Full text
No religion, or not sure · About 6 min ·  · The Church's record

Isn't it really just about power and control?

The short answer

At times, yes, and the records prove it. But power can't explain how the Church began: for most of its first 300 years, being a Christian could get you killed, and there was nothing to grab. Catholics believe authority in the Church exists to serve, and they judge their leaders by that.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

Big institutions protect themselves. And religious ones can use guilt and fear to keep people in line.

Plenty of young people feel it. In a 2021 US survey, young people were asked how much they trust religious institutions, out of ten.

Five or less, said 52% of those with a religion, and 80% of those without one.

Then came the abuse scandal: priests abusing children, and hiding it.

In 2018 only 31% of US Catholics rated the honesty of clergy, people like priests and ministers, as high. That was a record low.

And history gives critics plenty. Church jobs were bought and sold.

Take Alexander VI, elected in 1492 as , the leader of the whole Catholic Church. He was widely believed to have bought the job.

And in a Church whose priests promise not to marry, he had at least four children.

Power has been part of the story, and pretending otherwise helps nobody.

So the real question isn't whether churchmen have grabbed power. They have.

It's whether power is what the whole thing is really about.

Part 2 · There was nothing to grab

Go back to the very start.

Around AD 112, a Roman governor called Pliny wrote to the emperor about the Christians he was putting on trial.

Those who wouldn't give up their faith, he wrote, I ordered executed.

And what were these dangerous people doing? They met before dawn, and sang a hymn to Jesus, the one they followed, as to a god.

And they promised not to cheat, steal or commit adultery.

For most of Christianity's first 300 years, being a Christian could get you killed.

There was no power to grab, and no money in it.

Yet people kept joining, for about ten generations, though it offered nothing an ambitious person wants.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a bakery that's been in one family for generations. Today it's famous, with queues round the block.

The grandson running it barely looks up when you order, and the prices keep going up. You could say it's all about money now.

Maybe for him, it partly is. But that doesn't tell you why the bakery exists.

His great-grandmother started it from her kitchen window, baking bread for neighbours who could barely pay.

Some days she gave it away. She kept going through bad years, when nobody wrote about her and there was nothing in it for her.

To understand the bakery, you can't only look at today's queue. Look at how it began. The Church is like that.

Some of its leaders have used it for power. But power can't explain why people joined when it could get them killed.

Part 3 · A harder version

To be fair, there's a harder version of the question. Even with no money or property, early Christianity gave people a kind of power.

It offered belonging, certainty, and authority over its members. That's real, and the old sources alone can't rule it out.

Then again, every family, team and cause offers belonging and certainty. That doesn't make them a con.

What matters is what the people in charge do with it, and what they're told to do with it.

Part 4 · The boss is the servant

So what you can check is whether the Catholic Church's own founding words push against the abuse of power.

They do, and sharply.

Jesus told his , his twelve closest followers, that rulers lord it over people, but it shall not be so among you. Then he said:

whoever wishes to be great among you will be your servant
Mark 10:42–45

The Catholic Church teaches that authority in the Church is real, and that it exists entirely to serve.

Catholics believe that applies to everyone with authority in the Church, popes included.

The , the Church's summary of its beliefs, goes further. Church leaders, it says, must freely become the slaves of all.

In the 1960s the world's bishops met at the .

They called the Church at the same time holy and always in need of being purified.

Catholics don't claim their leaders are clean.

They claim Jesus is, and they measure their leaders against him.

Part 5 · It kept the evidence against itself

Here's something worth noticing. Institutions built only on control tend to bury the evidence against themselves.

The Catholic Church has buried some, as the abuse scandal showed. But it also kept, and published, a lot of evidence against itself.

Remember Alexander VI, the pope with at least four children? Those facts come from a Catholic encyclopedia.

And in 1881 Pope Leo XIII opened the Vatican's secret archives to scholars.

In 1998 the Vatican opened the files of its own Inquisition, its old court for heresy, to researchers too.

And when reform came, it named the abuse.

In 1562 the , a meeting of Catholic bishops in northern Italy, shut down the travelling fund-raisers who collected money by promising .

In Catholic teaching, an indulgence is a release from the after-effects of God has already forgiven.

Those after-effects are the damage and consequences sin leaves behind, which still need healing.

The Council condemned the fund-raisers' wicked abuses. And it admitted that earlier meetings had tried to stop them, and failed.

To be fair, that reform came late. Around 1517 , a German monk, had already stood up to the indulgence trade.

His protest helped start the Reformation, the split that created the churches. Luther was right that this was an abuse.

Today the rule that leaders serve has some teeth. Under a 2019 law, made permanent in 2023, bishops themselves can be reported.

They can be reported for things they did, or failed to do, to dodge abuse investigations.

The complaint today is often more personal: rules about sex that most people break, and a priest you have to confess to.

The Church's own law cuts against control here.

A priest who reveals anything said in confession is excommunicated on the spot, cut off from the .

The Church only requires Catholics to confess serious sins, at least once a year.

And the rules on sex bind priests and bishops more strictly than anyone.

To be fair, guilt has been misused. If you were made to feel dirty or afraid, the people teaching you got it wrong.

The Church teaches that guilt is meant to lead you to forgiveness, not to keep you down.

Power explains what some churchmen did with the Church.

But it doesn't explain why people joined when joining could get them killed, or why its founding words condemn the abuse of power.

Quick check

Think back to the bakery. The grandson barely looks up and keeps putting the prices up. What does that tell you about why the bakery started?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Read next
Sources 15
  1. Religion in Public, Trust in religious institutions is low among Gen Z (Springtide Research Institute data, 19 February 2021) · 52% of religiously affiliated and 80% of unaffiliated young people rate trust in religious institutions at 5 or below out of 10.
  2. Gallup, U.S. Catholics' Faith in Clergy Is Shaken (2019) · A record-low 31% of US Catholics rate the honesty and ethics of the clergy (no denomination specified) as high (2018).
  3. Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Pope Alexander VI · A Catholic reference work records his election by simony and his four children.
  4. Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96, to the Emperor Trajan (c. AD 112) · A Roman governor executes Christians and describes what they did when they met.
  5. Council of Trent, Session 21 (16 July 1562), Decree on Reformation, chapter 9 · Abolishes the questors of alms for their 'wicked abuses'.
  6. Mark 10:42–45 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus: whoever wishes to be great among you will be your servant.
  7. Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964), 8 · The Church at once holy and always in need of being purified.
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 876 · Ministry in the Church is service.
  9. Pope Francis, Vos estis lux mundi, updated (25 March 2023) · Bishops can be reported for interfering with or avoiding abuse investigations.
  10. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1472
  11. Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), Martin Luther · Luther's theses against the preaching of indulgences, 31 October 1517.
  12. National Catholic Register, Without 'Fear of Past,' Vatican Opens Secret Archives (1998) · the Holy Office (Inquisition) archives opened in 1998; Leo XIII opened the Vatican archives to scholars in 1881
  13. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1451–1458 · contrition leads to forgiveness; 1457, confess serious sins at least once a year
  14. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1461–1467 · 1467, the sacramental seal and its very severe penalties
  15. Code of Canon Law, canon 1386 (2021 revision of Book VI) · a confessor who directly violates the seal incurs an automatic excommunication