Part XI · Chapter 28
Seven sacraments

When did the Church settle on seven sacraments, and were the seven rites there before the number?

9 scenes · about 19 min read

The short answer

The number came late, around 1155. The rites came early: each of the seven has a witness before AD 260, though some of those witnesses are much stronger than others.

A is a holy sign that Catholics believe does what it shows. The list of exactly seven that stuck is by Lombard, a Paris teacher.

Before the 1100s the word covered many holy signs, and nobody fixed a number. Catholic historians say so too.

Catholics argue the practice came first, the counting later. Each of the seven has a root in the : and the Lord's Supper, forgiven by the , hands laid on the newly baptised and on new ministers, the sick anointed, marriage as a picture of and the Church.

The , the Catholic Church's official summary of teaching, says the Church 'has discerned over the centuries' which rites are sacraments.

Protestants say that's the wrong test. A sacrament needs God's command, a sign he set up, and a promise of .

On that test Reformed churches count two, baptism and the Lord's Supper (). Lutherans add , forgiveness spoken to someone who confesses. Medieval teachers, they say, grouped the rest in with them.

The , divided from Rome since 1054, keep all seven rites as holy mysteries. The rites were shared across that split, which suggests they are older than it.

Follow the trail

Nine documents: the seven rites appearing one by one in the first three centuries, then, eleven centuries after the apostles, the number.

Late first centuryRevealed2 min read

Elders anoint the sick with oil

The letter of James, in the New Testament

The earliest instruction for anointing the sick is in the New Testament. The letter of James tells a sick Christian to call the church's elders, who pray over him and anoint him with oil. It promises that the Lord will raise him up, and that his sins will be forgiven.

IWhat was going on

The letter of James is written to Christians scattered across the world, most likely Jewish believers. links it to James, a relative of Jesus who led the church in Jerusalem. Who wrote it, and when, is debated.

In that world sickness was frightening. There were no hospitals, and doctors were few. Many people assumed illness had something to do with sin.

IIWhat was at stake

A sick Christian might be too weak to come to church. What should the community do? Leave it to the doctor, or bring the sick person something more?

James answers with a practice, not a theory: call the church's elders to the bedside.

IIIRead the source
Is anyone among you sick? He should summon the presbyters of the church, and they should pray over him and anoint [him] with oil in the name of the Lord
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · James 5:14 (NABRE)

Why it matters

James names four things: the , the elders who led each church, and prayer, oil and the forgiveness of sins. The word presbyter later gave English the word priest.

Oil was ordinary medicine then. Here it is used in the name of the Lord, and it comes with a promise no medicine makes: the sick person's sins will be forgiven.

The show the Twelve already anointing the sick with oil and healing them (Mark 6:13).

The Catholic Church sees in this verse the sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick. In Catholic teaching, a sacrament is a sign from Christ that really gives the grace it shows.

The Orthodox keep it too, as Holy Unction. Unction simply means anointing.

It used to be called Extreme Unction, the last anointing. After , the Catholic ' worldwide of the 1960s, it was renamed and opened to anyone seriously ill, not only the dying.

c. AD 96Historical2 min read

Leaders appointed, and successors after them

Clement of Rome, writing to Corinth

Around AD 96 the church in Rome wrote to the church in Corinth, in Greece. The letter says the apostles appointed ministers and arranged for approved men to succeed them. It's the earliest Christian letter outside the New Testament to say the apostles planned for successors.

IWhat was going on

Around AD 96 the church in Rome wrote to the church in Corinth. Tradition names the writer , a leader in Rome.

Corinth had thrown out its leaders. Clement says one or two people stirred it up.

The leaders who were removed, he says, had served well and blamelessly. The letter calls them presbyters, elders.

IIWhat was at stake

Can a congregation sack the leaders the apostles' system put in place, just because some members want a change?

Rome's answer was no. Ministry is handed on in order: from the apostles to men they appointed, then to approved successors, with the whole church's consent.

IIIWhat happened

The letter makes its case at length. It talks about humility and peace, the example of , and the order the apostles set up.

It asks the troublemakers to step back and let the presbyters return. Messengers from Rome carried it, and were to report back.

IVWhat came of it

Around 170, Dionysius, bishop of Corinth, wrote that the Corinthians still read Clement's letter aloud in church on Sundays.

We don't know exactly how the quarrel ended. But the letter's idea of a ministry handed on in order stuck.

VRead the source
they appointed those [ministers] already mentioned, and afterwards gave instructions, that when these should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry.
First Epistle to the Corinthians · 1 Clement 44

Why it matters

The letter shows an office being handed on about sixty years after Jesus.

Catholics and Orthodox see here the roots of holy orders, the sacrament by which bishops, priests and are .

The New Testament already shows hands laid on for that office. The second letter to Timothy recalls the gift of God he received when laid hands on him (2 Timothy 1:6).

Most Protestants also have ordained ministers and value order. But they don't count ordination as a sacrament.

Clement's letter shows the office early. Reading it as a sacrament came with time.

c. AD 50–120Historical1 min read

A handbook explains how to baptise

The Didache, probably from Syria

An early church handbook called the Didache gives the words for baptism, and fallbacks for when things are hard. Use running water if there is any, other water if not. If there isn't enough to stand in, pour it three times on the head.

IWhat was going on

The Didache, Greek for the Teaching, is a short church handbook, probably from Syria. Its date is debated, anywhere from AD 50 to 120.

It was lost for centuries, then found in a library in Constantinople in 1873.

It reads like a manual for a young church. It says how to live, how to baptise and how to pray. It says how to celebrate the , the shared bread and cup, and how to treat travelling preachers.

IIWhat was at stake

Jesus had told his followers to baptise in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. But churches were spreading into dry towns and villages, and not every place had a river.

Did baptism have to be done one exact way, or could it be adapted?

IIIRead the source
And concerning baptism, baptize this way: Having first said all these things, baptize into the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit
The Didache (Teaching of the Twelve Apostles) · Didache 7

Why it matters

The handbook's fallbacks are practical. Running water if there is any, other water if not. Warm water if cold is impossible. And if there isn't enough to stand in, pour water on the head three times.

A rite with rules for hard cases is already in settled use. From the start, the water and the name mattered more than the method.

The words are the same ones used at Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestant baptisms today: in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

The Catholic Church accepts as valid the baptisms of most Protestant churches, because they use water and that threefold name.

c. AD 50–120Historical1 min read

Sins confessed in front of the church

The Didache

The Didache, an early church handbook, tells believers to admit their sins in church before they pray. Its chapter 14 ties this to the Sunday breaking of bread. It's the first step on a long road to the confession Catholics know today.

IWhat was going on

The Didache was written for small house churches. They met on the Lord's day, Sunday.

There they broke bread together, in the meal Christians call the Eucharist. In the handbook's Greek, church means the gathering of believers, not a building.

Its chapter 14 says: gather every Lord's day, break bread and give thanks, after first confessing your sins, so that your sacrifice may be pure. Anyone at odds with another must make peace first.

IIWhat was at stake

The first Christians knew they still sinned after baptism. How could people who had wronged each other share the Lord's table?

Jesus had said: if you remember that your brother has something against you, leave your gift at the altar and go and make peace first. The handbook turns that into practice.

IIIRead the source
In the church you shall acknowledge your transgressions, and you shall not come near for your prayer with an evil conscience.
The Didache (Teaching of the Twelve Apostles) · Didache 4

Why it matters

Behind the practice stood Jesus's words to the apostles after he rose: Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them (John 20:23). The road from here to private confession with a priest was long.

In the early centuries, grave sins were confessed and made up for in public, often only once in a lifetime.

From about the 600s, Irish monks spread private confession that could be repeated. In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council, a council of bishops in Rome, required confession at least once a year.

, the Catholic Sunday service, still usually begins with everyone present confessing their sins. It's an echo of the Didache.

c. AD 107–110Historical1 min read

Marry with the bishop's approval

Ignatius of Antioch, writing to Polycarp

Around AD 110, , a bishop on his way to execution, asked that couples marry with their bishop's approval. Outside the New Testament, it's the earliest surviving Christian text linking marriage to church authority. He wanted marriage to be lived according to God.

IWhat was going on

Ignatius was bishop of Antioch, one of the great cities of the East. Around AD 107–110, taken under guard to Rome to be killed, he wrote seven letters on the way. One was to , bishop of Smyrna.

IIWhat was at stake

In the Roman world marriage was a family matter, arranged between households. No priest or official was needed.

Christians were trying to live marriage differently: faithful, with husbands loving wives as Christ loves the Church.

Ignatius wanted the bishop involved, so that marriage would be according to God and not just desire.

IIIRead the source
But it becomes both men and women who marry, to form their union with the approval of the bishop, that their marriage may be according to God, and not after their own lust.
Letter to Polycarp · To Polycarp 5

Why it matters

The Catholic case for marriage starts with Jesus. Asked about divorce, he went back to the beginning: the two become one flesh, and what God has joined together, no human being must separate (Matthew 19:6).

The letter to the Ephesians then calls marriage a great mystery that points to Christ and the Church (Ephesians 5:32). Ignatius shows the Church already caring how Christians married. He asks for the bishop's consent, not for a ceremony.

The Church's part in marriage grew slowly. Blessings by priests became common over centuries.

The Council of Trent was the Catholic Church's answer to the Protestant Reformation. Only in 1563 did it require Catholics to marry before a priest and two witnesses for the marriage to count.

Even now, in the Latin Church, the Western part of the Catholic Church, the couple themselves give the sacrament to each other. The priest witnesses it.

In the Eastern churches, the priest's blessing is essential.

c. AD 155Historical1 min read

Only the baptised may eat

Justin Martyr, in Rome

Around AD 155 in Rome, told the emperor what Christians eat on Sunday, and who may eat it. Only the baptised may, if they believe the teaching and live as Christ commanded. Two rites already go together, in a fixed order.

IWhat was going on

Justin was a Christian philosopher teaching in Rome, executed for his faith around 165. Around 155 he wrote an open defence of Christians to Emperor Antoninus Pius.

Rumours said Christians ate human flesh at their secret meals. Justin answered by describing exactly what they did.

IIWhat was at stake

Talking openly about the Eucharist, the Christian meal of bread and wine, was risky. Its talk of eating flesh and drinking blood was what fed the rumours.

Justin chose honesty over hiding. He explained what Christians believed the food was, and who could share it.

IIIRead the source
And this food is called among us Εὐχαριστία [the Eucharist], of which no one is allowed to partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, and who has been washed with the washing that is for the remission of sins
The First Apology · First Apology 66

Why it matters

Justin says the food is not common bread and common drink. It is the flesh and blood of Jesus. And only the baptised, who believe and live by the teaching, may receive it.

Catholics and Orthodox still keep both rules. Communion, receiving the bread and wine, is for the baptised who share the faith.

Many Protestant churches also ask that those who receive be baptised believers.

c. AD 200–206Historical1 min read

A hand laid on after the water

Tertullian, in Carthage

Around AD 200, Tertullian, a Christian writer in Carthage in North Africa, described joining the Church in three steps. First the washing of baptism, then anointing with oil, then a hand laid on to invite the . To him it was all one rite.

IWhat was going on

Tertullian was a Christian writer in Carthage, in today's Tunisia, around AD 200. He was the first major Christian author to write in Latin.

He wrote On Baptism because a woman teacher from a fringe group had been telling Christians in Carthage that baptism didn't matter. Many had been persuaded.

IIWhat was at stake

If baptism is just water, why bother with it? Tertullian sets out to show what each part of the rite means and does.

That means describing it step by step, which is why his little book is so valuable today.

IIIRead the source
In the next place the hand is laid on us, invoking and inviting the Holy Spirit through benediction.
On Baptism (De Baptismo) · On Baptism 8

Why it matters

Outside the New Testament, this is the earliest surviving description of a hand laid on after baptism as a moment of its own. Even so, Tertullian doesn't treat it as a separate sacrament.

In his Carthage it was one service: water, oil, hands. Later the Western Church split it apart. As churches grew, priests baptised, and the bishop's anointing and laying on of hands came later, when he could visit.

But by 1274 a statement of faith at the Council of Lyons, a gathering of bishops in France, names confirmation as a sacrament of its own. Bishops give it by laying on hands.

The Eastern churches kept the three together. Their priests anoint straight after baptism, even infants, with oil blessed by the bishop. East and West both claim Tertullian's three moments.

AD 251Historical2 min read

Sins confessed to priests

Cyprian, bishop of Carthage

In 251, just after a persecution, , bishop of Carthage, urged Christians who had only thought of sacrificing to idols to confess it to God's priests. It's the earliest text here naming priests as the ones who hear confession.

IWhat was going on

In 250 Emperor Decius ordered everyone in the empire to sacrifice to the gods and get a certificate saying so. Many Christians gave in. Others bribed officials for a certificate.

Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, had gone into hiding so he could keep leading his people. He came back in 251 to a church full of people who had failed.

IIWhat was at stake

The lapsed, those who had given in, wanted to come back. Some confessors, Christians who had suffered for the faith, were handing out letters of peace that let them back in straight away.

Cyprian thought that was false mercy. Only God forgives, he said, and the sinner had to really repent. But who decides when, and how?

IIIWhat happened

In his book On the Lapsed, Cyprian sets out the way back: confession, then penance, then return through the bishop and priests. Penance means acts that show real sorrow.

He praises people who hadn't sacrificed but had thought about it, and came to God's priests to confess even that. They unburden their minds, and seek healing even for small wounds.

IVWhat came of it

Councils of bishops in Carthage and Rome agreed. The lapsed could come back after penance, judged by the bishop.

Novatian, a priest in Rome, refused to let them back at all, and set himself up as a rival bishop. The wider Church sided with mercy.

Cyprian himself was beheaded in 258, in the next persecution.

VRead the source
with grief and simplicity confess this very thing to God's priests, and make the conscientious avowal, put off from them the load of their minds, and seek out the salutary medicine even for slight and moderate wounds
On the Lapsed (De Lapsis) · On the Lapsed 28

Why it matters

Catholics see confession to a priest taking shape here: sin admitted out loud to the Church's minister, and forgiveness given through him. The setting is still a crisis, not yet ordinary routine.

Protestants generally confess to God directly. Lutherans and Anglicans also keep private confession as an option.

Cyprian's own words carry both readings: the priest's role is real, and God alone forgives.

c. 1155–1158Historical2 min read

A Paris teacher counts seven

Peter Lombard, in Paris

Around 1155 in Paris, a teacher named Peter Lombard listed the sacraments in one sentence. There were seven: baptism, confirmation, the bread of blessing (the Eucharist), penance, extreme unction, orders and marriage.

IWhat was going on

In the 1100s Paris was becoming the centre of learning in Europe. Peter Lombard, an Italian-born teacher at the cathedral school of Notre Dame, wrote the Sentences.

Its four books gather what the Church Fathers, the great Christian writers of the early centuries, had said on every question of faith.

He became bishop of Paris in 1159 and died the next year, in 1160.

IIWhat was at stake

For a thousand years Christian writers used the word sacrament loosely, for many holy signs and rites, not just seven.

Teachers now wanted order. Which signs were special, given by Christ, and why? Other lists in the same century counted differently.

IIIWhat happened

Lombard first defined the word strictly. A sacrament, he says, is a sign of God's grace that both bears its image and causes it. In plain words, it does what it shows.

That test narrowed the field. He then listed seven in one sentence, the same seven Catholics name today.

In English his Latin sentence reads: Now let us come to the sacraments of the new law: baptism, confirmation, the bread of blessing, that is, the Eucharist, penance, extreme unction, orders, marriage.

IVWhat came of it

The Sentences became the standard theology textbook in Europe's universities for centuries. and Bonaventure, the great teachers of the 1200s, lectured on it. So, later, did Martin Luther, who began the Protestant Reformation.

The seven appear in a statement of faith at the Council of Lyons in 1274, and in a decree at the Council of Florence in 1439. Councils are formal gatherings of the Church's bishops.

The Council of Trent made the number binding in 1547, after Luther had challenged it. Trent was the Catholic Church's answer to the Reformation.

VRead the source
Iam ad sacramenta novae Legis ac cedamus: quae sunt baptismus, confirmatio, panis benedictionis, id est eucharistia, poenitentia, unctio extrema, ordo, coniugium.
Sententiae in IV libris distinctae, Liber IV (Grottaferrata critical edition, Latin) · Book IV, dist. II, cap. 1, n. 1 (Latin)

Why it matters

Catholics see their Church recognising over time what it had always done. It did the same with the list of books in the Bible.

Protestants see a medieval category forced onto the early Church. The Orthodox keep all seven rites, but are wary of a closed count.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Catholics don't claim that the early Church counted to seven. The claim is that seven things were being done, and that the Catholic Church later recognised what they had in common.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church, its official summary of teaching, puts it in just those terms. The Church 'has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ'.

It 'has discerned over the centuries' which celebrations are sacraments in the strict sense. The practice comes first. The counting comes after.

The Catechism itself compares this to the of Scripture, the agreed list of books in the . Nobody has a first-century list of the 27 books of the New Testament either.

Those books were written, copied, read aloud and argued over for centuries before the list was fixed. Every Christian who uses that list relies on the Church's discernment.

The Catholic argument asks the reader to treat the seven the same way.

The , the Catholic Church's answer to the Reformation, says openly what it rests on. It isn't .

Trent appeals to 'the of the holy Scriptures, to the apostolic traditions, and to the consent of other councils and of the Fathers'. The Fathers are the great Christian writers of the early centuries.

For five of the seven, confirmation, penance, anointing, orders and marriage, the Church reads the Bible's texts through the tradition that practised them, and the decree says so openly.

Catholics see nothing odd in that. The second letter to the Thessalonians tells believers to hold on to the traditions they were taught either by an oral statement or by a letter of ours (2 Thessalonians 2:15). Protestants contest that ground, and the reasons are below.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Lutheran

, who began the Reformation, made the historical charge at full strength. He wrote it in The Babylonian Captivity of the Church, in 1520.

'We read simply nothing about these "sacraments" in the other Fathers, nor do they ever refer to them as sacraments; for the invention of sacraments is of recent date.'

Philip Melanchthon, Luther's colleague, then gave the settled Lutheran objection. He put it mildly.

'Neither do we believe it to be of any consequence, though, for the purpose of teaching, different people reckon differently, provided they still preserve aright the matters handed down in Scripture. Neither have the ancients reckoned in the same manner.'

On the Lutheran test, a sacrament has God's command, a sign he set up, and a promise of grace. That gives three: baptism, the Lord's Supper and absolution, the forgiveness spoken to someone who confesses.

The objection isn't to the rites but to their status. Confirmation and extreme unction, Melanchthon writes, are rites received from the Fathers that don't have God's command.

On the number itself he is relaxed. No sensible person, he says, will argue hard over it.

Reformed

Reformed churches, the tradition that comes from , hold two sacraments: baptism and the Lord's Supper.

They use the test the Protestant statements of faith share. A sacrament needs a command of God, a visible sign he set up, and a promise of grace attached to it.

Calvin argues the case in the last book of his Institutes, his great summary of the faith.

"Man, therefore, cannot institute a sacrament, because it is not in the power of man to make such divine mysteries lurk under things so abject."

In other words, only God can make ordinary things carry his grace.

And on the count: "This number seven is nowhere found in the ecclesiastical writers, nor is it well ascertained at what time it crept in."

Eastern Orthodox

The Orthodox keep all seven rites, and more. What they object to is the closed count, not any rite in it.

The Orthodox Church in America teaches its own members this: 'The practice of counting the sacraments was adopted in the Orthodox Church from the Roman Catholics. It is not an ancient practice of the Church and, in many ways, it tends to be misleading since it appears that there are just seven specific rites which are “sacraments” and that all other aspects of the life of the Church are essentially different from these particular actions.'

Not every Orthodox voice agrees. Patriarch Jeremias II of Constantinople, first in honour among the Orthodox bishops, is reported to have written in about 1576 that the mysteries are seven and no more.

Mysteries is the Orthodox word for sacraments.

Baptist and Anabaptist readers

Most Baptist and churches speak of two ordinances, baptism and the Lord's Supper, rather than sacraments. An ordinance is something Christ commanded his followers to do.

They hold that these show and confess grace, rather than give it.

On that reading the question of the number is settled before it is asked. The category the Catholic list assumes does not exist.

Academic historians

Historians don't seriously dispute the historical half of the Protestant charge. Early Christian writers used the words sacramentum (Latin) and mysterion (Greek), both roughly meaning a holy sign or mystery, loosely, for many things.

Sorting seven rites into one group was an achievement of the medieval schools in the 1100s. A definition made it possible.

The councils followed the teachers, not the other way round.

What historians don't conclude is that the rites were invented late. The documents show them being performed.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself6
Seven rites, one number, and the date of each10 steps

The rites first, one at a time, each with its earliest witness. Then the number, and the three councils that took it up.

The rites come early and the number comes late. How to read that gap is where Catholics and Protestants part.

  1. Baptism

    c. AD 155

    Justin gives the fullest early description: teaching, fasting, prayer, then washing in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.

    The Didache, an earlier church handbook, had already given those words and the fallbacks, fifty years or more before.

    “Then they are brought by us where there is water, and are regenerated in the same manner in which we were ourselves regenerated.”
    HistoricalThe First ApologyFirst Apology 61The evidence ↓
  2. Eucharist

    c. AD 155

    Justin calls it by its Greek name, Eucharistia, meaning thanksgiving. He keeps it for the baptised, and says it is not common bread.

    Paul is earlier still, around AD 55. He hands on Jesus's words over the bread and cup, and warns that whoever eats unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord (1 Corinthians 11:23–29).

    Chapter 9 of the Didache, the early handbook, already keeps the Eucharist for the baptised.

    “For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so likewise have we been taught that the food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh.”
    HistoricalThe First ApologyFirst Apology 66The evidence ↓
  3. Penance

    AD 251

    Cyprian names priests as the ones who receive the confession, and through whom forgiveness is given. Catholics read it in the light of Jesus's words to the apostles: whose sins you forgive are forgiven (John 20:23).

    The Latin phrase is per sacerdotes, through the priests. Does it mean the priest gives the forgiveness, or announces it? Protestant readers take the second view.

    “I entreat you, beloved brethren, that each one should confess his own sin, while he who has sinned is still in this world, while his confession may be received, while the satisfaction and remission made by the priests are pleasing to the Lord.”
  4. Anointing of the sick

    Late first century

    The rite is in the New Testament, in the letter of James, and the Twelve were already anointing the sick in Mark 6:13.

    The note beside the verse in the American bishops' own Bible points out that oil was ordinary medicine. But medicine doesn't forgive sins, and James promises that too. The Council of Trent read it as a sacrament for that reason.

    “The results of the prayer and anointing are physical health and forgiveness of sins. The Roman Catholic Church (Council of Trent, Session 14) declared that this anointing of the sick is a sacrament “instituted by Christ and promulgated by blessed James the apostle.””
    HistoricalSacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition)NABRE translators' note on James 5:15The evidence ↓
  5. Confirmation

    c. AD 35, narrated c. AD 85

    In Acts 8, apostles lay hands on new believers in Samaria who had already been baptised, and they receive the Holy Spirit. Paul does the same at Ephesus in Acts 19.

    The Letter to the Hebrews lists laying on of hands among the basic teachings, right after baptisms (Hebrews 6:2). The Catholic Church sees in these the Bible's root of confirmation. Others read Samaria as an unusual case: the apostles approving a new mission.

    Outside the New Testament, the earliest surviving description of a hand laid on after baptism, as a moment of its own, is Tertullian's. That is roughly 170 years after Pentecost, the day the Holy Spirit came on the apostles.

    He treats it as one movement in a single rite of joining the Church.

    “Then they laid hands on them and they received the holy Spirit.”
  6. Holy Orders

    c. AD 96

    The New Testament shows hands laid on for the office: the seven in Acts 6:6, and Timothy, who received a gift of God that way (1 Timothy 4:14; 2 Timothy 1:6).

    1 Clement, the letter from Rome to Corinth, is the earliest witness outside the New Testament to leaders being succeeded in an orderly way. It shows the apostles planning for the office to go on after them.

    That makes it a strong witness to the office, and a thin one to the rite. Clement says nothing about how the men were ordained. The laying on of hands in Acts and the letters to Timothy is the better evidence for that.

    “Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate.”
  7. Matrimony, and a great mystery

    1979

    Around AD 110 Ignatius asks that couples marry with the bishop's approval. That is consent, not a ceremony, and it is the thinnest of the seven early witnesses.

    Jesus calls marriage God's own joining (Matthew 19:6), and the letter to the Ephesians calls it a great mystery that points to Christ and the Church. Medieval teachers leaned heavily on one Latin word in that verse. The Clementine Vulgate, the Catholic Church's official Latin Bible from 1592, reads 'Sacramentum hoc magnum est', this is a great sacrament, at Ephesians 5:32.

    The Greek word there is mysterion, mystery. In 1979 the Church issued the Nova Vulgata, its new official Latin Bible, and it reads Mysterium hoc magnum est: this mystery is great, but I speak of Christ and the Church. That is why this step is dated 1979. Trent never rested the case on the word: it said the Apostle intimates the grace of marriage there.

    “32 Mysterium hoc magnum est; ego autem dico de Christo et ecclesia!”
  8. The number appears

    c. 1155

    Just one section before the list, Lombard sets the definition that makes a list possible. A sacrament in the proper sense is a sign of God's grace that both bears its image and causes it. So, he adds, sacraments were set up not only to signify grace but to make people holy.

    That test sorts the rites that give the grace they show from the many blessings earlier writers had also called sacraments.

    “Sacramentum enim proprie dicitur, quod ita signum est gratiae Dei et invisibilis gratiae forma, ut ipsius imaginem gerat et causa exsistat. Non igitur significandi tantum gratia sacramenta instituta sunt, sed et sanctificandi.”
  9. The councils take it up

    1274, 1439, 1547

    At Lyons in 1274, the seven are professed in a statement of faith from the Byzantine emperor, Michael VIII, not in one of the council's own rulings.

    At Florence in 1439, they are set out in a decree that calls itself a brief scheme to make teaching the Armenians easier.

    They were first fixed under anathema, a solemn condemnation of anyone who denies them, at Trent. Trent is 1547, after Luther's challenge, not before it.

    “CANON I.-If any one saith, that the sacraments of the New Law were not all instituted by Jesus Christ, our Lord; or, that they are more, or less, than seven, to wit, Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction, Order, and Matrimony; or even that any one of these seven is not truly and properly a sacrament; let him be anathema.”
  10. What the Church says about its own list

    1997

    The Catechism, the Catholic Church's official summary of teaching, doesn't claim the number was always counted. It says the Church came to recognise the seven gradually.

    It compares this to the settling of which books belong in the Bible. It's the same trust every Christian places in the list of New Testament books: the Church's judgement over time.

    “Thus the Church has discerned over the centuries that among liturgical celebrations there are seven that are, in the strict sense of the term, sacraments instituted by the Lord.”
Every claim this chapter leans on8 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Anointing the sick with oil by the presbyters of the church, with prayer and the forgiveness of sins, is commanded in the New Testament itself at James 5:14-15. This makes anointing one of the better attested of the seven. What the Council of Trent defined in 1551 adds elements the letter does not contain, above all that the matter of the sacrament is oil blessed by a bishop. Trent attributes those elements not to James but to apostolic tradition received from hand to hand, and says in the same chapter that the sacrament is only insinuated in Mark.

Rests on
  • James 5:14-15 (NABRE)
    “14 Is anyone among you sick? He should summon the presbyters of the church, and they should pray over him and anoint [him] with oil in the name of the Lord, 15 and the prayer of faith will save the sick person, and the Lord will raise him up. If he has committed any sins, he will be forgiven.”
  • NABRE translators' notes on James 5:14 and 5:15
    “* [5:14] In case of sickness a Christian should ask for the presbyters of the church, i.e., those who have authority in the church (cf. Acts 15:2, 22–23; 1 Tm 5:17; Ti 1:5). They are to pray over the person and anoint with oil; oil was used for …”
    Read the full passage
    “* [5:14] In case of sickness a Christian should ask for the presbyters of the church, i.e., those who have authority in the church (cf. Acts 15:2, 22–23; 1 Tm 5:17; Ti 1:5). They are to pray over the person and anoint with oil; oil was used for medicinal purposes in the ancient world (see Is 1:6; Lk 10:34). In Mk 6:13, the Twelve anoint the sick with oil on their missionary journey. In the name of the Lord: by the power of Jesus Christ. * [5:15] The results of the prayer and anointing are physical health and forgiveness of sins. The Roman Catholic Church (Council of Trent, Session 14) declared that this anointing of the sick is a sacrament “instituted by Christ and promulgated by blessed James the apostle.””
  • Session XIV, Extreme Unction, chapter I
    “Now, this sacred unction of the sick was instituted by Christ our Lord, as truly and properly a sacrament of the new law, insinuated indeed in Mark, but recommended and promulgated to the faithful by James the Apostle, and brother of the Lord. Is …”
    Read the full passage
    “Now, this sacred unction of the sick was instituted by Christ our Lord, as truly and properly a sacrament of the new law, insinuated indeed in Mark, but recommended and promulgated to the faithful by James the Apostle, and brother of the Lord. Is any man, he saith, sick among you ? Let him bring in the priests of the Church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord: and the prayer of faith shall save the sick man; and the Lord shall raise him up; and if he be in sins, they shall be forgiven him. In which words, as the Church has learned from apostolic tradition, received from hand to hand, he teaches the matter, the form, the proper minister, and the effect of this salutary sacrament. For the Church has understood the matter thereof to be oil blessed by a bishop.”
Other readings
  • Melanchthon grants that extreme unction is a rite received from the Fathers and denies that it is a sacrament properly so called: "Confirmation and Extreme Unction are rites received from the Fathers which not even the Church requires as necessary to salvation, because they do not have God's command."
  • The bishops' own note observes that "oil was used for medicinal purposes in the ancient world", which leaves open a reading of James as prayer accompanying ordinary medical care rather than as the institution of a rite.
  • A Protestant reader will say that Trent's own words, "insinuated indeed in Mark" and "apostolic tradition, received from hand to hand", concede that the institution is not on the page of Scripture.
Limits
  • James does not say the oil was blessed by a bishop, does not restrict the anointing to the danger of death, and does not call it a sacrament.
  • The date of the letter of James is disputed, with proposals running from the 50s to about AD 100.
  • No early source was verified for the elements Trent adds. The gap between James and the matter, form, minister and effect defined in 1551 is not filled by any document quoted here.
  • The brackets around "[him]" in the NABRE text are the translators' own, marking a supplied word.
  • Waterworth's 1848 English of Trent is the standard free text but is Victorian; the Latin should be checked before publication.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Each of the rites later counted among the seven is attested in a Christian document written centuries before anyone counted them. Baptism in the threefold name is set out with practical fallbacks in the Didache and described at length by Justin Martyr around AD 155. The Eucharist is named by its Greek name, restricted to the baptised, and described as not common bread by Justin. Appointment to ministry with deliberate provision for successors is in 1 Clement by about AD 96.

Rests on
  • Didache 7
    “But if you have not living water, baptize into other water; and if you can not in cold, in warm. But if you have not either, pour out water thrice upon the head into the name of Father and Son and Holy Spirit.”
  • Didache 9
    “But let no one eat or drink of your Thanksgiving (Eucharist), but they who have been baptized into the name of the Lord”
  • First Apology 61
    “Then they are brought by us where there is water, and are regenerated in the same manner in which we were ourselves regenerated. For, in the name of God, the Father and Lord of the universe, and of our Saviour Jesus Christ, and of the Holy Spirit, they then receive the washing with water.”
  • First Apology 66
    “And this food is called among us Εὐχαριστία [the Eucharist], of which no one is allowed to partake but the man who believes that the things which we teach are true, and who has been washed with the washing that is for the remission of sins, and unto regeneration, and who is so living as Christ has enjoined.”
  • 1 Clement 44
    “they appointed those [ministers] already mentioned, and afterwards gave instructions, that when these should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry.”
Other readings
  • Luther grants the practices and denies the category. His charge is that "the invention of sacraments is of recent date", which is about the word and the enumeration, not about whether the rites were performed.
  • Melanchthon's reply is that a rite is a sacrament only if it has God's command, an instituted visible sign and a promise of grace, and that on the Catholic definition the list could be extended to prayer, alms and afflictions.
  • The Orthodox objection is different again: the rites are all kept, and what is denied is that they form a closed class distinct from everything else the Church does.
Limits
  • Attestation of a rite is not attestation of its later status. Justin never uses a word equivalent to "sacrament"; he calls baptism the washing and illumination. The chapter headings on the New Advent text of the First Apology are nineteenth-century editorial additions, not Justin's.
  • Didache 9 contains no institution narrative and no words of Christ over the bread and cup, and some scholars doubt that Didache 9 and 10 describe a eucharist in the later sense at all.
  • 1 Clement attests appointment and orderly succession but does not mention a laying on of hands, an ordination prayer, or anything called a sacrament. The New Testament texts that do mention hand-laying for ministry, Acts 6:6, Acts 13:3, 1 Timothy 4:14 and 2 Timothy 1:6, were not read for this chapter and are deliberately not quoted here.
  • The Didache's date is genuinely disputed, with proposals running from the 50s to the mid second century, and the whole text survives in a single complete manuscript, Codex Hierosolymitanus 54, copied in 1056.
  • All the patristic quotations are nineteenth-century Ante-Nicene Fathers translations. Modern critical editions would be better citations.
  • This claim covers baptism, the Eucharist and orders only. Penance, anointing, confirmation and marriage are handled on their own claims, and two of those four are considerably weaker.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Confession of sins is attested early, but the practice changes shape across the centuries. Around AD 100 the Didache tells the believer to acknowledge transgressions in the assembly before praying, and to confess before the Sunday breaking of bread; it mentions no priest, no formula of absolution and nothing private. The earliest text verified for this chapter in which sins are confessed specifically to priests is Cyprian of Carthage in AD 251, and the setting is the crisis of the lapsed after the Decian persecution rather than ordinary Christian life. Annual private confession became binding on every Christian only with canon 21 of the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215. The Council of Trent in 1551 nonetheless states that the universal Church has always understood the entire confession of sins to be instituted by the Lord.

Rests on
  • Didache 4
    “In the church you shall acknowledge your transgressions, and you shall not come near for your prayer with an evil conscience.”
  • Didache 14
    “But every Lord's day gather yourselves together, and break bread, and give thanksgiving after having confessed your transgressions, that your sacrifice may be pure.”
  • On the Lapsed 28
    “with grief and simplicity confess this very thing to God's priests, and make the conscientious avowal, put off from them the load of their minds, and seek out the salutary medicine even for slight and moderate wounds”
  • On the Lapsed 29
    “I entreat you, beloved brethren, that each one should confess his own sin, while he who has sinned is still in this world, while his confession may be received, while the satisfaction and remission made by the priests are pleasing to the Lord.”
  • Canon 21 (1215)
  • Session XIV, Penance, chapter V (On Confession)
    “From the institution of the sacrament of Penance as already explained, the universal Church has always understood, that the entire confession of sins was also instituted by the Lord, and is of divine right necessary for all who have fallen after …”
    Read the full passage
    “From the institution of the sacrament of Penance as already explained, the universal Church has always understood, that the entire confession of sins was also instituted by the Lord, and is of divine right necessary for all who have fallen after baptism; because that our Lord Jesus Christ, when about to ascend from earth to heaven, left priests His own vicars, as presidents and judges, unto whom all the mortal crimes, into which the faithful of Christ may have fallen, should be carried, in order that, in accordance with the power of the keys, they may pronounce the sentence of forgiveness or retention of sins.”
Other readings
  • Reformed and Lutheran readers contest whether Cyprian's Latin, satisfactio et remissio facta per sacerdotes, means that the priest effects the remission or that he declares it. The Latin will bear either reading, and Wallis's English rendering does not settle it.
  • Trent's phrase "the universal Church has always understood" is the claim the documents test hardest. A reader may reasonably conclude from the Didache, Cyprian and Lateran IV that the practice developed in stages rather than standing constant.
  • Catholic readers answer that a constant thing can be practised in changing forms, and that Cyprian in 251 already assumes the priest's role rather than arguing for it, which suggests an established practice behind him.
Limits
  • The Fourth Lateran canon is cited here by number only. Its wording is not quoted on this claim; it is quoted on the existing claim SINS-LATERAN-21.
  • "Earliest text verified for this chapter" is not "earliest text in existence". Other second- and third-century material on penance was not searched for this chapter.
  • Cyprian's context is a crisis procedure for the lapsed after a persecution, not the ordinary routine of Christian life, and it should not be read as describing a settled universal sacrament.
  • The Didache passages describe corporate confession before the Sunday offering. Reading them as evidence for auricular confession would be reading in.
  • Waterworth's 1848 English of Trent is Victorian and occasionally loose, and the Hanover scan of the same file carries uncorrected OCR typos elsewhere. The Latin should be checked for any sentence this chapter leans on.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

04HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

Of the seven, marriage has the thinnest early evidence for being a sacrament in the later technical sense, and this chapter says so rather than defending it. The earliest Christian text verified here that connects marriage to church authority is Ignatius of Antioch's letter to Polycarp, about AD 107 to 110, and it asks only that men and women marry with the approval of the bishop. It describes no liturgy, no blessing, no officiating minister and nothing called a sacrament. The medieval argument rested instead on a single Latin word: the Clementine Vulgate renders Ephesians 5:32 as Sacramentum hoc magnum est, where the underlying Greek word is mysterion. The Church's own current official Latin text, the Nova Vulgata promulgated in 1979, prints Mysterium hoc magnum est in that verse, and the NABRE translates it This is a great mystery. Trent's canon anathematising the denial that matrimony is truly and properly one of the seven sacraments was promulgated on 11 November 1563, roughly fifteen centuries after the institution it claims.

Rests on
  • To Polycarp 5
    “But it becomes both men and women who marry, to form their union with the approval of the bishop, that their marriage may be according to God, and not after their own lust. Let all things be done to the honour of God.”
  • Ephesians 5:31-32 (NABRE)
    “31 “For this reason a man shall leave [his] father and [his] mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.” 32 This is a great mystery, but I speak in reference to Christ and the church.”
  • Ephesians 5:32 (Clementine Vulgate, Latin)
    “32 Sacramentum hoc magnum est, ego autem dico in Christo et in Ecclesia.”
  • Ephesians 5:32 (Nova Vulgata, Latin)
    “32 Mysterium hoc magnum est; ego autem dico de Christo et ecclesia!”
  • Session XXIV (11 November 1563), canon I
    “CANON I.-If any one saith, that matrimony is not truly and properly one of the seven sacraments of the evangelic law, (a sacrament) instituted by Christ the Lord; but that it has been invented by men in the Church; and that it does not confer grace; let him be anathema.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.14
    “14 Matrimony was not first instituted in the New Testament, but in the beginning, immediately on the creation of the human race. It has, moreover, God’s command; it has also promises, not indeed properly pertaining to the New Testament, but …”
    Read the full passage
    “14 Matrimony was not first instituted in the New Testament, but in the beginning, immediately on the creation of the human race. It has, moreover, God’s command; it has also promises, not indeed properly pertaining to the New Testament, but pertaining rather to the bodily life. Wherefore, if any one should wish to call it a sacrament, he ought still to distinguish it from those preceding ones [the two former ones], which are properly signs of the New Testament, and testimonies of grace and the remission of sins.”
Other readings
  • A common Catholic reply is that the sacramentality of marriage never rested on the Latin word alone. It rests on the whole of Ephesians 5, where the union of husband and wife is read as a sign of the union of Christ and the Church, and on the Church's practice of treating marriage as an act done before God and the bishop. On that reading the Nova Vulgata is a translation correction, not a doctrinal retreat, and Catholic teaching is untouched by it.
  • Ignatius's request can be read as the seed of everything that follows. If a marriage needs the bishop's approval to be according to God, then marriage is already a matter of the Church's order and not a private arrangement, and the later liturgy and the later canonical form grow from that root. This is a reasonable inference and it is an inference, not a datum in the text.
  • Melanchthon grants marriage God's command and God's promises and still refuses it the name of sacrament in the strict sense, because its promises pertain rather to the bodily life. He asks only that it be distinguished from baptism and the Supper. A Lutheran reader would say the disagreement here is narrower than it looks.
  • Trent's canon does not argue from Ephesians 5:32 in the sentence quoted here. It anathematises the claim that matrimony was invented by men in the Church. The Catholic case can be stated without the Vulgate reading, and after 1979 it has to be.
Limits
  • The dating and even the authenticity of the Ignatian corpus are debated. The standard view accepts the seven letters of the middle recension in the form quoted here, but a minority of scholars date them to the 160s or 170s, which would make this witness later than stated.
  • The Clementine Vulgate reading was taken from drbo.org, a devotional site rather than a critical edition. The reading itself is standard and uncontroversial, but a critical Vulgate such as Weber-Gryson would be the proper citation.
  • The change from Sacramentum to Mysterium in the Nova Vulgata is a change in the Church's official Latin text. It is not a change in Catholic teaching, and nothing in this claim asserts that it is.
  • Thinnest of the seven is a judgement about what this chapter was able to verify, not the verdict of an exhaustive survey. No early marriage liturgy, no patristic nuptial blessing and no early canonical material on marriage was retrieved for this chapter, and any of those could change the picture.
  • The Trent canon is quoted in Waterworth's 1848 English. The parenthesis "(a sacrament)" is the translator's supplement and not part of the council's Latin.
  • The NABRE's own note on Ephesians 5:21-33 claims only that Paul sees Christian marriage as taking on a new meaning symbolic of the relationship between Christ and the church.
  • The Apology of the Augsburg Confession is quoted here from paragraph 14 alone.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

05HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

Baptism is described at length in Christian documents of the late first and mid second centuries. A rite of confirmation distinct from baptism is not. The earliest text verified for this chapter that describes a post-baptismal laying on of hands as its own ritual moment is Tertullian, On Baptism 8, written about AD 200 to 206, roughly 170 years after Pentecost, and Tertullian presents the anointing and the hand-laying as the second and third movements of one initiation rather than as a separate sacrament. The single New Testament episode behind the rite, the laying on of hands at Samaria in Acts 8, was written down, on the usual dating, some fifty years after the event it narrates. Some scholars take it as the biblical root of confirmation; others read it as an account of an unusual situation, the Jerusalem apostles endorsing the mission to Samaria, rather than as the regular form of Christian initiation. By 1274 the profession of faith accepted at the Second Council of Lyons names confirmation as a sacrament in its own right, conferred by bishops. The separation happened somewhere in the interval between those two texts, and this chapter did not source it.

Rests on
  • Acts 8:14-17 (NABRE, bible.usccb.org)
    “Now when the apostles in Jerusalem heard that Samaria had accepted the word of God, they sent them Peter and John, who went down and prayed for them, that they might receive the holy Spirit, for it had not yet fallen upon any of them; they had only …”
    Read the full passage
    “Now when the apostles in Jerusalem heard that Samaria had accepted the word of God, they sent them Peter and John, who went down and prayed for them, that they might receive the holy Spirit, for it had not yet fallen upon any of them; they had only been baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. Then they laid hands on them and they received the holy Spirit.”
  • New American Bible, Introduction to the Gospel according to Luke (vatican.va)
    “the Gospel of Luke is dated by most scholars after that date; many propose A.D. 80-90 as the time of composition.”
  • Early Christian Worship, 2nd edn (2010), chapter 1, 'Confirmation' in the New Testament?, p. 5 (publisher's preview)
    “Other scholars, however, have contested this interpretation of the passages. They argue that the descriptions of Jesus’ baptism do not necessarily mirror the ritual structure of early Christian baptisms, and the two narratives in Acts may not …”
    Read the full passage
    “Other scholars, however, have contested this interpretation of the passages. They argue that the descriptions of Jesus’ baptism do not necessarily mirror the ritual structure of early Christian baptisms, and the two narratives in Acts may not describe the regular form of Christian initiation but instead be accounts of unusual situations: the mission of the Hellenists in Samaria had to be endorsed by the Jerusalem apostles, and the disciples of John needed baptism in the name of Jesus in order to receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.”
  • On Baptism 7
    “After this, when we have issued from the font, we are thoroughly anointed with a blessed unction, — (a practice derived) from the old discipline, wherein on entering the priesthood, men were wont to be anointed with oil from a horn, ever since Aaron was anointed by Moses.”
  • On Baptism 8, opening
    “In the next place the hand is laid on us, invoking and inviting the Holy Spirit through benediction.”
  • Denzinger 465 (DS 860), profession of faith of Michael Palaeologus, Second Council of Lyons, 1274
    “another is the sacrament of confirmation which the bishops confer through the imposition of hands when anointing the reborn”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.6
    “6 Confirmation and Extreme Unction are rites received from the Fathers which not even the Church requires as necessary to salvation, because they do not have God’s command. Therefore it is not useless to distinguish these rites from the former, which have God’s express command and a clear promise of grace.”
Other readings
  • The Catholic reading is that Tertullian is describing the whole complex that the Church later distinguishes into two sacraments, so the rite is present even where the category is not. On that reading nothing is added in the thirteenth century except the name and the separation.
  • The Catholic tradition takes Acts 8 as the scriptural warrant, and the Lyons profession describes confirmation in exactly the terms of that episode: an imposition of hands, given by bishops, to the already baptised. The rite as Lyons describes it is recognisably the gesture in Acts, whatever Acts was written to record.
  • Melanchthon grants that confirmation is an ancient rite and denies that it is a sacrament, because on the Lutheran test it lacks a command of God. That is an objection to the status of the rite, not to its antiquity.
  • Bradshaw, the Anglican liturgical historian, sets out both readings of Acts 8: some scholars find there the biblical foundation of later confirmation, others read it as an unusual situation. He concludes that 'at best, the New Testament evidence is inconclusive with regard to any post-baptismal ceremonies'. That is one scholar's survey, not a count of commentators.
Limits
  • The heart of this claim is what the sources do not show. No text between Tertullian around AD 206 and the Lyons profession of 1274 was verified for this chapter, so the actual separation of confirmation from baptism in the West is undocumented here. The claim records a gap in the evidence, not a reconstructed sequence of events.
  • The usual second and third century witness for the rite, the Apostolic Tradition attributed to Hippolytus, could not be obtained in a scholarly edition. Its date, authorship and Roman provenance are all now contested, and the only translation retrieved describes itself as a simplified version for the non-expert. It is deliberately not quoted here.
  • Acts 8:14-17 is quoted from the 2011 NABRE on bible.usccb.org, with verse numbers and footnote letters removed. The fifty-year gap rests on the usual dating: the New American Bible's introduction places Luke's Gospel after AD 70, many proposing AD 80-90, and Acts is the second volume of the same work, while the Samaria episode falls within a few years of the crucifixion in Acts' own sequence.
  • Tertullian is quoted in S. Thelwall's 1885 Ante-Nicene Fathers translation. The parenthesis "(a practice derived)" in chapter 7 is the translator's supplement, marked as such in that edition. A modern critical edition would be the better citation.
  • The Lyons wording rests on a single web reproduction of Deferrari's English Denzinger, hosted by a devotional aggregator. A cross-check against a second edition failed. The fact of the Lyons enumeration is independently corroborated by the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia, which says the same enumeration was made 'in the Profession of Faith of Michael Palaelogus, offered to Gregory X in the Council of Lyons (1274)'; the exact wording is not.
  • The Eastern practice, in which chrismation is administered together with baptism and confirmation is therefore never separated from it, is not documented in this chapter's sources. The Orthodox Church in America's catechesis names the rite "chrismation (or confirmation)" and says no more than that.
  • Bradshaw's Early Christian Worship is quoted from the publisher's free ten-page preview of the 2010 second edition, not from a full copy of the book.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

06HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

The earliest surviving text to enumerate exactly seven sacraments is Peter Lombard's Sentences, Book IV, distinction II, written around 1155 to 1158. The enumeration was made possible by Lombard's own definition one distinction earlier: a sacrament properly so called is a sign of God's grace that both bears its image and is its cause. The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia, a Catholic reference work carrying nihil obstat and imprimatur, states that the honour most probably belongs to Lombard and that for many centuries before him the enumeration of sacred signs was somewhat arbitrary. The Catechism of the Catholic Church does not contest the gradualness: it says the Church has discerned over the centuries which celebrations are sacraments in the strict sense.

Rests on
  • Book IV, dist. II, cap. 1, n. 1 (Latin)
    “1. De sacramentis novae Legis. Iam ad sacramenta novae Legis ac cedamus: quae sunt baptismus, confirmatio, panis benedictionis, id est eucharistia, poenitentia, unctio extrema, ordo, coniugium.”
  • Book IV, dist. I, cap. 4, n. 2 (Latin)
    “Sacramentum enim proprie dicitur, quod ita signum est gratiae Dei et invisibilis gratiae forma, ut ipsius imaginem gerat et causa exsistat. Non igitur significandi tantum gratia sacramenta instituta sunt, sed et sanctificandi.”
  • Number of the sacraments
    “Most probably this honour belongs to Peter Lombard (d. 1164) who in his fourth Book of Sentences (d. i, n.2) defines a sacrament as a sacred sign which not only signifies but also causes grace, and then (d.ii, n.1) enumerates the seven sacraments.”
  • Number of the sacraments, continuation
    “For many centuries all signs of sacred things were called sacraments, and the enumeration of these signs was somewhat arbitrary.”
  • CCC 1117
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of …”
    Read the full passage
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of God's mysteries, has determined its "dispensation."34 Thus the Church has discerned over the centuries that among liturgical celebrations there are seven that are, in the strict sense of the term, sacraments instituted by the Lord.”
Other readings
  • The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia draws its own inference from the speed of acceptance, calling it "proof positive that he did not introduce a new doctrine, but merely expressed in a convenient and precise formula what had always been held in the Church". That is an inference, not a datum. Rapid universal acceptance is equally consistent with the Sentences simply becoming the standard theology textbook of the medieval schools.
  • The Orthodox Church in America's catechesis draws the opposite conclusion from the same date: "The practice of counting the sacraments was adopted in the Orthodox Church from the Roman Catholics. It is not an ancient practice of the Church and, in many ways, it tends to be misleading".
  • Most academic historians read the enumeration as a twelfth-century scholastic achievement rather than the recovery of an apostolic list, while agreeing that the rites themselves are far older.
Limits
  • The Latin of the enumeration is quoted from a web transcription of the 1971 Grottaferrata critical edition that carries uncorrected OCR, and the hosting page warns of this on its own front page. Two artefacts sit in the quoted paragraph: "ac cedamus" for "accedamus", split across a line break, and "alla" for "alia" later in the same sentence. Verify against a printed Grottaferrata copy before publication.
  • No free published English translation of Sentences Book IV was available, so the quotation stands in Latin. Silano's translation is in copyright.
  • Earliest surviving is not the same as earliest. A twelfth-century list could have had predecessors that did not survive, and the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia reports a rival candidate, Otto of Bamberg in 1139, at second hand and without endorsing it. That report was not verified for this chapter.
  • The critical editors' own apparatus at this passage refers the reader to a dedicated study of the history of the sevenfold number. That study has not been read for this chapter.
  • The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia is a pre-critical reference work on patristic questions and is cited here for its concession, not for its patristics.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The number seven was taken up by councils in three stages, and every stage is late. It stands in the profession of faith of the emperor Michael Palaeologus accepted at the Second Council of Lyons in 1274. It is set out again at the Council of Florence on 22 November 1439, in the decree of union with the Armenians, which calls its own list a brief scheme drawn up for easier instruction. It is fixed under anathema for the first time at the Council of Trent, in the seventh session of 3 March 1547. Those dates fall roughly 1,240, 1,410 and 1,520 years after the apostolic age, and Trent comes after Luther's attack rather than before it. Each of the three enumerates rites that the documents show being performed centuries earlier, so on the record the enumeration is later than the practices it enumerates.

Rests on
  • Denzinger 465 (DS 860), Second Council of Lyons, 1274
    “The same holy Roman Church also holds and teaches that the ecclesiastical sacraments are seven: namely, one is baptism, concerning which we have spoken above; another is the sacrament of confirmation which the bishops confer through the imposition …”
    Read the full passage
    “The same holy Roman Church also holds and teaches that the ecclesiastical sacraments are seven: namely, one is baptism, concerning which we have spoken above; another is the sacrament of confirmation which the bishops confer through the imposition of hands when anointing the reborn; another is penance; another the Eucharist; another the sacrament of orders; another is matrimony; another extreme unction, which according to the doctrine of St. James is given to the sick.”
  • Council of Florence, Session 8 (22 November 1439), Exsultate Deo, the fifth head
    “Fifthly, for the easier instruction of the Armenians of today and in the future we reduce the truth about the sacraments of the church to the following brief scheme. There are seven sacraments of the new Law, namely baptism, confirmation, Eucharist, …”
    Read the full passage
    “Fifthly, for the easier instruction of the Armenians of today and in the future we reduce the truth about the sacraments of the church to the following brief scheme. There are seven sacraments of the new Law, namely baptism, confirmation, Eucharist, penance, extreme unction, orders and matrimony, which differ greatly from the sacraments of the old Law. The latter were not causes of grace, but only prefigured the grace to be given through the passion of Christ; whereas the former, ours, both contain grace and bestow it on those who worthily receive them.”
  • Session VII (3 March 1547), canon I on the sacraments in general
    “CANON I.-If any one saith, that the sacraments of the New Law were not all instituted by Jesus Christ, our Lord; or, that they are more, or less, than seven, to wit, Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction, Order, and …”
    Read the full passage
    “CANON I.-If any one saith, that the sacraments of the New Law were not all instituted by Jesus Christ, our Lord; or, that they are more, or less, than seven, to wit, Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction, Order, and Matrimony; or even that any one of these seven is not truly and properly a sacrament; let him be anathema.”
  • Session VII (3 March 1547), Proem
    “the sacred and holy, oecumenical and general Synod of Trent, lawfully assembled in the Holy Ghost, the same legates of the Apostolic See presiding therein, adhering to the doctrine of the holy Scriptures, to the apostolic traditions, and to the …”
    Read the full passage
    “the sacred and holy, oecumenical and general Synod of Trent, lawfully assembled in the Holy Ghost, the same legates of the Apostolic See presiding therein, adhering to the doctrine of the holy Scriptures, to the apostolic traditions, and to the consent of other councils and of the Fathers, has thought fit that these present canons be established and decreed”
  • Number of the sacraments
    “The same enumeration had been made in the Decree for the Armenians by the Council of Florence (1439), in the Profession of Faith of Michael Palaelogus, offered to Gregory X in the Council of Lyons (1274) and in the council held at London, in 1237, under Otto, legate of the Holy See.”
  • CCC 1117
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of …”
    Read the full passage
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of God's mysteries, has determined its "dispensation."34 Thus the Church has discerned over the centuries that among liturgical celebrations there are seven that are, in the strict sense of the term, sacraments instituted by the Lord.”
Other readings
  • The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia argues from the speed of acceptance that Lombard and the councils after him did not introduce a new doctrine but gave a precise formula to what had always been held. That is an inference rather than a datum. The same speed is equally consistent with the Sentences becoming the standard textbook of the medieval schools.
  • Trent states its own warrant in the proem, and the warrant is not Scripture alone: the holy Scriptures, the apostolic traditions, and the consent of other councils and of the Fathers. On the Catholic reading the councils ratify what was handed on rather than invent it, and the decree says so openly.
  • The Catechism does not resist the lateness. It says the Church has gradually recognised the seven and has discerned them over the centuries, and compares the process to the settling of the canon of Scripture.
  • Melanchthon's reply is that a difference in reckoning is of no consequence provided the things handed down in Scripture are preserved, and that the ancients did not reckon in the same manner either. On that reading the conciliar number is a teaching convention, not a revealed datum.
  • The Orthodox Church in America's catechesis reports the same enumeration arriving in the East from Rome and calls it not an ancient practice of the Church.
Limits
  • Defined at Lyons overstates the record. The list sits in a profession of faith made by the Byzantine emperor's delegation, whose text was drafted earlier under Clement IV in 1267, and not in a conciliar canon. The word sacrament does not occur once in Tanner's edition of the Lyons II constitutions as reproduced at papalencyclicals.net. Professed at Lyons is what the evidence supports.
  • The Lyons wording rests on a single web reproduction of Deferrari's English Denzinger, hosted by a devotional aggregator and therefore a weak witness to the text. The fact of the enumeration is corroborated by the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia; the wording is not.
  • Whether the Florence decree for the Armenians is a dogmatic definition or a catechetical and disciplinary instrument is debated among theologians. The decree describes itself as a brief scheme for the easier instruction of the Armenians, which is why the wording of its own framing is quoted here alongside the list.
  • Trent is quoted in J. Waterworth's 1848 English, which is the standard free translation but is Victorian and occasionally loose. The Hanover file carries uncorrected OCR typos elsewhere on the same page, though canon I and the proem are clean. The Latin at Denzinger 1601 should be collated before any sentence is leaned on.
  • The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia also reports a council held at London in 1237 under Otto, legate of the Holy See, making the same enumeration, and a rival claim that Otto of Bamberg reached the number in 1139. Neither report was verified for this chapter, and the second is not endorsed by the encyclopedia itself.
  • That the enumeration is later than the practices is carried by the attestation gathered on the other claims of this module. This claim documents the councils, not the rites.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Protestant objection is not that the seven rites were never performed. It is that only some of them are sacraments, because a sacrament properly so called is a rite that carries a command of God, an instituted visible sign, and an attached promise of grace. Luther applies that test in the Babylonian Captivity of 1520 and reaches two, baptism and the bread, on the ground that only in those two is both the divinely instituted sign and the promise of forgiveness found. Melanchthon applies it in the Apology of the Augsburg Confession in 1531 and reaches three, baptism, the Lord's Supper and absolution. Confirmation and extreme unction he calls rites received from the Fathers which do not have God's command. Calvin, in the Institutes, gives the Reformed form of the test: man cannot institute a sacrament, and the number seven is nowhere found in the ecclesiastical writers. The second half of the objection is about the number itself: Melanchthon holds that the ancients did not reckon in the same manner, that a difference of reckoning is of no consequence provided what Scripture hands down is preserved, and that if everything with God's command and a promise were counted, prayer, alms and afflictions could be numbered among the sacraments too. No prudent man, he says, will strive greatly over the number, provided what has God's command and promises is kept.

Rests on
  • Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), §1.18 (WA 6, 501)
    “AT THE OUTSET I must deny that there are seven sacraments, and hold for the present to but three — baptism, penance and the bread.”
  • Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), §7.4 (WA 6, 561)
    “We read simply nothing about these "sacraments" in the other Fathers, nor do they ever refer to them as sacraments; for the invention of sacraments is of recent date.”
  • Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), §9.3, concluding section
    “Nevertheless, it has seemed best to restrict the name of sacrament to such promises as have signs attached to them. The remainder, not being bound to signs, are bare promises. Hence there are, strictly speaking, but two sacraments in the Church of …”
    Read the full passage
    “Nevertheless, it has seemed best to restrict the name of sacrament to such promises as have signs attached to them. The remainder, not being bound to signs, are bare promises. Hence there are, strictly speaking, but two sacraments in the Church of God — baptism and bread; for only in these two do we find both the divinely instituted sign and the promise of forgiveness of sins. The sacrament of penance, which I added to these two,lacks the divinely instituted visible sign, and is, as I have said, nothing but a return to baptism.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.2
    “But here they bid us also count seven sacraments. We hold that it should be maintained that the matters and ceremonies instituted in the Scriptures, whatever the number, be not neglected. Neither do we believe it to be of any consequence, though, …”
    Read the full passage
    “But here they bid us also count seven sacraments. We hold that it should be maintained that the matters and ceremonies instituted in the Scriptures, whatever the number, be not neglected. Neither do we believe it to be of any consequence, though, for the purpose of teaching, different people reckon differently, provided they still preserve aright the matters handed down in Scripture. Neither have the ancients reckoned in the same manner.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.3-4
    “3 If we call Sacraments rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added, it is easy to decide what are properly Sacraments. For rites instituted by men will not in this way be Sacraments properly so called. For …”
    Read the full passage
    “3 If we call Sacraments rites which have the command of God, and to which the promise of grace has been added, it is easy to decide what are properly Sacraments. For rites instituted by men will not in this way be Sacraments properly so called. For it does not belong to human authority to promise grace. Therefore signs instituted without God’s command are not sure signs of grace, even though they perhaps instruct the rude [children or the uncultivated], or admonish as to something [as a painted cross]. 4 Therefore Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and Absolution, which is the Sacrament of Repentance, are truly Sacraments.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.6
    “6 Confirmation and Extreme Unction are rites received from the Fathers which not even the Church requires as necessary to salvation, because they do not have God’s command. Therefore it is not useless to distinguish these rites from the former, which have God’s express command and a clear promise of grace.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.11
    “But if ordination be understood as applying to the ministry of the Word, we are not unwilling to call ordination a sacrament.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.14
    “Wherefore, if any one should wish to call it a sacrament, he ought still to distinguish it from those preceding ones [the two former ones], which are properly signs of the New Testament, and testimonies of grace and the remission of sins.”
  • Apology of the Augsburg Confession XIII.16-17
    “16 Lastly, if among the Sacraments all things ought to be numbered which have God’s command, and to which promises have been added, why do we not add prayer, which most truly can be called a sacrament? For it has both God’s command and very many …”
    Read the full passage
    “16 Lastly, if among the Sacraments all things ought to be numbered which have God’s command, and to which promises have been added, why do we not add prayer, which most truly can be called a sacrament? For it has both God’s command and very many promises; and if placed among the Sacraments, as though in a more eminent place, it would invite men to pray. 17 Alms could also be reckoned here, and likewise afflictions, which are, even themselves signs, to which God has added promises. But let us omit these things. For no prudent man will strive greatly concerning the number or the term, if only those objects still be retained which have God’s command and promises.”
  • Augsburg Confession (1530), Article XIII.1-2
    “1 Of the Use of the Sacraments they teach that the Sacraments were ordained, not only to be marks of profession among men, but rather to be signs and testimonies of the will of God 2 toward us, instituted to awaken and confirm faith in those who use them.”
  • Institutes of the Christian Religion (1559), IV.19.2
    “Man, therefore, cannot institute a sacrament, because it is not in the power of man to make such divine mysteries lurk under things so abject.”
  • Institutes of the Christian Religion (1559), IV.19.3
    “This number seven is nowhere found in the ecclesiastical writers, nor is it well ascertained at what time it crept in.”
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church 1117 (vatican.va)
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of …”
    Read the full passage
    “As she has done for the canon of Sacred Scripture and for the doctrine of the faith, the Church, by the power of the Spirit who guides her "into all truth," has gradually recognized this treasure received from Christ and, as the faithful steward of God's mysteries, has determined its "dispensation." Thus the Church has discerned over the centuries that among liturgical celebrations there are seven that are, in the strict sense of the term, sacraments instituted by the Lord.”
  • Session VII (3 March 1547), foreword to the decree on the sacraments (Waterworth p. 54)
    “adhering to the doctrine of the holy Scriptures, to the apostolic traditions, and to the consent of other councils and of the Fathers”
  • The Orthodox Faith, vol. II, Worship: The Sacraments
    “The practice of counting the sacraments was adopted in the Orthodox Church from the Roman Catholics. It is not an ancient practice of the Church”
Other readings
  • The Catholic reply is the Catechism's own and not a stronger one. CCC 1117 says the Church has gradually recognised the seven and has discerned them over the centuries, and compares that discernment to the settling of the canon of Scripture. Nobody has a first-century list of the twenty-seven books either. The cost of the reply is that it locates the number in the Church's discernment, which is the authority a Protestant reader does not grant.
  • Trent answers the objection by stating a warrant wider than Scripture alone: the holy Scriptures, the apostolic traditions, and the consent of other councils and of the Fathers. That is precisely the warrant under dispute, so the two sides are not disagreeing about the documents but about what counts as evidence.
  • The Lutheran objection is milder than the popular version of it. Melanchthon will call ordination a sacrament if it is understood as the ministry of the Word, and will accept the name for matrimony provided it is distinguished from baptism and the Supper. He says that no prudent man will strive greatly concerning the number or the term, provided the things with God's command and promises are retained.
  • The Orthodox objection is a third position and not a Protestant one. All seven rites are kept, and what is denied is the closed count, which the Orthodox Church in America's catechesis describes as adopted from the Roman Catholics and not an ancient practice of the Church.
Limits
  • The objection as stated in the chapter's summary line, that only baptism and the Lord's Supper have dominical institution, is the Reformed and later popular form. The confessional Lutheran texts quoted here count three, including absolution, and the Augsburg Confession of 1530 never names a number at all. The question of the number is raised only in the Apology, in answer to the Catholic Confutation. Both facts should be stated wherever the two-sacrament formula is used.
  • The Protestant number was also reasoned to, inside a single treatise. Luther opens the Babylonian Captivity holding three sacraments, says in the same work that on a strict scriptural usage he should allow but a single sacrament with three sacramental signs, and closes holding two. A chapter that presses the lateness of the Catholic seven has to be equally candid about that.
  • The Reformed voice is quoted from Calvin's Institutes IV.19 only, in Henry Beveridge's 1845 translation as carried by the CCEL plain-text edition. The Belgic Confession and the Heidelberg Catechism were not quoted, and Calvin's chapter is polemical throughout: its title calls the five 'falsely so called'.
  • No Baptist or Anabaptist text is quoted anywhere in this claim or the chapter. The position of those churches, that baptism and the Lord's Supper are ordinances which signify rather than convey grace, is stated in summary only.
  • Luther is quoted from Steinhaeuser's 1915 translation as modernised for Project Wittenberg, whose editor notes that the text has not reached its final form. It is not a critical translation. The small-capital opening AT THE OUTSET is the electronic edition's styling, and so is the missing space in 'these two,lacks'.
  • The Apology and the Augsburg Confession are quoted from bookofconcord.org, which does not credit a translator on either page; the wording is that of the 1921 Triglot Concordia. The bracketed phrases inside the quotations are the German text of the Apology, printed inline as the Triglot does.
  • Luther's historical charge that the invention of sacraments is of recent date is right about the word and the number and wrong about the rites, which the documents show being performed. It is quoted here as the objection in its strongest form, not as a finding.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

Questions people ask next