Why do Catholics use unleavened bread? Is that a valid Eucharist?
Western Catholics use flat bread by an ancient custom that ties every Mass to the Last Supper, held at Passover time. And yes, it's truly the Eucharist: the Catholic Church teaches that flat and risen wheat bread both become Jesus's body, and most Eastern Catholics use risen bread, like the Orthodox.
Part 1 · Two kinds of bread
Christians share bread and wine to remember Jesus's last supper with his friends. Most churches call it , or the .
Catholics and the believe the bread truly becomes Jesus's body.
Go to Communion in an Orthodox church, and the bread is a real loaf, risen with yeast. Often someone in the parish bakes it.
It's a round prosphoro, stamped with a cross and the letters IC XC NIKA, which mean Jesus Christ conquers.
Go to most Catholic churches, and it's a thin, flat wafer.
Same Jesus, very different bread.
For many Orthodox, this isn't a small detail. For them, the risen loaf stands for the risen .
Flat bread belongs to , the Jewish feast remembering the escape from slavery in Egypt.
One Orthodox parish says flat bread is connected with mourning, while Communion is about the as much as the cross.
Byzantine writers added another reason.
To them, yeast was like the soul that gives bread life, so risen bread shows Christ's full humanity, soul and all.
Part 2 · The bread and the split
And most people never hear this part. The bread was also at the heart of the split between East and West.
East and West, the churches that became the Orthodox and the Catholic Church, had been one Church for about a thousand years.
1054 is the year usually given for the split, though they grew apart over centuries.
In the 1050s, Norman rulers in southern Italy were forcing Western, or Latin, customs on churches there that followed Greek ways.
In Constantinople, Patriarch hit back. He ordered the city's Latin churches to use risen bread, then closed them.
Insults flew both ways.
The split is usually put down to the 's authority, and a line the West added to the Creed.
The Creed is the summary of Christian belief.
But the historian Edward Siecienski, who studies the split, says the bread, more than either of those, was the spark that set it off.
So it's fair to ask: is flat bread a real Eucharist at all?
Part 3 · Both breads are real
The Catholic Church says yes. Flat or risen, it truly becomes Christ's body. The Church's word for that is valid.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, names only what's essential: wheat bread and grape wine.
A wafer looks thin, but it's still wheat bread, just baked without yeast.
And church law keeps it that plain. The bread must be only wheat, and recently made, so it can't spoil.
Nothing else may go in. A Vatican instruction calls adding fruit or sugar or honey a grave abuse.
Leaving out the yeast follows what church law calls the ancient tradition of the Latin Church, which is the Catholic Church's Western branch.
In 1439, Greek and Latin met in Florence, in Italy, to end the split.
They signed a decree of union.
On the bread, they agreed that the body of Christ is truly made in either one.
Each priest, they said, should follow the custom of his own Church, East or West.
To be honest, Florence settled the question for Catholics, not for the Orthodox.
The Greek bishops signed under heavy pressure, and nearly the entire Orthodox world rejected the union.
So how can two such different breads both be real? Here's an analogy that might help. Think of football.
The rules say the ball has to be a real football: round, the right size, the right weight, the right material.
But they don't say what it should look like. So different leagues play with different balls.
One keeps the classic black-and-white panels its fans have known for 50 years. Another brings out a new design every season, in bright colours.
Fans care about their ball. It carries their league's story, and nobody wants it swapped for no reason.
But nobody watching a match in another league shouts those goals don't count because of the ball.
A goal is a goal, as long as it went in with a real football and not a beach ball.
The Catholic Church sees the bread the same way. It has to be real wheat bread. Risen or flat is each Church's custom.
Part 4 · Which bread did Jesus hold?
So which bread did Jesus hold at the Last Supper, his last meal with his friends?
Matthew, Mark and Luke, three of the four , tell it as a Passover meal.
That was a week when Jewish homes kept out all yeast. But John's Gospel seems to put the meal a day earlier.
So scholars still argue about which bread Jesus held.
Western Catholics keep flat bread to tie every to the Last Supper.
The Catechism says Jesus chose the time of Passover to give his body and blood.
Orthodox writers answer that the Gospels call it artos, the everyday Greek word for bread, not azyma, the word for flat Passover bread.
Catholic writers reply that Mark uses artos for a meal he himself calls the Passover.
Many Orthodox add that Communion isn't a re-enactment of that night anyway. And the Eastern custom is just as old.
An old Catholic reference book judged that the probably used whatever bread was at hand.
Customs then grew differently in different places.
Part 5 · Not only a Western custom
Flat bread isn't only Western. The Armenian Church, an ancient Eastern Church, uses it too.
And inside the Catholic Church, it goes both ways. The Maronite Catholics of Lebanon use flat bread.
The , which many Orthodox call Uniates, belong to the Catholic Church but worship like the Orthodox.
Most of them use risen bread.
In the 1960s, the , a Catholic , spoke about the Eastern ways of worship.
It said they carry the tradition that has been handed down from the Apostles through the Fathers, meaning the great teachers of the early Church.
The council told Eastern Catholics to keep their own ways, and even to return to their ancestral traditions.
So in Catholic eyes, the risen bread isn't a favour from the pope in Rome. It's the East's own inheritance, and the whole Church's.
So is flat bread a real Eucharist? Yes, and so is risen bread.
A difference that once helped split the Church is now where the Catholic Church says: your bread and ours both become Jesus's body.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 13
- Aleteia, Why do Eastern Christians use leavened bread for the Eucharist? (22 March 2018) · In the Eastern tradition leavened bread stands for the resurrection; Eastern Catholics use it too.
- Saint John the Evangelist Orthodox Church (Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania), Why Do Orthodox Churches Use Leavened Bread For Communion? (25 May 2021) · An Orthodox parish's explanation: leaven and the Kingdom, unleavened bread and mourning, why the exact bread of the Last Supper isn't decisive.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Great Schism (church history series) · An Orthodox account of 1054: Latin pressure in southern Italy, Michael Cerularius, Leo of Ohrid on the azymes.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Azymites · An old, sharply Catholic account: Cerularius closes the Latin churches, Leo of Ohrid's letter, the Greeks' acceptance at Florence; Armenians and Maronites use unleavened bread.
- Catholic Answers, Arguing with the Orthodox about Bread · A Catholic case for unleavened bread; quotes the historian Edward Siecienski on the bread as the immediate cause of the schism.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1412 · The essential signs of the Eucharist are wheat bread and grape wine.
- Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 924 and 926 · The bread must be only wheat and recently made; the Latin Church uses unleavened bread by ancient tradition.
- Congregation for Divine Worship, Redemptionis Sacramentum (2004), 48 · Hosts purely of wheat; adding fruit, sugar or honey is a grave abuse.
- Council of Florence, Laetentur Caeli (1439) · The decree of union with the Greeks: Christ's body is truly made in leavened or unleavened bread.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Great Schism in the Papacy and the Conciliar Movement · Mark of Ephesus refused to sign Florence; the union was rejected by nearly the whole Orthodox world.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1339–1340 · Jesus chose Passover to give the Eucharist; the Eucharist fulfils the Passover.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Bread, Liturgical Use of · The Gospels differ on the day; the apostles probably used whatever bread was at hand; both kinds are valid.
- Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (21 November 1964), 1, 6 · The Eastern rites carry the apostolic tradition; Eastern Catholics should keep and recover their own ways.