← Orthodox
The pope and unity

Does Rome think the pope is above the councils?

Read it as an illustrated story · 8 min

Not above the faith, and not apart from the . and belong together, and neither may teach anything new. But a Catholic council in 1870 said you can't appeal from a pope to a council, and that a pope's solemn ruling doesn't need a later vote to count.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Code of Canon Law
canon 1404canon 333 §3

Here's the worry, and it's a serious one.

In the first thousand years, before the Catholic Church and the Orthodox went separate ways, big questions were settled by councils: meetings of bishops from every part of the Christian world. A council counted when the whole Church accepted it.6

The Orthodox still hold that. For them, being kept from error belongs to the whole Church, speaking through councils everyone accepts.7

Then you read what the , a Catholic council, said in 1870. A pope's solemn rulings on the faith are final of themselves, and not by the consent of the church.1 In other words, they don't need the Church to vote yes afterwards.

It also says you can't appeal from a pope's ruling to a council, as if the council were above him.1

Read cold, that sounds like one man above everyone.

That's a fair way to read the words. But each of those lines was aimed at something very specific.

What the line was aimed at

For centuries before 1870, a movement among Catholics, with deep roots in France, said a council is above the pope. A pope's teaching, it said, only became final once the bishops had agreed to it afterwards.4,7

So some Catholics once held a view close to the Orthodox one. The 1870 line was written against it.

Catholic and Orthodox scholars, studying it together in 2023, agreed that the line was not separating the pope from the and faith of the Church.7 No vote is needed afterwards. But the pope isn't teaching apart from what the Church believes.

Why does it matter that no vote is needed? Because without a final word, any ruling could be reopened forever.

Think of it like this

Think of a referee at a football match. It's the last minute of a cup final, the score is level, and a defender brings down a striker in the box. The referee blows his whistle and points to the spot. Penalty.

Even with video replays, the checks happen before the final call. Once he gives it, the call stands. The players don't troop into the changing room afterwards and vote on whether it counts. If they could, no match would ever really finish.

But the referee isn't above the game either. He didn't write the rules, and he can't make new ones up. He can't give a penalty because he likes one team's shirts. His whole job is to apply a rulebook that binds him as much as anyone on the pitch.

That's the Catholic picture of the pope. The call stands on its own, and it's still bound by the game.

Every analogy has a limit, and here it is. A referee answers to his league, which can review his calls after the match.

Catholics say a pope's solemn ruling has no league above it on earth. It answers to God, and to the faith it's bound by.

No pope can invent new beliefs

The Catholic Church teaches that a pope can never make up a new belief.

The same 1870 council said the was promised to 's successors not so that they might, by his revelation, make known some new . It was promised so they could guard and explain the faith handed down from the .1

The said it even more strongly in the 1960s. When the pope, or the bishops with him, define something, it must match what God has revealed, which all are obliged to abide by and be in conformity with.2 The pope is bound by that too.

In 1875, the German bishops explained what the 1870 council meant, and the pope said they had it right. The pope's power doesn't shrink the bishops' own, they said. And his teaching is bound to the , to tradition and to what the Church had already decided.4

Pope and council together

In Catholic teaching, the bishops together with the pope hold the highest authority over the whole Church, used most solemnly at a council. But they can't use it without the pope, and the gift of being kept from error belongs to them together with him.3

A council of the whole Church only counts if the pope confirms it, or at least recognises it.3 So a council isn't a court above the pope. And the pope isn't a ruler outside the council. He's its head, and a council isn't complete without him.

And popes are expected to listen first. The 1870 council itself listed ways they find out what the Church believes, such as calling councils or asking the churches around the world.1

Two examples. In 1854 a pope declared that Mary was free from from the first moment of her life. In 1950 another declared that she was taken body and soul into . Before each one, the pope wrote to bishops everywhere and asked what their people believed.4

Pope Francis put it this way in 2015: the Pope is not, by himself, above the Church; but within it as one of the .4

What if a pope got it wrong?

That leads to the obvious next question. If a pope solemnly taught something false, who could stop him?

Catholics answer in two parts. The first is the whole point of 1870: they believe it can't happen. The guarantee isn't the pope's brains or his goodness. It's the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter: God keeping his Church in the truth.1

So in Catholic eyes the safety net is God's promise, not a court.

The Orthodox reply that this is exactly the trust they can't place in one bishop. The head of the Church, they say, is , not a mortal, sinful man. For them the safety net is the whole Church, recognising its own faith in what a council says.7

The Orthodox point to a case from 553. A council at Constantinople went ahead without Pope Vigilius, who refused to attend.11

It even struck his name from the prayers in church. Months later, he accepted its rulings.11

Catholics say that approval is what made it count. The Orthodox say a council had acted without the pope, and even against him.

The second part: outside those rare solemn rulings, a pope can be wrong. In the 680s a council of the whole Church condemned an earlier pope, Honorius, as a heretic over a false teaching about Jesus, and Pope Leo II approved the verdict.8

Critics point to Honorius as proof that a pope can teach error. Catholics answer that his letters were never meant as a solemn ruling, and that Leo II condemned him for failing to stop the false teaching, not for teaching it.8

Even so, no Church court sits above a pope. Church law says The First See is judged by no one: the bishop of Rome can't be put on trial. And there's no appeal against his decisions.9,10

And if a pope openly taught against the faith? Many Catholic theologians have held that a pope who became a public heretic, teaching against a defined belief, would stop being pope by that very fact. A 1910 Catholic reference book adds that this is a hypothetical case which has never actually occurred.8

The nearest thing to a crisis came in the early 1400s, when two and then three men claimed to be pope at once. A council at Constance, in today's Germany, ended it. It removed one claimant whose election was in doubt, and the most likely rightful pope resigned.7,8

The same Catholic reference book calls that an emergency outside the normal rules, not a model for removing a pope.8

That council also declared that a council's authority stands above the pope's. The idea fed the French movement described above. The Catholic Church condemned it in the 1510s, and ruled it out in 1870.7

So the Catholic answer is trust: not in the man, but in God's promise to his Church. Whether that promise was ever given to one bishop is exactly what the Orthodox doubt.

The honest gap

To be honest, the 1870 council left a hole. The outbreak of the Franco-Prussian War cut it short, so it never finished what it meant to say about bishops. The Second Vatican Council finished that job in the 1960s.4

And it never said how a pope must consult the Church. A 2024 Vatican study admits it remained silent about the need to involve or consult the church.4 The Orthodox notice that silence, and fairly.

In 2007 the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue commission named the big open question. How should Catholic teaching on the pope be understood and lived, in the light of how the Church actually worked in its first thousand years?5

That's the question still on the table, and Catholics are asking it too.

So here it is in short. A pope can't make up a new belief, and he doesn't teach apart from what the Church believes.

A council can't overrule a pope, or count without him. And neither of them may teach anything new.

Sources11
  1. 1First Vatican Council, Pastor Aeternus (1870), chapter 4The definition, the ways popes consult the Church, and the limit: no new doctrine.
  2. 2Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 25Definitions follow Revelation, which binds all; the Church's assent is never lacking.
  3. 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 883–884, 891The college of bishops with the pope; councils and the pope's confirmation.
  4. 4Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, The Bishop of Rome (2024), Introduction 5 and 60–61, 65–66, 72Gallicanism, the 1875 German bishops, Vatican I cut short, Vatican I's silence on consulting the Church, the consultations before 1854 and 1950, Francis in 2015.
  5. 5Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 45How to read Vatican I and II in the light of the first millennium, named as the crucial question.
  6. 6Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy during the First Millennium (Chieti, 2016), 18Reception by the whole Church as the final test of an ecumenical council.
  7. 7Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy in the Second Millennium and Today (Alexandria, 2023), 1.15–1.16, 3.7, 3.10Agreed reading of not by the consent of the church (against the Gallican article of 1682); the Orthodox view that infallibility belongs to the whole Church. Constance (1414–1418) and conciliarism, condemned at Lateran V and excluded by Vatican I.
  8. 8Patrick Toner, "Infallibility", Catholic Encyclopedia (1910)Honorius; Constance and the doubtful claimant; the theologians' view that a pope who became a public heretic would cease to be pope, a case that never occurred.
  9. 9Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 1404"The First See is judged by no one."
  10. 10Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 333 §3No appeal or recourse against a decision of the pope.
  11. 11Second Council of Constantinople (553), acts and the decretal letter of Pope Vigilius (NPNF, New Advent)Vigilius refused to attend; the emperor's order to strike his name from the diptychs; six months later his letter confirming the council.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.