Jan Hus burned at Constance
The Council of Constance condemns the Czech preacher Jan Hus as a heretic and hands him to the secular power, which burns him on 6 July 1415, though he came under the king’s safe-conduct.
Jan Hus was a Czech priest and master of Prague's university who preached in Czech against the sins of the clergy, at a time when two and then three men claimed to be pope. He followed much of the English theologian John Wyclif, whose teaching had been condemned.
In his book On the Church he taught that the true Church is the number of those God has chosen for salvation, so that a wicked pope is no true head of it.
In 1414 he went to the Council of Constance under a safe-conduct from King Sigismund, hoping to be heard. Within weeks he was arrested.
On 6 July 1415 the council condemned him as a heretic and handed him to the secular authorities, who burned him outside the city that day. Bohemia rose in revolt, and from his followers came the Unity of the Brethren, today's Moravian Church.
The situation
Around 1400 Bohemia, today's Czech Republic, was part of the Holy Roman Empire. Germans held much of the power in its politics and at Prague's university, and many Czechs resented it.
Many were also bitter about their clergy. Even the Catholic Encyclopedia admits the clergy then ‘offered too many elements of weakness’ to reformers. And the Church had no clear head: from 1378 two men claimed to be , and from 1409 three.
Jan Hus, a priest and master of the university, preached in Czech at Prague's Bethlehem Chapel against the of the clergy. He read the English theologian John Wyclif closely, though Church authorities had already condemned many of Wyclif's ideas, and put one of his books into Czech.
In 1409 the king gave the Czechs control of the university, and thousands of German masters and students left. In 1410 the archbishop of Prague had Wyclif's books burned and excommunicated Hus: a church penalty cutting him off from the , not a physical punishment.
In 1411 Pope John XXIII, one of the three claimants, offered , a release from the punishment still owed for forgiven sins, to raise money for a war against the king of Naples. Hus attacked them.
Rome ordered his arrest, and late in 1412 Hus left Prague for the countryside, where he wrote his book On the Church.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Wyclif’s books burned in Prague, 1410
The Catholic Encyclopedia’s article on Hus traces how the Archbishop of Prague, on a papal bull, moved against Wyclif’s writings, and Hus with them.
“In accordance with the Bull the archbishop at the June synod of 1410, ordered Wyclif's writings to be burned and restricted preaching to the churches named above.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Jan Hus' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Jan Hus', by Joseph Wilhelm - 02
Indulgences for a pope’s war, 1411
What turned Hus from a critic into an open rebel, in Rome’s eyes, was his attack on the indulgences one of the rival popes offered to fund a war.
“With no less vehemence Hus attacked the Bulls (9 September and 2 December 1411) in which John XXIII proclaimed indulgences to all who would supply funds for the crusade against Ladislaus of Naples.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Jan Hus' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Jan Hus', by Joseph Wilhelm - 03
A clergy that invited attack
The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of the council describes the mood in Bohemia when Hus rose to lead it.
“he had gone rapidly to the front as a leader of his nation, then deeply embittered against the Germans dominant in the political and academic life of Bohemia”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', on Hus
What was at stake
On the Church taught that the true Church is ‘the total number of those predestined to ’, known to God alone. So, Hus argued, a pope living in sin is no true head of the Church, and a priest must preach even when forbidden.
When his judges ruled against him, he appealed over their heads to . The real question was who decides: the Church through its in , or each believer reading Scripture by his own conscience.
The men at Constance had come to end the and reform the Church. To them, Hus's ideas made the chaos worse: if no one could say who truly belonged to the Church, no bishop's or pope's ruling would hold.
They also lived in a world where heresy, denying a truth the Church holds as revealed by God, was a crime against the state as well. German law codes had punished it with burning since the 1200s.
Hus hoped to win the council over by argument. It meant to judge him.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The first condemned article
The council listed thirty articles from Hus’s books. The first sets out the idea of the Church on which the rest depend.
“There is only one holy universal church, which is the total number of those predestined to salvation.”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 15, condemned articles of J. Hus, no. 1 - 02
An appeal over the Church’s head
The sentence names Hus’s appeal from his judges to Christ as one of his chief offences.
“bypassing the church’s intermediaries, he has made appeal directly to our lord Jesus Christ, as to the supreme judge”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 15, sentence of degradation against J. Hus - 03
Burning for heresy was already the law
The same article notes that German law codes of the 1200s already prescribed the stake for heresy, which is how the council's judges saw the matter.
“In the medieval German codes known as the Sachsenspiegel (about 1225) and the Schwabenspiegel (about 1275), heresy is already punishable with the stake.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', on Hus
The event
King Sigismund, who had pushed for the council, urged Hus to come and gave him a safe-conduct, a royal letter of protection for his journey. Hus left Prague on 11 October 1414 and reached Constance on 3 November.
Pope John XXIII lifted his excommunication but banned him from saying or preaching. Hus kept saying Mass. On 28 November he was arrested and held, first in a Dominican convent and then in a castle.
His Czech friends protested that the king's word had been broken. Sigismund was angry at first, but on 1 January 1415 said he wouldn't stop the council dealing with heresy according to law.
Public hearings followed on 5, 7 and 8 June 1415. Hus denied some charges and defended other teachings. He refused to call his articles errors unless he was shown from Scripture that they were wrong.
On 6 July, in the cathedral, the council condemned him as a heretic, stripped him of the priesthood and handed him to the secular authorities. They burned him that day outside the city, and threw his ashes into the Rhine.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Hus’s answer, written in prison
On the eve of a hearing in June 1415, Hus wrote to his friend John of Chlum the reply he would give if he were allowed pen and paper.
“I, John Hus, a servant of Christ in hope, refuse to state that any one of the articles taken from my book is erroneous, lest I condemn the opinion of the holy doctors, and especially of the blessed Augustine.”
The Letters of John Hus, with introductions and explanatory notes · Letter LV, to John of Chlum (dated by the editors 6 June 1415), Workman and Pope (1904), p. 210 - 02
The king’s advice to the council
Sigismund, whose safe-conduct Hus carried, spoke to the council after the hearing of 8 June. Hus’s friends John of Chlum and Peter Mladenowic reported his words, which the editors of Hus’s letters retell.
“If, therefore, he be unwilling to adjure and preach against his errors, let him be burnt, or do with him according to your laws.”
The Letters of John Hus, with introductions and explanatory notes · Workman and Pope (1904), editors' introduction to Letter LVIII, pp. 217-18 - 03
Jerome of Prague, 30 May 1416
Jerome, a layman and Hus’s friend, recanted in prison, then withdrew his recantation before the council. The 1911 Britannica quotes the Italian humanist Poggio Bracciolini on his death.
“none of the Stoics with so constant and brave a soul endured death, which he (Jerome) seemed rather to long for.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Jerome of Prague'
The outcome
Bohemia took the burning as an insult to the whole nation. On 2 September 1415, 452 nobles of Bohemia and Moravia sealed a protest calling the sentence unjust. The council burned Hus's friend Jerome of Prague on 30 May 1416.
In July 1419 a Hussite crowd stormed Prague's town hall and threw the councillors from the windows to their deaths. Violence against priests and the burning of monasteries followed. Crusade after crusade against the Hussites failed.
Peace came only in 1436 with the Compacts of Basel, which let Bohemians receive the chalice at . Pius II declared them void in 1462. Hus became the nation's .
From a small, peaceful circle of his followers came the Unity of the Brethren, founded in 1457, today's Moravian Church. In 1999 expressed ‘deep regret for the cruel death inflicted on John Hus’, and in 2015 Francis said Hus had become ‘a reason for dialogue’.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
452 seals
On 2 September 1415 the nobles of Bohemia and Moravia answered the council.
“Four hundred and fifty-two of them appended their seals to a joint answer to the council, setting forth their conviction that the sentence on Hus was unjust and insulting to their country, that there were no heretics in Bohemia, that any assertion to the contrary was itself a heresy of the worst kind.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites', by Joseph Wilhelm - 02
A future pope’s verdict
Aeneas Sylvius Piccolomini, later Pope Pius II, was struck by how the two men died, as the Catholic Encyclopedia records.
“The death of both Hus and Jerome of Prague affected strongly other humanists of the time; Æneas Sylvius (later Pius II) said that they went to their deaths as men invited to a banquet.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', by Thomas Shahan - 03
The Compacts, 1436
After years of war, the envoys of the Council of Basel met the Bohemians at Jihlava (Iglau). Pius II declared the Compacts void in 1462.
“The representatives of the council, on their side, removed the ban from the Bohemians and acknowledged them as true sons of the Church.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites', by Joseph Wilhelm - 04
Prague, 30 July 1419
The Catholic Encyclopedia tells how the Hussite revolt began with killings at the New Town hall, followed by attacks on clergy and monasteries.
“all persons found therein were thrown out of the windows on to the spears and swords of the processionists, and hacked to pieces”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Hussites', by Joseph Wilhelm
For the trail
Here the Moravian channel leaves the main stream on the River, 50 years before Luther's Ninety-five Theses. In 1467 the Unity of the Brethren gave itself a ministry apart from the bishops in communion with Rome.
The Catholic reading is that authority was the real question. The Church teaches that bishops ‘by divine institution have succeeded to the place of the ’ (Lumen Gentium 20). An appeal from them to Christ alone leaves each conscience its own court.
On the method, the Church now stands nearer to Hus than to his judges. Among the articles the council condemned was his protest against handing the unrepentant to the state for punishment. Since 1965 the Church has taught that no one may be forced in religion.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Hus against the secular arm
Article 14 of those the council condemned is Hus’s protest against handing the unrepentant to the state. The Church’s teaching since 1965 stands far nearer to his protest than to the practice his judges defended.
“Doctors who state that anybody subjected to ecclesiastical censure, if he refuses to be corrected, should be handed over to the judgment of the secular authority, are undoubtedly following in this the chief priests, the scribes and the pharisees who handed over to the secular authority Christ himself”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 15, condemned articles of J. Hus, no. 14 - 02
A cardinal of Prague at Vatican II
In 1990 John Paul II recalled that Cardinal Beran, Archbishop of Prague, had spoken of Hus at the Second Vatican Council while defending religious freedom, and had deplored the excesses of that time. He returned to it in Prague in 1997.
“I quoted the "heartbreaking words" which I heard Cardinal Beran say at the Second Vatican Council on "the case of the Bohemian priest Jan Hus."”
Apostolic Journey to the Czech Republic: to the representatives of other religions · John Paul II, address to representatives of other Churches, Prague, 27 April 1997, §4 - 03
The Moravians’ own confession
The Moravian statement of faith does not tell the division as the fault of one side.
“We confess our share in the guilt, which is manifest in the severed and divided state of Christendom.”
The Ground of the Unity · The Ground of the Unity (Unity Synod 1995), Chapter I, The Unity of the Church
What the Church says
In 1999 John Paul II expressed ‘deep regret for the cruel death inflicted on John Hus, and for the consequent wound of conflict and division’. In 2015 Francis said Hus ‘has become a reason for dialogue’. Neither withdrew the council's judgement on his teaching about the Church.
On the burning itself the Church has changed course. It teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2), and in 2000 asked forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.
The same teaching judges the Hussite killings of priests and monks. Moravians born into their church ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3), and their baptism truly joins them to Christ (UR 22).
“This holy synod of Constance, seeing that God’s church has nothing more that it can do, relinquishes John Hus to the judgment of the secular authority and decrees that he is to be relinquished to the secular court.”
The sentence before it declares Hus ‘a true and manifest heretic’. A fortnight earlier he had written from prison: ‘If I were convinced that any of my articles were contrary to the truth, I would most gladly amend and revoke them, and teach and preach the opposite’.
Where people disagree
Did the council break the king's word? Czechs have always said so. The Catholic historian Funk, followed by the Catholic Encyclopedia, separates the arrest, which Bohemia counted a breach of faith, from the sentence, which a safe-conduct could never block.
Even the English editors of Hus's letters grant that only a papal safe-conduct could have shielded him from a church court. Yet in September 1415 the council itself decreed that no safe-conduct from emperors or kings could stop a competent judge inquiring into heresy.
Was Hus a heretic? He denied many of the charges, including the claim that bread remains bread after the consecration. His errors, as Catholics read them, concerned the Church itself: who belongs to it and who governs it.
Czech national tradition, and the churches that descend from his followers, see a reformer burned for preaching the . An older Catholic verdict, from 1908, called his principles a recipe for ‘both religious and civil anarchy’.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
The safe-conduct: the Catholic case
The Catholic Encyclopedia, following the church historian Franz Xaver von Funk, separates the arrest from the sentence.
“The former act was always accounted in Bohemia a violation of the safe-conduct and a breach of faith on the emperor's part; on the other hand they knew well, and so did Hus, that the safe-conduct was only a guarantee against illegal violence and could not protect him from the sentence of his legitimate judges.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', by Thomas Shahan - 02
Hus’s own editors agree in part
Herbert Workman, who edited Hus’s letters in English, makes the same point in a footnote.
“In reality the Pope's safe-conduct could alone have guaranteed his immunity from the Inquisition. Sigismund's safe-conduct did not reach the spiritual sphere.”
The Letters of John Hus, with introductions and explanatory notes · Workman and Pope (1904), p. 160, note 1 - 03
But the council ruled on safe-conducts
Eleven weeks after Hus died, the council settled the question in its own favour. The editors of the decrees summarise the session.
“It is also decreed that, notwithstanding safe conducts of emperors and kings and others, a competent judge can inquire into heresy”
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Council of Constance, session 19 (23 September 1415), editors' summary - 04
What Hus denied
Accused of Wyclif’s teaching that bread remains bread after the consecration, Hus rejected the charge, as the Moravian historian J. E. Hutton tells the scene.
“I have never held, taught or preached ... that in the sacrament of the altar material bread remains after consecration.”
A History of the Moravian Church (2nd edition) · J. E. Hutton, A History of the Moravian Church (1909), Book One, ch. II - 05
A harsh Catholic verdict from 1908
The older Catholic reading judged Hus’s principles a danger to Church and state alike, and said so bluntly.
“They were surely incompatible with either the ecclesiastical or the civil order of the time, and would at any period have bred both religious and civil anarchy, had they been put into practice.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Council of Constance', by Thomas Shahan
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Council of Constance · 1414–1418 · papalencyclicals.net, from Norman P. Tanner (ed.), Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils
- Jan Hus; translated and edited by Herbert B. Workman and R. Martin Pope · 1904 · Hodder and Stoughton; Internet Archive full text (University of Toronto copy)
- Thomas Shahan · 1908 · Robert Appleton Company; New Advent transcription
- John Paul II · 1999-12-17 · Holy See
- J. E. Hutton · 1909 · Moravian Publication Office, London; Project Gutenberg eBook #2099