Anselm
Archbishop of Canterbury, Doctor of the Church · England · feast 21 April

Anselm was an Italian from Aosta who became a monk and teacher at Bec in Normandy, where he wrote that he believed in order to understand. Dragged against his will into the archbishopric of Canterbury in 1093, he spent the rest of his life refusing to let English kings rule the Church, and twice went into exile for it. He died at dawn in 1109, soon after a monk had read him Christ’s words at the Last Supper from that day’s Gospel of the Passion.1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9
Known for
- The ProslogionWriting
First titled Faith Seeking Understanding. Its argument, in plain words: even someone who denies God can think of “that than which nothing greater can be thought”. But what really exists is greater than what is only imagined, so the greatest thing we can think of must really exist. It is called the ontological argument.10,11,12,13,14,15
- Cur Deus HomoWriting
Why God became man. His answer: our sin left a debt of honour to God too great for any human being to pay. Only God could pay it, yet only a human being ought to, so God became man and paid it by his death. It is called the satisfaction view of the cross.16,17,18,19,20
- Faith and reason togetherTeaching
He did not seek to understand in order to believe; he believed, and then used reason to grasp what his heart believed and loved. Benedict XVI calls him the founder of scholastic theology, the careful reasoning about the faith taught in the medieval schools.3,21,22
- Standing up to the kings of EnglandLeadership
As Archbishop of Canterbury he refused to let the king hand out Church offices, and went into exile twice. Henry I gave up the claim at a council in London in 1107. A council Anselm asked for in 1102 condemned selling people “like brute animals”.6,23,24,25,26,27
The court on the mountain
Anselm was born in Aosta in 1033 or early 1034, under the Alps. His father Gundulf was a Lombard, coarse and wasteful; his mother Ermenberga was devout, and spoke to him of God, who dwelt on high. Living among mountains, the boy thought heaven must be on their summits.
One night he dreamed he climbed to the court of God the great King, scolded the King’s idle reapers on the way, and sat at the feet of the King, who asked him kindly who he was and had white bread brought for him to eat.1,28,29,30,31,32
Snow on Mont Cenis
At fifteen he asked to become a monk. His father would not allow it, even when Anselm, who had prayed to fall ill so that the monks would take him, lay sick and begged for the habit. After his mother died he drifted, like a ship that has lost its anchor.
His father’s harshness finally drove him out. With one companion he crossed Mont Cenis on foot, so hungry that he ate snow, until the servant found some bread left in the baggage.33,34,35,36
Lanfranc’s pupil
After three years in Burgundy and France he came to the abbey of Bec in Normandy, drawn by the fame of its prior Lanfranc, and became his favourite pupil. He hesitated to become a monk there, where Lanfranc would overshadow him, then decided that it would do him good to be surpassed by others.
He took the habit in 1060, at twenty-seven. In 1063, when Lanfranc left, he was made prior and master of the school; some monks who thought they had a better claim resented the young stranger, and he won them over by gentleness.2,37,38,39,40,41,42
The tree tied up
An abbot once complained to him that the boys in his monastery grew only worse, though “we do not cease beating them day and night”. If you planted a tree in your garden and tied it up on every side, Anselm answered, it would grow crooked and good for nothing. “Are they not human beings?
Are they not of the same nature as you are?” A craftsman did not shape a fair image out of gold by blows alone; along with the stripes, boys needed fatherly kindness and gentleness to lift them up.43,44,45,46
Faith seeking understanding
At Bec he wrote the Monologion and the Proslogion. Eadmer says he could think of nothing else for days until the argument came clear, and then the wax tablets he wrote it on went missing.
He wrote it out again on fresh tablets, and these were found broken to pieces; he pieced them together and had them copied onto parchment. In the Proslogion he called God “that than which nothing greater can be thought”, and argued that such a being must exist in reality, not only in the mind.
A monk named Gaunilo wrote an answer on behalf of the fool who says there is no God, and Anselm replied. In the same book he prayed: “I believe in order to understand.”3,11,13,14,47,48,49
Abbot of Bec
When Herluin, the founder of Bec, died, the monks elected Anselm abbot. He threw himself on the ground in tears and begged them not to lay this burden on him; they threw themselves down and begged him to accept.
He was loved there: “Many of you surrounded me with such a tender and sweet affection,” he wrote to them later, “that each one might have had the impression that I never loved anyone else to the same extent.” At Canterbury, when Lanfranc doubted that the Saxon archbishop Ælfheah, killed by the Danes for refusing a ransom that would ruin his people, was a true martyr, Anselm answered that whoever dies for truth and justice dies for Christ.50,51,52,53,54
The staff in his fist
William Rufus kept Canterbury vacant for four years. In 1093, lying ill and afraid, he named Anselm archbishop. Anselm refused.
The bishops dragged him to the sick king’s bed and pressed the pastoral staff against his clenched fist, and carried him to church singing the Te Deum, the Church’s ancient hymn of thanksgiving, while he cried, “It is nought that ye are doing.” It was hard to tell, he wrote, whether madmen were dragging a sane man or sane men a madman.
They had yoked to one plough, he told them, an untameable bull and an old and feeble sheep.4,5,55,56,57,58,59,60,61
The hunted hare
Riding once from Windsor to Hayes, as archbishop, he saw his young men’s dogs chase a hare, which ran under his horse’s feet.
When the riders laughed at the catch, Anselm burst into tears.
“You laugh,” he said, “but for the poor unhappy creature there is nothing to laugh at”: so the soul, he said, flies hunted at death, looking for a hand to save it. He forbade the dogs to touch it, and the hare ran off free into the fields and woods.62,63,64
Rest at Schiavi
In 1097, two years after he had stood up for Pope Urban II’s authority before the king’s council at Rockingham, a new quarrel broke out, and he asked leave to go to Rome; refused at first, he was then told to sail within ten days. He crossed Mont Cenis again dressed as a simple monk, while monks along the way asked him for news of Anselm.
In the hill village of Schiavi, where the air was fresh and the plains were fainting with heat, he said, “Here shall be my rest for ever,” and finished Cur Deus Homo, on why God became man.17,24,65,66,67,68
The council at Bari
At the Council of Bari in 1098 the Pope had him make the Latin case to the Greek bishops of southern Italy on the Holy Spirit: the Latins said the Spirit comes from the Father and the Son (the filioque), the Greeks from the Father, as the original creed says. There he also saved his own king from excommunication, the Church penalty that cuts a person off from the sacraments.69,70
Faithful to God
Henry I recalled him, and at once demanded that Anselm receive investiture from him afresh: the ceremony in which the king handed a new bishop his staff and ring, as if the office were the king’s to give. Anselm refused; he cleared the way for Henry to marry Edith, daughter of St Margaret of Scotland, and his council at Westminster in 1102 condemned the trade “by which men are sold like brute animals”.
In 1103 he was exiled again, and could come home only when Henry gave up investing bishops; the settlement was sealed in London in 1107. “I prefer to disagree with those who agree among themselves,” he wrote, “than disagree with God.”6,23,25,26,27,71,72
The origin of the soul
In his last years he grew too weak to ride and was carried in a litter; food became loathsome to him, but he had himself carried every day in a chair to Mass. On Palm Sunday one of his monks told him he was going to his Lord’s Easter court.
If God willed it, he said, he would gladly go; but if he could stay “at least till I have solved a question which I am turning in my mind, about the origin of the soul”, he would be grateful, for he did not know whether anyone would finish it after him.73,74,75,76
At my table
On the Tuesday evening he could no longer speak clearly, but raised his hand and made the sign of the cross over them all. Before dawn the monk beside him read the Passion appointed for that day.
At the words “Ye are they which have continued with me in my temptations ... that ye may eat and drink at my table” his breathing slowed. They laid him on sackcloth and ashes, and he died as morning broke on 21 April 1109.
Benedict XVI saw in it the fulfilment of the boy’s dream of the King’s bread.7,8,9,77,78
In their own words
“UP now, slight man! flee, for a little while, thy occupations; hide thyself, for a time, from thy disturbing thoughts. Cast aside, now, thy burdensome cares, and put away thy toilsome business. Yield room for some little time to God; and rest for a little time in him. Enter the inner chamber of thy mind; shut out all thoughts save that of God, and such as can aid thee in seeking him; close thy door and seek him.”79
“I do not endeavour, O Lord, to penetrate your sublimity, for in no wise do I compare my understanding with that; but I long to understand in some degree your truth, which my heart believes and loves. For I do not seek to understand that I may believe, but I believe in order to understand.”3
“Many of you surrounded me with such a tender and sweet affection that each one might have had the impression that I never loved anyone else to the same extent”52
Stories told about them
Loved and retold, but not all of them records. Each says when it was first written down.
In the hill village of Schiavi, where he rested during his first exile, a spring of fresh, health-giving water was said to have gushed from the rock when Anselm prayed, and for centuries it bore the name of the Archbishop of Canterbury.80,81
A local tradition recorded by R. W. Church (1870), who remarks that the presence of such a man raised the expectation of miracles.
When his body was embalmed, the balsam seemed never to run out; and the stone coffin, which looked too small for him, grew to fit.82
Part of the story of his death as it was handed down; R. W. Church (1870) calls it that story’s “fringe of wonder and legend”.
What the Church says
Feast: 21 April
His name passed into the roll of saints, though how is not clear: Thomas Becket asked for his canonisation without effect, and it is ascribed to a papal bull, a formal letter of the pope, of 1494, said to be of Alexander VI. Dante had already placed him among the saints in Paradise.
Clement XI declared him a Doctor of the Church in 1720, and his feast is kept on 21 April.83,84,85,86
Benedict XVI called him “the founder of scholastic theology”, the “Magnificent Doctor”, a saint “truly to be considered European”, born in Italy, a monk in Normandy and archbishop in England, in whom “faith and reason ... are found wonderfully united”. He recalled Anselm’s love for the Mother of God: “Mary, it is you whom my heart yearns to love.”
The English historian Freeman remembered him as “the man who saved the hunted hare and stood up for the holiness of Ælfheah”.21,22,87,88,89
The evidence89 quotations from 10 sources · ✓ checked line by line
Each quotation was compared, word for word, with a saved copy of the page it comes from.
- 1Born in Aosta in 1033 or early 1034; a coarse, spendthrift father and a devout mother.
“St Anselm was born in 1033 (or at the beginning of 1034) in Aosta, the first child of a noble family. His father was a coarse man dedicated to the pleasures of life who squandered his possessions. On the other hand, Anselm's mother was a profoundly religious woman of high moral standing”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 2He became a monk of Bec in 1060.
“This prelate decided in favour of the monastic life, and Anselm became a monk in the Abbey of Bec. This was in 1060.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 3'I believe in order to understand.'
“I do not endeavour, O Lord, to penetrate your sublimity, for in no wise do I compare my understanding with that; but I long to understand in some degree your truth, which my heart believes and loves. For I do not seek to understand that I may believe, but I believe in order to understand.”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009, quoting Proslogion 1 · the Holy See - 4Rufus kept Canterbury vacant four years; in 1093, ill, he named Anselm; Anselm was dragged to the bedside and the staff thrust into his closed hand.
“He was dragged by force to the King's bedside, and a pastoral staff was thrust into his closed hand; he was borne thence to the altar where the "Te Deum" was sung.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 5The king fell ill early in 1093 and named Anselm.
“The King fell ill early in the new year (1093), and on his sick-bed he was moved to repentance.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 6In 1103 his fidelity cost him exile; only in 1106, when Henry renounced investiture, could he return.
“In 1103, this fidelity even cost him the bitterness of exile from his See of Canterbury. Moreover, it was only in 1106, when King Henry I renounced his right to the conferral of ecclesiastical offices, as well as to the collection of taxes and the confiscation of Church properties, that Anselm could return to England”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 7The Passion was read; at 'Ye are they which have continued with me' his breathing slowed; laid on sackcloth and ashes he died.
“The congregation of the brethren were already chanting matins in the great church, when one of those who watched about our Father took the book of the Gospels and read before him the history of the Passion, which was to be read that day at the mass. But when he came to our Lord's words, 'Ye are they which have con- tinued with me in my temptations, and I appoint unto you a kingdom, as my Father hath appointed unto me, that ye may eat and drink at my table,' he began to draw his breath more slowly.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 8He died at daybreak on the Wednesday before Maundy Thursday, 21 April 1109.
“He passed away, as morning was breaking, on the Wednesday before the day of our Lord's Supper, the 21st of April, in the year of our Lord's Incarnation ... 1109”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 9Laid on sackcloth and ashes, he died among his children.
“so he was removed from his bed, and laid upon sackcloth and ashes. And thus, the whole family of his children being collected round him, he gave up his last breath into the hands of his Creator, and slept in peace.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 10He first titled the work Faith Seeking Understanding.
“To this work he had given this title : Faith Seeking Understanding. He finally named it Proslogium”
Anselm, translated by Sidney Norton Deane (1903), Proslogium · Open Court, via archive.org · Preface, heading · their own words or the earliest accounts - 11God is 'that than which nothing greater can be thought'; Gaunilo objected and Anselm replied.
“Starting from the notion that God is "that than which nothing greater can be thought", he argues that what exists in reality is greater than that which is only in the mind”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 12His chief achievement in philosophy: the ontological argument in the Proslogium.
“Anselm's chief achievement in philosophy was the ontological argument for the existence of God put forth in his "Proslogium".”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · Catholic reference - 13Gaunilo's criticism and Anselm's reply.
“The validity of the argument was disputed at the outset by a monk named Gaunilo, who wrote a criticism on it to which Anselm replied.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 14Gaunilo wrote In behalf of the fool.
“an appendix In behalf of the fool by Gaunilon”
Anselm, translated by Sidney Norton Deane (1903), Proslogium · Open Court, via archive.org · Title · their own words or the earliest accounts - 15The Proslogion's argument: the fool understands the words; what exists in reality is greater than what is only in the understanding; so that than which nothing greater can be conceived exists in both.
“For, when he hears of this, he understands it. ... Therefore, if that, than which nothing greater can be conceived, exists in the understanding alone, the very being, than which nothing greater can be con ceived, is one, than which a greater can be conceived. But obviously this is impossible. Hence, there is no doubt that there exists a being, than which nothing greater can be conceived, and it exists both in the understanding and in reality.”
Anselm, translated by Sidney Norton Deane (1903), Proslogium · Open Court, via archive.org · Proslogium, chapter II · their own words or the earliest accounts - 16The question of the book: why God became man and by his death restored life to the world, when he might have done it otherwise.
“for what cause or necessity, in sooth, God became man, and by his own death, as we believe and affirm, restored life to the world”
Anselm, translated by James Gardiner Vose (1854-55), Cur Deus Homo · Open Court, via archive.org · Book I, ch. 1 · their own words or the earliest accounts - 17He finished at Schiavi what he began in England: Cur Deus Homo.
“What he began amid the fears and distresses of uncongenial England, he finished in the light and peaceful summer days of his mountain retreat at Schiavi.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XII · scholarship - 18Cur Deus Homo throws a flood of light on the theology of the Atonement.
“his "Cur Deus Homo" throws a flood of light on the theology of the Atonement”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · Catholic reference - 19The question of the book: why God became man when he could have saved the world another way.
“restored life to the world ; when ... he might have done this, by means of some other be ing, angelic or human, or merely by his will”
Anselm, translated by James Gardiner Vose (1854-55), Cur Deus Homo · Open Court, via archive.org · Cur Deus Homo, I, 1 · their own words or the earliest accounts - 20Cur Deus Homo's answer: only God can make the satisfaction, only man ought to, so the God-man must make it.
“Therefore none but God can make this satisfaction. Boso. So it appears. Anselm. But none but a man ought to do this, other wise man does not make the satisfaction. ... which none but God can make and none but man ought to make, it is necessary for the God- man to make it.”
Anselm, translated by James Gardiner Vose (1854-55), Cur Deus Homo · Open Court, via archive.org · Cur Deus Homo, II, vi · their own words or the earliest accounts - 21Benedict XVI: 'Magnificent Doctor', founder of scholastic theology.
“the founder of scholastic theology, to whom Christian tradition has given the title: "Magnificent Doctor"”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 22Faith and reason are wonderfully united in Anselm.
“Indeed, faith and reason fides et ratio are found wonderfully united in Anselm.”
Benedict XVI, 15 April 2009, Letter to Cardinal Giacomo Biffi for the ninth centenary of the death of St Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Letter to Cardinal Biffi, 15 April 2009 · the Holy See - 23Under Henry I he refused a fresh investiture from the king.
“Henry required the Archbishop himself to receive a fresh investiture. Anselm alleged the decrees of the recent Roman council and declared that he had no choice in the matter.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 24Fresh trouble in 1097; he asked leave to go to Rome, was refused, then told to sail within ten days.
“Fresh trouble arose in 1097. ... Anselm declined and asked leave to go to Rome . This was refused, but after a meeting at Winchester Anselm was told to be ready to sail in ten days.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 25The London council of 1107 settled the matter: the king gave up investiture, prelates did homage for their lands.
“At length, in a council held in London in 1107, the question found a solution. The King relinquished the claim to invest bishops and abbots , while the Church allowed the prelates to do homage for their temporal possessions.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 26The Council of Westminster in 1102 condemned the trade by which men were sold like brute animals.
“Among the canons is one against the "wicked trade used hitherto in England, by which men are sold like brute animals."”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIII · scholarship - 27The council was held about Michaelmas 1102 at Westminster.
“chaelmas 1102, at Westminster, of the bishops and abbots of the whole realm.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIII · scholarship - 28His father Gundulf was a Lombard; his mother Ermenberga Burgundian; he learned piety from her.
“His father, Gundulf, was a Lombard who had become a citizen of Aosta , and his mother, Ermenberga, came of an old Burgundian family .”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 29His mother spoke of God on high; living in the mountains he thought heaven was on their summits.
“The child had heard his mother speak of God , Who dwelt on high ruling all things. Living in the mountains, he thought that Heaven must be on their lofty summits.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 30A boy who grew up in the mountains; to meet God one must climb to the top.
“To Anselm "a boy who grew up in the mountains" as his biographer Eadmer describes him (Eadmer, Vita Sancti Anselmi, I, 2) it seemed impossible to imagine anything greater than God”
Benedict XVI, 15 April 2009, Letter to Cardinal Giacomo Biffi for the ninth centenary of the death of St Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Letter to Cardinal Biffi, 15 April 2009 · the Holy See - 31The dream: the mountain, the lazy reapers, the King and his cupbearer, the white bread.
“it chanced that one night he saw in a vision that he must go up to the summit of the mountain and hasten to the court of God , the great King. But before he began to ascend the mountain, he saw in the plain through which he had passed to its foot, women , who were the King's handmaidens, reaping the corn; but they were doing this very negligently and slothfully .”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Life of St Anselm, I, i (as translated in the Catholic Encyclopedia, 1907) · New Advent · Life of St Anselm, I, i · their own words or the earliest accounts - 32The King asked who he was; white bread was brought and he feasted.
“Then with cheery kindliness he was asked who and whence he was and what he was seeking. To these questions he made answer as well as he knew . Then at the Master's command some moist white bread was brought him by the cupbearer and he feasted thereon in his presence”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Life of St Anselm, I, i (as translated in the Catholic Encyclopedia, 1907) · New Advent · Life of St Anselm, I, i · their own words or the earliest accounts - 33At fifteen he asked to be a monk; his father refused, even when he was ill; after his mother's death he drifted.
“At the age of 15, he asked to be admitted to the Benedictine Order but his father brought the full force of his authority to bear against him and did not even give way when his son, seriously ill and feeling close to death, begged for the religious habit as a supreme comfort. After his recovery and the premature death of his mother, Anselm went through a period of moral dissipation.”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 34He prayed to fall ill so the monks would take him.
“The boy then made a strange prayer . He asked for an illness, thinking this would move the monks to yield to his wishes.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 35His mother's death left him like a ship without anchor.
“His love for his mother in some measure restrained him. But on her death it seemed that his anchor was lost, and he was at the mercy of the waves.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 36His father's harshness drove him out; he crossed Mont Cenis on foot, ate snow, and was saved by bread in the baggage.
“At this time his father treated him with great harshness; so much so that he resolved to leave his home. Taking a single companion, he set out on foot to cross Mont Cenis. At one time he was fainting with hunger and was fain to refresh his strength with snow, when the servant found that some bread was still left in the baggage”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 37Three years in Burgundy and France, then Bec and Lanfranc.
“After passing nearly three years in Burgundy and France , he came into Normandy and tarried for a while at Avranches before finding his home at the Abbey of Bec, then made illustrious by Lanfranc's learning.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 38Under Lanfranc he became the favourite pupil and confidant.
“it was not long before he became not only the favourite pupil but also the teacher's confidante”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 39He hesitated to become a monk at Bec, where Lanfranc would overshadow him, then saw it would do him good.
“But at first he felt some reluctance to enter the Abbey of Bec, where he would be overshadowed by Lanfranc . After a time, however, he saw that it would profit him to remain where he would be surpassed by others.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 40He became a monk and priest at twenty-seven.
“at the age of 27 he entered the monastic order and was ordained a priest”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 41At twenty-seven he entered the monastery; in 1063 he became prior and master of the school, preferring persuasion to force.
“When Lanfranc became Abbot of Caen in 1063, Anselm, after barely three years of monastic life, was named Prior of the Monastery of Bec and teacher of the cloister school”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 42Some monks resented the young stranger; he won them by gentleness.
“At first his promotion to the office vacated by Lanfranc gave offence to some of the other monks who considered they had a better claim than the young stranger. But Anselm overcame their opposition by gentleness”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 43An abbot complained that his boys got worse though beaten day and night.
“" What are we to do with them?" he asked in despair: "do what ... we will they are perverse and incorrigible ; we do not cease beating them day and night, and they only get worse."”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 44Anselm's answer: a tree tied up on all sides grows crooked.
“" Constrain them ! Tell me, my lord abbot, if you planted a tree in your garden, and tied it up on all sides so that it could not stretch forth its branches, what sort of tree would it turn out when, after some years, you gave it room to spread 1 Would it not be good for nothing, full of tangled and crooked boughs”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 45'Are they not human beings?'
“But, for the love of God, I wish you would tell me why you are so harsh with them ? Are they not human beings 1 Are they not of the same nature as you are ? Would you like, if you were what they are, to be treated as you treat them”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 46A craftsman does not shape gold with blows alone; with the stripes boys need fatherly kindness.
“did you ever see a craftsman fashion a fair image out of a plate of gold or silver by blows alone ? ... So, if you would mould your boys to good, you must, along with the stripes which are to bow them down, lift them up and assist them by fatherly kindness and gentleness.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 47At Bec he wrote the Monologium and Proslogium.
“It was likewise during this period that he composed some of his philosophical and theological works, notably, the "Monologium" and the "Proslogium".”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 48Eadmer's story: days of thought; the first tablets went missing; the argument was rewritten on fresh tablets.
“He could think of nothing else for days together. And when at last he saw it clearly, he was filled with joy , and made haste to commit it to writing. The waxen tablets were given in charge to one of the monks but when they were wanted they were missing. Anselm managed to recall the argument, it was written on fresh tablets and given into safer keeping.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 49The tablets were found broken; he pieced them together and had it copied on parchment.
“But when it was wanted it was found that the wax was broken to Pieces. Anselm with some difficulty put the fragments together and had the whole copied on parchment for greater security.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 50Herluin, founder of Bec, died and Anselm was elected to succeed him.
“on the death of Herluin, founder and first Abbot of Bec Anselm was elected to succeed him.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 51Elected abbot, he lay prostrate weeping before the brethren, who prostrated themselves in turn.
“The Abbot-elect fell prostrate before the brethren and with tears besought them not to lay this burden on him, while they prostrated themselves and earnestly begged him to accept the office.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 52He wrote to his monks of the tender affection of so many of them.
“Many of you came to Le Bec.... Many of you surrounded me with such a tender and sweet affection that each one might have had the impression that I never loved anyone else to the same extent”
Benedict XVI, 15 April 2009, Letter to Cardinal Giacomo Biffi for the ninth centenary of the death of St Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Letter to Cardinal Biffi, quoting Anselm, Ep. 156 · the Holy See - 53Ælfheah was killed by the Danes for refusing a ransom that would impoverish his people.
“a Saxon archbishop , Elphage (Ælfheah), who had been put to death by the Danes for refusing to pay a ransom which would impoverish his people. Lanfranc doubted his claim to the honours of a martyr since he did not die for the Faith.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 54At Canterbury he argued that Ælfheah, killed for refusing a ransom, died for Christ, for Christ is truth and justice.
“Moreover, Christ is truth and justice and he who dies for truth and justice dies for Christ.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 55Rufus kept Canterbury vacant four years after Lanfranc died.
“When Lanfranc died, William Rufus kept the See of Canterbury vacant for four years, seized its revenues, and kept the Church in England in a state of anarchy .”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 56They dragged him to the sick king, who was in anguish and fear.
“At last they dragged him by main force to the sick king's room : William, in his anguish and fear, was deeply anxious about the matter”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · History of Recent Events, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 57He kept his hand clenched; they forced the staff against it; carried to church crying 'It is nought that ye are doing'.
“But when the king presented it, Anselm kept his hand firmly clenched and would not take it. They tried by main force to wrench it open ; and when he cried out with the pain of their violence, they at last held the staff closely pressed against his still closed hand.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · History of Recent Events, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 58'It is nought that ye are doing.'
“he was carried, rather than led, to a neighbouring church, still crying out, It is nought that ye are doing”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · History of Recent Events, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 59His own description: madmen dragging one in his senses, or sane men a madman.
“It would have been difficult to make out whether madmen were dragging along one in his senses, or sane men a madman, save that they were chanting, and I, pale with amazement and pain, looked more like one dead than alive.”
Anselm, Letter to the monks of Bec on his election (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Letter to the monks of Bec · their own words or the earliest accounts - 60The untameable bull and the old and feeble sheep yoked to one plough.
“They had yoked together to the plough the untameable bull with the ... and feeble sheep ; and no good could come of the union.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · History of Recent Events, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 61The scene was on 6 March 1093.
“This happened on the First Sunday in Lent, March 6, 1093.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. IX · scholarship - 62Riding from Windsor to Hayes, a hunted hare took refuge under his horse; he wept at the laughter.
“the story of the hare, which, when he was riding one day, after he had become archbishop, from Windsor to Hayes, the young men about him started and chased with their dogs. The hare took refuge under the feet of his horse.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as told by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 63When the soldiers laughed, Anselm burst into tears: the hare is the image of the departing soul.
“When the soldiers crowded round with noisy triumph at the capture, Anselm burst into tears. " ' You laugh,' he said, ' but for the poor un- happy creature there is nothing to laugh at or be glad for ; its mortal foes are about it, and it flies to us for life”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 64He forbade the dogs to touch it and it ran free.
“Then he rode on, and with a loud voice forbade that the dogs should touch the hare ; and the creature, glad and at liberty, darted off to the fields and woods.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 65At Rockingham in March 1095 he upheld Pope Urban II's authority before the council of the realm.
“This grave question was referred to a council of the realm held at Rockingham in March, 1095. Here Anselm boldly asserted the authority of Urban .”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 66In 1097 he left for Rome, crossing Mont Cenis as a simple monk; monks along the way asked him for news of Anselm.
“In the spring he resumed his journey and crossed Mont Cenis with two companions all travelling as simple monks . At the monasteries on their way they were frequently asked for news of Anselm.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 67At Schiavi, a hill village near Telese, he rested and finished Cur Deus Homo.
“The little village was perched on a hill-top ; there was no one living in it but the labourers and a monk who super- intended them : the summer sky was bright, the mountain air was sweet and fresh and healthy, while the plains were fainting with the heat.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XII · scholarship - 68'Here shall be my rest for ever'; he finished Cur Deus Homo there.
“Hie requies mea, he broke forth, in the words of the Psalm — " Here shall be my rest for ever : here will I dwell, for I have a delight therein."”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XII · scholarship - 69At Bari in October 1098 he argued against the Greeks on the procession of the Holy Spirit, and interceded for William.
“In October, 1098, Urban held a council at Bari to deal with the difficulties raised by the Greeks in regard to the procession of the Holy Ghost. Here Anselm was called by the Pope to a place of honour and bidden to take the chief part in the discussion.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 70The council would have excommunicated William but for Anselm's intercession.
“His own case was also brought before this council, which would have excommunicated William but for Anselm's intercession.”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 71He cleared the way for Henry to marry Edith, who had worn the veil without vows.
“He helped to remove the obstacle in the way of his marriage with Edith, the heiress of the Saxon kings. The daughter of St. Margaret had sought shelter in a convent , where she had worn the veil, but had taken no vows .”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 72'I prefer to disagree with those who agree among themselves, than disagree with God.'
“I am Christian, I am a monk, I am a Bishop; I therefore want to be faithful to all, in accordance with the debt I have to each one" ( Ep. 314), applied. In this perspective he does not hesitate to affirm: "I prefer to disagree with those who agree among themselves, than disagree with God"”
Benedict XVI, 15 April 2009, Letter to Cardinal Giacomo Biffi for the ninth centenary of the death of St Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Letter to Cardinal Biffi, quoting Anselm, Ep. 314 · the Holy See - 73In his last years he was carried in a litter; food became loathsome; he was carried daily to Mass in a chair.
“so that, when he was moving from place to place, he was from that time carried in a litter, instead of riding on horseback.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 74Food had become loathsome to him.
“every kind of food by which nature is sustained became loathsome to him.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 75Carried daily in a chair to the consecration of the Lord's body.
“from his strong desire to attend the consecration of the Lord's body, which he venerated with a special feeling of devotion, he caused himself to be carried thither every day in a chair.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 76On Palm Sunday he said he would gladly stay to solve the question of the origin of the soul.
“He answered, 'If His will be so, I shall gladly obey His will. But if He willed rather that I should yet remain amongst you, at least till I have solved a question which I am turning in my mind, about the origin of the soul, I should receive it thankfully for I know not whether any one will finish it after I am gone.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 77On Tuesday evening he could no longer speak; he raised his hand and made the sign of the cross.
“He raised his right hand, as if he was suffering nothing, and made the sign of the Holy Cross ; and then dropped his head and sank down.”
Eadmer, monk of Canterbury, Anselm's secretary and companion, Life of St Anselm and History of Recent Events (as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm, 1870) · Macmillan, via archive.org · Life of St Anselm, as translated by R. W. Church · their own words or the earliest accounts - 78Benedict XVI: the dream of the banquet found its fulfilment.
“So it was that the dream of the mysterious banquet he had had as a small boy, at the very beginning of his spiritual journey, found fulfilment.”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 79The opening of the Proslogium.
“UP now, slight man ! flee, for a little while, thy occupations; hide thyself, for a time, from thy dis turbing thoughts. Cast aside, now, thy burdensome cares, and put away thy toilsome business. Yield room for some little time to God ; and rest for a little time in him. Enter the inner chamber of thy mind; shut out all thoughts save that of God, and such as can aid thee in seeking him ; close thy door and seek him.”
Anselm, translated by Sidney Norton Deane (1903), Proslogium · Open Court, via archive.org · Proslogium, ch. 1 · their own words or the earliest accounts - 80A well at Schiavi was said to have sprung from the rock at his prayer.
“The name of the Archbishop of Canterbury clung for centuries to a well of fresh and health-giving water, the spring of which was said to have gushed out of the rock in answer to his prayers.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XII · scholarship - 81The presence of such a man raised the expectation of miracles.
“As was to be expected, the presence of such a man raised the expectation of ... miracles.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XII · scholarship - 82The wonders at his burial: the inexhaustible balsam and the coffin that grew.
“The story of his departure, told so simply and naturally, has its fringe of wonder and legend. The balsam with which his body was embalmed seemed inexhaustible; the stone coffin, which seemed too small, wonderfully enlarged itself.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIV · scholarship - 83His canonisation: demanded without effect by Becket; ratified by a bull of 1494 said to be of Alexander VI.
“His name, as was to be ex- pected, passed into the roll of saints ; but apparently the steps of the process are not clear. His canonisa- tion was demanded, but without effect, by Thomas Becket : the final ratification of it is ascribed to a papal bull some centuries later.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIV · scholarship - 84The bull was addressed to Cardinal Morton in 1494; the Pope is said to have been Alexander VI.
“It was addressed to Cardinal Morton, Archbishop of Canterbury under Henry VH. in 1494.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIV · scholarship - 85Dante had already placed him among the lights of the sun in Paradise.
“Dante had consecrated his memory, and assigned him a place with those whom the Church honoured as her saints.”
R. W. Church, Dean of St Paul's (1870), Saint Anselm · Macmillan, via archive.org · ch. XIV · scholarship - 86Clement XI declared him a Doctor of the Church in 1720; his feast is 21 April.
“he has been declared a Doctor of the Church by Clement XI , 1720, and in the office read on his feast day (21 April) it is said that his works are a pattern for all theologians .”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm · Catholic reference - 87Benedict XVI: truly European, born in Italy, monk in Normandy, archbishop in England.
“The Saint is truly to be considered European, who was born in northern Italy in the year 1033 and became a Benedictine monk in the Abbey of Bec in Normandy in the year 1060, finally he departed from this world as Archbishop of Canterbury in Anglia in 1109.”
Benedict XVI, 7 March 2009, Message to the Abbot Primate of the Confederated Benedictines for the ninth centenary of the death of St Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Message to the Abbot Primate, 7 March 2009 · the Holy See - 88His prayer to Mary.
“"Mary, it is you whom my heart yearns to love", St Anselm wrote, "it is you whom my tongue ardently desires to praise".”
Benedict XVI, 23 September 2009, General Audience: Saint Anselm · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 23 September 2009 · the Holy See - 89Freeman: the man who saved the hunted hare and stood up for Ælfheah.
“to be handed down in the annals of humanity as the man who saved the hunted hare and stood up for the holiness of Ælfheah”
William Kent, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 1 (1907), St. Anselm · New Advent · St. Anselm, quoting E. A. Freeman · Catholic reference
The life rests on Eadmer, Anselm's secretary and companion, whose Life and History of Recent Events are quoted as translated in R. W. Church's Saint Anselm (1870), with Eadmer's account of the childhood dream as translated in the Catholic Encyclopedia (1907); on Anselm's own Proslogion (Deane, 1903) and letters (as translated in Benedict XVI's letter of 15 April 2009); on Benedict XVI's catechesis of 23 September 2009; and on the Catholic Encyclopedia for dates. The sources differ on the year he became abbot (1078 or 1079) and on the date of the final settlement with Henry I (Benedict XVI gives 1106 for his return; the Catholic Encyclopedia gives the London council of 1107); the life gives both where it matters. His canonisation is obscure and is told as the sources tell it. Researched 2026-09-26.