Rome falls in the West
The Visigoths sack Rome in 410; in 476 the last western emperor is removed. Augustine answers those who blame the Christians.
In 410 the Visigoths, who were Christians but Arians, meaning they did not believe the Son was fully God, sacked Rome for three days, the first time the city had fallen to an enemy in 800 years. Pagans blamed the Christians for abandoning the old gods. In North Africa, Augustine began his answer, The City of God.
The western empire never recovered. In 476 a Germanic general, Odoacer, removed the last western emperor, a boy named Romulus Augustulus. Germanic kings now ruled the West, the emperor ruled on in Constantinople, and in many cities the bishop became the person people turned to.
The situation
For centuries Germanic peoples had lived beyond the Rhine and the Danube, trading with Rome, raiding it and serving in its armies. In 376, fleeing the Huns, the Visigoths crossed the Danube into the empire.
Many of them were Christians, but Arian Christians, taught by missionaries like Ulfilas, who translated the into Gothic. They did not believe the Son was fully God.
Mistreated by Roman officials, the Visigoths rebelled, and in 378 they killed the emperor Valens at Adrianople. Theodosius made peace with them. After he died in 395, the empire was split between his sons, and the western half was the weaker.
The Visigoths' king, Alaric, wanted land and a recognised place for his people inside the empire. When the western government wouldn't give it, he marched on Rome itself.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Across the Danube, then against the emperor
The Catholic Encyclopedia tells how the Visigoths entered the empire fleeing the Huns, and why they turned on it.
“In 376 a force of 200,000 Visigoths crossed the Danube, but oppression by the governors led to a revolt. They traversed the country plundering as they went, and defeated Valens in 378 near Adrianople.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Visigoths' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Visigoths' - 02
What Alaric wanted
The same article describes Alaric's aim: a Gothic kingdom on Roman soil, tied to Roman civilisation.
“Alaric sought to establish a Germanic kingdom on Roman soil by bringing his people into connection with Roman civilization.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Visigoths' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Visigoths'
What was at stake
Rome had not fallen to a foreign enemy in 800 years. To many it was the eternal city, protected by its gods for as long as they were honoured.
Now the temples were closed and the emperors were Christian. If Rome fell, many pagans would say the Christians had caused it by abandoning the gods.
The event
In August 410 Alaric's army entered Rome and plundered it for three days. Buildings were burned, and people were killed, raped and enslaved.
Alaric's Goths were Christians of their own kind. They spared those who took refuge in the churches of the and the shrines of the , Christian or pagan, reports.
Refugees fled across the sea to North Africa. There Augustine, of Hippo, heard pagans blaming for the disaster. He began a reply that grew into 22 books: The City of God.
The western empire never recovered. Vandals took North Africa, and Rome was sacked again in 455. In 476 a general named Odoacer removed the last western emperor, a boy called Romulus Augustulus, and ruled Italy as king.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Augustine on the pagans who blamed Christ
Augustine's opening complaint: some who survived by sheltering in Christian churches then blamed Christ for the city's suffering.
“Meanwhile I will briefly, and to the best of my ability, explain what I meant to say about these ungrateful men who blasphemously impute to Christ the calamities which they deservedly suffer in consequence of their own wicked ways”
The City of God, Book I · City of God I.1 - 02
476: a king in Italy
The Catholic Encyclopedia records the end of the western line of emperors.
“Odoacer spared his life, gave him a year's income, and sent him with his relatives to Cape Misenum opposite Baia.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Romulus Augustulus' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Romulus Augustulus'
The outcome
There was no longer a Roman emperor in the West. The emperor in Constantinople ruled on, and the East would call itself the Roman Empire for another thousand years.
In the West, Germanic kings now ruled, and by 500 the map looked like this: Visigoths in Spain, Vandals in Africa, Franks in Gaul, Ostrogoths in Italy. Most were Arian Christians ruling Catholic populations; the Franks were pagan, until their king Clovis was a Catholic around 500.
In many cities the bishop became the person people turned to: the one who stayed, bargained with kings, ransomed captives and fed the poor.
For the trail
Augustine's answer shaped how Christians understood history. Every human city rises and falls, Rome included. The Church is not the empire, and its hope doesn't depend on any kingdom.
That freed the Church in the West to outlive Rome. The monk and the of later footprints, and , are the Church carrying on without an emperor.
What the Church says
The Church honours Augustine as a saint and a Doctor of the Church. His City of God, written in answer to the sack of Rome, shaped the Christian belief that the Church does not depend on any empire.
Think of it like this
When the company folds, the night shift keeps the lights on.
The empire that had protected and then sponsored the Church collapsed in the West. The people who stayed at their posts were mostly bishops and monks, who went on teaching, feeding and praying with no government above them. Augustine gave them the reason: they had never belonged to the company in the first place.
“The reliquaries of the martyrs and the churches of the apostles bear witness to this; for in the sack of the city they were open sanctuary for all who fled to them, whether Christian or Pagan .”
Where people disagree
Historians argue about the word ‘fall’. Some see a violent collapse that wrecked trade, cities and reading. Others see a slower change, as Roman and Germanic ways blended.
And 476 meant less to people at the time than it does to us. Odoacer still acknowledged the emperor in Constantinople, and daily life in Italy went on.
This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.
- Augustine of Hippo · c. 413 · New Advent, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers I/2
- 1907–1912 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- 1907–1912 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent