the Great

In 590 Rome was half empty, struck by flood and plague and threatened by the Lombards, and the emperor’s men were far away. Gregory, a monk who had once run the city as its prefect, was elected pope against his will.

He used the Church’s estates to feed the city, negotiated with the Lombards himself, sent a monk named Augustine, not the famous bishop of Hippo, with about forty monks to convert England in 597, wrote a handbook for bishops, and reformed parts of the Roman Mass. The papacy became, in practice, the government of Rome, and Gregory still refused the title ‘universal bishop’.

“And you will become by so much the greater as you restrain yourself from the usurpation of a proud and foolish title … Wherefore, dearest brother, with all your heart love humility, through which the concord of all the brethren and the unity of the holy universal Church may be preserved.”
Registrum Epistolarum (Letters) · Register 5.18, to John, bishop of Constantinople (595)
What the Church says

The Church honours Gregory as a saint and a Doctor of the Church, and calls him ‘the Great’. The title he used for the pope, ‘servant of the servants of God’, is still used by popes today.

Saints of this age

17 lives, among many

Signs in this age

Why they are here. A Catholic does not believe in the Real Presence, that Christ is truly present in the consecrated bread and wine, because of Lanciano; the doctrine is older than every case in this column and would stand if all of them fell. The signs are here because people ask, because the site promised to show what the documents say, and because the honest answer to ‘are they real’ is that some are well documented as events, several have been judged supernatural or worthy of belief by their bishops, none is part of the faith itself, and ==no Catholic is obliged to believe in any of them==.

  • Tradition says that in the eighth century a monk of the Greek rite, doubting the Real Presence during Mass at Lanciano, meaning that Christ is truly present in the consecrated bread and wine, saw the host, the bread of Mass, become flesh and the wine become blood, which set into five pellets. The flesh and the pellets are still displayed in the sanctuary of San Francesco.

    Not established: No record exists from within eight hundred years of the event.