If all believers are priests, why do Catholics have priests and call them 'Father'?
Catholics agree that every baptised Christian shares in Christ's priesthood. But they believe Jesus also set some apart to serve the rest, the way Israel had priests inside a whole priestly people. They're called Father the way Paul called himself a father to the people he'd brought to faith.
Part 1 · The worry
Two verses sit behind this question. A priest, in the Bible, is someone set apart to offer sacrifices to God for the people.
In a letter, tells ordinary believers they're a royal priesthood.
And Jesus says:
Call no one on earth your father; you have but one Father in heaven.
So a special group of priests, all called Father, can look like a step backwards.
Jesus pulled down the wall between ordinary people and God. Did Catholics build it back up?
Part 2 · Every Christian is a priest
started the Reformation in 1517.
He said every Christian is made a priest at . And Catholics agree with him.
The Catholic Church teaches that the whole community of believers is priestly. Every baptised Christian shares in 's priesthood.
They live it out through a life of faith, hope, and charity. Charity here means love.
But Luther also wrote: It is true that all Christians are priests, but not all are pastors.
And most churches still ordain ministers: they set some people apart to lead.
So the real question isn't whether to have ministers. It's what their job is.
Setting some apart inside a whole priestly people goes back a long way.
After God led the people of Israel out of slavery in Egypt, they camped at Mount Sinai in the desert.
There God told the whole people of Israel: You will be to me a kingdom of priests. He meant every one of them.
Yet inside that priestly people, he set apart one tribe, Levi, to look after the place of worship.
And within Levi, one family, Aaron's, served as the priests at the altar, where offerings were made to God.
A tribe was one of Israel's twelve family groups. It was a whole nation of priests, and still some were set apart for a job.
Catholics see the same pattern in the Church today. There's the priesthood all baptised people share, and there's the priesthood of and priests.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says they're different in kind, not just in degree.
Different how? The first is every believer's whole life offered to God, through faith, hope and love.
The second is passed on to a few by its own , .
A sacrament is a sign through which Catholics believe God really acts.
Through this one, Christ builds up and leads his Church, for everyone else's sake.
The Catechism says that second priesthood is at the service of the common priesthood, the one everyone shares.
It copies Christ, who by love made himself the least and the servant of all.
There's still only one real priest, in the deepest sense. The Catechism says it bluntly:
Only Christ is the true priest, the others being only his ministers.
Part 3 · Protestants have a fair point
To be fair, the Bible itself shows something here.
In the , the Greek word for priest is never used for a church leader.
It's kept for Christ, and for all believers together. Church leaders are called elders and overseers instead.
Over time, Christians started calling the leaders who led priests.
In fact, the English word priest comes from the Greek presbyteros, which means elder: the very word the New Testament uses for church leaders.
A 1982 report by Protestant, and Catholic scholars says the word links these leaders' work to Christ's priesthood.
So the gap isn't about the word. Anglicans often say Father too, and so do the Orthodox.
The real difference between Catholics and most Protestants is whether ordained ministers are priests who offer the , the bread and wine of Communion.
Some of that gap has closed.
In 2013, Lutherans and Catholics repeated together that all the baptized who believe in Christ share in the priesthood of Christ.
They still disagree about whether ordination is a sacrament.
Part 4 · What about “call no one father”?
Now back to Jesus's words, call no one on earth your father. Read the verse in its place.
Jesus is criticising religious leaders who love the best seats and the grand titles.
In the same breath, Jesus also says not to be called teacher.
So if it's a strict ban on words, every Christian who says teacher, Doctor or Dad is breaking it.
A footnote in the New American Bible, a Catholic translation, says Jesus is forbidding the pride that comes with titles, not just the titles.
That warning is real, and it hits Catholic priests as hard as anyone.
Some Christians say Jesus only meant a father in the faith, not your dad.
But the New Testament uses the word that way too.
wrote to one church:
I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel.
Stephen, the first Christian killed for his faith, stood before the judging him and began: My brothers and fathers.
So Catholics read Jesus's words as a warning about pride, not a ban on a word. Here's an analogy that might help.
Think of a little girl whose dad has a best friend from school.
He's at every birthday party, and he taught her to ride a bike. When her dad was in hospital, he picked her up from school.
She calls him Uncle Ben, but he isn't her uncle. And nobody thinks she's confused about who her family is.
She doesn't call him that because he's taking her dad's place.
Her dad is still her dad, and the friend would be the first to say so.
She calls him that because of what he does for her.
He turns up, he looks out for her, and he treats her like his own.
And that's what Father means for a priest. It isn't a claim to replace God, or to stand where only God can stand.
It's a family word for someone who isn't literally family, but who looks after you like family.
So a Catholic priest isn't meant to stand between you and God.
He's meant to stand beside you, one of a priestly people, set apart to serve the rest.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 9
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1539–1551 · Israel's priesthood; the common priesthood of all the baptised; the ministerial priesthood as service.
- 1 Peter 2:9 (New American Bible) · Believers as a royal priesthood.
- Matthew 23:1–12, with the New American Bible's notes (on vatican.va) · Call no one on earth your father; the note on titles and pride.
- 1 Corinthians 4:15 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Paul: I became your father in Christ Jesus.
- Acts 7:2 (New American Bible) · Stephen addresses the council as brothers and fathers.
- Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), 162–165, 177 · Luther on the priesthood of all believers and on pastors; the shared Lutheran–Catholic statement.
- Exodus 19:6 (New American Bible) · Israel as a kingdom of priests.
- Wiktionary, "priest": etymology · English priest from Old English prēost, from Late Latin presbyter, from Greek presbyteros, elder.
- World Council of Churches, Faith and Order, Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (Lima, 1982), Ministry 17 and commentary · Protestant, Orthodox and Catholic theologians on why the New Testament doesn't call ministers priests, and why the early Church did.