Christianity becomes the empire's religion
Theodosius makes the Nicene faith the law of the empire and closes the pagan temples. In 390 Ambrose makes the emperor do penance.
In 380 the emperor Theodosius ordered all his subjects to hold the faith of the bishops of Rome and Alexandria, the faith of Nicaea. Over the next twelve years his laws banned pagan sacrifice and closed the temples.
Within 80 years of the last persecution, Christianity had gone from a crime to the empire’s official religion.
The same emperor learned that bishops could stand up to him. After he ordered a massacre at Thessalonica in 390, Ambrose, bishop of Milan, refused to celebrate the Eucharist in his presence until he repented, and Theodosius did public penance.
The situation
In 313 Christianity became legal. For the next 60 years it grew under emperors who favoured it, but Rome's old gods kept their temples, festivals and worshippers, especially among the great families of Rome.
One emperor, Julian, tried to turn the clock back, restoring the old gods from 361. He died in battle against the Persians less than two years later, and the attempt died with him.
Christians were divided among themselves too. For decades emperors had backed who rejected the creed of Nicaea, and in many cities rival bishops claimed the same church.
In 378 the emperor Valens was killed fighting the Goths at Adrianople. The western emperor, Gratian, chose a Spanish general, Theodosius, to rule the East. He came from a family that held the Nicene faith.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
A Nicene family
The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that Theodosius's parents held the Nicene faith when its opponents were strongest.
“His father, the Comes Theodosius, was a distinguished general; both he and the mother Thermantia were Catholics at a time when Arianism was at its strongest.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I'
What was at stake
Theodosius faced invading Goths, a divided Church and an empire still half pagan. Like every Roman ruler before him, he believed the empire's safety depended on worshipping God rightly.
Earlier emperors had applied that belief to the old gods, and punished Christians for refusing them. The question now was whether a Christian emperor would do the same in reverse.
The event
In February 380 Theodosius issued a law from Thessalonica. Later that year, after a serious illness, he was . All his subjects were to hold the faith taught by to the Romans and held by the bishops of Rome and Alexandria.
Only those who confessed the Father, the Son and the as equal could call themselves the Catholic Church. Others were to be treated as heretics, people who reject a teaching of the faith, and punished.
He gave the churches of Constantinople to the Nicene bishops and called the of 381. The historian Sozomen says his laws against other Christian groups were severe, but mostly meant to frighten, not to punish.
Against the old religion he went step by step. By 391 and 392 his laws banned pagan sacrifice and closed the temples. Christians destroyed some of them. In 391 a crowd backed by Alexandria's bishop, Theophilus, tore down the Serapeum, the great temple of the god Serapis.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Who may be called the Catholic Church
Sozomen, writing in the 440s, summarises the law of 380.
“He enacted that the title of Catholic Church should be exclusively confined to those who rendered equal homage to the Three Persons of the Trinity, and that those individuals who entertained opposite opinions should be treated as heretics , regarded with contempt, and delivered over to punishment.”
Ecclesiastical History, Book VII · Church History 7.4 - 02
Laws meant to frighten
The Catholic Encyclopedia quotes Sozomen's judgement that the emperor threatened more than he punished.
“However Sozomen says that the emperor "made severe punishment by his laws but did not carry them out, for he did not wish to punish, but only to frighten his subjects, that they might think as he did about Divine things, And he praised those who were converted of their own accord"”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I', citing Sozomen 7.12 - 03
Sacrifice treated as treason
The same article sums up the laws against the old religion.
“In short his laws put an end finally to the old cult, at any rate as far as open and public use is concerned.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'Theodosius I'
The outcome
Within 80 years of the last persecution, Christianity had gone from a crime to the official religion. Now it was the old religion that was against the law.
The same emperor learned that the Church's bishops could stand up to him. In 390 a crowd in Thessalonica killed his officials. Theodosius ordered a punishment in which thousands of citizens were massacred; the ancient figure is 7,000.
Ambrose, bishop of Milan, wrote to him privately. He would not celebrate the in the emperor's presence until Theodosius repented. The emperor took off his royal robes and did public penance in church.
When Theodosius died in 395, the empire was split between his two sons, one in the East and one in the West. It was never united again.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Ambrose: 'I dare not offer the sacrifice'
Ambrose's private letter to the emperor after Thessalonica. He does not threaten; he refuses to celebrate the Eucharist with the emperor present until he repents.
“I dare not offer the sacrifice if you intend to be present.”
Letter 51, to Theodosius · Letter 51 - 02
'Stripping himself of every emblem of royalty'
Ambrose described the penance in his funeral sermon for Theodosius in 395, as quoted by the Catholic Encyclopedia.
“"Stripping himself of every emblem of royalty", says Ambrose in his funeral oration (c. 34), "he publicly in church bewailed his sin . That public penance, which private individuals shrink from, an Emperor was not ashamed to perform;”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'St. Ambrose' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'St. Ambrose', quoting De obitu Theodosii 34
For the trail
This is the beginning of what later ages called Christendom: a society where Church and state were bound together, and faith was public law.
It brought an emperor who could be called to account by a bishop. It also brought the state's power to punish into matters of faith, a pattern that would cost many lives in the centuries ahead.
It's the first time the River shows Christians holding the power to force others. Much of the story from here is about how they used it.
What the Church says
The Church honours Ambrose as a saint and a Doctor of the Church, a title for saints whose teaching has served the whole Church. Its own teaching today rejects using the state to force faith: no one is to be forced to act against their beliefs in religion, privately or publicly (Dignitatis Humanae 2).
Think of it like this
The tenants become the landlords.
For three centuries Christians lived as tenants in a house that belonged to Rome's gods, and were thrown out whenever the owner chose. Under Theodosius the deeds changed hands. The new owners promised to run the house better, and in some ways did, but they also began evicting others.
“He made known by this law his intention of leading all his subjects to the reception of that faith which Peter, the chief of the apostles , had, from the beginning, preached to the Romans, and which was professed by Damasus, bishop of Rome , and by Peter, bishop of Alexandria.”
Where people disagree
Historians debate how far these laws were enforced. Pagans remained numerous for generations, especially in the countryside and among Rome's old families.
The famous scene of Ambrose stopping the emperor at the church door comes from a later writer, Theodoret. Even the Catholic Encyclopedia judges it greatly exaggerated; Ambrose's own letter is quieter and firmer.
The Church's teaching today is clear on the deeper question. The taught in 1965 that no one may be forced to act against their beliefs in religion.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
The church-door scene was exaggerated
The Catholic Encyclopedia itself rejects the dramatic version of the story.
“The long-received story, set afoot by the distant Theodoret, which extols the Saint's firmness at the expense of his equally pronounced virtues of prudence and meekness - that Ambrose stopped the Emperor at the porch of the church and publicly upbraided and humiliated him - is shown by modern criticism to have been greatly exaggerated.”
Catholic Encyclopedia, 'St. Ambrose' · Catholic Encyclopedia, 'St. Ambrose'
This page was written from general knowledge. Its key quote hasn’t been checked against the source yet, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it.
- Sozomen · c. 440s · New Advent, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers II/2
- 1907–1912 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- Ambrose of Milan · 390 · New Advent, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers II/10