← Orthodox
The pope and unity

If we reunited, would the Orthodox have to accept everything Rome defined after 1054?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

No one can promise a full answer yet. But the Catholic Church has said unity should lay no burden beyond what is essential. It must be a meeting of sister Churches, not the being swallowed up. How Rome's later councils would count is being studied together now.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Here's the problem. After East and West split, a break usually dated to 1054, the Catholic Church kept holding big councils, and counts some of them as councils of the whole Church.4 The Orthodox count only seven, the last in 787.8,9

Some of those later councils taught things the Orthodox reject. Above all, the 1870 teaching that the has full power over every church and is kept from error in his solemn rulings.

Popes also defined two teachings of their own about Mary. In 1854: she was free from , the wound we're all born with, from her first moment. The Orthodox reject that.11,12

In 1950: she was taken body and soul into . Many Orthodox believe that too, but reject a pope making it binding.13,14

So the fear is fair. Would reunion mean signing up to everything Rome decided while the East wasn't even in the room?

The hesitation runs deep. A big 2017 survey found that in most Orthodox countries of Eastern Europe, fewer than half wanted reunion.6,10

Yet most also said the two faiths have a lot in common.6 But the hesitation is about real beliefs, above all the pope's role.

Only what is essential

Rome won't call its later teachings false. But it has said a lot about what it would and wouldn't ask.

First, it says real unity can't be bought by blurring the faith. The warned against a fake peace, where everyone smiles and the meaning of Catholic belief quietly gets clouded.2

But the same set the rule for unity with the East: to impose no burden beyond what is essential.2 And it said the Eastern Churches have the power to govern themselves according to the disciplines proper to them: their own rules, their own way of running things.2

It added that Catholic beliefs form a hierarchy of truths. That isn't about ranks of . It means some beliefs sit right at the heart of the faith, and others further out.2

None of them is optional for Catholics. But talks can start from the centre and work outwards.

In 1993 the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue commission described the unity both sides want: neither absorption nor fusion but a meeting in truth and love.3 Not one Church swallowing the other. Two sisters meeting.

Measured by the first thousand years

Then something remarkable. In 1982, a German theologian called Joseph Ratzinger wrote that, on the pope's role, Rome must not require more of the East than was formulated and lived during the first millennium.1

That was a theologian's view, not a Church ruling.

But twenty-three years later, that same man became Pope Benedict XVI. And a 2024 Vatican study quotes his words again, as a sign of hope.1

said the Catholic Church desires nothing less than between East and West: being one Church again. He found the model in the first thousand years, when Christians felt at home in any Church.5

Think of it like this

Picture a class split into two groups for a big project. Halfway through the term the groups fell out, and each carried on in a different room.

While they were apart, one group wrote forty extra pages. New sections, new rules for the layout, a whole chapter on who gets the final say. Some of it is genuinely good. The other group never saw it, was never asked about it, and never signed off on any of it.

Now the class wants to hand in one project together. What's the fair way to do it? It isn't to slide the forty pages across the desk and say sign under everything we wrote.

It's to start from what both groups had agreed before the split, and sort out together what's really core. Some of the new pages might turn out to be worth keeping. But that's something you work out side by side, not something one side hands to the other.

So what about 1870?

In 2007 the joint commission admitted that after the split, each side kept holding its own councils. A way back to deciding things together, it said, still has to be found.4

So would the Orthodox have to accept 1870? Catholics can't call it false. But the 2024 Vatican study gathers a proposal from the talks: read the 1870 teaching afresh, even in new words, faithful to the original intention but set inside a Church that works as a family of Churches.1

Another proposal: separate the pope's role as head of the Western Church from his role serving the unity of everyone.1 What all that would mean in practice hasn't been agreed.

There are signs of the spirit, though. When the pope prayed the Creed at Nicaea with the Ecumenical Patriarch in 2025, he left out the West's added words, and the Son.7 Rome doesn't need the East to say everything the way the West says it.

That isn't new. In 1995 the Vatican's office for Christian unity said the Creed's original Greek wording has conciliar, ecumenical, normative, and irrevocable value.15

It agreed with the East that the Father is the one source of the Son and the Spirit, which the added words seemed to deny.15

So would the Orthodox have to accept everything? Rome has said it would ask only what is essential.

And the two teachings about Mary? Honestly, no pope or joint commission has settled that yet. Catholics can't call them false.

Much is already shared. The Orthodox teach Mary had no of her own, and many believe she was taken body and soul to heaven.14

And John Paul II and the 2024 Vatican study both look to the first thousand years as the guide. What exactly counts as essential is the question the two Churches are now answering together.

Sources15
  1. 1Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, The Bishop of Rome (2024), 91, 178–179Quotes Ratzinger (Theologische Prinzipienlehre, 1982, p. 209); proposes a re-reception of Vatican I.
  2. 2Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 11, 16, 18No false irenicism; a hierarchy of truths; Eastern self-government; no burden beyond what is essential.
  3. 3Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Balamand Document (1993), 14Communion as neither absorption nor fusion but a meeting in truth and love.
  4. 4Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Ravenna Document (2007), 39Councils held separately after the split; ecumenical consensus must be re-established.
  5. 5John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 61Full communion between East and West, inspired by the first millennium.
  6. 6Pew Research Center, Orthodox Christians ... lukewarm toward reconciling with Roman Catholic Church (8 November 2017)Fewer than half of Orthodox in 12 of 13 countries favour communion with Rome.
  7. 7USCCB / Catholic News Service, Though Nicaea is a ruin, its Creed stands (28 November 2025)The Creed prayed together at İznik without the filioque.
  8. 8Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Synodality and Primacy during the First Millennium (Chieti, 2016), 18The seventh ecumenical council (Nicaea II, 787) and how councils were received.
  9. 9Ecumenical Patriarch Anthimos VII and his Synod, Patriarchal Encyclical (1895), 7–13The Orthodox speak of the Church of the seven Ecumenical Councils.
  10. 10Pew Research Center, Orthodox Christianity in the 21st Century (full report, 8 November 2017), chapter 3By country: Orthodox for and against the two Churches being in communion again (Greece 35% for, 40% against, 25% unsure).
  11. 11Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus (8 December 1854)The definition of the Immaculate Conception.
  12. 12St John the Evangelist Orthodox Church, "What Orthodox Christians Believe About the Immaculate Conception"An Orthodox parish explains why Orthodoxy rejects the doctrine.
  13. 13Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1 November 1950)The definition of the Assumption and its binding force.
  14. 14Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2: Dormition of the TheotokosThe Orthodox teach Mary is without personal sins, and that having died she was raised up by her Son.
  15. 15Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, The Greek and Latin Traditions regarding the Procession of the Holy Spirit (1995)The Creed's original Greek wording has conciliar, ecumenical, normative and irrevocable value; the Father as the sole origin of the Son and the Spirit.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.