Do I have to believe in purgatory the way Rome describes it?
Not the way most people picture it. Only a little is binding for Catholics: some people who die as God's friends still need to be made clean, through what an old council called cleansing pains, and our prayers help them. A place, a fire, a length of time: none of that has ever been defined. What many Orthodox reject is the medieval picture, and you're not asked to believe it.
Part 1 · The worry
Say the word purgatory, and many people picture a third place between and .
Souls burn in real fire to pay off a debt, and the Catholic Church can cut their sentence short.
Catholics, Protestants and the are the three main branches of Christianity. Orthodox Christians often call the Catholic Church Rome, after the 's city.
And for many Orthodox, that picture is exactly the problem. It sounds like a court, not a family.
The argument is old. East and West, Orthodox and Catholic, were one Church for about a thousand years, and then they grew apart.
In the 1430s, from both sides, the leaders of the Church in each region, met at Florence, in Italy, to end the split.
One Greek bishop there, St Mark of Ephesus, fought the medieval picture. He agreed that some souls must be cleansed after death.
But not by fire, he said, and not in some place, because that has not been handed down to us.
And both Churches pray for the dead, and always have. Catholics do it above all at , the Catholic Sunday service.
The Orthodox do it at memorial services, often on the third, ninth and fortieth days after a death. Greeks call them mnimosyna, and Russians panikhida.
So the real argument was never about whether to pray for the dead.
It's about what's left once you take away the medieval pictures.
Part 2 · What you're actually asked to believe
Take those pictures away, and here's what the Catholic Church teaches.
Some people die as God's friends but aren't yet fully healed of . God finishes the work after death, and our prayers help.
The , the Catholic Church's official summary of its beliefs, puts the core like this:
All who die in God's grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven.
Notice the words assured of their eternal salvation. They're safe. Purgatory isn't a second chance, or a halfway hell.
Christians believe Jesus rose from the dead, and brings everyone who comes home to him through death into life with him.
So why the cleansing at all? Here's an analogy that might help. Imagine you've flown across the world for a cousin's wedding.
The flight took 14 hours. You land late, rush straight to the venue, and you're still in yesterday's shirt.
The music has already started. Your seat at the dinner is guaranteed. Your name card is on the table, next to your favourite aunt.
Nobody is going to turn you away at the door.
But you'd still want to slip upstairs first, shower, and put on something clean.
Catching yourself in the mirror stings a bit: you see how rough you look. And scrubbing off a day of travel takes effort.
Nobody is making you. You just want to walk in ready for the feast.
Nobody calls the shower a punishment. It's getting ready for the party.
That's as Catholics see it. The guest is already in.
The cleaning is real, and it can hurt, the way facing the truth about yourself hurts. But it's for the feast.
So what did the Catholic Church actually define? The official ruling came from that same meeting at Florence, in 1439, and it's short.
Souls who die truly sorry, before they've made up for their sins, are cleansed after death by cleansing pains, and our prayers help them.
In the 1560s, another meeting of bishops, the , added nothing new.
It told bishops to keep hard questions out of sermons, and to stamp out anything that smelled of superstition or money.
Florence's ruling speaks of pains, but it says nothing about fire or a place.
The Catechism does use the old picture of a cleansing fire. But a picture that helps explain isn't a definition.
So no, you don't have to picture it the medieval way.
The fire, the place and the length of time have never been defined.
Part 3 · Why Catholics believe it
So why do Catholics believe in it at all? First, because of the ancient habit of praying for the dead.
The Catechism points to a book called Second Maccabees. It's in Catholic and Orthodox Bibles, but not ones.
In it, Judas Maccabeus, a Jewish army leader long before Jesus, offers a sacrifice for soldiers already killed in battle.
He isn't the Judas who betrayed Jesus. That was a different man.
And the Church has prayed for the dead from the beginning, above all at the , the meal Jesus gave at his last supper.
Praying for the dead only makes sense if they can still be helped.
Second, God is holy, and we have to be honest about ourselves. Most of us die forgiven, but not yet fully changed.
, one of the first Christian leaders, wrote about someone who is saved, but only as through fire.
In 2007 Pope Benedict XVI, then the leader of the Catholic Church, offered a beautiful way to read that fire.
Some theologians, people who study the faith, think the fire which both burns and saves is Christ himself, he wrote.
Meeting him burns away what's false in us, and heals us.
offered it as a way to explain, not as a new rule.
But how can anything be left once you're forgiven? The Catechism says sin does two kinds of harm. Serious sin cuts us off from God.
Forgiveness heals that break. But every sin also leaves an unhealthy attachment, damage that still needs healing, here or after death.
The Church calls that leftover damage the temporal punishment of sin. Temporal just means it lasts for a time.
The word punishment can make it sound like a court again, not a family. But it isn't God taking revenge. The Catechism says these punishments:
must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without, but as following from the very nature of sin.
Here's where come in. An indulgence is a release from that temporal punishment, for sins whose guilt has already been forgiven.
The Church grants it, under conditions it sets.
To be honest, indulgences once got tangled up with money.
The same Council of Trent abolished the collectors who preached indulgences while raising money, because of the scandal they caused.
Part 4 · The prayer we share
If you're Orthodox, you already pray for the dead in words a Catholic could say. One Orthodox prayer for the departed asks God to:
give rest to the souls of Thy departed servants in a place of brightness, a place of refreshment, a place of repose, where all sickness, sighing, and sorrow have fled away. Pardon every transgression which they have committed, whether by word or deed or thought.
That prayer asks God to forgive the dead and bring them to rest. It takes for granted that they can still be helped after death.
Catholics pray for the same thing, above all at Mass, so that the dead, thus purified, may see God.
So is purgatory what you're praying for at a memorial service, a panikhida?
The prayer is the same. The disagreement is over how to explain what it asks for.
To be honest, a real gap is left. Benedict XVI noted that the East doesn't accept that souls suffer to be cleansed after death.
And there's no single Orthodox view. Some speak of a cleansing helped by the Church's prayers. Others speak only of a time of waiting.
But what's left, once the medieval pictures are gone, is small, and most of it is shared.
You're asked to believe that God finishes what he starts in us, and that love for the dead can still reach them.
St Mark of Ephesus, the Greek bishop who fought the medieval picture at Florence, believed both of those too.
Think back to the wedding. Why do you slip upstairs to shower before you walk in?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 9
- OrthodoxWiki, Purgatory · St Mark of Ephesus's statement at Florence; Orthodox views including the toll-houses.
- Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (30 November 2007), 47–48 · The fire as Christ himself; prayer for the dead common to East and West; what the East does not accept.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1030–1032 · The final purification of the elect; prayer for the dead from the beginning.
- Council of Florence, Laetentur Caeli (6 July 1439) · Souls "cleansed after death by cleansing pains", helped by the living.
- Council of Trent, Session 25: Decree on Purgatory (December 1563) · Subtle questions kept out of sermons; superstition and money-making forbidden.
- Council of Trent, Session 21, chapter 9 (16 July 1562) · The office of questors of alms abolished.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1473 · Temporal punishment and indulgences, not God's vengeance.
- Orthodox Church in America, Questions & Answers: Prayers for the Departed · Panikhida, Mnemosyno and the other memorial services; the third, ninth and fortieth days; boiled wheat and honey.
- Orthodox Church in America, Prayers: For the Departed · The prayer "O God of spirits and of all flesh": rest for the departed and pardon of their sins.