Why can't Latin Catholic priests marry when ours can?
Because for Latin Catholic priests, staying unmarried is a church rule, not a belief. The Catholic Church calls married Eastern priests an old and rightful custom, and its own Eastern Churches ordain married men. In East and West alike, no one marries after becoming a priest.
Part 1 · The question
If you're , your parish priest may well have a wife and children, sitting in church with everyone else.
So a Catholic priest who can't marry can look strange.
The rule that priests don't marry belongs to the Latin Church, the Catholic Church's Western branch.
Latin here is the branch's name, not the language the priest speaks.
And it's a fair question. was the first of the . And Peter was married.
The tell how Jesus healed Peter's mother-in-law.
In a letter to Timothy, a younger leader he had trained, says a should be married only once.
The Orthodox rule is old. A married man can become a priest, but it must be the first marriage for him and his wife.
A single man can't marry once he's , which means made a priest. Bishops come from single men or widowers, usually monks.
These rules go back at least to the Council in Trullo, a meeting of Eastern bishops in 692.
It protected priests' marriages, and rejected the Roman habit of asking new priests to stop living with their wives.
Part 2 · A rule, not a belief
Here's what many people don't know. The Catholic Church teaches that the priesthood itself doesn't require a man to stay unmarried.
Celibacy, staying unmarried for God, is a rule of the Western Church, not part of what a priest is.
The , the Catholic of the 1960s, said so directly.
It pointed to the practice of the early Church, and to the Eastern Churches, where there are married priests of highest merit.
And it said:
This holy synod, while it commends ecclesiastical celibacy, in no way intends to alter that different discipline which legitimately flourishes in the Eastern Churches.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says the Eastern way has long been considered legitimate.
It says those married priests exercise a fruitful ministry.
It also names a rule both sides share. Holy Orders is the Catholic name for being made a , priest or bishop.
In the East as in the West a man who has already received the sacrament of Holy Orders can no longer marry.
So how can both ways be right? Here's an analogy that might help. Think of two schools that go back to the same founder.
One is a boarding school. Its teachers live on campus, eat with the students, run the evening study and are there at lights-out.
The boarding school asks them to make it their home.
The other is a day school. Its teachers finish at five, then go home to their own husbands, wives and children.
Both have real teachers. Both teach the same subjects, and care about the same kind of students.
Nobody at the day school is a second-class teacher.
The boarding school's rule is a choice about the kind of life it wants its teachers to model, and in principle it could change.
It says nothing against the teachers at the day school. That's how the Catholic Church sees married Eastern priests.
Part 3 · How the West got there
The West went the other way, step by step. Around 300, a meeting of bishops in Spain told married clergy to stop having children.
Many in the West held that this continence, married clergy living with their wives as brother and sister, went back to the apostles.
The East disagreed. The Council in Trullo appealed to the apostles' own rule to let priests keep living with their wives.
By the 1100s, a priest in the West couldn't validly marry at all. So the difference is more than a thousand years old.
Why keep it? Not because marriage is second-best. Latin Catholics see it as a way of living the priesthood like Jesus, who never married.
The Catholic Church's book of law calls it a special gift of God that lets a priest serve with an undivided heart.
It echoes Paul, who wrote that a married man is rightly pulled two ways, while an unmarried man can give God his whole attention.
Because it's a rule, not a belief, it could change in principle.
But the same council that praised married Eastern priests said it again approves and confirms the Latin rule.
Part 4 · Where Rome got it wrong
Now the honest part. Eastern Catholics belong to the Catholic Church, but live the Eastern way, with married priests.
From the 1880s, thousands of them moved from the Carpathian mountains and western Ukraine to the United States.
Latin bishops there protested against the married Eastern priests. In 1890 the Church's leaders in Rome barred those priests from the United States.
In 1929 they barred all married priests from North America.
It hurt. Families split, and an estimated 200,000 of these Catholics joined the Orthodox Church.
Francis lifted the ban in 2014.
The same year, Orthodox and Catholic scholars asked for exactly that, so the Orthodox could trust their tradition would be safe in any future unity.
Part 5 · Married priests in the Catholic Church
Today the Eastern Catholic Churches, the ones many Orthodox call Uniates, each set their own rule.
All but two may ordain married men, and the two exceptions are both in India.
Like the Orthodox, all of these Churches choose bishops only from unmarried men.
The Latin rule has exceptions too. Married men can become permanent deacons: men who stay deacons for life, one rank below priests.
And some married Anglican priests, from the Church of England's family of churches, become Catholic and are ordained Catholic priests.
So even in the West, a married priest isn't unthinkable. And to an Orthodox reader, the Catholic answer is this.
Your married priests aren't something Rome puts up with. They're an ancient tradition the Catholic Church calls rightful and keeps in its own house.
The Latin rule is a different way of honouring the same priesthood.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 10
- Mark 1:29–31 (New American Bible, USCCB) · Jesus heals Simon Peter's mother-in-law.
- 1 Timothy 3 (New American Bible, USCCB) · A bishop, and deacons, should be married only once.
- Orthodox Church in America, Holy Orders · The Orthodox rules: married priests in a first marriage, no marriage after ordination, bishops unmarried.
- Council in Trullo (692), canons 6, 12, 13 · No marriage after ordination; married priests keep their wives, against the Roman custom.
- Second Vatican Council, Presbyterorum Ordinis (7 December 1965), 16 · Celibacy is not demanded by the nature of the priesthood; the Eastern discipline is legitimate.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1579–1580 · Latin celibacy, married permanent deacons, and the legitimate Eastern discipline.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), Celibacy of the Clergy · The Western history: Elvira (between 295 and 302), Trullo (692), and the Lateran Councils of 1123 and 1139.
- Code of Canon Law, canon 277 · Latin clerics are bound to celibacy, a special gift of God for an undivided heart.
- ByzCath, Pope Francis restores right of Eastern Catholics to ordain married men worldwide (2014) · The 1890 and 1929-30 bans, the loss of about 200,000 faithful, CCEO canon 758 §3, the two Indian Churches that don't ordain married men, and the 2014 lifting.
- North American Orthodox-Catholic Theological Consultation, statement on married Eastern Catholic clergy (2014) · Orthodox and Catholic theologians: Cum data fuerit (1929) divided communities; lifting the restrictions would reassure the Orthodox.