The RiverCrisis and calls for reform
1378–1417

The Western Schism

Two, then three, rival popes divide the Western Church for almost forty years, until the Council of Constance ends the split in 1417.

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

From 1309 the popes lived at Avignon in France. Gregory XI brought the papacy back to Rome and died there in 1378.

Under pressure from a Roman crowd, the cardinals elected an Italian, Urban VI; months later most of them said the vote was forced and elected Clement VII, who went back to Avignon.

Europe split between them, and even saints took different sides. A council at Pisa in 1409 added a third pope.

The Council of Constance ended it in 1417, removing or accepting the resignation of all three and electing Martin V. Its claim that a council stands above a pope was argued for a century.

Where we are

The situation

For almost 70 years, from 1309, the had lived at Avignon, in what is now southern France. The popes of those years were French, and so were most of the cardinals. The Romans felt abandoned.

In January 1377 Gregory XI brought the papacy back to Rome. Catherine of Siena, an Italian laywoman whose letters had begged him to come home, had pressed him hard. He died in Rome on 27 March 1378.

Everything now hung on the next election. If the cardinals chose a Frenchman, the Romans feared he'd take the papacy straight back to Avignon. They wanted a Roman pope, or at least an Italian.

Sixteen cardinals were in Rome: four Italians, one Spaniard and 11 Frenchmen, most of whom formed their own faction from the Limousin region. No group could win alone, and each was wary of the others.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Three popes at once

    By the time the Council of Constance opened, an attempt to end the schism at Pisa in 1409 had produced a third claimant instead of a solution.

    “To bring unity back to the church and to make an end to the schism which had divided the church since 1378 and which the council held at Pisa in 1409 had not healed but rather aggravated when it elected Alexander V as a third pope. When the council of Constance opened, Christians owed obedience to three different popes”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · editorial introduction (Tanner) on the papalencyclicals.net page
  2. 02

    Catherine of Siena and the return to Rome

    The Catholic Encyclopedia credits Catherine's pleading with Gregory XI's decision to leave Avignon, against the wishes of the French king and most of the cardinals.

    “Nevertheless she made such a profound impression upon the mind of the pope, that, in spite of the opposition of the French king and almost the whole of the Sacred College, he returned to Rome (17 January, 1377).”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'St. Catherine of Siena'
The problem

What was at stake

Who is the pope? For most of history that's a simple question. In 1378 it got two answers, and both came from the same cardinals.

In April they elected Urban VI, crowned him, and wrote to Europe's rulers that he was pope. By September the same men said the Roman crowd had forced the vote, so it didn't count.

If the April vote was free, Urban was pope and any second election was illegal. If it was made under fear, it was void. Only the men in the room could say, and they said both things.

For ordinary Christians this wasn't theory. Which were lawfully appointed, which pope to name in the prayers at , whom to obey: all of it turned on the answer.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Haec sancta: a council claims power 'immediately from Christ'

    To end a schism among popes, the council declared that everyone, 'even papal', must obey it in matters of faith, schism and reform.

    “First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith , the eradication of the said schism and the general reform of the said church of God in head and members.”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 5 (6 April 1415)
  2. 02

    Which sessions count is itself disputed

    The editors of the decrees note that the ecumenical standing of the sessions before Martin V's election, and the force of his later approval, are matters of dispute.

    “With regard to the ecumenical nature of the sessions, there is dispute about those before the election of Martin V and also about the significance and force of the approval which he gave to the matters transacted by the council.”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · editorial introduction (Tanner)
What happened

The event

The conclave, the locked meeting where cardinals elect a pope, opened on 7 April 1378. Romans got into the palace and stayed all night, drinking the wine and shouting ‘Romano lo volemo, o al manco Italiano’: a Roman, or at least an Italian.

Next morning the alarm bells rang. The cardinals quickly settled on Bartolomeo Prignano, archbishop of Bari: Italian, not a cardinal, and known as an honest, hard-working official. Later that day they voted for him again, to remove any doubt.

At first all went well. Every cardinal honoured Urban, they crowned him on 18 April, and even the six cardinals still in Avignon accepted him. Then Urban turned on them, harsh, suspicious and quick to anger, insulting the men he meant to reform.

That summer the French cardinals left Rome. On 2 August they declared the election invalid, and on 20 September, at Fondi, 13 cardinals elected Robert of Geneva as Clement VII. Driven out of southern Italy, he settled at Avignon.

Europe split almost in half. France, Spain and Scotland followed ; most of Italy and Germany, England and Flanders followed Urban. Each pope excommunicated the other, a church penalty cutting someone off from the , and each named new cardinals so his line could go on.

Go further· 5 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A night in the Vatican, April 1378

    The Catholic Encyclopedia's life of Urban VI tells how the crowd got into the palace before the vote.

    “When the cardinals entered the Vatican some of the populace stole into the palace and tried to extort the promise that an Italian pope would be chosen. Cardinal d'Aigrefeuille declared that the cardinals could not make any such concessions, but the disappointed people remained in the Vatican the whole night, drinking the wine”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Urban VI' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Urban VI'
  2. 02

    The cardinals at first accepted Urban

    Even the cardinals who later rejected him first wrote to Europe's rulers announcing his election.

    “On the very next day the Sacred College gave official notification of Urban's accession to the six French cardinals in Avignon; the latter recognized and congratulated the choice of their colleagues.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', part 1
  3. 03

    Frequens: councils to be held regularly

    Before electing a pope, the council decreed that general councils should meet at fixed intervals, as the cure for heresy and schism.

    “The frequent holding of general councils is a pre-eminent means of cultivating the Lord’s patrimony. It roots out the briars, thorns and thistles of heresies, errors and schisms, corrects deviations, reforms what is deformed and produces a richly fertile crop for the Lord’s vineyard.”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 39 (9 October 1417), Frequens
  4. 04

    A rule against elections made under fear

    The same session voided any future papal election brought about by fear or pressure, the charge that had started the schism in 1378.

    “If it happens in the future that the election of a Roman pontiff is brought about through fear, which would weigh upon even a steadfast man, or through pressure, then we declare that it is of no effect or moment and cannot be ratified or approved by subsequent consent even if the state of fear ceases.”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 39
  5. 05

    11 November 1417: one pope again

    The conclave elected Cardinal Oddo Colonna, who took the name Martin V.

    “On 11 November cardinal Oddo Colonna is elected pontiff as Martin V.”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 41 (8 November 1417), editors' note
What came of it

The outcome

Thirty years of talks failed. In 1409 cardinals from both sides held a , a gathering of bishops to settle Church matters, at Pisa.

Pisa removed both popes and elected a third, but neither of the others stepped down. Now there were three.

The Council of Constance (1414–18), pushed by Sigismund, king of Germany and Hungary and later emperor, ended it. It deposed, that is formally removed, John XXIII, the Pisan pope. Gregory XII of the Roman line resigned of his own accord.

Benedict XIII of the Avignon line refused. When the Spanish kings abandoned him, so did Vincent Ferrer, his own confessor. Constance deposed him in 1417, and on 11 November elected Martin V.

To get there, Constance had declared in 1415 that even a pope must obey a general council in matters of faith, the and reform. That claim, conciliarism, was argued for a century.

The in 1870 rejected it, defining the pope's full authority over the whole Church.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Vincent Ferrer gives up Benedict XIII

    The saint who had been the Avignon pope's chief support turned against him once the Spanish kings did.

    “St. Vincent Ferrer hitherto the main support of Benedict, and his confessor, now gave him up as a perjurer”
    Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance'
  2. 02

    Reform 'in head and members' promised

    The council's own formula for its second task, after unity, was reform of the Church in head and members; its later sessions passed statutes on it.

    “the general reform of the said church of God in head and members”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, sessions 5 and 43
  3. 03

    The question left open

    Whether Haec sancta binds the Church is where the fifteenth-century argument about councils and popes begins, and it runs into the Reformation and past 1870.

    “the teachings of Vatican 1 on papal primacy are inconsistent with those of the first [non-ecumenical] Council of Constance [in particular the famous session 5, Haec Sancta, which taught conciliarism] , but not with those of the second [ecumenical] one”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · editorial note on the papalencyclicals.net page
Why it matters

For the trail

For 39 years sincere Christians couldn't tell who the pope was. Even the saints took different sides. Catherine of Siena wrote letters for Urban; Vincent Ferrer, a famous Spanish preacher, backed Clement.

So Catholics don't claim that their leaders are always wise, holy or even easy to identify. What they hold is narrower: that keeps the Church from losing the faith, not that every pope or cardinal acts well. The chapter on crisis sets it out.

It also shows how the split was healed. No side won the argument. All three claimants resigned or were removed, so the Church could start again with one pope.

The 1378 conclave left a rule behind. In 1417 Constance declared that any papal election made under fear or pressure is void.

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Saints on both sides

    The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia lists the holy people who followed each claimant in good faith.

    “The saints themselves were divided: St Catherine of Siena, St. Catherine of Sweden, Bl. Peter of Aragon, Bl. Ursulina of Parma, Philippe d'Alencon, and Gerard de Groote were in the camp of Urban; St. Vincent Ferrer, Bl. Peter of Luxemburg, and St. Colette belonged to the party of Clement.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Western Schism', part 1
  2. 02

    What the Church does not claim

    Forty years with two or three popes is the plainest evidence that Catholicism does not claim its leaders are always competent, holy or even identifiable. What it claims the Spirit protects is narrower, and the chapter on crisis sets it out.

    “everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it”
    Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 5
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Church has never solemnly ruled which line was lawful, but its official list of popes counts the Roman line (Urban VI, Boniface IX, Innocent VII, Gregory XII) as the true popes of the Schism.

The idea that grew out of Constance, that a council stands above a pope, was not accepted. The Church teaches that no council is ecumenical unless Peter's successor confirms it, and that the pope has ‘full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church’ (CCC 882, 884).

In plain terms

Think of it like this

Three men each holding a letter that says they're the rightful head, and no court that everyone accepts.

For nearly 40 years Europe had two and then three men claiming to be pope, each with his own cardinals, each excommunicating the others, splitting kingdoms, universities and even saints between them. It ended when a council removed or accepted the resignation of all three and started again.

Read the text
“First it declares that, legitimately assembled in the holy Spirit, constituting a general council and representing the catholic church militant, it has power immediately from Christ; and that everyone of whatever state or dignity, even papal, is bound to obey it in those matters which pertain to the faith, the eradication of the said schism and the general reform of the said church of God in head and members.”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 5 (6 April 1415), Haec sancta

The decree by which a council ended a schism among popes. Whether it binds the Church is still argued; the notes below give the arguments.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Was Urban really pope? The Church has never formally ruled on it. The Avignon side said the crowd's threats made the April vote unfree. The Roman side answered that the cardinals voted twice, crowned Urban and served him for months before objecting.

Most historians and lawyers have sided with Rome. In 1904 the Vatican's corrected list of popes kept Urban and his successors and left out the Avignon and Pisan claimants. A Catholic encyclopedia in 1912 called that ‘a very strong presumption’, not proof.

Who was to blame? That same encyclopedia faults the cardinals, whose evidence was ‘conflicting, not disinterested, and perhaps insincere’.

Others stress Urban's temper. Years later, when some of his own cardinals plotted against him, he had them tortured, and five were put to death.

Constance's decree Haec sancta, that a council stands above a pope, is still argued over. Some Catholic theologians hold it bound only that emergency, or never bound at all. histories read it as a council placing itself above the pope.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Which line was legitimate: a Catholic reference work's answer in 1912

    The Catholic Encyclopedia surveys six centuries of argument and concludes that a decision is now possible 'if not definitive'. Its strongest evidence is the 1904 official list of popes, which dropped the Avignon and Pisan claimants; it calls that a presumption, not a proof.

    “After six centuries we are able to judge more disinterestedly and impartially, and apparently the time is at hand for the formation of a decision, if not definitive, at least better informed and more just. ... If this deliberate omission is not proof positive, it is at least a very strong presumption in favour of the legitimacy of the Roman popes”
  2. 02

    The Orthodox reading: a council above the pope

    The Orthodox Church in America's history reads Constance as the high point of a movement that held councils supreme, and quotes Haec sancta as the council's own claim to bind even the pope.

    “The West in the early decades of the 15th century was in turmoil over the relationship between the Papacy and Church councils. Some held that the Papacy was supreme. Others held that the authority of the Church councils supersedes that of the Pope of Rome. ... This council, the 16th in the listing of ecumenical councils of the Roman Church, also asserted that even the Pope is to be subject to the dictates of an ecumenical council”
  3. 03

    Urban and the cardinals who plotted against him

    The Catholic Encyclopedia does not spare Urban: cardinals who conspired to depose him were tortured, and all but one were put to death at Genoa.

    “During the voyage the Bishop of Aquila, one of the conspirators, was executed, and the cardinals, excepting Adam Aston, were put to death at Genoa, in spite of the intervention of the doge.”
    Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Urban VI' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Urban VI'

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next