Full text
Catholic · About 8 min ·  · The Church today

Does the Catholic Church teach that Protestants and Orthodox Christians are not really Christians?

The short answer

No. The Catholic Church teaches that everyone baptised into Christ is truly a Christian, a brother or sister in the Lord. That includes baptised evangelicals and Pentecostals as much as the Orthodox. It also says full unity is still missing, and that the Orthodox Churches are the closest to it. It does say most Protestant churches aren't Churches in its strict sense, because they lack bishops in the apostles' line. That's about how a church is built, not whose faith is real.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

Maybe your cousin left for an evangelical church, or a classmate goes to a Pentecostal one. Both are kinds of church.

And someone told you Catholics say they aren't real Christians.

Catholics, the and Protestants are the three main branches of Christianity. Does the Catholic Church count the other two out?

Many people have also heard an old Catholic saying: no salvation outside the Church.

Salvation means being brought home to God. It sounds like everyone else is shut out.

And there's a real claim underneath.

The said the one Church of subsists in the Catholic Church. We'll come back to what that means.

So are other Christians second-class, or not Christians at all?

Part 2 · Baptism makes you family

The Catholic answer to both is no.

What counts is faith in Christ and .

The says the baptised have a right to be called Christians.

Catholics accept them as brothers in the Lord. Which church did the baptising doesn't matter, as long as it was a true baptism.

The Council said those who believe in Christ and have been truly baptized are already joined to the Catholic Church, even if not yet fully.

What about the old splits between the churches? The Catechism says people on both sides were to blame.

Nobody born into another church is guilty of them.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a family that fell out years ago over a will.

Some of the siblings stopped coming to the big family dinner at Christmas.

Their kids grew up across town. They went to different schools, and never really knew why the families stopped talking.

Birthdays came and went without a phone call. They just knew there were empty chairs at the table.

But those kids are still family. They still carry grandma's surname, and some of them have her laugh.

Nobody blames them for a fight that happened before they were born. When they turn up at a wedding or a funeral, people hug them.

Family that's been split is still family. Nobody has to prove they belong.

What's missing is the shared table.

The Church honours what other Christians have: the written Word of God; the life of grace, God's free help; faith, hope, and charity, meaning love.

It even says the uses their churches as means of : real ways God saves people.

So what about that old saying, no salvation outside the Church?

The Catechism says it's aimed at people who know that God set up the Catholic Church as necessary.

Knowing that, they still refuse to join it, or to stay in it.

It's not aimed at people who, through no fault of their own, don't know Christ and his Church.

So Christians raised in another church aren't the people it's talking about.

Part 3 · Where the real differences are

Start with the Orthodox, whose heartland is Greece, Eastern Europe and the Middle East. The Orthodox and Catholic Churches split apart around 1054.

They have in an unbroken line from the .

And they have the same .

So the Catholic Church calls their Churches true particular Churches: real Churches, though not in full union with the .

The Catechism says very little is missing before the two could share .

The Orthodox see it from their side. They believe they're the ones who kept the ancient faith unchanged.

Still, in 1993 theologians from both sides agreed their Churches recognize each other as Sister Churches, like sisters in one family.

Then there are the Protestant churches, which began with the Reformation, the break in the 1500s.

The Catholic Church's warmth towards them is real, but so is the difference.

With most of them, evangelical and Pentecostal churches included, the Catholic Church says something that can sting.

First, remember the Council's words, that the one Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church?

It means Catholics believe everything Christ gave his Church is still all there in the Catholic Church.

And much that is holy and true is found outside it too.

In 2000 the Vatican put it this way: Christ's Church continues to exist fully only in the Catholic Church.

Fully is the key word. It doesn't say Christ's Church is found only there, but that it's found in full only there.

The same document looked at Christian groups without bishops in that unbroken line from the apostles.

Without such bishops, Catholics believe, there's no valid . So it said they are not Churches in the proper sense.

In Catholic language, a Church in the strict sense is built on bishops in that line.

In the Catholic Church's view, Protestant churches don't have them, so Catholic documents call them ecclesial communities, which simply means Christian communities.

Here's what it doesn't mean. It doesn't mean they aren't Christians, that their faith isn't real, or that God isn't at work among them.

The same document says their members are joined to Christ by baptism, and already truly, if not fully, united with the Catholic Church.

Many evangelicals would say the Catholic Church is using the wrong yardstick. For them, a church isn't defined by bishops at all.

A 1974 statement of evangelical belief, the Lausanne Covenant, puts it simply:

The church is the community of God's people rather than an institution.
Lausanne Covenant (1974), 6

Protestants and Anglicans took the 2000 wording as aimed at them, and said so. The Anglican churches grew from the Church of England.

Even a Catholic theologian wished the Vatican had also said what he saw clearly: God's has reached people through their preaching for centuries.

It's a claim about how a church is built, not whose faith is real.

And if a friend tells you Catholics aren't real Christians, the Catholic answer is the same both ways: baptism into Christ makes you family.

Part 4 · Two harder cases

Now say your cousin was baptised Catholic as a baby. Later he joined an evangelical church and was baptised again.

Is he still Catholic?

In the Catholic Church's eyes, his first baptism still stands. The Catechism says Baptism cannot be repeated, and no can wipe out its mark.

The mark says he belongs to Christ. And the Church's own law still applies to him, as someone baptised Catholic.

One practical result: if he marries one day, the Catholic Church will still ask him to marry the Catholic way for it to count.

If he's marrying someone who isn't Catholic and there are serious difficulties, he can ask the bishop's permission to marry another way.

So he's a Catholic who has stepped away. How serious that was depends on what he understood and freely chose.

Only God sees that fully. But is he family? Yes. He's baptised into Christ, and he believes in Christ.

And if he ever wants to come back, the door is open. He'd start by talking to a priest.

Often that includes confession. Catholics believe Christ gave it for all sinful members of his Church.

One more hard case: groups that use Christ's name but don't believe Jesus is God.

One example, from the Philippines: the Iglesia ni Cristo teaches that Jesus is God's sinless Son, but Man and not God.

So it rejects the : the belief that the one God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

So does a baptism like theirs count? Here's the Catholic Church's test.

A baptism counts when it's given with water, in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

And the person baptising must intend to do what the Church does.

The meaning behind the words matters too. In 2001 the Vatican ruled that baptisms by the Latter-day Saints, often called Mormons, don't count.

They say the right words, but for them the names mean three gods who form one divinity, not one God.

The words are the same, but the faith is different.

Not every wrong idea of God cancels a baptism, though. The Church long accepted baptisms by the Arians, who denied Jesus was fully God.

And the Iglesia ni Cristo? The Philippine bishops list its baptism among those that aren't valid.

So in Catholic eyes, the baptism that makes someone family, in the sense of this answer, is missing there.

Either way, a ruling like this is about a rite, a church's ceremony, not about anyone's heart.

The Vatican stressed that its Mormon ruling wasn't a judgement on the people in that church. And Catholics hope for anyone who sincerely seeks God.

Last of all, Catholics admit their share of the wounds.

In 1995 wrote that the pope's role is a difficulty for most other Christians, because of painful memories. Then he wrote:

To the extent that we are responsible for these, I join my Predecessor Paul VI in asking forgiveness.
Pope John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (1995), 88

So Catholics hold two things at once. Other baptised believers are truly Christians, and family. And full unity, one table at Communion, is still missing.

It's worth praying and working for. The disagreement is about the shape of the Church, not about whether you belong to Christ.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

That’s the last question in this set.
Sources 21
  1. Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964), 8 and 15 · The Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church; elements of truth outside it.
  2. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (6 August 2000), 16–17 · Orthodox Churches as true particular Churches; other communities not Churches in the proper sense.
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 817–819, 838 · The baptised have a right to be called Christians; blame on both sides; the Spirit uses other communities as means of salvation; closeness to the Orthodox.
  4. Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (21 November 1964), 3 · The baptised are in real, if imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 846–848 · What "outside the Church there is no salvation" means, and whom it does not mean.
  6. Ecumenical Patriarchate, Reply to the Papal Encyclical of Leo XIII on Reunion (1895) · The Orthodox view: union by the West's return to the ancient faith.
  7. Joint International Commission, Balamand Statement (1993), 14 · Catholic and Orthodox Churches recognise each other as Sister Churches.
  8. Francis A. Sullivan SJ, 'The Impact of Dominus Iesus on Ecumenism', America (28 October 2000) · A Catholic theologian on how Anglicans and Protestants received the document, why the Council spoke of "ecclesial communities", and the grace communicated through their ministry.
  9. Pope John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint (25 May 1995), 88 · The papacy as a difficulty for other Christians; a request for forgiveness.
  10. Lausanne Covenant (1974), 6: The Church and Evangelism · Evangelicals: the church is the community of God’s people rather than an institution.
  11. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1272 · Baptism marks a person as Christ’s for ever and cannot be repeated.
  12. Pew Research Center, Orthodox Christians support key church policies (8 November 2017) · Orthodoxy's heartland in Central and Eastern Europe; Orthodox and Catholics in schism since 1054.
  13. Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 11 · Church laws bind those baptised in the Catholic Church or received into it.
  14. Pope Benedict XVI, Omnium in mentem (26 October 2009) · Removes the 'formal act' of leaving the Church from the marriage canons, so Catholics who leave are still bound by the Catholic form of marriage.
  15. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1446 · Confession is for all sinful members of the Church, a new chance to convert.
  16. Pasugo (Iglesia ni Cristo), Biblical proofs that Christ is not God · INC's own statement that Christ is man and not God.
  17. Wikipedia, Iglesia ni Cristo (read October 2026) · INC teaching: registered 1914 as the restored church, Jesus the Son of God but not God, rejects the Trinity, salvation through INC membership, the Catholic Church as the church that fell away.
  18. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Response to a dubium on the validity of baptism conferred by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (5 June 2001) · Latter-day Saints baptism not valid.
  19. Luis Ladaria SJ, The question of the validity of baptism conferred in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (2001, on vatican.va) · Why: the same words, but a different faith in Father, Son and Spirit, unlike the Arians; not a judgement on members.
  20. Diocese of St. Petersburg (Florida), Office of Worship and Marriage Tribunal, Valid-Invalid Baptisms: A Roman Catholic Guide (2014) · A diocesan guide drawn from two standard canon law handbooks; lists Iglesia ni Cristo and Jehovah's Witnesses among baptisms considered invalid.
  21. Catholic Bishops' Conference of the Philippines, Episcopal Commission on Doctrine of the Faith, Valid Baptisms Recognized by the Catholic Church in the Philippines (2020) · Lists Iglesia ni Cristo among invalid baptisms.