Henry VIII dissolves the monasteries
The Crown closes every monastery, friary and convent in England, turns out thousands of monks, friars and nuns, strips the shrines, and executes the abbots and northern rebels who resist.
In 1535 England's monasteries, convents and friaries still fed many of the poor and held a large share of the land, and Henry VIII, newly head of the Church, needed money. Thomas Cromwell, the king's deputy in church matters, sent inspectors whose reports accused many monks and nuns of immorality.
In 1536 Parliament gave the king every house worth less than £200 a year, saying that ‘manifest sin’ was rife in the small houses while in the great ones religion was ‘right well kept’. Within four years the great houses were gone too.
The north rose in 1536 to save the abbeys, in the Pilgrimage of Grace, and was put down with executions of leaders, abbots and monks. Shrines such as Thomas Becket's at Canterbury were stripped. In 1539 the abbots of Glastonbury, Reading and Colchester were executed.
By one Catholic historian's count about 8,000 monks, friars and nuns lost their homes; the land went to the Crown, and much of it was sold on to courtiers and gentry.
The situation
In 1535 England had close to 900 religious houses, by one modern count: abbeys of monks, convents of nuns, and friaries of friars who preached in the towns. Their members took vows of poverty, chastity and obedience and prayed the Church's daily services.
The houses did more than pray. Many of the local poor relied on them for food and shelter, and they kept large libraries of hand-copied books. Some had grown lax, and a papal inquiry of 1489 had already found abuses.
They were also rich. Glastonbury alone was valued in 1535 at more than £3,300 a year. Henry VIII, now head of the Church in England after his break with Rome, needed money, and the houses held a large share of the country's land.
Some monks had already paid for resisting. In 1535 the Carthusians of London, a strict and silent order, refused to accept the king as head of the Church, and their prior was hanged at Tyburn.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
The poor who relied on the abbeys
Modern historians list the effect on the poor among the causes of the northern rising of 1536.
“The Dissolution of the Monasteries also affected the local poor, many of whom relied on them for food and shelter.”
Wikipedia, 'Pilgrimage of Grace' · Wikipedia, 'Pilgrimage of Grace', causes: economic (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08)
What was at stake
In 1535 Thomas Cromwell, Henry's deputy over the Church, sent inspectors round the houses. They moved fast, and their reports charged many monks and nuns with sexual and other abuses.
Critics then and since have asked what the inspections were for. Was the aim to reform the houses, or to close them and take their wealth?
The Act of 1536 gave Parliament's answer. It said ‘manifest sin’ was rife in the small houses, while in the great monasteries religion was ‘right well kept and observed’. Houses worth under £200 a year were to close, and their monks would move into the great ones.
The event
In 1536 Parliament gave the king every house worth under £200 a year; the chronicler John Stow counted 376. Officials broke each house's seal, took its silver, stripped the lead from the roofs and broke up the bells.
In October 1536 Lincolnshire and then Yorkshire rose in the Pilgrimage of Grace. Tens of thousands marched under the badge of the Five Wounds of and put monks back into their houses.
Their leader, the lawyer Robert Aske, said people feared the closures would destroy religion in England.
The king promised a pardon and a hearing. After a fresh rising in 1537, he had the leaders executed, abbots and monks among them: 216 people in all, by one count.
From 1537 the friaries and the great abbeys were pressed to surrender one by one. In September 1538 the shrine of Thomas Becket, the archbishop killed in Canterbury Cathedral in 1170, was stripped, and nearly every other shrine in England with it.
In November and December 1539 the abbots of Glastonbury, Reading and Colchester were executed. Richard Whiting of Glastonbury, old and sick, was hanged with two of his monks on Glastonbury Tor. By 1540 no religious house was left.
Go furtherFold· 8 notes, each with its source
- 01
The charge, in the Act's words
Froude, who defended the dissolution, printed the preamble of the 1536 Act in full. It opens with this charge. The Statutes of the Realm text in Gee and Hardy differs only in small points of wording.
“as manifest sin, vicious, carnal, and abominable living, is daily used and committed among the little and small abbeys, priories, and other religious houses of monks, canons, and nuns, where the congregation of such religious persons is under the number of twelve”
History of England from the Fall of Wolsey to the Defeat of the Spanish Armada, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries' · J. A. Froude, History of England, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries', quoting the preamble of 27 Henry VIII c. 28 - 02
How a house was taken down
Gasquet pieced the routine together from the commissioners' accounts. It often took six or seven weeks from the first visit until the house was dismantled and the last of its people had gone.
“called for and defaced the convent seal, the symbol of corporate existence, without which no business could be transacted; desecrated the church; took possession of the best plate and vestments "unto the King's use"; measured the lead upon the roof and calculated its value when melted; counted the bells”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Suppression of English Monasteries under Henry VIII', by F. A. Gasquet - 03
Why the north rose
Robert Aske, the lawyer who led the Yorkshire rising, explained it in his narrative to the king. Their special grudge, he added, was against Cromwell.
“In all parts of the realm men's hearts much grudged with the suppression of abbeys , and the first fruits , by reason the same would be the destruction of the whole religion in England .”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Pilgrimage of Grace', quoting Aske's Narrative to the King - 04
How many died for the Pilgrimage
Wikipedia, a tertiary source, gives this total for the executions that followed the rising: lords and knights, abbots, monks and commoners.
“In total 216 were executed”
Wikipedia, 'Pilgrimage of Grace' · Wikipedia, 'Pilgrimage of Grace', section on the aftermath (tertiary; retrieved 2026-09-24) - 05
The Crown's reason for pulling down shrines
Cromwell's injunctions of 1538 told the clergy that pilgrimages and offerings to images and relics were idolatry, and ordered abused images taken down.
“great threats and maledictions of God, as things tending to idolatry and superstition, which of all other offences God Almighty does most detest and abhor”
The Second Royal Injunctions of Henry VIII · Second Royal Injunctions of Henry VIII (1538), art. 6 (Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (1896), No. LXIII, p. 277) - 06
Nearly every shrine
Becket's was the most famous shrine to go, but it did not go alone.
“The martyr's holy remains are believed to have been destroyed in September, 1538, when nearly all the other shrines in England were dismantled”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas Becket', by Herbert Thurston, closing paragraph - 07
The last abbot of Glastonbury
In 1535 the visitor Richard Layton had reported that Glastonbury's monks were kept so strictly they could not offend. By 1539 it was the last house standing in Somerset. It was stripped while its sick, elderly abbot was held in the Tower, and he was condemned on evidence never made public.
“From Wells they were carried to Glastonbury and hanged on the summit of St. Michael's Tor, and as usual afterwards Whyting's head was cut off and stuck on the gateway of the abbey and his body, divided into four parts, was distributed to Bridgwater, Ilchester, Wells and Bath.”
A History of the County of Somerset, vol. 2 · Victoria County History, Somerset, vol. 2 (1911), 'The abbey of Glastonbury' - 08
Cromwell's memorandum
Before any trial, Cromwell's own notes had settled the outcome.
“The abbat of Glaston to be tried at Glaston, and also executed there with his complycys.”
Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography (1900), 'Whiting, Richard', quoting Cromwell's 'Remembrances'
The outcome
By the Catholic historian Gasquet's estimate, about 8,000 monks, canons, friars and nuns lost their homes. A modern estimate puts the number of religious nearer 12,000.
Heads of houses and many monks and nuns received pensions. Many others, and the servants who had worked for the houses, were left to wander in search of a living.
The land passed to the Crown, which gave or sold much of it to courtiers and gentry and spent much of the money on war. Six new dioceses, areas each led by a , were founded from it.
The libraries were scattered. Even John Bale, a who backed the closures, complained that new owners used the monks' books to scour candlesticks and sold them to grocers.
Go furtherFold· 7 notes, each with its source
- 01
How many lost their homes
Gasquet's breakdown was about 3,200 monks and canons from the greater houses, 1,800 friars and 1,560 nuns, plus those turned out of the lesser houses in 1536.
“it is probably not far from the truth to say that the number of religious men and women expelled from their homes by the suppression were, in round numbers, about 8000.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Suppression of English Monasteries under Henry VIII', by F. A. Gasquet - 02
A higher modern count
Wikipedia, a tertiary source, quotes the historian George W. Bernard's larger estimate of the houses and people on the eve of the dissolution.
“There were nearly 900 religious houses in England, around 260 for monks, 300 for regular canons , 142 nunneries and 183 friaries; some 12,000 people in total, 4,000 monks, 3,000 canons, 3,000 friars and 2,000 nuns.”
Wikipedia, 'Dissolution of the monasteries' · Wikipedia, 'Dissolution of the monasteries', opening section, quoting G. W. Bernard (tertiary; retrieved 2026-09-24) - 03
Pensions, and those without
Gairdner also reports the imperial ambassador Chapuys being told that 20,000 people were cast adrift by the first suppression alone, a figure Gairdner thought vague and probably exaggerated but a sign of widespread hardship.
“It is true that a considerable number of the monks and nuns received pensions, but very many were turned out of the houses which had been their homes and wandered about in search of means to live.”
The Cambridge Modern History, vol. II: The Reformation, ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII' · Cambridge Modern History, vol. II (1904), ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII', by James Gairdner - 04
Where the wealth went
Hunt's summary of how the monastic lands and treasure were used.
“Of the enormous wealth thus gained Henry spent a part on national defence, a little on the foundation of the bishoprics of Westminster, dissolved in 1550, Bristol, Chester, Gloucester, Oxford and Peterborough, and gave the lands to men either useful to or favoured by himself, or sold them to rich purchasers.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'England, The Church of', the Reformation era - 05
The libraries, in a Protestant's words
John Bale, a Protestant writer who himself supported the dissolution, lamented what the new owners did with the monks' books. Matthew Digby Wyatt quotes him in an 1861 history of manuscript illumination.
“A grete nombre of them wych purchased of those superstycyose mansyons reserved of those lybrarye bokes, some to serve their jaks, some to scoure theyr candelstyckes, and some to rubbe theyr bootes; some they solde to the grossers and sope sellers”
History, Theory, and Practice of Illuminating, Part I, 'What Illuminating Was' · M. Digby Wyatt, History, Theory, and Practice of Illuminating (1861), Part I, 'What Illuminating Was', quoting John Bale - 06
Glastonbury's monks afterwards
Some survivors were still drawing pensions under Mary. In 1556 four of them, then living at Westminster, asked the queen to let them restore the abbey without any endowment; she died before anything was done.
“Twenty-five names of Glastonbury monks appear in Cardinal Pole's pension list of 1553.”
A History of the County of Somerset, vol. 2 · Victoria County History, Somerset, vol. 2 (1911), 'The abbey of Glastonbury' - 07
Land that bound the gentry to the break
When Cardinal Pole reconciled England to Rome in November 1554, Parliament first had to be reassured on one point.
“the fears of the rich appeased by the assurance that they would not have to surrender the monastic lands”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'England, The Church of', reign of Mary
For the trail
The closures made the break with Rome very hard to undo. The historian Pollard records the view of William Cecil, later Elizabeth's chief minister, that the transfer of monastic wealth was what really secured the Reformation.
Thousands of families now held former church land. When Mary reconciled England to Rome in 1554, the holders of abbey lands first had to be promised they could keep them.
A way of life that had shaped English prayer, learning and care for the poor for centuries was ended in four years, by law and by force.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Cecil's judgement
Pollard, in the 1911 Britannica, on what the dissolution did for the Reformation.
“the dissolution of the monasteries which, by transferring enormous wealth from the church to the crown, really, in Cecil’s opinion, ensured the reformation.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Henry VIII. of England', by A. F. Pollard
What the Church says
The Church honours as martyrs the abbots executed in 1539 for resisting, Richard Whiting of Glastonbury and the abbots of Reading and Colchester, and beatified them, declaring them blessed, in the 1890s.
It holds that consecrated life, the vows of poverty, chastity and obedience lived in community, belongs to the life and holiness of the Church (Lumen Gentium 44). Mary briefly restored a few houses in the 1550s.
Most religious communities came back only around 1800, when monks and nuns fleeing the French Revolution settled in England.
“considering also that divers and great solemn monasteries of this realm, wherein (thanks be to God) religion is right well kept and observed, be destitute of such full numbers of religious persons, as they ought and may keep”
The same preamble charges the small houses with "manifest sin". Three years later the great houses went the same way: the Act of 1539 (31 Henry VIII c. 13) vested in the Crown every house surrendered since 1536, describing the surrenders as made of the abbots' "voluntary minds, good wills and assents, without constraint".
Where people disagree
Were the houses as corrupt as the inspectors said? The Protestant historian Froude defended the inspectors as upright and accepted their picture. He pointed to the papal inquiry of 1489, which had also found abuses.
The Catholic historian Gasquet argued that the houses were doomed before they were inspected. County commissioners in 1536 found many of the same communities of good character, though Gasquet admitted some reports were damning.
James Gairdner, who edited the state papers of Henry's reign, judged the inspectors' reports not credible, while allowing that monastic life had long been in decline.
Pollard warned that both schools were coloured: Froude wrote as an admirer of Henry, and Gasquet with strong religious feeling.
Go furtherFold· 6 notes, each with its source
- 01
Froude: the visitors told the truth
The Protestant historian J. A. Froude defended the visitors and accepted their picture of the houses, though he admitted he could not settle whether the stories were true.
“Legh and Leyton, the two principal commissioners, were young, impetuous men, likely to execute their work rather thoroughly than delicately; but, to judge by the surviving evidence, they were as upright and plain-dealing as they were assuredly able and efficient.”
History of England from the Fall of Wolsey to the Defeat of the Spanish Armada, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries' · J. A. Froude, History of England, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries' - 02
Froude: Rome had found abuses too
Froude answered the charge that the inquiry was a pretext by pointing to an earlier inquiry ordered by a Pope.
“At length, in the year 1489, at the instigation of Cardinal Morton, then Archbishop of Canterbury, a commission was issued by Innocent VIII. for a general investigation throughout England into the behaviour of the regular clergy.”
History of England from the Fall of Wolsey to the Defeat of the Spanish Armada, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries' · J. A. Froude, History of England, ch. X, 'The Visitation of the Monasteries' - 03
Gasquet: condemned before inspected
Gasquet argued that suppression was already planned before the visitors set out, and that the county commissioners of 1536 reported the characters of the same communities to be, in Gairdner's words, almost uniformly good.
“the monasteries were doomed prior to these visitations, and not in consequence of them, as we have been asked to believe according to the traditional story.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Suppression of English Monasteries under Henry VIII', by F. A. Gasquet - 04
Gasquet's concession
Gasquet did not claim that every house was blameless.
“the charges brought against the good name of some at least of the monasteries , by these chosen emissaries of Cromwell are, it must be confessed, sufficiently dreadful, although even their reports certainly do not bear out the modern notion of wholesale corruption.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Suppression of English Monasteries under Henry VIII', by F. A. Gasquet - 05
Gairdner: not credible
Gairdner, who calendared the state papers, also noted that the visitors had reported the great houses just as vicious as the small ones, which the Act of 1536 denied.
“It is impossible, for many reasons, to attach much credit to these reports, or to think highly of the character of the Visitors.”
The Cambridge Modern History, vol. II: The Reformation, ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII' · Cambridge Modern History, vol. II (1904), ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII', by James Gairdner - 06
A warning about both schools
A. F. Pollard, reviewing the historians of Henry's reign in 1911, judged both main narratives coloured.
“Froude’s famous portraiture of Henry is coloured by the ideas of hero-worship and history which the author imbibed from Carlyle, and the rival portraits in Lingard, R. W. Dixon’s Church History and Gasquet’s Henry VIII. and the Monasteries by strong religious feeling.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Henry VIII. of England', by A. F. Pollard, bibliography
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Parliament of England · 1536 · Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (London: Macmillan, 1896), No. LXI, pp. 257–68; Internet Archive OCR (item documentsillustrat00geeh)
- Parliament of England · 1539 · Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (London: Macmillan, 1896), No. LXIV, pp. 281–303; Internet Archive OCR (item documentsillustrat00geeh)
- Francis Aidan Gasquet · 1911 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- James Anthony Froude · 1893 (new edition) · Longmans, Green, and Co., London; Wikisource transcription
- James Gairdner · 1904 · Cambridge University Press; Wikisource transcription
- Victoria County History · 1911 · British History Online