From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/saints-hear-us
← Protestant or evangelicalCan the saints hear us? Isn't praying to them talking to the dead?
Read it as an illustrated story · 8 minCatholics believe the saints, Christians who've died and are with God, aren't dead but alive. They know our prayers through God, not by their own power. Asking them to pray isn't calling up the dead, which the forbids. It's asking family in to pray for you.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
The worry comes from the Bible. God's law bans anyone who tries to get messages from the dead.1
No verse shows a believer asking someone in heaven to pray. And even if you could ask, how could Mary or hear millions of prayers at once?
This isn't a new question. In the early 400s, a priest named Vigilantius said that after death, nobody's prayers for anyone else can be heard. Even his own agreed with him.2
What the Bible actually forbids
So look closely at what that law bans. It sits in a list with fortune-tellers and people who cast spells.1 The point was making the dead talk, so you could learn secrets or see the future.
The Bible tells one story of exactly that. Saul, Israel's king, was facing a battle he expected to lose, and God had gone silent: no answer in dreams, by the sacred lots or through prophets.13
Saul had driven the mediums out of the land himself. Now he put on a disguise, went by night to a woman at Endor who was a medium, and said: conjure up for me the one I ask you to. He wanted Samuel, the prophet who had died.13
Samuel's answer was terrible. Saul and his sons would die the next day.13 A later book of the Bible says Saul died partly because he had sought counsel from a ghost, rather than from God.14
Look at what Saul did. God had gone quiet, so he went around God, to a medium, to drag a dead man back and make him tell the future. That's what the law forbids, and Catholics agree it's forbidden.
The notes in a Catholic Bible add that the living can't reach the dead at will. If Samuel really appeared, it was God's doing, not the medium's.13
Asking a saint to pray isn't that.
You don't summon anyone, you don't want information, and you don't control anything.
You ask a fellow believer to take your need to God.
The Catholic Church is just as firm about that line. The rejects conjuring up the dead and recourse to mediums, along with horoscopes and fortune-telling.3
Séances and spirit mediums are out. Asking Peter to pray for you is in.
Are they really dead?
Jesus answered this one himself. Some religious leaders told him the dead don't rise. Jesus replied that God is not God of the dead, but of the living, for to him all are alive.5
For Christians, someone who died in isn't gone.
The Bible gives a picture of this. It says we run our race surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses.4 Many Protestants read witnesses as examples of faith to look back on, not people watching. Catholics read it as both.
Think of it like this
Picture a big city marathon. You're at kilometre 40, and you're done. Your legs are burning, the sun is beating down, and every part of you wants to stop and sit on the kerb.
Then you look up. Along the barriers near the finish are runners who crossed the line hours ago. They've got medals round their necks and foil blankets on their shoulders. They could have gone home. Instead they've walked back to cheer, and they're shouting the names printed on the bibs of strangers still running.
They've already finished. They know exactly how much this hurts. And they want every single one of you to make it.
That's how Catholics see the saints. They've finished the race, and they're cheering you home. They're not gone. They're closer to the finish line than you are.
Revelation shows people in heaven holding the prayers of believers before God, like bowls of incense.6 It shows people who died for their faith calling on God to act on earth.7
Revelation is full of symbols, so Catholics don't build the whole belief on it. But heaven in these pictures isn't asleep. It's praying.
One family, through Christ
The Catholic Church teaches that death doesn't break the family of believers. Those on earth, those being made ready for heaven in , and those in heaven are one Church.10
The saints do not cease to intercede with the Father for us, it says. To intercede means to pray on someone's behalf.10
Everything the saints offer for us, they gained on earth through the one mediator between God and men, Christ Jesus.10 Even in heaven, their prayers run through Jesus. They don't compete with him. They pray alongside us, to him.
The Catechism says the saints constantly care for those whom they have left on earth. So we can and should ask them to intercede for us and for the whole world.8
What about my grandmother?
In many families the real question isn't séances but ancestors. Can you ask a grandmother who died loving Jesus to pray for you? Is that different from ancestor rituals?
Catholics pray for their own dead. The Catechism says that prayer can also make their intercession for us effective.10 So a Catholic can ask a believing grandmother to pray for them, to God, the way they'd have asked her while she was alive.
Africa's Catholic bishops took this question seriously. In 1995, after their meeting in Rome, wrote that Africans' love of life leads them to honour their ancestors, believing the dead continue to live and remain in with them.15
He asked whether that might be, in some way, a preparation for the Christian belief that the saints are still part of the family.15
He also asked for care. A custom can be taken into Christian life only if it fits the Christian message and keeps communion with the whole Church, and care must be taken to avoid syncretism, mixing faiths into something new.15
And he left the details open. He passed on the bishops' wish for study groups in each country on marriage, the of ancestors, and the spirit world.15 So there's no single list, for the whole Catholic Church, of which customs stay and which go. Families can ask their own bishop or priest.
But the Catechism rules out turning to the dead, or to anyone who claims to speak for them, for power, protection or secrets. It rejects charms and all practices of magic or sorcery.3
Asking a grandmother who loved Jesus to pray for you is fine. Making offerings so her spirit will bring the family luck crosses the line.
The difference is where your trust goes. Asking for prayer hands your need to God. Trying to win the dead's protection puts your trust in them.
So how do they hear?
To be honest, the Catechism doesn't spell this out. The usual Catholic answer comes from , a priest and teacher who lived about 800 years ago.
The saints don't know everything, he said, and they don't hear with ears. They see God, and in God they see the prayers of those who ask for their help.11
And he didn't hide the hard part. He quoted an earlier bishop who wondered how the dead could keep track of the affairs and actions of the living.11 His answer was that the bishop meant what the dead can know by themselves. What the saints know of us, they see in God.11
So this is a belief worked out from the verses above, not something one verse spells out.
Lutherans put the other side well. Their 1531 defence of the grants that in heaven they pray for the Church in general.16
But it doesn't follow, it says, that we should ask them, since Scripture gives neither a command, nor a promise, nor an example.16
Catholics answer that believers ask each other for prayer, and the saints are still believers, alive in God. The first Christians did it too.
The first Christians did it too
Under St Sebastian's church in Rome there's a room from the 200s. Its walls are covered with more than 600 scratched prayers to Peter and .9
It was a hall where Christians gathered for meals in memory of their dead, and they left their prayers on the walls.9 Asking the saints wasn't invented later.
When Vigilantius denied the saints could pray for us, Jerome, the great Bible scholar of the day, answered him with a simple point. If and prayed for others while they were alive, how much more must they do so when once they have won their crowns.2
The asks the saints to pray too. In its own words: we ask the holy person to pray for us.12
You're not talking to the dead. You're asking the living, who are closer to God than you are, to pray for you.
Sources16
- 1Deuteronomy 18:9-14 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The ban on fortune-telling, spells and consulting the dead.
- 2Jerome, Against Vigilantius (406), 6States Vigilantius's objection and Jerome's reply; the introduction dates it and names the bishop who agreed.
- 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2110-2117Divination, mediums and conjuring up the dead rejected.
- 4Hebrews 12:1-2 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"Surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses."
- 5Luke 20:27-40 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"For to him all are alive."
- 6Revelation 5:8 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Bowls of incense, the prayers of the holy ones.
- 7Revelation 6:9-11 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The martyrs under the altar cry out to God.
- 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2683The saints care for those on earth; we can and should ask their prayers.
- 9Wikipedia, "Catacombs of San Sebastiano"The mid-third-century triclia with over 600 graffiti invoking Peter and Paul.
- 10Catechism of the Catholic Church, 954-962The communion of saints and their intercession through Christ.
- 11Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, Supplement, q. 72, a. 1The saints know our prayers by seeing God, not by knowing everything; Augustine's doubt answered.
- 12Orthodox Church in America, "Canonization of Saints"Orthodox Christians ask the saints for their prayers.
- 131 Samuel 28, with note on verse 12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Saul consults the medium at Endor to call up Samuel; the note says the living cannot reach the dead at will, and any real appearance was God's doing.
- 141 Chronicles 10:13–14, with note (New American Bible)Saul died partly because he had sought counsel from a ghost rather than from the Lord.
- 15John Paul II, Ecclesia in Africa (14 September 1995), 43, 62, 64, 67Veneration of ancestors as a possible preparation for belief in the communion of saints; inculturation must fit the Christian message and avoid syncretism; study commissions on the veneration of ancestors and the spirit world.
- 16Apology of the Augsburg Confession (1531), Article XXI, Of the Invocation of SaintsThe Lutheran view: the saints pray for the Church in general, but Scripture gives no command, promise or example for asking them.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.