From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/how-rome-sees-the-orthodox-churches
← OrthodoxDoes the Catholic Church regard the Orthodox Churches as true Churches, or as schismatics?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minAs true Churches. The Catholic Church teaches that the have real , real priests and a real , and calls them sister Churches. It still calls the split a , a broken relationship rather than a broken faith, and blames no Orthodox Christian alive today for it.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 818 and 8382089
- Vatican II
- Unitatis Redintegratio, 14–16
- Vatican doctrine office
- Dominus Iesus, 17Note on the Expression 'Sister Churches'Communionis Notio, 17
If you're Orthodox, you may have heard two very different words from Catholics. One is warm: sister Churches, an old Eastern name for Churches that are family to each other. The other sounds cold: schismatics, people who broke away.
So which one does the Catholic Church really mean?
To be fair, both words come with a history. For centuries each side treated the other as outside the true Church. A statement Catholics and Orthodox wrote together in 1993 admits it: Catholics said was found only in their Church, and the Orthodox said the same back.1
Some Christians were even a second time when they switched sides.1 Neither side comes out of this clean.
A real Church, says Rome
The Catholic answer may surprise you. The Catholic Church holds that the Orthodox Churches are true Churches.2
Why? Because of two things it believes they never lost. Their bishops stand in an unbroken line going back to the . And so their Communion is real: at an Orthodox altar, Catholics believe, the bread and wine truly become .2,3
A Vatican document from 2000 says it straight out. The Orthodox Churches are true particular Churches: real local Churches, in their own right.2
The change of tone came at the in the 1960s. The bishops picked up that old Eastern phrase, sister Churches, and said the Orthodox are joined to Catholics in closest intimacy.3
They even admitted Rome hadn't always respected the East's right to run its own life by its own laws.3
The goes further still. It says the two are so close that it lacks little to attain the fullness that would permit a common celebration of the Lord's .4
In other words, they're almost at the same altar. Almost.
You can see it in practice
The Catholic Church backs the words with action. If an Orthodox Christian becomes Catholic, the Catholic Church doesn't baptise them again.
It doesn't redo their chrismation either, the anointing with holy oil the East gives straight after baptism. Both are accepted as real.5
And in that 1993 statement, both sides promised to teach their own people that the other Church has bishops in the line of the apostles, and real .1
So is it a schism?
In Catholic terms, yes. But look at what that word actually means.
The Catechism defines schism as refusing to submit to the , or to be in communion with the Church members under him. It's a different thing from heresy, which is denying a truth of the faith.6
And communion here doesn't mean the bread and wine. It means being one Church: one table, one faith, one family life.
That's what's missing. The Orthodox don't accept the pope's first place and authority over the whole Church, so their communion with Rome isn't full.2
That's the dividing line. Not whether Christ is there. The same Vatican document says the Church of Christ is present and operative also in these Churches.2
And nobody alive today is to blame for the break. The Catechism says people raised in a separated Church can't be charged with the split. It calls them brothers in the Lord.4
Think of it like this
Think of a band that played together for years. Then comes a bitter fight over who should lead it, and the band splits in two. Each half keeps touring under its own name.
Years go by. Both halves still play the same old songs, with the same chords, and the crowds still sing the same choruses back. Their musicians learned from the same teachers. Anyone who hears either half knows straight away: that's the real music.
What's gone is the one stage. They don't play together, and they still can't agree who should have the final say.
That's how the Catholic Church sees the Orthodox. The music is real. What's broken is that the two no longer share one stage. And the split hurts both halves, not just one.
How the Orthodox see it
The Orthodox see it the other way round. At a on Crete in 2016, bishops from most Orthodox Churches said the Orthodox Churches together are the one Church of Christ.7 Four Churches stayed away from that council. One of them, the Russian Church, said a council without all the Churches couldn't truly speak for the whole Orthodox world.9
The Orthodox say almost the same thing about themselves that Catholics say about theirs.
Sisters, and a mother
That's why the Vatican is careful with the word sister. In 2000 its office for teaching said the word fits Churches side by side: Rome and Constantinople, say, are sister Churches. The Church of Rome can be called the sister of all the others.8
So Rome isn't Constantinople's mother. What the note calls mother is the one Church of Christ that every local Church belongs to. That's why it won't call the Catholic Church as a whole a sister of the Orthodox. That would sound like two Churches of Christ, and Catholics believe there's only one.8
Where the two still differ is on where that one Church is found whole. Catholics believe it's in the Churches joined to the pope.2 The Orthodox believe it's in theirs.7
And the Vatican says plainly what it thinks is missing. The Orthodox, it says, lack with the Catholic Church, because they don't accept the pope's .2
A 1992 Vatican letter even calls their life as local Churches wounded by it. Many Orthodox find that hard to hear.10
The same letter says the split also injures the Catholic Church. In the Catholic view, the wound runs both ways.10
Medieval Orthodox bishops answered Rome with the same family picture. In their view, as the Vatican's own note records, Rome is only the first among sisters of equal dignity.8
So the honest answer is both, but not equally. In Catholic eyes, the Orthodox are a true Church in a broken relationship, not a broken Church. The break is real. So is everything it didn't take away.
Sources10
- 1Catholic-Orthodox Joint Commission, Balamand Document (1993), 10, 30Admits past exclusive claims on both sides and rebaptism (10); faults belong to both sides; each to teach the other's sacramental life (30).
- 2Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (2000), 17Churches with apostolic succession and a valid Eucharist are true particular Churches.
- 3Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 14–16Eastern Churches as sister Churches with true sacraments and their own discipline.
- 4Catechism of the Catholic Church, 818 and 838Those born into separated Churches aren't blamed; communion with the Orthodox lacks little.
- 5Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), 99No doubt about the validity of baptism and chrismation in the Eastern Churches.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2089The Catholic definition of schism.
- 7Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church, Message (Crete, 2016)The Orthodox Churches as the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church, not a federation.
- 8Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Note on the Expression 'Sister Churches' (2000)How Rome uses the term, and its limit.
- 9Wikipedia, Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church (2016)Four Churches stayed away, and why; the 2007 Moscow-Constantinople quarrel over Estonia at the Catholic-Orthodox talks.
- 10Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Communionis Notio (1992), 17Without communion with Peter's successor the Orthodox Churches' existence as particular Churches is wounded; this also injures the Catholic Church.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.