From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/do-i-have-to-believe-in-purgatory
← OrthodoxDo I have to believe in purgatory the way Rome describes it?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minNot the way most people picture it. Only a little is binding for Catholics: some who die as God's friends still need cleansing, and our prayers help them. A place, a fire, a length of time: none of that is defined. What many reject is the medieval picture.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
Say the word and many people picture a third place between and . Souls burn in real fire to pay off a debt, and the Catholic Church can cut their sentence short.
For many Orthodox, that's exactly the problem. It sounds like a court, not a family.
A Greek , St Mark of Ephesus, fought that picture when East and West met at Florence in the 1430s. He agreed some souls must be cleansed after death. But not by fire, in some place, because that has not been handed down to us.1
Both Churches pray for the dead, and always have: Catholics above all at , the Orthodox at their memorial services (mnimosyna to Greeks, panikhida to Russians).1,2,3,8
So the real argument was never about whether to pray for the dead.
It's about what's left once you take away the medieval pictures.
What you're actually asked to believe
The Catholic Church teaches that some people die as God's friends but aren't yet fully healed of . God finishes the work after death, and the prayers of the living help. The puts the core like this:
All who die in God's grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven.
Notice the words assured of their eternal . They're safe. Purgatory isn't a second chance or a halfway hell. The Catechism says it's entirely different from the punishment of the damned.3
Think of it like this
Imagine you've flown across the world for a cousin's wedding. The flight took fourteen hours. You land late, rush straight to the venue, and you're still in yesterday's shirt.
The music has already started. Your seat at the dinner is guaranteed. Your name card is on the table, next to your favourite aunt. Nobody is going to turn you away at the door.
But you'd still want to slip upstairs first, shower, and put on something clean. Catching yourself in the mirror stings a bit: you see how rough you look. And scrubbing off a day of travel takes effort.
Nobody is making you. You just want to walk in ready for the feast.
Nobody calls the shower a punishment. It's getting ready for the party. That's purgatory as Catholics see it. The guest is already in.
The cleaning is real, and it can hurt, the way facing the truth about yourself hurts. But it's for the feast.
What was never defined
The official ruling, from the Council of Florence in 1439, is short. Souls who die truly sorry, before they've made up for their sins, are cleansed after death by cleansing pains, and our prayers help them.4
It says nothing about fire or a place. The Catechism does use the old picture of a cleansing fire.3 But a picture that helps explain isn't a definition.
In the 1560s the added nothing new. It told bishops to keep hard questions out of sermons, and to stamp out anything that smelled of superstition or money.5 It also abolished the collectors who preached while raising money, because of the scandal they caused.6
So no, you don't have to picture it the medieval way. The fire, the place and the length of time have never been defined.
Why Catholics believe it
First, the ancient habit of praying for the dead. The Catechism points to a book called Second Maccabees. It's in Catholic and Orthodox Bibles, but not ones. There Judas Maccabeus, a Jewish army leader long before Jesus (not the Judas who betrayed him), offers a sacrifice for soldiers killed in battle.3
And the Church has prayed for the dead from the beginning, above all at the .3 Praying for the dead only makes sense if they can still be helped.
Second, God's holiness and our honesty. Most of us die forgiven but not yet fully changed. pictures someone saved, but only as through fire (1 Corinthians 3:15).
In 2007 Benedict XVI offered a beautiful way to read that fire. Some theologians, he wrote, think the fire which both burns and saves is himself.2 Meeting him burns away what's false in us and heals us.2 He offered it as a way to explain, not as a new rule.
Forgiven, but still healing
This is the part many people find hardest: how can anything be left once you're forgiven?
The Catechism says sin does two kinds of harm. Serious sin cuts us off from God, and forgiveness heals that. But every sin also leaves an unhealthy attachment behind: a pull, a habit, damage that still needs healing, here or after death.7
The Church calls that leftover damage the temporal punishment of sin. An indulgence is a release from that temporal punishment, for sins whose guilt has already been forgiven. The Church grants it, under conditions it sets.7
The word punishment can make it sound like a court again, not a family. But it isn't God taking revenge. The Catechism says these punishments must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without, but as following from the very nature of sin.7
What your memorial prayers ask
If you're Orthodox, you already pray for the dead in words a Catholic could say. Memorial services are often held on the third, ninth and fortieth days after a death.8 And one Orthodox prayer for the departed asks God to:9
give rest to the souls of Thy departed servants in a place of brightness, a place of refreshment, a place of repose, where all sickness, sighing, and sorrow have fled away. Pardon every transgression which they have committed, whether by word or deed or thought.
That prayer asks God to forgive the dead and bring them to rest. It takes for granted that they can still be helped after death.
Catholics pray for the same thing, above all at Mass, so that the dead, thus purified, may see God.3
So is purgatory what you pray for at a panikhida? The prayer is the same. The disagreement is over how to explain what it asks for.
What still divides
To be honest, a real gap is left. Benedict XVI noted that the East doesn't accept that souls suffer to be cleansed after death.2
And there's no single Orthodox view. Some speak of a cleansing helped by the Church's prayers. Others speak only of a time of waiting.1
But the core is small and shared. You're asked to believe that God finishes what he starts in us, and that love for the dead can still reach them. St Mark of Ephesus believed both of those too.
Sources9
- 1OrthodoxWiki, PurgatorySt Mark of Ephesus's statement at Florence; Orthodox views including the toll-houses.
- 2Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (30 November 2007), 47–48The fire as Christ himself; prayer for the dead common to East and West; what the East does not accept.
- 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1030–1032The final purification of the elect; prayer for the dead from the beginning.
- 4Council of Florence, Laetentur Caeli (6 July 1439)Souls "cleansed after death by cleansing pains", helped by the living.
- 5Council of Trent, Session 25: Decree on Purgatory (December 1563)Subtle questions kept out of sermons; superstition and money-making forbidden.
- 6Council of Trent, Session 21, chapter 9 (16 July 1562)The office of questors of alms abolished.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1473Temporal punishment and indulgences, not God's vengeance.
- 8Orthodox Church in America, Questions & Answers: Prayers for the DepartedPanikhida, Mnemosyno and the other memorial services; the third, ninth and fortieth days; boiled wheat and honey.
- 9Orthodox Church in America, Prayers: For the DepartedThe prayer "O God of spirits and of all flesh": rest for the departed and pardon of their sins.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.