Full text
Protestant or evangelical · About 7 min ·  · Worship and the sacraments

Why confess sins to a priest instead of straight to God?

The short answer

Catholics are taught to confess straight to God, every day. Confession to a priest is required for serious sin and recommended for everyday ones, and Catholics believe Jesus set it up himself. The priest speaks God's forgiveness out loud, in Jesus's name. It was never his own.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

If you grew up , confession to a priest can sound like putting a man between you and God.

You can pray to Jesus anywhere, even at 3 a.m. And the promises that if we confess our , God forgives them.

So why queue up in a church to tell a priest?

Catholics agree with more of that than you might think. They're taught to confess straight to God every day.

And every , the Catholic Sunday service, opens with a prayer for forgiveness.

Sin means choosing against love, for God and for other people. The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says it bluntly:

Only God forgives sins.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1441

But it goes on: Jesus gives this power to men to exercise in his name. So the priest has no power of his own.

The real question is whether Jesus really did set up a human way to pass on God's forgiveness. Catholics believe he did.

Part 2 · What Jesus handed on

On the evening he rose from the dead, Jesus came to his and told them:

Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins you retain are retained.
John 20:23

To retain means to hold back. It's hard to do either without hearing what the sins are.

Matthew's tells of a paralysed man brought to Jesus.

Jesus forgives his sins, and then he heals him.

The man gets up and goes home. And the crowd praises God for giving such authority to human beings.

Notice they say human beings, not just Jesus.

A Catholic Bible's note says this points to Matthew's own church already claiming that authority to forgive sins.

A letter in the tells sick believers to call the church's elders.

The elders pray over them, and the letter says their sins will be forgiven.

Many evangelicals read Jesus's words, whose sins you forgive, differently.

They see in them authority to announce forgiveness to everyone who believes, not a power kept for priests and ministers.

They also point to that same letter. It says confess your sins to one another: to any believer, not only a priest.

That's a serious reading. The real disagreement is who carries on this power to forgive: every believer, or the leaders the handed it to.

Catholics believe and priests carry it on today. The also confess to a priest.

And among Protestants, not every church dropped it. Lutheran churches, the oldest Protestant family, say private confession to a pastor should be kept.

Anglicans have a prayer book.

It tells a priest visiting the sick to invite a private confession, and then pronounce forgiveness.

So did confession to a priest carry on after the first followers, or was it made up later?

was a bishop who led the Church in Carthage, in North Africa.

Around AD 251, he wrote about Christians who had given up their faith under threat.

Cyprian complained that some rushed back to before confession has been made of their crime.

They hadn't yet been made clean by the hand of the priest. Cyprian doesn't argue for this. He takes it for granted.

To be honest, the way it's done has changed, and the Catholic Church says so.

In the first centuries, Christians who'd committed very grave sins, like murder or adultery, did penance in public.

That meant showing their sorrow openly, often for years, before being welcomed back. In some regions, it was allowed only once in a lifetime.

Then in the 600s, Irish missionaries, inspired by the Eastern monastic tradition, spread the private, repeatable confession Catholics know today.

So the private form came later. But underneath, the Catechism says, the Church still forgives in Jesus's name through the bishop and his priests.

What stayed the same? The Catechism names it: contrition, confession, and satisfaction, which means being sorry, owning up and making amends.

And, from the other side, God's action through the intervention of the Church. Public or private, that part hasn't changed.

Part 3 · Why say it out loud?

So why say it out loud? Partly because sin is never only private. It hurts the people around you, and the whole family of believers.

Reconciliation means making peace. The Catechism says:

Reconciliation with the Church is inseparable from reconciliation with God.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1445

And partly because of how people are made. Confessing your sins, the Catechism says, even from a simply human point of view, frees us.

Saying it out loud makes you look straight at what you did, and own it.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a fight with your mum. You said things you didn't mean.

Then you slammed your bedroom door so hard the pictures shook.

An hour later, you're lying on your bed feeling awful. You're sorry, truly. And honestly, she's probably forgiven you already.

But you don't know that yet. So you keep replaying it, wondering how bad it was.

So you get up and walk into the kitchen. She's at the sink. You say it out loud, to her face: I'm sorry, Mum.

She dries her hands, turns around, and says: It's okay. Come here. And something in your chest lets go.

Hearing it from outside your own head is part of how forgiveness lands.

And that's what the priest is for. Catholics believe he forgives in Jesus's name, out loud, so you hear God's you're forgiven.

And the priest's words keep God first and himself last. They begin God, the Father of mercies.

Only at the very end does he say I absolve you from your sins. To absolve means to set free.

And if the priest is a sinner himself? He is. But the Catechism says the minister's sin cannot impede the fruit of grace.

In plain words, the priest's own sins can't block what God gives. It's God's forgiveness, not his.

One more thing: confession doesn't replace putting things right with people you hurt.

One must do what is possible in order to repair the harm, the Catechism says: give back what you took, or clear someone's name.

Part 4 · The rules, and when it was abused

So when do Catholics have to go? It depends on how serious the sin is.

A serious sin, which Catholics call mortal sin, is a serious wrong, done knowing it's serious, and freely chosen. It breaks your friendship with God.

From the age of discretion, roughly when a child can tell right from wrong, Catholics must confess serious sins at least once a year.

Someone who knows they've committed a serious sin must not receive Communion before confessing, even if they're deeply sorry.

The one exception is a serious reason to receive, with no chance to get to confession.

Confessing everyday faults isn't required, but it's strongly recommended.

And everything you say is protected by the seal of confession: the priest can never repeat it.

But some priests have used confession to groom people, winning their trust in order to abuse them. That has to be said.

In 1922 the Vatican issued a rule for putting on trial priests who used confession to seek sex.

It was reprinted in 1962, and it did require victims to report them.

But it also made everyone in the case, the people who reported it included, swear to keep it secret.

Secrecy like that can end up shielding the abuser instead of the people he hurt.

That rule stayed until new rules replaced it in 2001. Now a priest who seeks sex through confession can be thrown out of the priesthood.

One who breaks the seal is excommunicated straight away, which means he's barred from Communion and the Church's other sacred rites.

None of that undoes the harm already done.

So, back to where we started: why a priest, and not straight to God? Only God forgives, and the Catholic Church says so.

Catholics go to a priest because they believe Jesus sent men to forgive in his name, out loud, so you can actually hear the words.

Quick check

Think back to the fight with your mum. If she'd probably forgiven you already, why walk into the kitchen at all?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 13
  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1440–1449 · Only God forgives sins; the power given to the apostles; how the practice changed; the words of absolution.
  2. John 20:19–23 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · The risen Jesus breathes on the disciples: "Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them."
  3. James 5:13–16 (New American Bible) · The sick call the presbyters, who pray and anoint; sins are forgiven.
  4. Cyprian of Carthage, On the Lapsed (c. 251), 16 · Assumes confession and the priest's hand before returning to Communion.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1455–1460 · Why confession frees us; which sins must be confessed and which are recommended.
  6. The Augsburg Confession (1530), Article XI · The founding Lutheran confession keeps private absolution.
  7. Anthony Sparrow, A Rationale upon the Book of Common Prayer (1672), Visitation of the Sick · Quotes the Prayer Book's rubric: the sick person's special confession, then the priest's absolution.
  8. Holy Office, Instruction Crimen sollicitationis (1962) · Procedures for solicitation in confession; accusers and witnesses bound to confidentiality.
  9. Code of Canon Law, canons 1385–1386 (Book VI as revised in 2021) · Solicitation in confession can mean dismissal; breaking the seal brings automatic excommunication.
  10. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Historical introduction to the norms of Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela (2001) · Crimen sollicitationis issued in 1922, reprinted in 1962, and used until the 2001 norms replaced it.
  11. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1550 · The minister is not kept from sin, but his sin cannot block the grace of the sacraments.
  12. Matthew 9:1–8, with the New American Bible's note (on vatican.va) · The crowd praises God for giving such authority "to human beings"; the note on Matthew's church.
  13. Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith: Penance · The Orthodox sacrament of confession, now usually made in the presence of the priest, with the prayer of absolution.