Henry VIII breaks with Rome
Refused an annulment by the Pope, Henry VIII makes himself head of the Church in England and puts to death those who will not accept it, among them John Fisher, Thomas More and the London Carthusians.
Henry VIII had been married to Catherine of Aragon since 1509. Only a daughter, Mary, survived, and Henry feared that without a son England could fall back into civil war over the throne.
From 1527 he asked Pope Clement VII to annul the marriage, that is, to declare it had never been valid, so that he could marry Anne Boleyn. Clement, whose Rome had just been sacked by the troops of Catherine's nephew, the Emperor Charles V, would not.
So Henry broke with Rome. In 1533 his own Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, annulled the marriage, and in November 1534 Parliament declared the king ‘the only supreme head in earth of the church of England’. Denying it became treason.
In 1535 three Carthusian priors were hanged at Tyburn, and Bishop John Fisher and Sir Thomas More were beheaded.
The situation
Henry VIII became king of England in 1509, at 17. His father had won the crown in battle in 1485, ending decades of on-and-off civil war between rival royal families, the Wars of the Roses. Many at Henry's court could remember what a fight over the throne cost.
The same year Henry married Catherine of Aragon, a Spanish princess and the widow of his older brother Arthur. Church law forbade marrying a brother's widow, so the granted a dispensation, a formal exception to a church rule.
Henry was a loyal Catholic. In 1521 he wrote a book against , and Pope Leo X gave him the title Defender of the Faith.
But Catherine's babies kept dying, sons among them. Only a daughter, Mary, born in 1516, lived. By 1526 it was fairly clear there would be no son from the marriage, and no woman had yet ruled England in her own right.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
No son, and a fear of civil war
Pollard explains why a daughter did not settle the matter for Henry: no woman had yet reigned in England in her own right, and many thought women were barred from the throne.
“No candidate living could have secured the succession without a recurrence of civil war.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Henry VIII. of England', by A. F. Pollard
What was at stake
From 1527 Henry asked the pope for an annulment: a ruling that his marriage had never been valid. It isn't a divorce. It says there was never a true marriage to end.
Henry said his conscience troubled him because Catherine had been his brother's wife. He was also in love with Anne Boleyn, a lady of the court, and he wanted a wife who could give him a son.
Pope Clement VII couldn't simply say yes. An earlier pope had already granted the dispensation, and Catherine swore that her first marriage, to Arthur, had never been consummated. If that was true, her marriage to Henry was valid.
Politics pressed too. In May 1527 the troops of the Emperor Charles V, Catherine's nephew, sacked Rome, and was held in the Castel Sant'Angelo for more than seven months. Ruling against Catherine meant defying the most powerful man in Europe.
In July 1529 Clement called the case to Rome. The question became who had the last word over the Church in England: the pope or the king.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
A pope held prisoner
Charles V's troops sacked Rome in May 1527. The Catholic Encyclopedia doubts the emperor ordered the horrors, but notes what he allowed afterwards.
“he allowed him to remain a virtual prisoner in the Castle of Sant’ Angelo for more than seven months”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Pope Clement VII' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Pope Clement VII', by Herbert Thurston - 02
Fisher spoke for the queen
When the case was heard in England before the pope's legates in 1529, Bishop Fisher was Catherine's chief defender.
“he appeared on the Queen's behalf in the legates' court, where he startled his hearers by the directness of his language”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'St. John Fisher' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'St. John Fisher'
The event
Henry turned to Parliament. In 1531 the clergy were made to call the king Supreme Head of the Church, adding ‘so far as the law of allows’. In 1532 they gave up their power to make church law, and Thomas More resigned as Lord Chancellor.
In 1533 appeals to Rome were forbidden. In May Henry's new Archbishop of Canterbury, , declared his first marriage void. In July the pope declared Henry excommunicated: a church penalty that cut him off from the until he repented, not a physical punishment.
The sentence was held back to give him time, and only put into force in 1538.
In 1534 any adult could be made to swear an oath to the new line of , which also rejected the pope's authority. Bishop John Fisher and Thomas More refused it and were sent to the Tower of London.
In November Parliament passed the , making the king ‘the only supreme head in earth of the church of England’. A Treasons Act made it treason to deny him that title.
On 4 May 1535 three priors of the Carthusians, a strict, silent order of monks, were hanged at Tyburn with a Bridgettine monk and a parish priest. Fisher was beheaded on 22 June and More on 6 July.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
The Treasons Act of the same session
Passed alongside the Act of Supremacy, it made it high treason from 1 February 1535 to wish, by words or writing, to deprive the king of his dignity or title, or to call him a heretic or schismatic. Fisher and More were accused of trying to deprive the king of his new title.
“that the king our sovereign lord should be heretic, schismatic, tyrant, infidel or usurper of the crown”
Treasons Act (1534), 26 Henry VIII c. 13 · Treasons Act, 26 Henry VIII c. 13 (Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (1896), No. LVII, p. 248) - 02
The prior of the London Charterhouse at Tyburn
John Houghton, prior of the London Charterhouse, spoke to the crowd from the scaffold on 4 May 1535. Afterwards one of his quarters, with an arm, was hung over the Charterhouse gate to frighten his monks into taking the oath. They still refused.
“Our holy mother the Church has decreed otherwise than the king and parliament have decreed, and therefore, rather than disobey the Church, we are ready to suffer.”
Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography (1891), 'Houghton, John (1488?–1535)' - 03
A cardinal's hat and a head
In May 1535 Pope Paul III made the imprisoned Fisher a cardinal, apparently hoping Henry would treat him more gently. It had the opposite effect.
“Henry forbade the cardinal's hat to be brought into England , declaring that he would send the head to Rome instead.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'St. John Fisher' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'St. John Fisher' - 04
More's last word on the statute
At his trial on 1 July More kept silent on the supremacy. Once condemned, he spoke.
“after his condemnation he declared frankly as to the statute that it was against his conscience, as he could never find, in all his studies, that a temporal lord ought to be head of the spiritualty.”
The Cambridge Modern History, vol. II: The Reformation, ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII' · Cambridge Modern History, vol. II (1904), ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII', by James Gairdner
The outcome
England was cut off from Rome. Thomas Cromwell, a layman, was made the king's deputy to run the Church.
Henry did not become a . He kept the , the Catholic Sunday service, and his Six Articles of 1539 made denying it a crime punished by burning.
His church killed on both sides. Reformers were burned for heresy, teaching the Church judged false, and Catholics were hanged for denying his supremacy. In the London Charterhouse alone, fifteen more monks died on the scaffold or starved in Newgate prison.
Catherine died in January 1536, and Anne was beheaded that May. Henry's third wife, Jane Seymour, gave him his son, Edward, in 1537. By then the closing of the monasteries had begun.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
Both sides at one place, 30 July 1540
Henry's church punished Protestant belief and Catholic loyalty to Rome alike. The Catholic Encyclopedia records one day that shows both.
“On 30 July, 1540, of six victims who were dragged to Smithfield, three were Reformers burnt for heretical doctrine , and the other three Catholics , hanged and quartered for denying the king's supremacy.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Henry VIII' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Henry VIII', by Herbert Thurston - 02
The Six Articles, 1539
Henry's Act of 1539 kept Catholic teaching on the Mass and made denial of it a burning matter, with no chance to save oneself by recanting.
“therefor have and suffer judgment, execution, pain, and pains of death by way of burning, without any abjuration, clergy, or sanctuary to be therefor permitted”
Act of Six Articles (1539), 31 Henry VIII c. 14 · Act of Six Articles, 31 Henry VIII c. 14 (Gee and Hardy, Documents Illustrative of English Church History (1896), No. LXV, p. 307) - 03
A single despotism
William Hunt, writing the Britannica's 1911 article on the Church of England, drew this conclusion about what the break did for the English Church itself.
“By breaking the bonds of Rome Henry did not give the church freedom; he substituted a single despotism for the dual authority which pope and king had previously exercised over it.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'England, The Church of', the Reformation era - 04
How Europe took it
James Gairdner, who edited the state papers of Henry's reign, describes the reaction to the deaths of Fisher and More.
“These executions filled the world with horror, both at home and abroad.”
The Cambridge Modern History, vol. II: The Reformation, ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII' · Cambridge Modern History, vol. II (1904), ch. XIII, 'Henry VIII', by James Gairdner - 05
The London Carthusians
After the three priors of 4 May 1535, the monks of the London Charterhouse kept refusing the oath.
“During the next five years, fifteen of the London Carthusians perished on the scaffold or were starved to death in Newgate Gaol.”
Catholic Encyclopedia · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The Carthusian Order'
For the trail
Here the Anglican channel leaves the trunk. It left over authority, not : Parliament declared that neither king nor kingdom meant to leave the Catholic faith of Christendom.
Fisher, More and the Carthusians did not die over Henry's marriage as such. They died because they would not say that a king could be head of the Church.
The question they died for, who may command a Christian's conscience, runs through the rest of England's story. Under Edward, Mary and Elizabeth, whoever held the Crown used the same power against whoever disagreed.
What the Church says
The Church honours John Fisher and Thomas More as saints and martyrs, canonised together in 1935; in 2000 John Paul II named More patron of statesmen and politicians. The Carthusian priors hanged in 1535 were canonised in 1970 among the Forty Martyrs of England and Wales.
The Church holds that the authority they died for, the pope's authority over the whole Church, was given by Christ (Lumen Gentium 22).
It also teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges every burning in this story, the Catholic ones included.
“the king our sovereign lord, his heirs and successors, kings of this realm, shall be taken, accepted, and reputed the only supreme head in earth of the church of England, called Anglicana Ecclesia”
The Act goes on to give the king full power to "visit, repress, redress, reform, order, correct, restrain, and amend all such errors, heresies, abuses" in the Church. Mary repealed it; Elizabeth's Act of 1559 restored the Crown's authority but not this title.
Where people disagree
Why did Henry do it? The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1910 allows that he wanted a son, but calls his worries of conscience fictitious and points to his passion for Anne Boleyn.
The historian Pollard, writing in the 1911 Britannica, held that the succession was the main point. He noted that Henry's efforts were all aimed at a wife, not a mistress, and that no heir could have taken the throne without risking civil war.
Anglicans deny that Henry founded a new church. They say the church in England, there since Roman times and refounded by of Canterbury's mission in 597, was reformed and carried on.
The Catholic side has something to own as well. As Lord Chancellor, More agreed with the heresy laws and enforced them, and six people were burned for heresy in his time in office. The Catholic Encyclopedia counted four.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
Conscience or passion: the Catholic reading
Herbert Thurston, writing in 1910, notes that while Henry said his conscience troubled him about marrying his brother's widow, he was asking Rome for a dispensation to marry Anne, whose sister Mary had been his mistress.
“and the fictitious nature of Henry's conscientious scruples about his marriage is betrayed by the fact that he himself was now applying for a dispensation of precisely the same nature as that which he scrupled about”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Henry VIII' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Henry VIII', by Herbert Thurston - 02
The succession: a secular reading
A. F. Pollard argued that the want of a male heir, and the fear of civil war over the throne, drove the policy more than Anne did.
“All these considerations were magnified by Henry’s passion for Anne Boleyn, though she certainly was not the sole or the main cause of the divorce. That the succession was the main point is proved by the fact that Henry’s efforts were all directed to securing a wife and not a mistress.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Henry VIII. of England', by A. F. Pollard - 03
Harsh, but necessary?
Pollard also made the strongest case for the supremacy itself, while naming its methods plainly.
“The royal supremacy over the church and the means by which it was enforced were harsh and violent expedients; but it was of the highest importance that England should be saved from religious civil war, and it could only be saved by a despotic government.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Henry VIII. of England', by A. F. Pollard - 04
Reformed, not founded: the Anglican reading
Anglicans do not accept that Henry founded a new church. The Britannica's 1911 article on the Church of England opens by stating their position.
“in spite of changes in doctrine and ritual, it remains the same church that was planted in England at the end of the 6th century.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'England, The Church of', opening paragraph - 05
More and the heretics
The Catholic Encyclopedia does not hide that More, as Lord Chancellor from 1529 to 1532, enforced the heresy laws. It counts four people put to death for heresy in his time, and defends him on the ground that he always tried first to bring the accused to recant.
“He agreed with the principle of the anti-heresy laws and had no hesitation in enforcing them.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas More' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas More'
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Parliament of England · 1534-11 · Wikisource, transcribing John W. Parker, The Statutes Relating to the Ecclesiastical and Eleemosynary Institutions of England, vol. 1 (London, 1845)
- Herbert Thurston · 1910 · Robert Appleton Company; online at New Advent
- Albert Frederick Pollard · 1911 · Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th edition, vol. 13; Wikisource transcription
- James Gairdner · 1904 · Cambridge University Press; Wikisource transcription
- Thompson Cooper · 1891 · Smith, Elder & Co., London; Wikisource transcription