Simony, the buying and selling of ordination, consecration and church office, was condemned by name in Catholic conciliar legislation from the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 to the Fifth Lateran Council in 1514, and each renewal of the law states that the previous legislation had failed.
- Libellus de symoniacis, Part I, sermon on Leo IX (trans. W. L. North, from MGH Libelli de Lite II)
“But what is even worse than all this - hardly anyone was found who either was not a symoniac [himself] or had not been ordained by symoniacs.”
- Canon 63, On simony (trans. H. J. Schroeder, 1937)
“We have learned with certainty that in many places and by many persons exactions and base extortions are made for the consecration of bishops, the blessing of abbots, and the ordination of clerics, and that a tax is fixed as to how much this one or …”
Read the full passage“We have learned with certainty that in many places and by many persons exactions and base extortions are made for the consecration of bishops, the blessing of abbots, and the ordination of clerics, and that a tax is fixed as to how much this one or that one is to receive and how much this one or that one is to pay; and what is worse, some endeavor to defend such baseness and depravity by an appeal to a custom of long standing.”
- Session 43 (21 March 1418), decree On simoniacs, issued by Martin V with the approval of the council (Tanner)
“Many constitutions have been issued in the past against the evil of simony, but they have not been able to eradicate the disease.”
- Session 9 (5 May 1514), clause renewing the constitutions against simony (Tanner)
“So that the stain and disease of abominable simony may be driven out for ever not only from the Roman curia but also from all christian rule, we renew the constitutions issued by our predecessors, also in sacred councils, against simoniacs of this kind, and we prescribe that they be observed unaltered.”
- Session 9 (5 May 1514), bull on reform of the curia, opening paragraph (Tanner)
“When we notice, out of solicitude for our said pastoral office, that church discipline and the pattern of a sound and upright life are worsening, disappearing and going further astray from the right path throughout almost all the ranks of Christ's …”
Read the full passage“When we notice, out of solicitude for our said pastoral office, that church discipline and the pattern of a sound and upright life are worsening, disappearing and going further astray from the right path throughout almost all the ranks of Christ's faithful, with a disregard for law and with exemption from punishment, as a result of the troubles of the times and the malice of human beings, it must be feared that, unless checked by a well-guided improvement, there will be a daily falling into a variety of faults under the security of sin and soon, with the appearance of public scandals, a complete breakdown.”
- A Catholic reading takes repeated condemnation as evidence of a conscience at work: the abuse is named, legislated against and eventually stopped, and the naming is done by the Church itself rather than by its opponents.
- A Lutheran or Reformed reading takes the same sequence as evidence that the institution could not correct itself, since three and a half centuries of law produced further law rather than enforcement, and enforcement came only after large parts of Europe had left.
- A caution this site records on its own account, and not on any historian's: renewal clauses are a standard formula in canonical legislation, so a council conceding that earlier legislation had failed is in part following a convention, and the concession cannot by itself be read as a measured finding about how far the law was being obeyed. No study of canonical drafting was consulted for this chapter.
- None of these texts gives a proportion. Lateran IV says only 'many places and by many persons'.
- Bruno of Segni is a Gregorian reform partisan writing a festal sermon in praise of Leo IX around 1094-1101 about the Church of the 1040s, roughly forty-five to fifty years after the events, and his opening is rhetoric rather than measurement.
- The Fordham electronic text of Lateran IV carries scanning typos elsewhere in the same document, and Schroeder's 1937 translation is standard but not a critical edition.
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).