Part XVI · Chapter 36
Bad popes, antipopes and scandals

If the pope is Christ's chosen shepherd, how could popes buy the office, father children and put a corpse on trial, and how could bishops hide the abuse of children? What exactly did Christ promise?

10 scenes · about 27 min read

The short answer

Because never promised good . The scandals are real, and Catholics wrote down most of them.

In 897 a pope put his dead predecessor on trial. In 1045 a pope sold the papacy. Renaissance popes bribed cardinals and fathered children.

In our own time, moved priests who abused children and hid what they had done. On the abuse of children the Catholic Church has no defence.

What Catholics believe Christ promised is narrow. In 1870 the said a pope is kept from error only when he solemnly defines a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Church.

None of these popes did that to teach something false. The hardest case, Pope Honorius in the 630s, wrote a careless letter about Christ's will that defined nothing.

That doesn't prove the Catholic claim. It shows the claim wasn't broken where it could have been. And reform almost always came late.

Follow the trail

Ten scenes, from Constantinople in the 600s to Dublin in 2009, most of them told in the Catholic Church's own documents.

681Historical2 min read

A council condemns a pope by name

The Third Council of Constantinople, confirmed by Pope Leo II

In 681 a of the whole Church, meeting at Constantinople, condemned Pope Honorius I by name. He had died more than forty years before. His letter had given cover to a false teaching, and the pope in Rome confirmed the sentence.

A gold apse mosaic with Saint Agnes in the centre in jewelled robes, flanked by two popes; the pope on the left holds a model of the church.
The seventh-century apse mosaic of Sant'Agnese fuori le mura, Rome. Pope Honorius I, who rebuilt the church, stands on the left holding its model.
IWhat was going on

In the 600s the Roman Empire was ruled from Constantinople, today's Istanbul, and it was fighting for its life. A long war with Persia had only just ended. From the 630s Arab armies were taking Syria, Palestine and Egypt.

Many Christians in those lands had rejected the of 451. A council is a meeting of bishops, and this one had said Christ is fully God and fully man in one person.

They had rejected it for nearly two hundred years. The emperor Heraclius badly wanted them back in one Church with him. A divided empire was easier to conquer.

IIWhat was at stake

Church leaders in Constantinople found a formula that seemed to bridge the gap: Christ has one 'operation', one activity. In Egypt whole communities came back into the one Church on that basis.

But a monk named Sophronius objected. If Christ had no real human activity, he wasn't fully human. The argument soon moved on to Christ's will, his power to choose, and the same problem came with it.

The question was whether Jesus really chose, as a man, to obey the Father.

IIIWhat happened

Around 634 Sergius, the patriarch of Constantinople, wrote to Pope Honorius in Rome for advice. A patriarch is the bishop of one of the great senior churches.

Honorius answered that it was best not to speak of one operation or of two. He wrote that 'we acknowledge one Will of our Lord Jesus Christ'. He seems to have meant that Christ's human will never fought against God's.

But the words gave cover to the teaching called Monothelitism, Greek for 'one will'.

IVWhat came of it

Honorius died in 638 with a good name. Supporters of the one-will teaching went on quoting his letter for decades.

In 680–681 the Third Council of Constantinople taught that Christ has two wills, divine and human, working in harmony. It condemned Honorius by name and anathematised him: it declared him cut off from the Church.

Pope Leo II confirmed the sentence. But he explained that Honorius was condemned for failing to stamp out the one-will teaching, not for teaching it.

VRead the source
And with these we define that there shall be expelled from the holy Church of God and anathematized Honorius who was some time Pope of Old Rome, because of what we found written by him to Sergius, that in all respects he followed his view and confirmed his impious doctrines.
Third Council of Constantinople (680-681): extracts from the Acts and the sentence against the Monothelites · Session XIII, sentence against the Monothelites (trans. H. Percival, NPNF 2nd series vol. 14)

Why it matters

Honorius is the hardest case for the Catholic belief that a pope is kept from error when he defines the faith. And it was a council of the Church that made the record, not the Church's critics.

Catholics answer that his letter was careless and harmful, but defined nothing for the whole Church. The answer that a council judging a pope is exactly the right order of things. Both readings are set out below.

January 897Historical2 min read

A dead pope is put on trial

Pope Stephen VI

In January 897 in Rome, Pope Stephen VI had the body of Pope Formosus dug up. It was dressed in a pope's robes and put on trial. It was political revenge, carried out in a church court.

IWhat was going on

By the late 800s the empire of Charlemagne, which had joined much of western Europe under one ruler, had broken up. Rival lords fought over Italy and over the title of emperor. Only a pope could give that title, by crowning.

The popes also ruled lands around Rome, and Roman noble families fought over who would be elected. A pope who crowned the wrong man made deadly enemies.

IIWhat was at stake

Formosus became pope in 891. He was forced to crown Guido of Spoleto and his son Lambert as emperors. Spoleto was a dukedom in central Italy, and its dukes pressed hard on Rome.

So Formosus secretly called in a rival, the German king Arnulf. Arnulf took Rome and was crowned by Formosus in 896.

Then Arnulf fell ill and went home, and Formosus died in April 896. Lambert and his mother Agiltrude came back into power in Rome, determined to undo everything Formosus had done.

IIIWhat happened

Stephen VI, probably under pressure from Lambert and his mother, called a synod, a church meeting, of the Roman clergy. Formosus's corpse was set on a throne in a pope's robes. A , a junior clergyman, answered for him.

The charge was a real church rule. A bishop wasn't meant to move from one diocese to another, and Formosus had been bishop of Porto before Rome.

The synod declared him never truly pope. It cancelled every he had performed, so the priests and bishops he had made were declared not ordained.

IVWhat came of it

Rome turned against Stephen. Later in 897 he was thrown out and strangled.

Within two years Popes Theodore II and John IX had Formosus reburied in St Peter's and cancelled the trial. Then Sergius III, pope from 904 to 911 and from the opposing party, approved it again.

Priests ordained by Formosus were left unsure for years whether they were priests at all.

VRead the source
A deacon was appointed to answer for the deceased pontiff, who was condemned for performing the functions of a bishop when he had been deposed and for passing from the See of Porto to that of Rome. The corpse was then stripped of its sacred vestments, deprived of two fingers of its right hand, clad in the garb of a layman, and ultimately thrown into the Tiber.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Stephen (VI) VII' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Stephen (VI) VII', by Horace Mann

Why it matters

It shows how low the papacy could sink when Roman politics took hold of it. A church court became a weapon.

It also shows something that kept happening: later popes undid what bad popes had done. The trial of a dead man was reversed, even if it took time, and even if a later pope brought it back.

963Historical2 min read

A prince's son is made pope, then removed

Liudprand, bishop of Cremona, reporting the Roman synod of 963

In 955 Octavius, son of the prince who ruled Rome, became pope at eighteen and took the name John XII. His father had made the nobles swear to elect him. In 963 a synod of bishops heard grave charges against him and removed him.

IWhat was going on

For most of the first half of the 900s, a few Roman noble families controlled the papacy. The strongest was the family of Theophylact, his daughter Marozia and her son Alberic.

Alberic ruled Rome as its prince for over twenty years. Before he died in 954, he made the nobles swear in St Peter's that his son Octavius would be the next pope. The papacy had become a family inheritance.

IIWhat was at stake

Octavius became pope in December 955 and took the name John XII. He was a teenage prince, more interested in war and hunting than in the Church. His court gained a name for immorality.

Then King Berengar of Italy seized lands the pope ruled. John called in the German king Otto I and crowned him emperor in 962. Then he turned against Otto and plotted with Otto's enemies.

IIIWhat happened

Otto came back to Rome in November 963, and John fled. A synod, a church meeting, of about fifty Italian and German bishops met in St Peter's, with Otto presiding.

It heard charges of murder, adultery, incest and perjury, lying under oath. It also heard charges of simony, selling church offices. Liudprand, bishop of Cremona and one of Otto's men, wrote the main account of the synod.

The synod removed John. Then, against church law, it chose a layman, someone who wasn't a priest, and he became Leo VIII.

IVWhat came of it

Once Otto left, John came back early in 964. He drove out Leo VIII and punished those who had turned against him, some by mutilation. He died in May 964, still in his twenties.

The German emperors went on claiming a say in who became pope for the next hundred years.

VRead the source
As regards his adultery, though they had no visual information, they knew for certain that he had carnal acquaintance with Rainer's widow, Stephana his father's concubine, the widow Anna, and his own niece, and that he had turned the holy palace into a brothel and resort for harlots.
The Works of Liudprand of Cremona: Antapodosis, Liber de rebus gestis Ottonis, Relatio de legatione Constantinopolitana · Liber de rebus gestis Ottonis (Chronicle of Otto's Reign), ch. 10, trans. F. A. Wright (1930), p. 222

Why it matters

A word of caution about the source. Liudprand served Otto, and he wrote to justify removing a pope. But Catholic historians accept that John's life was a scandal.

The real lesson is what happens when the papacy belongs to a local family. It took two centuries of reform to free the election of popes from Roman nobles and emperors.

1045 to 1046Historical2 min read

A pope sells the papacy

Benedict IX and his godfather John Gratian

In 1045 in Rome, Pope Benedict IX handed the papacy to his godfather, a priest, for a large sum of money. Within a year three men claimed to be pope.

IWhat was going on

In the early 1000s the counts of Tusculum, a noble family from the hills outside Rome, controlled the election of popes. Two brothers from the family had already been pope.

In 1032 the count, Alberic, put his own son on the papal throne at about twenty. He became Benedict IX.

The Catholic Encyclopedia, a Catholic reference work of the early 1900s, calls him 'a disgrace to the Chair of Peter', the papacy.

IIWhat was at stake

In 1044 a rival group drove out of Rome and set up another pope, Sylvester III. Benedict fought his way back.

Then he asked his godfather, John Gratian, whether a pope could resign. It is said he wanted to marry. John was a priest known for his good life, and he wanted Rome rid of an unworthy pope. He paid Benedict to step down.

IIIWhat happened

John Gratian was recognised as pope in May 1045 and took the name Gregory VI. Even Peter Damian, a strict reformer, welcomed him at first.

But buying a church office is simony. It is named after Simon the magician, who tried to buy the apostles' power in Acts 8, the 's account of the first Christians.

Benedict soon changed his mind and claimed the papacy again. Sylvester never gave up his claim either. Rome had three men calling themselves pope.

IVWhat came of it

Clergy and lay people asked the German king Henry III to restore order. In December 1046 bishops met in a synod at Sutri, a town north of Rome. It removed Sylvester and set Benedict aside.

Gregory VI was persuaded that his own election was simony, and he resigned. A German bishop became Pope Clement II.

Gregory's chaplain, a monk named Hildebrand, went with him into exile. He later became Pope Gregory VII, the great reformer.

VRead the source
he offered to give up the papacy into the hands of his godfather for a large sum of money. ... John Gratian in all good faith and simplicity paid him the money and was recognized as pope in his stead.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Gregory VI' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Gregory VI', by Horace Mann

Why it matters

The sale of the papacy was the lowest point, and it was also where the turn began. Within a few years popes started a long campaign against simony and against kings choosing bishops.

In 1059 a decree gave the election of popes to the cardinals, the senior clergy of Rome. Cardinals still elect the pope today.

c. 1376Historical2 min read

A laywoman tells the pope to reform

Catherine of Siena, writing to Gregory XI at Avignon

For decades the popes lived at Avignon, in today's southern France. Catherine of Siena, an Italian laywoman, wrote to Pope Gregory XI. Come home to Rome, she told him, and clear corrupt clergy out of the Church. She didn't soften her words.

A painted panel set between gilded columns: a pope enthroned under a canopy with cardinals in red below him, and in the foreground a crowd, a nun among them; a Latin inscription runs along the bottom.
Cristoforo Roncalli, Saint Catherine persuades Gregory XI to return from Avignon to Rome (1582), in the house of Saint Catherine, Siena. The inscription credits the return to Catherine's urging.
IWhat was going on

In 1305 a French archbishop was elected pope and took the name Clement V. Rome was torn by violent feuds between noble families. The powerful French king, Philip IV, pressed to stay near France.

From 1309 the popes lived at Avignon, a city on the river Rhône. They stayed nearly seventy years.

Most of the popes and cardinals of this time were French. Many Christians saw the papacy as a tool of the French crown.

IIWhat was at stake

The pope is the bishop of Rome. A bishop living hundreds of kilometres from his own church looked wrong to many. Meanwhile Italy was sliding into war.

The pope's court also grew rich. Complaints about greedy and immoral clergy were loud across Europe.

IIIWhat happened

Catherine Benincasa of Siena was a laywoman in the Dominican Third Order: people who follow a religious order's way of life without being nuns. She dictated her letters to helpers.

She wrote to Gregory XI again and again. Come back to Rome, she told him, and make peace in Italy. Pull out the bad priests and rulers like weeds from a garden.

In 1376 she went to Avignon herself to urge him.

IVWhat came of it

Gregory left Avignon against the wishes of the French king and most of his cardinals. He reached Rome on 17 January 1377.

He died about a year later. His death led straight into a worse crisis, the Great Western Schism, a split over who was pope, told in the next scene.

Pope Pius II declared Catherine a saint in 1461. In 1970 Paul VI named her a Doctor of the Church, a title for saints whose teaching the whole Church learns from.

VRead the source
Do you uproot in the garden of Holy Church the malodorous flowers, full of impurity and avarice, swollen with pride: that is, the bad priests and rulers who poison and rot that garden. Ah me, you our Governor, do you use your power to pluck out those flowers!
Saint Catherine of Siena as Seen in Her Letters · Letter to Gregory XI, in Saint Catherine of Siena as Seen in Her Letters, trans. Vida D. Scudder (1905), pp. 130-131

Why it matters

The Catholic Church honours as a saint a woman who told a pope, to his face, that he was failing. Correcting popes is part of the Catholic tradition, not something only outsiders do.

It also shows reform coming from below, from a laywoman with no office, as often as from above.

1415 to 1417Historical2 min read

A council ends a split with three popes

The Council of Constance

For almost forty years two, then three, men claimed to be pope. The Council of Constance, in today's Germany, ended it. It removed two of them, accepted the third's resignation, and in 1417 elected Martin V.

A two-page coloured drawing from a manuscript: on the left a crowd of bishops and cardinals gathers before a timber building; on the right a man leans from a window of a fenced conclave house holding up a cross.
The election of Martin V at the Council of Constance, 11 November 1417, from the chronicle of Ulrich Richental (copy of about 1464).
IWhat was going on

Pope Gregory XI died in Rome in March 1378. The cardinals, the senior clergy who elect a pope, met to choose his successor. A Roman crowd surrounded them, demanding a Roman pope, or at least an Italian.

They elected an Italian archbishop, who became Urban VI. Urban turned out to be harsh and erratic with the cardinals.

Within months most of them said the election had been forced by fear. They elected a rival, Clement VII, who went back to Avignon in southern France.

IIWhat was at stake

Now there were two popes, each with his own cardinals, and each excommunicated the other's followers. Excommunication is a church penalty that cuts someone off from the until they reconcile; it's not a physical punishment.

Europe split along political lines. France, Scotland and in time the Spanish kingdoms backed Avignon. England, most of the Holy Roman Empire, centred on Germany, and others backed Rome.

Ordinary Catholics couldn't be sure who the real pope was. Saints stood on both sides.

IIIWhat happened

In 1409 cardinals from both sides met at Pisa, in Italy. They deposed both popes, removing them from office, and elected a third. Neither of the first two stepped down, so Pisa made three popes instead of one.

In 1414 Sigismund, king of Germany and later emperor, pressed the Pisan pope, John XXIII, to call a council at Constance. John fled, and he was deposed in 1415. He is a different man from the twentieth-century pope of the same name.

The Roman pope, Gregory XII, formally called the council himself and then resigned. Benedict XIII, of the Avignon line, refused to go. He was deposed in 1417.

IVWhat came of it

On 11 November 1417 the council elected Martin V, and nearly all of Europe accepted him. Benedict XIII held out in a castle in Spain with a handful of followers until he died.

The Catholic Church's list of popes counts the Roman line as the true one. It calls the others antipopes, men who claimed to be pope without being so.

The Catholic Encyclopedia, a Catholic reference work of the early 1900s, admits that this rests on 'a very strong presumption', not proof.

VRead the source
The said holy synod decrees, determines and ordains for the good of unity in God's church that neither the lord Baldassare de Cossa, recently John XXIII, nor Angelo Correr nor Peter de Luna, called Gregory XII and Benedict XIII by their respective obediences, shall ever be re-elected as pope.
Council of Constance (1414–1418), decrees · Session 12 (29 May 1415), decree that none of the three contenders may be re-elected (Tanner)

Why it matters

The split shows the papacy at its weakest. It wasn't one bad pope: no one was sure who the pope was.

Constance also claimed that a council stood above the pope. Later popes rejected that idea, and Catholics still argue over how to read it. What everyone agreed on was the result: one pope again.

1492 to 1503Historical2 min read

Rodrigo Borgia becomes Pope Alexander VI

Rodrigo Borgia, Pope Alexander VI

In 1492 in Rome, Rodrigo Borgia became Pope Alexander VI, very likely through bought votes. As a priest he had fathered children. As pope he used his power to build up his family.

Fresco detail of a kneeling, tonsured older man in profile, hands joined in prayer, wearing a heavy gold cope studded with jewels.
Alexander VI kneeling, a detail of Pinturicchio's Resurrection fresco in the Borgia Apartments of the Vatican (1492-1494), painted during his pontificate.
IWhat was going on

By the late 1400s the pope was also a prince. He ruled the Papal States, a band of land across central Italy. Italy was split into rival states, and France and Spain were about to fight over it.

Renaissance Rome was a city of great art and great money. Cardinals often lived like princes, and families competed to place their sons in the Church's top jobs.

IIWhat was at stake

Rodrigo Borgia came from a Spanish family. His uncle, Pope Callixtus III, made him a cardinal at twenty-five. As a priest he fathered four children with Vanozza Catanei, among them Cesare and Lucrezia.

He was able and hard-working, and he served under five popes. But church law required priests in the West to stay unmarried and chaste. He was everything the Church's own law said a priest must not be.

IIIWhat happened

He was elected in 1492 and took the name Alexander VI. It was widely believed he had bribed the cardinals. He fathered another child while pope. He used papal power to win lands and titles for his children.

His son Cesare led papal armies to take back towns in the Papal States, often for the family's benefit.

Savonarola was a friar in Florence who preached against the pope. In 1497 he was excommunicated, cut off from the sacraments. In 1498 Florence's own government tried and executed him, with papal envoys present.

IVWhat came of it

When his son Juan was murdered in 1497, Alexander was shaken. He set up a group of cardinals to reform the Church. Its decrees were never issued.

He died in 1503. His reign became the most famous symbol of a corrupt papacy.

And it is a Catholic reference work, the Catholic Encyclopedia, that says he went on living as pope the life that had disgraced him as a cardinal.

VRead the source
Notwithstanding these and similar actions, which might seem to entitle him to no mean place in the annals of the papacy, Alexander continued as Pope the manner of life that had disgraced his cardinalate
Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Pope Alexander VI' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Pope Alexander VI', by James Loughlin

Why it matters

Catholics don't defend Alexander VI. The point is narrower: he did not use his office to teach anything false about faith or morals.

What the Borgia years show is the cost of a Church that let power and family run it. Twenty years later, much of northern Europe broke away.

1503 to 1521Historical2 min read

One pope leads armies, the next overspends

Julius II and Leo X

From 1503 Pope Julius II rode out in armour at the head of his own armies. His successor, Leo X, spent the treasury dry and sold church offices to refill it. Under Leo, a fund-raising campaign in Germany set off Martin Luther's protest.

IWhat was going on

The popes ruled the Papal States, their lands in central Italy. From 1494 they were caught up in the Italian Wars, as France, Spain, Venice and the Holy Roman Empire fought over Italy.

They were also building. In 1506 Julius II began the new St Peter's Basilica in Rome, one of the most expensive buildings in Europe. He hired Michelangelo to paint the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel.

IIWhat was at stake

Julius II won the papacy in 1503 with promises and bribes to the cardinals. He believed a pope could only be free if he held his own lands firmly. So he rode out in armour to win back Perugia and Bologna.

Leo X came from the Medici, the ruling family of Florence. He had been made a cardinal at thirteen. He loved art, music and lavish living, and he spent far beyond what the Church could raise.

IIIWhat happened

Within two years Leo had emptied the treasury Julius left. To raise money he created church offices and sold them.

The Catholic Encyclopedia, a Catholic reference work, says that jubilees and turned into money-making. Jubilees were special holy years.

An indulgence is the Church's release from the temporary punishment still due for sins already forgiven. A gift of money was one of the good works that could gain it.

In Germany a preacher named Johann Tetzel sold one for the building of St Peter's. The way he did it made forgiveness look for sale.

IVWhat came of it

In 1517 Martin Luther, a monk and professor at Wittenberg in Germany, wrote his Ninety-Five Theses. They argued against the way indulgences were being preached.

In 1521 Leo excommunicated Luther, cutting him off from the Church. Leo died the same year, owing 400,000 ducats, the gold coins of the day.

The protest he had brushed aside was splitting the Western Church.

VRead the source
Jubilees and indulgences were degraded almost entirely into financial transactions, yet without avail, as the treasury was ruined.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Leo X' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Leo X', by Klemens Löffler

Why it matters

Leo's reign is where bad popes stopped being a local scandal and became a reason for millions to leave. The chapter 'What was wrong in the medieval Church' tells the story of indulgences and the Reformation.

The Council of Trent (1545–1563), the Catholic bishops' great reforming meeting, later ordered an end to all money-making from indulgences. It brought in lasting reforms. It came a generation too late.

1522 to 1523Historical2 min read

A pope admits the rot began at the top

Adrian VI, in his instructions to his envoy Francesco Chieregati

In January 1523 Pope Adrian VI, a strict Dutch theologian, had his envoy speak to the German princes at Nuremberg. His message was that the rot in the Church had started at the top, with the popes.

An engraved bust portrait of a lean pope in profile wearing an embroidered cope, with a papal coat of arms in the corner and the Latin legend Adrianus VI Papa Traiectensis Belga.
Adrian VI, 'of Utrecht', in an engraving from Onofrio Panvinio's portraits of the popes (1568).
IWhat was going on

Adrian was born in Utrecht, in the Netherlands, in 1459, to a humble family. He became a theology professor and tutor to the future emperor Charles V. Then he became a bishop in Spain, and governed Spain as regent for Charles.

When Leo X died, the cardinals elected Adrian in January 1522, though he had never been to Rome. He was known for living simply. Rome's courtiers mocked him as a foreigner.

IIWhat was at stake

Luther's movement was spreading fast in Germany. At the same time the Ottoman Turks had taken Belgrade in 1521 and were threatening Hungary and the island of Rhodes.

Adrian needed the German princes united, both to deal with Luther and to defend Europe. He knew they would not listen to a papacy that wouldn't admit its faults.

IIIWhat happened

He sent a nuncio, a papal ambassador, to the Diet at Nuremberg. The Diet was the assembly of the German princes. In January 1523 the nuncio laid Adrian's written instruction before it.

It said that for years terrible things had gathered around the Holy See, the papacy. The sickness had spread 'from the head to the members, from the Popes to the hierarchy'.

Adrian promised to reform Rome first.

IVWhat came of it

The princes answered with demands. They wanted German complaints against Rome put right, and a free council of the Church on German soil. Luther wrote against Adrian.

In Rome the curia, the pope's own offices, resisted his reforms. Rhodes had fallen to the Turks at the end of 1522.

Adrian died in September 1523, after only twenty months as pope.

VRead the source
We know well that for many years things deserving of abhorrence have gathered round the Holy See; sacred things have been misused, ordinances transgressed, so that in everything there has been a change for the worse.
The History of the Popes from the Close of the Middle Ages, vol. IX (Adrian VI and Clement VII) · Ludwig Pastor, The History of the Popes, vol. IX, ed. R. F. Kerr (3rd edition), pp. 134-135, translating the instruction

Why it matters

A pope said in writing that the papacy itself was the source of the corruption. It's one of the most honest documents any pope has issued.

It also shows that honesty alone wasn't enough. Without time and support, the reform he promised had to wait for the Council of Trent, the bishops' great reforming meeting.

2009Historical2 min read

An inquiry exposes the cover-up in Dublin

The Commission of Investigation into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin (the Murphy report)

In 2009 an Irish state inquiry reported on the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin. It found that for decades the archdiocese had put its own reputation ahead of children who had been abused by its priests.

IWhat was going on

For most of the 1900s the Catholic Church in Ireland was one of the most trusted institutions in the country. It ran most schools and many hospitals, and priests were rarely questioned.

From the 1990s, survivors began to speak publicly. Inquiries followed. The first was into the Diocese of Ferns, then one into church-run industrial schools, homes for poor and neglected children, then one into Dublin.

IIWhat was at stake

The Commission took a sample of 46 priests of the archdiocese, the Catholic Church's district around Dublin. It looked at how Church and State handled complaints against them between 1975 and 2004. It examined complaints made by more than 320 people.

The question was not only what the priests had done. It was what the people in charge knew, and what they did about it.

IIIWhat happened

The report found that until at least the mid-1990s the archdiocese's priorities were secrecy, avoiding scandal, and protecting the Church's reputation and its assets. Children's welfare came after those.

Abusers were moved instead of stopped. The archdiocese didn't report complaints to the Gardaí, the Irish police, before 1996. It did not even apply its own church law against abusers.

In 1987 it took out insurance against claims. All the while, four archbishops in turn kept the knowledge to themselves.

IVWhat came of it

Several bishops resigned. In 2010 Pope Benedict XVI wrote a letter to the Catholics of Ireland. To survivors he wrote: 'You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry.'

Inquiries in Pennsylvania in the United States, in Australia and in France found the same pattern. The Catholic Church has since changed its law, as the documents at the end of this chapter show.

Survivors' groups say bishops still investigate bishops.

VRead the source
The Dublin Archdiocese's pre-occupations in dealing with cases of child sexual abuse, at least until the mid 1990s, were the maintenance of secrecy, the avoidance of scandal, the protection of the reputation of the Church, and the preservation of its assets. All other considerations, including the welfare of children and justice for victims, were subordinated to these priorities.
Commission of Investigation: Report into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin (the Murphy report), chapter 1, Overview · Report into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin (2009), chapter 1, paragraph 1.15

Why it matters

Of everything in this chapter, this is the hardest. These were not distant medieval quarrels. They were children harmed in living memory, and leaders who chose the institution over them.

On the abuse of children the Catholic Church has no defence, and its recent popes have said so in their own words.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic reading starts with what Christ actually promised. He chose twelve , knowing one of them, Judas, would betray him. In John's he says: 'Did I not choose you twelve? Yet is not one of you a devil?'

He also told a story of a field where the weeds grow with the wheat until the harvest.

The , its official summary of teaching, draws the plain conclusion. Christ's presence in his ministers does not preserve them from 'human weaknesses, the spirit of domination, error, even '.

Nothing in Catholic teaching ever promised good popes.

What the Catholic Church does claim is narrower. It claims the Church as a whole will not lose the faith. And it claims a pope is kept from error when he solemnly defines a teaching for the whole Church.

The First Vatican Council was a meeting of the world's Catholic bishops in 1870. It said the was promised to 's successors, the popes, 'not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new '.

The promise was to guard what the apostles handed on. That is a promise about definitions, not about conduct.

Honorius is the real test, and the Catholic answer is specific. His letter was official, careless and harmful. But it defined nothing and bound no one.

The council of 681 that condemned him also accepted a letter from the pope of its own day, Agatho, as the faith of Rome. And Pope Leo II explained the sentence as one for negligence.

The Catholic Encyclopedia, a Catholic reference work of the early 1900s, still admits that Honorius was 'a heretic, not in intention, but in fact'. The case shows a pope failing, not a definition failing.

The Orthodox answer that this line between a letter and a definition was drawn in 1870, so applying it to a letter of about 634 is unfair. The Catholic reply is that Vatican I claimed to state what the Church had held before.

So the fair test is whether the older record fits it, not whether the old writers used its words.

Here the council of 681 itself is the evidence. It condemned Honorius as a man, and the same council accepted Agatho's letter as the faith of Rome. A council that thought a pope had defined heresy for the whole Church could hardly have done both.

The Orthodox can fairly reply that this still shows a council judging a pope. Both readings fit the record. What it doesn't show is a pope binding the whole Church to an error.

The , the Catholic bishops' meeting of the 1960s, called the Church 'at the same time holy and always in need of being purified'. The record shows both halves.

A synod at Sutri ended a sold papacy in 1046. The Council of Constance ended the split over who was pope in 1417. Adrian VI's confession pointed toward the reforms of the .

In 2000 led the Church in confessing before God the sins of members 'whose disobedience to you contradicts the faith we profess'. A Catholic can point to the reforms, but not to their speed.

On the abuse of children there is no defence to offer. The Catholic Church's recent popes have admitted the failure in plain words.

In 2018 a grand jury in Pennsylvania, in the United States, reported on abuse there. A grand jury is a panel of citizens that investigates crimes.

It wrote that priests 'were raping little boys and girls, and the men of God who were responsible for them not only did nothing; they hid it all.'

Benedict XVI named among the causes 'a misplaced concern for the reputation of the Church and the avoidance of scandal'. Francis wrote: 'We showed no care for the little ones; we abandoned them.'

What changed can be dated. In 2001 Rome took abuse cases out of the bishops' sole hands. In 2019 it obliged clergy to report abuse to church authorities, and brought bishops who obstruct investigations under the law.

The same year it lifted the pontifical secret, the Vatican's strictest rule of confidentiality, from these cases. In 2020 it published its own report on how Theodore McCarrick, later removed from the priesthood for sexual abuse, became a cardinal.

A fair objection is that the Catholic claim could survive any fact. It could not. A solemn papal definition that contradicted an earlier one would break it, and none appears in this record.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Lutheran readers

, the German monk who began the Reformation, listed the pope's abuses in To the Christian Nobility (1520). The first was moral. He called it 'a horrible and frightful thing' that the vicar of Christ, the pope, lived in more splendour than any king.

By 1537 the Smalcald Articles, a statement of faith Luther wrote for the Lutheran churches, had moved the charge from conduct to the office itself.

They say the Church 'can exist very well without such a head'. Even a head chosen by men, as at Constance, 'deposing three and electing a fourth', would not help.

They call the pope 'the very Antichrist', Christ's great enemy, because he will not let Christians be saved without his power. On this reading the bad popes were the symptom, and the claim itself was the disease.

Reformed readers

The Reformed churches, the family that includes the Presbyterians, set out their faith in the Westminster Confession of 1647. It agrees that every church on earth is mixed.

It says: 'The purest churches under are subject both to mixture and error; and some have so degenerated as to become no churches of Christ, but synagogues of Satan.'

So the Reformed question is not whether bad men were present, which Catholics admit. It is whether a church can decay until it stops being a church.

The American Presbyterian revision of 1903 put the conclusion without the older language.

It rejects any man's claim to be vicar of Christ, his stand-in, and head of the Church. Such a claim, it says, 'is unscriptural, without warrant in fact, and is a usurpation dishonoring to the Lord Jesus Christ'.

Eastern Orthodox readers

In 1895 the Ecumenical Patriarchate, the office of the senior bishop of the Orthodox world in Constantinople, answered Pope Leo XIII.

It wrote that no one on earth is infallible, kept from error, except Christ himself.

In its words: 'The orthodox Eastern and catholic Church of Christ, with the exception of the Son and Word of God, who was ineffably made man, knows no one infallible upon earth.'

It cites Honorius among its evidence, and the council of 681, which the Orthodox count as the sixth council of the whole Church. He was 'condemned in the seventh century by the sixth Ecumenical Council as a heretic, and the popes who succeeded him acknowledged and accepted his condemnation.'

On this reading a council judged a pope, which is the right order. The Catholic line between a letter and a definition was drawn later, to protect a teaching the early Church did not hold.

Abuse survivors' advocates

Two American groups, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) and BishopAccountability.org, judge the reforms by results.

In 2021 SNAP wrote: 'Inviting an arsonist to investigate the fire he started will never produce the desired evidence and accountability.'

In 2023 BishopAccountability.org called the revised Vos estis, the Vatican's law on reporting abuse, 'self-policing packaged as accountability'.

Under it, bishops still investigate bishops. The public need not be told. Reporting to the police and civil courts is required only where local law demands it.

The group counted around 40 bishops investigated under the law, out of roughly 5,600. On this reading the rules changed, but control of the process did not.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
The documents, from the Gospel to the inquiries12 steps

Twelve documents, in date order. Some soften the worst of the old stories, and some make the recent record darker. Both kinds are here.

  1. Weeds among the wheat

    Gospel of Matthew

    Jesus tells a story about a field where an enemy sowed weeds among the wheat. The owner forbids his servants to pull the weeds up before the harvest.

    The New American Bible, a Catholic translation, has a note that reads it as a warning not to jump ahead of God's final judgement. Jesus explains that 'the field is the world'.

    So the story expects evil among Jesus's own followers. But it is no reason to leave a known abuser in ministry.

    “The slaves of the householder came to him and said, 'Master, did you not sow good seed in your field? Where have the weeds come from?' He answered, 'An enemy has done this.' His slaves said to him, 'Do you want us to go and pull them up?' He replied, 'No, if you pull up the weeds you might uproot the wheat along with them. Let them grow together until harvest”
    RevealedThe New American Bible (vatican.va IntraText edition; 1986 revised New Testament)Matthew 13:27-30 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText edition)The evidence ↓
  2. The office and the man

    Fifth century

    Pope Leo I, known as Leo the Great, preached on the anniversary of his election in the fifth century. He said that Peter's dignity lives on in whoever holds his see, his office as bishop of Rome, however unworthy that man is.

    Catholics count Peter, Jesus's leading apostle, as the first pope.

    Leo meant himself, and he was being humble. The line he draws, between the office and the man in it, is the one the whole Catholic answer rests on. Later popes tested it far harder than Leo did.

    “that in my humble person he may be recognized and honoured, in whom abides the care of all the shepherds, together with the charge of the sheep commended to him, and whose dignity is not abated even in so unworthy an heir.”
    InferenceSermon 3: On his birthday, III, delivered on the anniversary of his elevation to the pontificateLeo the Great, Sermon 3, On the anniversary of his elevation, section 4 (trans. C. L. Feltoe, NPNF 2nd series vol. 12)The evidence ↓
  3. The pope who confirmed the verdict

    682

    Pope Leo II confirmed the decrees of the council of 681. The Catholic Encyclopedia says it is his approval that gives the council its rank as a council of the whole Church.

    His words about Honorius are harsh. But in letters to Spain he explained them: Honorius had fostered the false teaching 'by his negligence', rather than taught it.

    From the eighth century to the eleventh, every new pope swore an oath that named Honorius among the condemned.

    “We anathematize the inventors of the new error, that is, Theodore, Sergius ... and also Honorius, who did not attempt to sanctify this Apostolic Church with the teaching of Apostolic tradition, but by profane treachery permitted its purity to be polluted.”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I'Leo II's letter confirming the council, as quoted in Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', by John ChapmanThe evidence ↓
  4. What the First Vatican Council defined

    1870

    When the First Vatican Council met in 1870, Honorius 'figured in every pamphlet and every speech', the Catholic Encyclopedia records.

    The council defined a narrow gift. It covers a pope speaking ex cathedra, Latin for 'from the chair'. That means speaking as shepherd of all Christians, and defining a teaching on faith or morals for the whole Catholic Church.

    It says the Holy Spirit was promised to guard the faith, not to add to it.

    “For the holy Spirit was promised to the successors of Peter not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new doctrine, but that, by his assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles.”
    InferencePastor Aeternus, First Dogmatic Constitution on the Church of ChristPastor Aeternus, chapter 4, paragraph before the definitionThe evidence ↓
  5. A Catholic historian weighs Adrian's words

    Early twentieth century

    The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1907 called Adrian's admission 'exaggerated', and said the Protestant reformers seized on it.

    Ludwig Pastor, a Catholic historian who worked from the Vatican's own archives, disagreed.

    He also noted that Adrian drew 'a sharp and definite line between the divine and human elements in the Church'. The members could be corrupt while the faith itself stood.

    “the corruption in Rome was undoubtedly as great as Adrian described it to be.”
    HistoricalThe History of the Popes from the Close of the Middle Ages, vol. IX (Adrian VI and Clement VII)Ludwig Pastor, The History of the Popes, vol. IX, ed. R. F. Kerr, pp. 136-137The evidence ↓
  6. The chronicler behind the worst stories

    1930

    The tales of Theodora, a Roman noblewoman, and her daughter Marozia making popes come mainly from one man. Liudprand of Cremona was a bishop who served the emperor Otto I. The Catholic Encyclopedia says he 'constantly slandered the Romans, whom he hated'.

    His translator, F. A. Wright, quotes the historian Previté-Orton's verdict, shown here, and calls it 'not altogether unjust'. The same verdict grants that Liudprand 'was no liar'.

    And the *Liber Pontificalis*, the Book of the Popes, also names Pope Sergius III as father of Marozia's son, Pope John XI.

    “he evidently made no record at the time and when he wrote rested wholly on a memory which rejected dates and political circumstances and was singularly retentive of amorous scandal however devoid of probability.”
    HistoricalThe Works of Liudprand of Cremona: Antapodosis, Liber de rebus gestis Ottonis, Relatio de legatione ConstantinopolitanaF. A. Wright, introduction to The Works of Liudprand of Cremona (1930), pp. 21-22, quoting Previté-Orton in the Cambridge Medieval History, III, 160The evidence ↓
  7. The secret of the Holy Office

    1962

    The 1917 Code of Canon Law, the Catholic Church's book of laws, punished a cleric's sexual offences.

    In 1962 the Holy Office, the Vatican department for doctrine, issued an instruction first written in 1922. It tells church judges to weigh the Code's penalties (canon 2359 §2) in cases of abuse of children.

    But it sent such cases to the local bishop's court, under a procedure written for priests who used confession to ask for sex. It bound everyone in the court to permanent silence, under pain of excommunication.

    Accusers and witnesses swore secrecy too, though they faced a penalty only if expressly warned.

    “all those persons in any way associated with the tribunal, or knowledgeable of these matters by reason of their office, are bound to observe inviolably the strictest confidentiality, commonly known as the secret of the Holy Office, in all things and with all persons, under pain of incurring automatic excommunication”
    HistoricalCrimen sollicitationis — Instruction on the manner of proceeding in cases of the crime of solicitationInstruction of the Holy Office, 16 March 1962, no. 11 (English translation on vatican.va)The evidence ↓
  8. Rome takes the cases, and names the old mistake

    2001

    The 1983 Code of Canon Law punished a cleric's abuse of a minor under sixteen. The penalty could go as far as removal from the clergy (canon 1395 §2). But it left trials to the dioceses.

    On 30 April 2001 John Paul II took these cases into Rome's hands. Abuse of anyone under eighteen by a cleric was reserved to the Vatican's doctrine office, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

    Bishops had to report such cases there. Benedict XVI revised the rules in 2010.

    The Congregation's own history doesn't use the word cover-up. It describes the habits that made one possible.

    “A “pastoral attitude” to misconduct was preferred and canonical processes were thought by some to be anachronistic. A “therapeutic model” often prevailed in dealing with clerical misconduct. The bishop was expected to “heal” rather than “punish”. An over-optimistic idea of the benefits of psychological therapy guided many decisions concerning diocesan or religious personnel, sometimes without adequate regard for the possibility of recidivism.”
    HistoricalThe Norms of the Motu Proprio Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela (2001): Historical IntroductionCongregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, historical introduction to the norms of Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutelaThe evidence ↓
  9. The first national count

    2004

    In 2002 the American bishops ordered a national study, and John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York carried it out.

    Dioceses holding 98 per cent of the country's diocesan priests answered. So did religious orders holding about 80 per cent of the priests in those orders.

    It counted only allegations not withdrawn or known to be false. That gave 4,392 priests, 4 per cent of the 109,694 reported as serving from 1950 to 2002.

    The researchers said they could not know how many cases were never reported.

    “The total number of priests with allegations of abuse in our survey is 4,392. ... A total of 10,667 individuals made allegations of child sexual abuse by priests.”
    HistoricalThe Nature and Scope of Sexual Abuse of Minors by Catholic Priests and Deacons in the United States, 1950-2002The Nature and Scope of Sexual Abuse of Minors by Catholic Priests and Deacons in the United States, 1950-2002, executive summary, p. 4The evidence ↓
  10. Australia counts its priests

    2017

    Australia's Royal Commission, a national public inquiry, surveyed all 201 Catholic Church authorities. It asked about claims received from 1980 to February 2015. In all, 4,444 people had made claims of child sexual abuse.

    A second survey counted priests. Of 9,025 who served between 1950 and 2010, 507 were alleged perpetrators. An allegation is not a finding.

    The Commission judged the response before the 1990s to show 'catastrophic failures of leadership over many decades'.

    “Seven per cent of the priests who ministered in this time period were alleged perpetrators, taking into account their duration of ministry (the weighted proportion). When duration of ministry was not taken into account, 5.6 per cent of these priests were alleged perpetrators (the unweighted proportion).”
  11. The rule of silence is lifted

    2019

    In May 2019 Pope Francis issued a law called Vos estis lux mundi, Latin for You are the light of the world. It obliged clergy and members of religious orders to report abuse promptly to church authorities.

    It also brought bishops who obstruct investigations within its reach. In December he removed the pontifical secret, the Vatican's strictest rule of confidentiality, from these cases. Now officials may obey civil reporting laws, and victims may speak.

    In 2021 he rewrote the Church's law on crimes and penalties, saying 'great damage was done' by reluctance to punish. In 2023 Vos estis was reissued without its trial period.

    “The pontifical secret does not apply to accusations, trials and decisions involving the offences referred to in ... The person who files the report, the person who alleges to have been harmed and the witnesses shall not be bound by any obligation of silence with regard to matters involving the case.”
    HistoricalRescriptum ex audientia promulgating the Instruction On the Confidentiality of Legal ProceedingsInstruction On the Confidentiality of Legal Proceedings, nos. 1 and 5, promulgated by rescript of 6 December 2019 (vatican.va)The evidence ↓
  12. France: an estimate and a verdict

    2021

    France's independent commission, chaired by Jean-Marc Sauvé, surveyed 28,010 adults. From that survey it estimated that about 216,000 adults now living in France had been abused as children by clergy and members of religious orders since 1950.

    Its 95 per cent confidence range, the band the true figure very likely falls in, runs from 165,000 to 270,000. Counting lay church workers, the estimate rises to 330,000.

    It is an estimate, not a count. The commission judged recent safeguards late, and 'imposed in reaction to events'.

    “Faced with this scourge, for a very long time the Catholic Church's immediate reaction was to protect itself as an institution and it has shown complete, even cruel, indifference to those having suffered abuse.”
    HistoricalSexual Violence in the Catholic Church, France 1950-2020: Summary of the Final ReportSexual Violence in the Catholic Church, France 1950-2020: Summary of the Final Report (5 October 2021), p. 2The evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on11 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Pope Honorius I (625-638) answered a formal question from Patriarch Sergius of Constantinople, about 634, with a letter that spoke of one will in Christ (Sergius had asked about one or two 'operations'). In 681 the Third Council of Constantinople anathematised him by name, and Pope Leo II confirmed the council, explaining in letters to Spain that Honorius had fostered the heresy by negligence. The letter decided, defined and condemned nothing, which is the Catholic reason for holding that the case does not touch papal infallibility.

Rests on
  • Session XIII, sentence against the Monothelites (trans. H. Percival, NPNF 2nd series vol. 14)
    “And with these we define that there shall be expelled from the holy Church of God and anathematized Honorius who was some time Pope of Old Rome, because of what we found written by him to Sergius, that in all respects he followed his view and confirmed his impious doctrines.”
  • Session XVI, acclamations
    “To Honorius, the heretic, anathema!”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'The letter of Sergius to Honorius'
    “The Monothelite question was raised about 634 in a letter to this pope from the Patriarch of Constantinople, Sergius.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'The reply of Honorius', quoting the letter
    “Wherefore we acknowledge one Will of our Lord Jesus Christ, for evidently it was our nature and not the sin in it which was assumed by the Godhead”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'The reply of Honorius'
    “His answer to Sergius did not decide the question, did not authoritatively declare the faith of the Roman Church, did not claim to speak with the voice of Peter; it condemned nothing, it defined nothing.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', quoting Leo II's letter of confirmation
    “We anathematize the inventors of the new error, that is, Theodore, Sergius ... and also Honorius, who did not attempt to sanctify this Apostolic Church with the teaching of Apostolic tradition, but by profane treachery permitted its purity to be polluted.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', quoting Leo II to the Spanish bishops
    “With Honorius, who did not, as became the Apostolic authority, extinguish the flame of heretical teaching in its first beginning, but fostered it by his negligence.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'In what sense Honorius was condemned'
    “the council did not think that it stultified itself by asserting that Honorius was a heretic (in the above sense) and in the same breath accepting the letter of Agatho as being what it claimed to be, an authoritative exposition of the infallible faith of the Roman See”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'In what sense Honorius was condemned'
    “It is clear that no Catholic has the right to defend Pope Honorius. He was a heretic, not in intention, but in fact”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'In what sense Honorius was condemned'
    “also in the oath taken by every new pope from the eighth century to the eleventh in the following words: "Together with Honorius, who added fuel to their wicked assertions"”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'Modern controversies on the subject'
    “at the time of the Vatican Council Honorius figured in every pamphlet and every speech on ecclesiastical subjects”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Honorius I', section 'Character and work of Honorius'
    “Pope Honorius was much respected and died with an untarnished reputation. Few popes did more for the restoration and beautifying of churches of Rome, and he has left us his portrait in the apsidal mosaic of Sant Agnese fuori le mura.”
Other readings
  • The Ecumenical Patriarchate's encyclical of 1895 reads the case as proof that a pope can fall into heresy and be judged by a council: Honorius, 'having fallen into the Monothelite heresy, was condemned in the seventh century by the sixth Ecumenical Council as a heretic, and the popes who succeeded him acknowledged and accepted his condemnation.'
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia records that Gallican writers such as Bossuet, and Protestant writers generally, held that Honorius had formally defined heresy and was condemned for doing so.
  • Some Catholic apologists before 1870 argued that the Acts had been falsified or that Leo II withdrew the charge of heresy. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1910 rejects both views as untenable or baseless.
Limits
  • The council's words are taken from the NPNF English extracts (Percival, 1900), not from the Greek acts.
  • Leo II's letter survives in Greek and Latin forms that differ. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes a milder Latin reading, 'attempted to pollute its purity', and does not treat either as certain.
  • Whether a letter of this kind could ever count as a solemn definition is a judgement made in the light of the definition of 1870. The Orthodox objection is precisely that this standard is later than the case.
  • The date 'about 634' for Sergius's letter is the Catholic Encyclopedia's.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

In January 897 Pope Stephen VI had the corpse of his predecessor Formosus exhumed, dressed in papal vestments and tried before a synod of Roman clergy, probably under pressure from the emperor Lambert and his mother. The body was condemned and thrown into the Tiber. Within two years Stephen's second successor and John IX had Formosus reburied in St Peter's and the verdict annulled, but Sergius III (904-911) later approved it again.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Formosus', by J. P. Kirsch
    “Shortly afterwards (4 April, 896) Formosus died.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Pope Stephen (VI) VII', by Horace Mann
    “Whether induced by evil passion or perhaps, more probably, compelled by the Emperor Lambert and his mother Ageltruda, he caused the body of Formosus to be exhumed, and in January, 897, to be placed before an unwilling synod of the Roman clergy.”
  • “A deacon was appointed to answer for the deceased pontiff, who was condemned for performing the functions of a bishop when he had been deposed and for passing from the See of Porto to that of Rome. The corpse was then stripped of its sacred …”
    Read the full passage
    “A deacon was appointed to answer for the deceased pontiff, who was condemned for performing the functions of a bishop when he had been deposed and for passing from the See of Porto to that of Rome. The corpse was then stripped of its sacred vestments, deprived of two fingers of its right hand, clad in the garb of a layman, and ultimately thrown into the Tiber.”
  • “Before he was put to death by strangulation, he forced several of those who had been ordained by Formosus to resign their offices”
  • “the corpse, clad in papal vestments, was withdrawn from the sarcophagus and seated on a throne; close by stood a deacon to answer in its name”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), 'Pope Formosus', final paragraph
    “In 897 the second successor of Stephen had the body, which a monk had drawn from the Tiber, reinterred with full honours in St. Peter's. He furthermore annulled at a synod the decisions of the court of Stephen VI, and declared all orders conferred …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 897 the second successor of Stephen had the body, which a monk had drawn from the Tiber, reinterred with full honours in St. Peter's. He furthermore annulled at a synod the decisions of the court of Stephen VI, and declared all orders conferred by Formosus valid. John IX confirmed these acts at two synods, of which the first was held at Rome and the other at Ravenna (898). On the other hand Sergius III (904-911) approved in a Roman synod the decisions of Stephen's synod against Formosus”
Other readings
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia's two articles weigh Stephen's motive differently. Horace Mann (1912) thinks he was 'more probably' compelled by Lambert and Ageltruda; J. P. Kirsch (1909) says Stephen 'lent himself' to Agiltrude's vengeance. Both treat the synod as political rather than doctrinal.
Limits
  • The two Catholic Encyclopedia articles disagree on a detail: Mann says two fingers were cut from the corpse's right hand, Kirsch says three. The chapter does not repeat the number in its own prose.
  • No contemporary account of the synod was compared; the dates and sequence rest on the Catholic Encyclopedia, which cites the Liber Pontificalis, Auxilius and Vulgarius.
  • The name of Stephen's second successor, who reburied Formosus, is not given in the text compared.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

In the tenth century the papacy was controlled by Roman noble families. Octavius, son of the ruler of Rome, was made pope as John XII at eighteen in 955, was accused before a synod in 963 of simony, perjury, murder and adultery, and died in 964. The fullest accounts, including the stories of Theodora and Marozia making popes, come from Liudprand of Cremona, a partisan witness whom the Catholic Encyclopedia calls a slanderer of the Romans; but the Liber Pontificalis independently names Pope Sergius III as father of Marozia's son John XI.

Rests on
Other readings
  • A Catholic reading, following the Catholic Encyclopedia, discounts Liudprand's sexual stories about Theodora and Sergius III as the slanders of a hostile outsider writing decades later, while accepting that John XII was 'a coarse, immoral man'.
  • A skeptical reading notes that the Liber Pontificalis, a Roman source with no reason to flatter Liudprand's patron, also names Sergius III as John XI's father, so the Catholic Encyclopedia's defence of Sergius is itself contestable.
Limits
  • Wright's 1930 translation survives here only as an OCR copy on archive.org, with scanning errors in places; the passages quoted were chosen from clean lines and compared word for word.
  • The Latin of Liudprand and of the Liber Pontificalis was not compared.
  • The charges at the synod of 963 are testimony at a hostile trial called by the emperor, reported by the emperor's man. They are not findings.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia itself is not consistent: its article on John XI calls him Marozia's son by Alberic, while noting that the Liber Pontificalis names Sergius.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Benedict IX was placed on the papal throne by his father at about twenty in 1032. Driven from Rome in 1044, he returned, and in 1045 resigned the papacy to his godfather John Gratian, who paid him a large sum and became Gregory VI. With three claimants in the field, a synod at Sutri in December 1046, called at the request of the German king Henry III, ended all three claims. A Catholic tradition holds that Benedict died a penitent at Grottaferrata.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia presents Gregory VI as acting 'in all good faith and simplicity' to rid Rome of Benedict. The synod of Sutri nonetheless treated his purchase as simoniacal, and he laid down the office.
Limits
  • The two Catholic Encyclopedia articles describe Sutri differently: the Benedict IX article says all three were deposed there, the Gregory VI article says Gregory abdicated. The chapter says the synod ended all three claims.
  • The Grottaferrata tradition of Benedict's repentance is recorded by the encyclopedia as 'more probable', not certain.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

From 1309 the popes resided at Avignon. Catherine of Siena wrote to Gregory XI urging him to return to Rome and purge the Church of bad priests, and he reached Rome on 17 January 1377. After the disputed election of Urban VI in April 1378 the cardinals chose a rival, Pisa added a third line in 1409, and the Council of Constance removed all three claimants and elected Martin V on 11 November 1417. An antipope is a false claimant against a canonically elected pope; which line was legitimate has never been solemnly defined, and the official list was revised in 1904.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Pope Clement V', by Thomas Shahan
    “For some time (1305-1309), Pope Clement resided at different places in France (Bordeaux, Poitiers, Toulouse), but finally took up his residence at Avignon”
  • Letter to Gregory XI, trans. Vida D. Scudder (1905), pp. 130-131
    “Do you uproot in the garden of Holy Church the malodorous flowers, full of impurity and avarice, swollen with pride: that is, the bad priests and rulers who poison and rot that garden. Ah me, you our Governor, do you use your power to pluck out those flowers!”
  • Letter to Gregory XI, trans. Vida D. Scudder (1905), p. 131
    “Alas, what confusion is this, to see those who ought to be a mirror of voluntary poverty, meek as lambs, distributing the possessions of Holy Church to the poor: and they appear in such luxury and state and pomp and worldly vanity, more than if they had turned them to the world a thousand times!”
  • “in spite of the opposition of the French king and almost the whole of the Sacred College, he returned to Rome (17 January, 1377).”
  • “Catherine was canonized by Pius II in 1461.”
  • Editorial footnote 1 on the papalencyclicals.net page (not from Tanner)
    “This council was occasioned by The Schism begun when the cardinals who had elected Urban VI pope on 8th April 1378 and who had all repeatedly recognised him subsequently, decided in view of his offensive zeal for reform to claim that the pressure …”
    Read the full passage
    “This council was occasioned by The Schism begun when the cardinals who had elected Urban VI pope on 8th April 1378 and who had all repeatedly recognised him subsequently, decided in view of his offensive zeal for reform to claim that the pressure they had been under during his election had invalidated it. In September 1378 they elected Robert of Genoa [anti] pope Clement VII.”
  • Editorial introduction (Tanner)
    “the council held at Pisa in 1409 had not healed but rather aggravated when it elected Alexander V as a third pope”
  • Session 12 (29 May 1415)
    “The said holy synod decrees, determines and ordains for the good of unity in God's church that neither the lord Baldassare de Cossa, recently John XXIII, nor Angelo Correr nor Peter de Luna, called Gregory XII and Benedict XIII by their respective obediences, shall ever be re-elected as pope.”
  • “the Council of Constance (1414) deposed the suspicious John XXIII, received the abdication of the gentle and timid Gregory XII, and finally dismissed the obstinate Benedict XIII. On 11 November, 1417, the assembly elected Odo Colonna, who took the name of Martin V.”
  • “In 1904 the "Gerarchia Cattolica", basing its arguments on the date of the Liber Pontificalis, compiled a new and corrected list of sovereign pontiffs. Ten names have disappeared from this list of legitimate popes, neither the popes of Avignon nor those of Pisa being ranked in the true lineage of St. Peter.”
  • “A false claimant of the Holy See in opposition to a pontiff canonically elected.”
  • “If this deliberate omission is not proof positive, it is at least a very strong presumption in favour of the legitimacy of the Roman popes”
Other readings
  • The Smalcald Articles (1537) read Constance, 'deposing three and electing a fourth', as proof that the Church can choose and remove its head as a human arrangement.
  • The Orthodox Church in America's history reads Constance as a Western council placing itself above the pope, and does not count it as ecumenical.
Limits
  • Session 12 of Constance (29 May 1415) came before Gregory XII's convocation of the council on 4 July 1415, and the editors of the decrees note that the standing of sessions before Martin V's election is disputed.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia calls the 1904 list 'a very strong presumption', not proof, in favour of the Roman line.
  • Scudder's translation of Catherine's letter is from 1905; the Italian was not compared, and the letter is not precisely dated.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Rodrigo Borgia, made a cardinal at twenty-five by his uncle Callixtus III, fathered four children with Vanozza Catanei after his ordination and another son while pope as Alexander VI (1492-1503); a reform commission he set up in 1497 produced decrees that were never promulgated. Julius II (1503-1513) bribed his way to election, had fathered three daughters before it, and led his own armies. Leo X, a cardinal at thirteen, exhausted the treasury, sold high offices and let indulgences become financial transactions.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Some nineteenth-century Catholic writers tried to defend Alexander VI; the Catholic Encyclopedia reports that Pastor and others judged their efforts failures.
  • Luther's open letter of 1520 treats the splendour and money of the Renaissance papacy as proof that the office itself had become unchristian.
Limits
  • Whether Alexander VI bought his election is not proven. The Catholic Encyclopedia calls it the general belief and 'not improbable' but 'difficult to prove', and says the election was valid under the law of the time. The chapter therefore says Julius II, not Alexander VI, bribed his way to election.
  • The saying 'Let us enjoy the papacy' attributed to Leo X rests on a Venetian ambassador the Catholic Encyclopedia calls not unbiased and not present; it is not used.
  • The indulgence campaign of 1517 is treated in the chapter 'What was wrong in the medieval Church' and is only referred to here.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Adrian VI (pope from 9 January 1522 to 14 September 1523) sent his nuncio Francesco Chieregati to the Diet of Nuremberg with an instruction, composed about the end of November 1522 and laid before the Diet in January 1523, which admitted that corruption had spread from the Holy See downward and promised to reform the Roman curia first. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1907 calls the admission exaggerated; Ludwig Pastor, the Catholic historian of the popes, says the corruption was as great as Adrian described.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907) and, as Pastor reports, Pallavicino judged the admission exaggerated or impolitic. Pastor rejects the charge of exaggeration.
  • Philip Schaff, a Protestant historian, prints a different English version of the same passage and presents it as the Curia's first such confession, while noting Adrian's opposition to doctrinal reformation.
Limits
  • The Latin of the instruction was not compared. Pastor's English (ed. Kerr) and Schaff's English differ in wording; the sense is the same.
  • Pastor's table of contents dates Chieregati's presentation to the Diet to 3 January 1523; his note dates the composition to about 25 November 1522, 'which may be correct'. The chapter says 1522 for the writing and January 1523 for its reading.
  • The English wording quoted in the chapter is the translation printed in Pastor's History of the Popes, vol. IX (ed. R. F. Kerr); Schaff's Protestant translation reads 'for some time many abominations'.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Church authorities concealed clerical abuse of children for decades: the Murphy report (2009) found the Dublin archdiocese put secrecy, scandal-avoidance, reputation and assets above children, and the Pennsylvania grand jury (2018) described a pattern of transferring abusers. Canon law already punished the crime: the 1962 reprint of the 1922 instruction Crimen sollicitationis applies the 1917 Code's penalties (canon 2359 section 2) to abuse of pre-adolescent children, and canon 1395 section 2 of the 1983 Code punished abuse of a minor under sixteen. But cases stayed with local bishops, under the secret of the Holy Office until 2001. Rome reserved the cases to itself on 30 April 2001 (age raised to eighteen; revised 21 May 2010); Vos estis lux mundi (7 May 2019) required clergy to report to church authorities and reached bishops who obstruct investigations; a rescript of 6 December 2019 lifted the pontifical secret; a revised Book VI of the Code took effect on 8 December 2021; a revised Vos estis took effect on 30 April 2023. The Holy See's McCarrick report (10 November 2020) documented failures under John Paul II and Benedict XVI.

Rests on
Other readings
  • BishopAccountability.org (2023) and SNAP (2021) judge Vos estis ineffective because bishops still investigate bishops, the public need not be informed and civil reporting depends on local law.
  • The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith argues that judging the canonical norms of the past century by modern child-protection standards is 'gravely anachronistic', while admitting that a therapeutic model and an over-optimistic trust in psychology guided many decisions.
Limits
  • It is not accurate to say that before 2001 there was no universal law against clerical abuse of children: the 1962 instruction applied the 1917 Code's canon 2359 section 2 to it, and the 1983 Code punished it (canon 1395 section 2, victims under sixteen). What changed in 2001 was that cases were reserved to Rome and the age raised to eighteen. The text of canon 2359 itself was not saved; it is known here only as the 1962 instruction cites it.
  • The Pennsylvania description of a 'playbook' was drawn up by FBI analysts for the grand jury from six dioceses' files. It describes a pattern in those files, not a written policy.
  • The McCarrick report was prepared by the Holy See's own Secretariat of State.
  • The existing source entries SRC-CRIMEN-SOLLICITATIONIS, SRC-SST-2001, SRC-VOS-ESTIS-2019 and SRC-RESCRIPT-2019-SECRET point to magisterium.com; the texts were compared today on vatican.va (saved files named in the note).
  • The Congregation's historical introduction says most copies of the 1962 reprint were never distributed; that is the Congregation's own account.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

Catholic teaching does not promise that popes or bishops will be holy or competent. Christ chose Judas among the Twelve and said the weeds would grow with the wheat until the harvest; the Catechism teaches that Christ's presence does not preserve his ministers from 'error, even sin'; and the Second Vatican Council calls the Church at the same time holy and always in need of being purified. What the First Vatican Council defined in 1870 is that a pope is kept from error when he defines ex cathedra a doctrine of faith or morals for the whole Church, the Spirit being promised to guard the apostolic deposit, not to reveal new doctrine.

Rests on
  • Matthew 13:27-30 (NAB, vatican.va IntraText __PVM.HTM)
    “The slaves of the householder came to him and said, 'Master, did you not sow good seed in your field? Where have the weeds come from?' He answered, 'An enemy has done this.' His slaves said to him, 'Do you want us to go and pull them up?' He …”
    Read the full passage
    “The slaves of the householder came to him and said, 'Master, did you not sow good seed in your field? Where have the weeds come from?' He answered, 'An enemy has done this.' His slaves said to him, 'Do you want us to go and pull them up?' He replied, 'No, if you pull up the weeds you might uproot the wheat along with them. Let them grow together until harvest”
  • Matthew 13:38
    “the field is the world”
  • Note on Matthew 13:24-30
    “The refusal of the householder to allow his slaves to separate the wheat from the weeds while they are still growing is a warning to the disciples not to attempt to anticipate the final judgment of God by a definitive exclusion of sinners from the kingdom.”
  • John 6:70-71 (NAB, vatican.va IntraText __PXE.HTM)
    “Jesus answered them, "Did I not choose you twelve? Yet is not one of you a devil?" He was referring to Judas, son of Simon the Iscariot; it was he who would betray him, one of the Twelve.”
  • Sermon 3, section 4 (NPNF)
    “that in my humble person he may be recognized and honoured, in whom abides the care of all the shepherds, together with the charge of the sheep commended to him, and whose dignity is not abated even in so unworthy an heir.”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4
    “For the holy Spirit was promised to the successors of Peter not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new doctrine, but that, by his assistance, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles.”
  • Pastor Aeternus, chapter 4, the definition
    “when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole …”
    Read the full passage
    “when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA, that is, when, in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole church, he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter, that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.”
  • CCC 1550
    “This presence of Christ in the minister is not to be understood as if the latter were preserved from all human weaknesses, the spirit of domination, error, even sin. the power of the Holy Spirit does not guarantee all acts of ministers in the same way.”
  • CCC 827
    “All members of the Church, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners. In everyone, the weeds of sin will still be mixed with the good wheat of the Gospel until the end of time.”
  • Lumen Gentium 8
    “the Church, embracing in its bosom sinners, at the same time holy and always in need of being purified, always follows the way of penance and renewal.”
  • Unitatis Redintegratio 6
    “Christ summons the Church to continual reformation as she sojourns here on earth. The Church is always in need of this, in so far as she is an institution of men here on earth.”
Other readings
  • Many Protestant readers accept that the visible Church is mixed but deny that any office in it carries a guarantee; the Westminster Confession says some churches degenerate until they are no churches of Christ.
  • Orthodox readers accept indefectibility of the Church but locate it in the whole body, not in the bishop of Rome.
Limits
  • The Catholic claim that no pope has ever defined a false doctrine depends on which papal acts count as definitions; that question is treated in the chapter on Vatican I.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Named public inquiries on three continents document the scale of clerical sexual abuse of children. The John Jay study (2004) counted allegations, not withdrawn or known to be false, against 4,392 US priests serving from 1950 to 2002, 4 per cent of the 109,694 priests the dioceses and religious communities reported, made by 10,667 people. Australia's Royal Commission (2017), from claims received by Catholic authorities from 1980 to 2015 and a survey of priests, found that 507 of 9,025 priests serving from 1950 to 2010 were alleged perpetrators: 5.6 per cent by head count, 7 per cent weighting for length of ministry. France's CIASE (2021) estimated from a population survey 216,000 victims of clergy and religious since 1950 (95 per cent range 165,000 to 270,000). Ireland's Ryan report (2009) found abuse endemic in boys' institutions, and Pennsylvania's grand jury (2018) identified over three hundred predator priests and over a thousand child victims.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The John Jay researchers note that more than a third of all allegations were made only in 2002-2003, so their figures are a count of what dioceses knew, not of what happened.
  • The CIASE figure is an estimate projected from a population survey, not a count of cases, and it includes abuse by religious who were not priests.
Limits
  • The inquiries used different methods and periods and cannot be added together or compared as rates.
  • The Ryan report concerns industrial and reformatory schools run by religious congregations for the Irish State; it also found the State's Department of Education at fault.
  • The Pennsylvania figures concern six of the state's eight dioceses and count allegations in diocesan files, most too old to prosecute.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11InferenceDisputed Quotes checked

Whether the record of bad popes and scandals is compatible with the Catholic claim is disputed. Catholic teaching distinguishes the holiness of the Church from the sins of its members and confesses those sins, as at the Day of Pardon in 2000. Lutheran confessions (1537) hold that the papacy is a human institution, unnecessary to the Church, and call the pope Antichrist because he will not let Christians be saved without his power; the Westminster Confession (1647) holds that churches can degenerate until they cease to be churches; and the Ecumenical Patriarchate (1895) holds that no one on earth but Christ is infallible, citing Honorius.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Catholic answer is that the holiness of the Church is Christ's gift and does not depend on its ministers, while the sins of its members are real and are confessed.
  • The Lutheran answer is that the Church continues wherever the Gospel is preached and the sacraments administered, with or without the pope.
  • The Orthodox answer is that the Church is indefectible as a whole, and that its councils may judge any bishop, including Rome's.
Limits
  • The Westminster Confession's article calling the pope 'that Antichrist' was replaced in the American Presbyterian revision of 1903; the chapter quotes the revision for the modern Reformed view.
  • The 1895 encyclical is a formal reply to Leo XIII's Praeclara gratulationis, polemical by genre; later Orthodox-Catholic dialogue is not covered here.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next