Anointing the sick with oil by the presbyters of the church, with prayer and the forgiveness of sins, is commanded in the New Testament itself at James 5:14-15. This makes anointing one of the better attested of the seven. What the Council of Trent defined in 1551 adds elements the letter does not contain, above all that the matter of the sacrament is oil blessed by a bishop. Trent attributes those elements not to James but to apostolic tradition received from hand to hand, and says in the same chapter that the sacrament is only insinuated in Mark.
- James 5:14-15 (NABRE)
“14 Is anyone among you sick? He should summon the presbyters of the church, and they should pray over him and anoint [him] with oil in the name of the Lord, 15 and the prayer of faith will save the sick person, and the Lord will raise him up. If he has committed any sins, he will be forgiven.”
- NABRE translators' notes on James 5:14 and 5:15
“* [5:14] In case of sickness a Christian should ask for the presbyters of the church, i.e., those who have authority in the church (cf. Acts 15:2, 22–23; 1 Tm 5:17; Ti 1:5). They are to pray over the person and anoint with oil; oil was used for …”
Read the full passage“* [5:14] In case of sickness a Christian should ask for the presbyters of the church, i.e., those who have authority in the church (cf. Acts 15:2, 22–23; 1 Tm 5:17; Ti 1:5). They are to pray over the person and anoint with oil; oil was used for medicinal purposes in the ancient world (see Is 1:6; Lk 10:34). In Mk 6:13, the Twelve anoint the sick with oil on their missionary journey. In the name of the Lord: by the power of Jesus Christ. * [5:15] The results of the prayer and anointing are physical health and forgiveness of sins. The Roman Catholic Church (Council of Trent, Session 14) declared that this anointing of the sick is a sacrament “instituted by Christ and promulgated by blessed James the apostle.””
- Session XIV, Extreme Unction, chapter I
“Now, this sacred unction of the sick was instituted by Christ our Lord, as truly and properly a sacrament of the new law, insinuated indeed in Mark, but recommended and promulgated to the faithful by James the Apostle, and brother of the Lord. Is …”
Read the full passage“Now, this sacred unction of the sick was instituted by Christ our Lord, as truly and properly a sacrament of the new law, insinuated indeed in Mark, but recommended and promulgated to the faithful by James the Apostle, and brother of the Lord. Is any man, he saith, sick among you ? Let him bring in the priests of the Church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord: and the prayer of faith shall save the sick man; and the Lord shall raise him up; and if he be in sins, they shall be forgiven him. In which words, as the Church has learned from apostolic tradition, received from hand to hand, he teaches the matter, the form, the proper minister, and the effect of this salutary sacrament. For the Church has understood the matter thereof to be oil blessed by a bishop.”
- Melanchthon grants that extreme unction is a rite received from the Fathers and denies that it is a sacrament properly so called: "Confirmation and Extreme Unction are rites received from the Fathers which not even the Church requires as necessary to salvation, because they do not have God's command."
- The bishops' own note observes that "oil was used for medicinal purposes in the ancient world", which leaves open a reading of James as prayer accompanying ordinary medical care rather than as the institution of a rite.
- A Protestant reader will say that Trent's own words, "insinuated indeed in Mark" and "apostolic tradition, received from hand to hand", concede that the institution is not on the page of Scripture.
- James does not say the oil was blessed by a bishop, does not restrict the anointing to the danger of death, and does not call it a sacrament.
- The date of the letter of James is disputed, with proposals running from the 50s to about AD 100.
- No early source was verified for the elements Trent adds. The gap between James and the matter, form, minister and effect defined in 1551 is not filled by any document quoted here.
- The brackets around "[him]" in the NABRE text are the translators' own, marking a supplied word.
- Waterworth's 1848 English of Trent is the standard free text but is Victorian; the Latin should be checked before publication.
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).